Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Where is your household income?

209 replies

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 12:22

https://ifs.org.uk/toolsanddresources/wheredooyoufitt_in#tool-results-section

AIBU to think this doesn't reflect society as a whole as there is a lot of wealth especially in business that may not get classed as income?

People I know are in the top 5 percent.

The illustratous 85k that has been talked about on here is

With a household after tax income of £84954 per week, you have a higher income than around 99% of the population - equivalent to about 65.3 million individuals.

Guess people are property and inheritance rich too.

My aunts and uncles are way richer than me but my income looks better on paper. They are retired with lots of property.

Where do you feature on the scale? Clearly nobody has to answer.

It's not the whole picture far from it I think?

OP posts:
Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 15:52

The problem with it is that it doesn't ask enough questions about costs not that it isn't making enough assumptions about costs.

That's exactly what I've said though: that the assumptions in the tool are such that it is meaningless and that no proper comparison at an individual household level could be made without the tool also factoring in their specific large necessary costs such as housing and childcare. Not that it should make more assumptions, that the tool should include boxes to enter individual values on these and make comparisons on the net figure.

proppy · 12/04/2023 15:51

On that topic, the tool should probably stratify the top 1% into ten deciles of its own. This would be far more revealing. And provide a separate chart of their income levels per decile.

That would be interesting

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 15:49

Botw1 · 12/04/2023 15:35

@Nepmarthiturn

I despair at the level of privilege blindness and wealth inequality

Me too. But that won't be helped by attacking the wrong targets, therefore "tools" like this which give misleading information are unhelpful in terms of establishing the policies that will fix the issue.

On that topic, the tool should probably stratify the top 1% into ten deciles of its own. This would be far more revealing. And provide a separate chart of their income levels per decile.

The actual problem that needs addressing might then become more apparent to more people.

Aturnipforthebooks · 12/04/2023 15:49

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 15:45

I don't agree that single parents will definitely have higher childcare costs. I know lone parents who have lower childcare costs than me because they get help from grandparents

🙄🙄

So might a couple.

A tool like this works on averages. For it to calculate that it thinks on average a lone parent would be better off than a couple with the same income is obviously false, as copious economic data demonstrates to be the case.

The point is that no such tool can tell you which percentage or even decile your particular household is in within even three or four deciles of accuracy in some cases if it does not factor in the very highest costs that most households face: housing and childcare. There can be no meaningful comparison unless these are included in the calculation and it is the remaining disposable income that is compared.

Therefore, per my posts that have explained all of this, the tool does not provide any meaningful information for economic comparison.

I agree, it's useless but I also think your points aren't sound as you think they are.

The problem with it is that it doesn't ask enough questions about costs not that it isn't making enough assumptions about costs.

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 15:45

I don't agree that single parents will definitely have higher childcare costs. I know lone parents who have lower childcare costs than me because they get help from grandparents

🙄🙄

So might a couple.

A tool like this works on averages. For it to calculate that it thinks on average a lone parent would be better off than a couple with the same income is obviously false, as copious economic data demonstrates to be the case.

The point is that no such tool can tell you which percentage or even decile your particular household is in within even three or four deciles of accuracy in some cases if it does not factor in the very highest costs that most households face: housing and childcare. There can be no meaningful comparison unless these are included in the calculation and it is the remaining disposable income that is compared.

Therefore, per my posts that have explained all of this, the tool does not provide any meaningful information for economic comparison.

Highlyflavouredgravy · 12/04/2023 15:42

YunaBalloon · 12/04/2023 14:44

They're adults. Supporting them is considered optional.

Ha!!!

Mangomingo · 12/04/2023 15:41

I’m absolutely LOLing at “we’re not rich because we spend all our money” posts.
We are also in top 1%. I know we are very fortunate and we do spend a lot of money. I can’t have everything I want but I can have lots and lots.

proppy · 12/04/2023 15:39

What each of us on this thread would need to earn to feel wealthy is probably unreasonable!

I won't ever feel wealthy because of property prices. 10 years ago a house my way would have been around 700k which was somewhat achievable. Those houses are now 1.5m plus. I work with lots of people who earn similar to me but are in very expensive houses that didn't cost much simply because of age differences. Someone I know made a million pound profit because they bought in the early 00s.

