Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that private school parents are demonised?

665 replies

Imsorryyoufeelthatway · 12/04/2023 11:09

Starting this threat to vent and as an antidote to the Closing all private schools would benefit state schools thread. In short, I'm a bit fed up with private school parents being bashed for buying a better education for their children, while parents who 'don't believe in private education' and spend a fortune on homes/second homes/rental properties in catchment areas for 'good' state schools then another fortune on tutors seem to get off scot free.

I'm also fed up with private school parents all being lumped in the same category. We're not all selfish, mega-wealthy, Bullingdon Club (or female equivalent, if there was one...) alumni; many of us are ordinary people (I'm a working class lass from a council estate whose parents worked as cleaners and in warehouses) who've worked bloody hard to be able to afford a better start in life for our children than we had. We were the first people in our families to go to university (on full grants, when they existed), the first to have careers not just jobs, and the first to own our own homes. No-one has ever handed us a penny – my DH got the train to university with £4.50 in his pocket and had to get a job straight away to buy food. No bank account, no trust fund, no-one paying his rent. We've managed to achieve social mobility against the odds, yet we're not allowed to celebrate this because we've chosen to invest in our children's future rather than over-priced property in 'good' state school catchment areas.

Yes, we all know that private schools are a major cause of inequality. Parents like us have literally lived and breathed that inequality our whole lives and we'd do anything to prevent our children having to do the same. We think that all children should have access to high quality education in safe, inspirational environments where they can achieve their potential, not just ours. But most state schools in the UK just cannot meet this requirement. We also know that if catchment areas for state schools were mixed-up, and the schools in deprived areas had an influx of children from more affluent areas and vice versa, then this would likely make things more equal over time. But our children are not part of a social experiment. In short, if those of us who had difficult starts in life and went to terrible schools choose to work our arses off so our children don't have to, can't we be given some credit?

So please, the next time you're tempted to lump a private school parents into the same category and give them a bashing, take a moment to consider their reasons and background. Rant over.

OP posts:
Devoutspoken · 17/04/2023 10:26

Some people just send their kids to the local schools, having moved into that area before kids were even on the agenda, mind blowing, I know

faffadoodledo · 17/04/2023 10:04

This catchment area argument applies to so few kids. At the school
Mine attended there was no choice. Unless parents on low or average paid jobs were going to up sticks and risk all.
I find this argument is generally made by people in an income bracket which doesn't apply to most of the population. Choice is a pipe dream for most.

Bromptoncocktail37 · 17/04/2023 09:58

PuttingDownRoots · 12/04/2023 11:42

My observation is the biggest critics of Private Schools are often those who spend massive amounts of money moving into the "right" catchment.

Getting rid of Private Schools won't magically make failing schools better. Just drive the insane catchment areas

Also those who suddenly are 'very church-attending Catholics/add whatever religion you like here' to boost their kids chances of getting in.
Then are never seen in associated religious institute again

Tuftytail · 17/04/2023 09:57

D and I policy means diversity and inclusivity i.e. everybody in. Whilst work needs to be done on breaking the public school stranglehold in some areas, to automatically exclude privately educated pupils is just another form of discrimination.

xyxygy · 17/04/2023 09:54

Oh, and on "it would further siphon talent from state schools" - the state schools which would lose that talent aren't really serving those pupils well enough in the first place, otherwise they wouldn't lose them. While there's obviously a "greater good" aspect to consider, the individuals are important too. Sacrificing their potential education for the sake of ideology helps no-one, IMO.

xyxygy · 17/04/2023 09:50

faffadoodledo · 17/04/2023 09:31

Intriguing idea @xyxygy
One problem with that is that it would further siphon talent from state schools. I speak as someone whose children would have been shoe ins for such help (unless means tested). They stuck in with the state system and literally couldn't have done better grade wise.
Scholarships and bursaries are about buying talent. Sure it might be good for the student (or may make no difference). But it's always good for the school.
Parents are always flattered by the school chipping in because they think it makes their child special. But the benefit goes both ways

Interesting tho. And do think private schools will always be with us. I don't like them, but I really don't see them going anywhere. The best way to weaken them of course is to strengthen the state system. Trouble with that is that the decision makers send their kids private, so have no skin in the state game.

Well, the way I see it, closing the private schools is completely unworkable - the government wouldn't be able to afford the assets, or the education of 600k students, or the teachers (we'd effectively be in a TUPE situation, which means they'd have to maintain those teachers on their existing benefits packages).

The obvious thing to do is to co-opt them as part of the state system and take them over from the inside - that way, everybody wins. The schools get to stay open, the scholarship kids get a higher-value education, the non-scholarship kids are in less-overcrowded schools, and the government gets a win on education (something they haven't had in decades, if ever).

Of course, it would require that the government don't use the opportunity to cut the education budget - per-pupil funding would need to increase proportionally.

