Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Where is your household income?

209 replies

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 12:22

https://ifs.org.uk/toolsanddresources/wheredooyoufitt_in#tool-results-section

AIBU to think this doesn't reflect society as a whole as there is a lot of wealth especially in business that may not get classed as income?

People I know are in the top 5 percent.

The illustratous 85k that has been talked about on here is

With a household after tax income of £84954 per week, you have a higher income than around 99% of the population - equivalent to about 65.3 million individuals.

Guess people are property and inheritance rich too.

My aunts and uncles are way richer than me but my income looks better on paper. They are retired with lots of property.

Where do you feature on the scale? Clearly nobody has to answer.

It's not the whole picture far from it I think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nepmarthiturn · 13/04/2023 12:26

This. I'm quite shocked actually. Our basic income + child benefit and tax credits (which we have survived on for years) puts us in the bottom 13%. When I now add on DDs PIP and my carers allowance (both of which we only started receiving last month) that puts up to the bottom 22%. But we live in a nice house and are mortgage free, so we have always been able to give the kids plenty of activities, have an annual UK holiday and do trips out etc. We have certainly never felt 'poor'. Of course we have always had to be careful and prioritise, but no way would I have said that we've spent well over a decade in the bottom 13% - I honestly would have put us somewhere 'middling'. The kids all do music lessons and sports - DD has been horse riding every week for years. To me, it just feels like it is too blunt a tool to have any real use.

Based on what you've said though you are in the middle if not higher. The problem is the tool considers only income not expenses, so the conclusions are meaningless. No consideration either of wealth or assets: pensions, and particularly owning a house mortgage free alone would move you several deciles in terms of disposable income after essential costs which is all that really matters in terms of standard of living.

Nepmarthiturn · 13/04/2023 12:23

Botw1 · 13/04/2023 08:06

@Nepmarthiturn

I clearly said it would never be achievable.

It should be

We shouldn't be ok with a system that results in Bezos, Musks and kardashians

Yet folk will comtinue to defend it because they're selfish

I'm not defending it. I think huge changes are needed and ultimately will be forced because there'll be no other option as resources become ever more scarce. I don't see the people who benefit from the status quo reliquishing it voluntary though I'm afraid.

And the people who do benefit for it aren't people on PAYE with larger salaries, or small business owners. It is the super rich, the top 0.3% or so. The tool conveniently provides no stratifying of their income... it simply says it is "off the side of the chart" 😏😒

TriceratopsRocks · 13/04/2023 12:15

user1471453601 · 12/04/2023 19:09

This link shows what I always maintain. It's not enough to know what's coming in, you also need to know what's going out. My calculations "showed" I was amongst the poorest in the country. That is complete nonsense. We have no mortgage or debts, except utilities, and live a good life. Until recently, when ill health intervened, I had 8 weeks holiday a year and ate out at least twice a week.

This. I'm quite shocked actually. Our basic income + child benefit and tax credits (which we have survived on for years) puts us in the bottom 13%. When I now add on DDs PIP and my carers allowance (both of which we only started receiving last month) that puts up to the bottom 22%. But we live in a nice house and are mortgage free, so we have always been able to give the kids plenty of activities, have an annual UK holiday and do trips out etc. We have certainly never felt 'poor'. Of course we have always had to be careful and prioritise, but no way would I have said that we've spent well over a decade in the bottom 13% - I honestly would have put us somewhere 'middling'. The kids all do music lessons and sports - DD has been horse riding every week for years. To me, it just feels like it is too blunt a tool to have any real use.

Botw1 · 13/04/2023 08:06

@Nepmarthiturn

I clearly said it would never be achievable.

It should be

We shouldn't be ok with a system that results in Bezos, Musks and kardashians

Yet folk will comtinue to defend it because they're selfish

Changechangechanging · 13/04/2023 07:52

Christ, I am a single parent and a bog standard teacher but I come in at higher than 58% of the population. That shocks me as a one income household and not a very high salary. Clearly I nees.to.get my priorities straight.

OneHundredOtters · 13/04/2023 07:32

We're in the top 98% DINKs living in London. We have plenty to be honest, we buy whatever we want and save a lot. We don't have particularly expensive tastes though. Cheap runabout, no designer clothes/handbags etc.

Trying for a baby though so know once we have to pay for childcare things will feel a lot tougher.

It does bring home how fucked the London housing market is though. We'd love to move out of our flat and even with good salaries and lots of equity we are struggling to afford a house in zone 2. It surely can't be sustainable long term?

HP79 · 13/04/2023 00:44

"With a household after tax income of £1,136 per week, you have a higher income than around 91% of the population..."

I'm surprised we're in the top 9% as I'd have guessed top 25-40%, however most of our social circle are people that are economically like us and so we're in a bit of a middle-class bubble.

We're DINKS, fly economy, stay in budget hotels, only eat out twice a month... no major extravagances really. However, we have a nice house and all our spare cash goes on overpaying the mortgage, so we'll hopefully be mortgage-free by the time we're 52 (him) and 48 (me). I realise that's a lifestyle choice and we're privileged to be able to do that. We have an appreciating asset that we can downsize from at some point and boost our retirement pot, which many people won't have. We can heat the house and don't have to watch the pennies at the supermarket, which I am eternally grateful for.