Aturnipforthebooks · 12/04/2023 15:38

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 15:27

I don't agree on your logic with this. Why would it assume that childcare costs are higher? Kids may be school age...

It was calculated based on young dependents. Even if they are at school, a single adult providing for them financially is likely to need to be working more than school hours in term time and therefore have very large childcare costs whereas two parents can juggle this between them and use fewer hours of childcare. For a start they will have a minimum of 8 weeks of annual leave to cover school holidays, not 4. With some foresight and planning two adults can arrange their working lives so that one drops off at school and one picks up for example, while both still working full time hours. This is not an option for a single parent with a full time job. Does this really need explaining, the single parents would have higher costs, while also trying to do everything in half the time? Confused

I don't agree that single parents will definitely have higher childcare costs. I know lone parents who have lower childcare costs than me because they get help from grandparents,

I do agree that childcare costs are a massive factor in this but it would make sense to ask this as a separate question rather than make a load of assumptions.

But the biggest issue with this tool is that it ignores assets.

Botw1 · 12/04/2023 15:35

@Nepmarthiturn

I despair at the level of privilege blindness and wealth inequality

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 15:35

proppy · 12/04/2023 15:32

I agree this is a relatively crude tool but in terms of managing people’s expectations about their relative income it serves its purpose. For many it is eye opening to learn they earn more than average.

Is the calculator based on all income or just PAYE? I think wealth is about far more than just income.

It says so include all income. Whether people have done I do not know. But it takes no account of wealth as you say, or essential outgoings, or variations in cost of living across the country, so it is utterly meaningless anyway.

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 15:34

I despair at the level of understanding of basic economics and tax on these kind of threads. They are useful for that at least: a regular reminder of why we are in the state we're in and why there isn't sufficient public pressure for politicians to implement evidence-based, sensible policies that would improve things for everyone.

BankMum · 12/04/2023 15:34

It is interesting that so many replying here are at the higher end of the spectrum, I guess it's the demographic of MN. My household is top 5%. We do know we are lucky and feel comfortable but I think for that kind of % you would expect to feel wealthy....I guess that's where the incredulity comes in. What each of us on this thread would need to earn to feel wealthy is probably unreasonable!

proppy · 12/04/2023 15:32

I agree this is a relatively crude tool but in terms of managing people’s expectations about their relative income it serves its purpose. For many it is eye opening to learn they earn more than average.

Is the calculator based on all income or just PAYE? I think wealth is about far more than just income.

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 15:27

I don't agree on your logic with this. Why would it assume that childcare costs are higher? Kids may be school age...

It was calculated based on young dependents. Even if they are at school, a single adult providing for them financially is likely to need to be working more than school hours in term time and therefore have very large childcare costs whereas two parents can juggle this between them and use fewer hours of childcare. For a start they will have a minimum of 8 weeks of annual leave to cover school holidays, not 4. With some foresight and planning two adults can arrange their working lives so that one drops off at school and one picks up for example, while both still working full time hours. This is not an option for a single parent with a full time job. Does this really need explaining, the single parents would have higher costs, while also trying to do everything in half the time? Confused

Ithurtsthebackofmyeyes · 12/04/2023 15:26

fellrunner85 · 12/04/2023 15:24

An income higher than 99% of the population

.... but that can't be right. We're skint!

We pay far more in taxes than most of you, for starters. Then add into that thousands in school fees; two Range Rovers to run (we live rurally so need them); the housekeeper (we have serious jobs with long hours so this is a need, not a want); paying into investments and pensions; mortgage on our £900k house; smaller mortgage on our very modest holiday cottage in Cornwall (again, a need not a want - we need downtime from our very stressful jobs); the piano, tennis and skiing lessons; and livery for the pony - and there's hardly anything left.

By the end of the month we're honestly struggling to pay for the Ocado orders.

You have to pay livery? Gosh, you don’t have land and stabling at home? You really are skint.

Aturnipforthebooks · 12/04/2023 15:26

fellrunner85 · 12/04/2023 15:24

An income higher than 99% of the population

.... but that can't be right. We're skint!