There will never be a situation where the education system is equal by financial status. Hell, there's just as much geographical inequality within the state system as there is between state and private schools. It strikes me that fixing the postcode lottery when it comes to state schools would be a far more useful endeavour than the politically-charged war against affluence...not least, because if the state system is in a more equal state (preferably more capable, rather than a lowest-common-denominator approach), then the other side of the problem goes away anyway.

faffadoodledo · 17/04/2023 09:31

Intriguing idea @xyxygy
One problem with that is that it would further siphon talent from state schools. I speak as someone whose children would have been shoe ins for such help (unless means tested). They stuck in with the state system and literally couldn't have done better grade wise.
Scholarships and bursaries are about buying talent. Sure it might be good for the student (or may make no difference). But it's always good for the school.
Parents are always flattered by the school chipping in because they think it makes their child special. But the benefit goes both ways

Interesting tho. And do think private schools will always be with us. I don't like them, but I really don't see them going anywhere. The best way to weaken them of course is to strengthen the state system. Trouble with that is that the decision makers send their kids private, so have no skin in the state game.

Nordicrain · 17/04/2023 09:12

I don't care what individuals do about schooling - most people do what they think is best for their own families. I do care that my taxes are subsidising their children getting an advantage over others when it could be going to the state education system., so I strongly feel that the businesses that run these schools should NOT be tax exempt.

xyxygy · 17/04/2023 09:10

Getting rid of the private schools won't solve a thing. Those folk expecting the government to both a) find more money, and b) put it into the education system to support the influx of kids from private schools are delusional.

All that will mean is all the kids get whatever scraps of education the government think they can get away with.

A far better option would be to force all independent schools to fill at least 20% (just plucking a number out of the air) of their places with means-tested scholarship students, and fund it themselves - likely primarily using their charitable status.

My school did it, and I benefited from it - as did my daughter - because our school did exactly that.

That'd be around 120k pupils suddenly getting access to a better education and the state system being relieved of that financial burden, rather than 600k pupils descending on an already overstretched state system.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 08:53

'The DEI policy is a very broad stroke one. Not aimed at employers to block anyone because that is discrimination.'

The reality is, in my huge global company, we are now looking for, actively seeking, people from lower socio-economic backgrounds, state educated and using everything we can to do that - including recruiting A level student grads into entry level positions, offering work experience and apprenticeships to state educated people and those from more diverse backgrounds, supporting younger staff from lower socio economic backgrounds with extra payments so they can afford to take our entry level positions, favouring candidates from state schools & rejecting Oxbridge, St Andrews etc canditates.
It's very easy to do this without 'discriminating' - for starters any real evidence of actual work experience - bar work, fast food, shop work etc is preferable to 'interned at mummy's gallery' 'worked' at daddy's friend's music company.

The reality is - we want a smart, diverse workforce that reflects the real world. ANd the real world isn't the 6% or so who go through private education, it's everyone else.

Devoutspoken · 17/04/2023 08:24

Brunetemic, not sending your kids to private school is a good place to start

justasking111 · 17/04/2023 08:04

The DEI policy is a very broad stroke one. Not aimed at employers to block anyone because that is discrimination.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 06:35

‘f, as an employer, you are turning someone down on the basis that they went to an independent school then you are guilty of some weird discrimination’

its not some ‘weird’ anythinG, it’s the implementation of DEI policies couples with the fact that more and more senior people
in companies are no longer from privately educated backgrounds.
the stranglehold of 6/7% privately educated people iIs finally starting to ease.
about time to.

brunettemic · 16/04/2023 22:21

Who cares, I’m pretty sure all the people who hear moaning about inequality do very little to balance all the other inequalities in life. There’s some form of inequality everywhere you look, is that a good thing? Of course not but you can’t stop it, inequality is on so many levels, many of which can’t be changed.

SmartHome · 16/04/2023 22:15

Wishful thinking, made up nonsense - employers don't give a shit what type of school applicants went to by the time they are evaluating them for a jobs 5 or 6 years later. Universities have the contextual scheme to widen acess to university and don't give a damn beyond that - as long as they offer the requisite number of contextual places and can report on that, they care about bums on seat and tuition fees. They don't care if those fees come from rich parents, loans or bursaries.

I employ graduates and we barely notice the schools - I would only know if the were private if it was a recgnicable name and I very rarely ask for or get that information. Mostly 'institution-blind now so I know degree subject, class, a Level subjects and number of GCSEs. That's it. I really don't care where they went to school either.