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 20:55

Good luck getting Governments around the world to behave as a "global society" with common regulations and values. People in the UK apparently didn't even want to be part of a European society where fundamental cultural values were already commonly shared, to achieve greater public goods for all in terms of issues like rights, environment etc that require international cooperation.

Botw1 · 12/04/2023 20:31

@Nepmarthiturn

I didnt say it existed

We need (as a global society) to figure it out.

Or we could just keep destroying the planet

BMW6 · 12/04/2023 20:15

I think Assets should be added into the equation to achieve a realistic measure of Wealth.

Market value of property(ies)
Size of Pension Pot
Cars/boats
Jewellery
Artworks

Its one thing to say you have no cash left each month after bills, but if you have a massive mortgage on a house worth 1m you must accept that you are more wealthy than someone in a home worth 150k, and if you are paying into a pension that will pay 40k pa, you will be much better off than those relying solely on State Pension.

You are simply buying more assets.

Hhjfue · 12/04/2023 19:50

We are in the top 5% - though in practice when we take into account childcare, pensions and mortgage £2000 - we have exactly the same amount as my retired parents who get £2500 per month from their pensions and are apparently in the 51% of the population. So yes it really is a very blunt tool.

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 19:17

user1471453601 · 12/04/2023 19:09

This link shows what I always maintain. It's not enough to know what's coming in, you also need to know what's going out. My calculations "showed" I was amongst the poorest in the country. That is complete nonsense. We have no mortgage or debts, except utilities, and live a good life. Until recently, when ill health intervened, I had 8 weeks holiday a year and ate out at least twice a week.

Exactly this. It's meaningless to look at income without also accounting for essential expenses. The net figure is what tells you how "well off" someone is in terms of monthly/ annual income. Then there's the issue of wealth. This tool can't be used to make any meaningful comparisons because it looks only at one side of the equation. Income alone tells you nothing of any use, except at the very extremes.

It's a bit like when you see things in the media about X company have made £££££ revenue this year, ignoring the fact it may have made no profit or even a loss.

user1471453601 · 12/04/2023 19:09

This link shows what I always maintain. It's not enough to know what's coming in, you also need to know what's going out. My calculations "showed" I was amongst the poorest in the country. That is complete nonsense. We have no mortgage or debts, except utilities, and live a good life. Until recently, when ill health intervened, I had 8 weeks holiday a year and ate out at least twice a week.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 12/04/2023 18:59

Better then 49% but we are also mortgage free so that means financially we are pretty well off, especially as we are quite frugal

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 18:56

Which one is that and how does it work?

Botw1 · 12/04/2023 18:52

@Nepmarthiturn

One that doesn't pretend that continuous growth abd wealth acquisition is possible?

One that isn't actively destroying the planet and leaving the vast majority of people in abject poverty?

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 18:49

Abandoning capitalism.

What system are you suggesting instead?

Botw1 · 12/04/2023 18:34

@proppy

I suggest tackling wealth inequality

Starting with appropriate taxation on corporations and linked wages.

Tackling housing and fuel and food costs

Investing in education and health care. Tackling the root causes of poverty.

Abandoning capitalism.

Of course none of these things will happen because those with the most money never think they have enough

cloudonego · 12/04/2023 18:33

The tool does not work...

It considers how many dependents and people there are in the household too, a single person with £1400 a week will be higher on the graph than a family of 4.

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 17:57

YerAWizardHarry · 12/04/2023 17:35

With a household after tax income of £1400 per week, you have a higher income than around 92% of the population - equivalent to about 60.7 million individuals.

which is apparently “higher” than the person above who has £1900 a week?

The tool does not work...

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 17:53

So you’re saying there’s literally no way you could lower your housing costs and still work where you work. No cheaper areas / rentals / ex social housing within an hours drive. Righto.

Huh? My comments have been about economics and the validity of the economic comparisons the tool is trying to make which - with such large gaps in the data is requests to be input - mean its conclusions are essentially meaningless. I said nothing about my own situation at all. Confused

13Bastards · 12/04/2023 17:52

Lol higher than 97% of the population? I live in a two up two down, I doubt it 🤣

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 17:51

Sorry, the clarity of your point must have been lost amongst all the eye rolls and patronising language you use. Never mind.

So now I'm to blame that other people can't read? Never mind.

Emotionalstorm · 12/04/2023 17:41

Emotionalstorm · 12/04/2023 17:39

Yes I owe her a lot and I really appreciate what she's done for me. She loves children. If I'm going to be honest, I did not have a strong desire for children but it would devastate my mum if she didn't get any grandchildren. That had a huge impact on my decision to have my daughter. My husband is asking for another one because she's worried my daughter is too bossy and spoilt.

He's*

Emotionalstorm · 12/04/2023 17:41

proppy · 12/04/2023 17:38

Perhaps they think your job is less of a tie since they have you a house though?

I have no idea what they're thinking. I will work it out when the time comes. Hopefully my daughter will be independent by then and maybe I can step back to take care of them. They've done a lot for me and I don't want to hand them off to a care home if I can help it.