We pay far more in taxes than most of you, for starters. Then add into that thousands in school fees; two Range Rovers to run (we live rurally so need them); the housekeeper (we have serious jobs with long hours so this is a need, not a want); paying into investments and pensions; mortgage on our £900k house; smaller mortgage on our very modest holiday cottage in Cornwall (again, a need not a want - we need downtime from our very stressful jobs); the piano, tennis and skiing lessons; and livery for the pony - and there's hardly anything left.

By the end of the month we're honestly struggling to pay for the Ocado orders.

😂😂😂

Ithurtsthebackofmyeyes · 12/04/2023 15:25

higher income than around 99% of the population - equivalent to about 65.3 million individuals

midgemadgemodge · 12/04/2023 15:25

😀

fellrunner85 · 12/04/2023 15:24

An income higher than 99% of the population

.... but that can't be right. We're skint!

We pay far more in taxes than most of you, for starters. Then add into that thousands in school fees; two Range Rovers to run (we live rurally so need them); the housekeeper (we have serious jobs with long hours so this is a need, not a want); paying into investments and pensions; mortgage on our £900k house; smaller mortgage on our very modest holiday cottage in Cornwall (again, a need not a want - we need downtime from our very stressful jobs); the piano, tennis and skiing lessons; and livery for the pony - and there's hardly anything left.

By the end of the month we're honestly struggling to pay for the Ocado orders.

Foreversearch · 12/04/2023 15:23

I agree this is a relatively crude tool but in terms of managing people’s expectations about their relative income it serves its purpose. For many it is eye opening to learn they earn more than average.

The median salary is c£33k which means 50% of the working population earn this or less.

A lot of peoples perception about their income level is skewed by their outgoings, but many are either short term or investment. Child care is expensive but relatively short term, university is 3 years etc. A mortgage is investing in an asset (rent is not), pension is investing in future income etc. The c20-25 years having and raising children are usually the most expensive but also when you are investing for the future. Long term an above average salary should lead to comfortable later life and retirement.

A factor it is also the level of debt people are willing to accrue vs savings. When the COL goes up as sharply as it has, regardless of income, some people feel the squeeze much harder than others because of the lifestyle choices they have made in the past.

Botw1 · 12/04/2023 15:21

@Nepmarthiturn

Or, less patronisingly, people are aware how taxation works, still have similar outgoings and don't get help from UC or with childcare so are fully aware how much further higher wages go

IncompleteSenten · 12/04/2023 15:20

4 adults in this house as my children are in their 20s. Household income isn't the same as my and my husband's income though. We don't spend our sons' money!

Where is your household income?
FloydPepper · 12/04/2023 15:20

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 14:29

One problem with people grasping the reality appears to be that they haven't calculated how much they'd have to earn as a gross salary to receive what they do as net income between their net pay and UC, child benefit, childcare funding etc, because these are untaxed, and they have little idea of how the overall percentage of tax you pay on your income increases rapidly as you earn more when this is factored in. I think if many did that calculated and realised the gross salary they'd need to earn to have the net income they do entirely from their own earnings it might bring more sense to the discussion. That is the only way that a proper comparison could be made. Then factoring in self-funded rent/ mortgage and childcare on top of that and comparing the remaining disposable income.

Absolutely

this is the main flaw with these types of threads and comparisons. People just don’t think that what they get in their pockets (from whatever source) equates to a much higher salary that people then pay tax on.

Aturnipforthebooks · 12/04/2023 15:19

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 15:13

The calculator itself also seems to be fundamentally flawed in that I've also jist tried putting the exact same income into it for a single adult household with two dependants, and then a two adult household with two dependants (same ages), and it says the one adult household is richer than the two adult one. 😵‍💫🤣 Despite the obvious fact the lone parent would have far higher childcare costs, obviously.

Whoever designed this "tool" has made a hash of it.

I don't agree on your logic with this. Why would it assume that childcare costs are higher? Kids may be school age...

If there is an one less person to clothe and feed then of course he household would be better off financially.

Swipe left for the next trending thread