Changechangechanging · 16/04/2023 22:05

It’s started to not have the kudos it used to- employers want smart candidates, grounded in real the real world. Not people who’ve been hand-held, coddled and coached through their entire life

you know lots of people who've been through the independent system then? enough to say that they've all been hand-held, coddled and coached? Because in my experience, the ones who are coddled are those in state schools with parents who refuse to take responsibility for their parenting (or lack of) and who see their children as best friends, not children who require routines, boundaries and rules. Most independent school children have been big in sports, having been coached into team members who help and support each other, often taking on coaching responsibility for younger students in school. Sure, they may well have tutors when struggling but mainly they work hard and play hard and go on to work hard at university, acheive good grades and move to their chosen field of work. Of course, some kids in independents struggle to reach that level of acheivements, and of course are hand-held and coddled and coached. But it takes all sorts and most of us find our way, even if for some of us, we take longer than others.

If, as an employer, you are turning someone down on the basis that they went to an independent school then you are guilty of some weird discrimination but also won't always be recruiting the best person possible to the job available. I have yet to come across an employer that discriminates on this basis because it is ultimately about getting in the right person in the right place to maximise profits/success. Otherwise, why exist? I would suggest having a look at your own prejudices before dismissing literally thousands of people as not smart, not grounded, coddled and coached. It certainly isn't true in my experience - and I have worked in a number of schools with differing catchments.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 16/04/2023 21:13

Universities and employers are now looking to actively avoid having private educated candidates. It’s started to not have the kudos it used to- employers want smart candidates, grounded
in real the real world. Not people who’ve been hand-held, coddled and coached through their entire life.

Easterfunbun · 16/04/2023 13:13

@LuvSmallDogs

Isn’t that the truth? I had the unfortunate reality of going to a private school for my secondary Ed. 100 percent scholarship based on my brains and not my parents wallets. Awful, awful girls. I’m still miles ahead of them now too. I yearned for the local state.

Dobby123456 · 14/04/2023 12:24

Hobbi · 14/04/2023 12:01

@Dobby123456

As you've 'rephrased' twice now in the face of the facts the suggestion that you just invented things for your original post has some credibility. Yes, Tories will vote for their self-interest, it's the main principle of the modern Conservative Party. Whether or not their self-interest should be promoted due to privilege and result in disadvantage for others is another matter, and the education of journalists is entirely irrelevant.

My attempts to rephrase were in order to have a more constructive conversation. You are being very unnecessarily antagonistic and rather proving the OP's original point!

I think I'll leave this now.

LuvSmallDogs · 14/04/2023 12:03

I wouldn't stick my kids in private school if millions fell out the sky into my backyard. My dad and sister both got given free rides at mostly fee-paid single sex colleges decades apart.

Both full of nasty one-upmanship, snobby Yah-Brigade teenagers who bullied the few working/lower middle class kids who got there with their own brains instead of someone else's bank account. DSis's in particular was very mean girls, had an eating disorder epidemic, and even pregnancies which didn't happen in my rough secondary.

I'd rather my kids associated with normal, decent folk and the odd little shit than that hellscape.

Hobbi · 14/04/2023 12:01

@Dobby123456

As you've 'rephrased' twice now in the face of the facts the suggestion that you just invented things for your original post has some credibility. Yes, Tories will vote for their self-interest, it's the main principle of the modern Conservative Party. Whether or not their self-interest should be promoted due to privilege and result in disadvantage for others is another matter, and the education of journalists is entirely irrelevant.

Dobby123456 · 14/04/2023 11:53

Hobbi · 14/04/2023 11:19

@Dobby123456

You're not misinformed, you're making things up for political purposes. The only policy is to require establishments with charitable status behave like charities or lose the tax benefits thereof. There is no reference to abolishing private education, nor any indication that there ever would be.

You are so right! I'm actually an employee of the Tory party come on here to deliberately misinform - but you've caught me out! 😂

Let me rephrase: Considering that the Labour Party attitude to private education tends to be more 'anti' you would perhaps expect more people who have been through the private sector to consistently vote Tory than actually do. Quite a number of the journalists who work for the Guardian have been through the private system. People are able to look objectively at the school system, see the pros and cons for society in general, and weigh up other factors, rather than blindly clinging to a system that they've benefitted from.

Hobbi · 14/04/2023 11:19

@Dobby123456

You're not misinformed, you're making things up for political purposes. The only policy is to require establishments with charitable status behave like charities or lose the tax benefits thereof. There is no reference to abolishing private education, nor any indication that there ever would be.

Dobby123456 · 14/04/2023 10:52

Hobbi · 14/04/2023 10:47

@Dobby123456
"Considering that Labour policy is to tax private education or abolish it altogether...'
Nice way to first misrepresent and then simply lie about Labour's policy.

Perhaps I'm misinformed? I thought abolishing private education was a Labour ideal, even if they might not actually be planning to do it the week they get back into government. I wasn't intending to misrepresent! Clearly, a lot of people weigh this up and still vote Labour somtimes.

Hobbi · 14/04/2023 10:47

@Dobby123456
"Considering that Labour policy is to tax private education or abolish it altogether...'
Nice way to first misrepresent and then simply lie about Labour's policy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread