Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that private school parents are demonised?

665 replies

Imsorryyoufeelthatway · 12/04/2023 11:09

Starting this threat to vent and as an antidote to the Closing all private schools would benefit state schools thread. In short, I'm a bit fed up with private school parents being bashed for buying a better education for their children, while parents who 'don't believe in private education' and spend a fortune on homes/second homes/rental properties in catchment areas for 'good' state schools then another fortune on tutors seem to get off scot free.

I'm also fed up with private school parents all being lumped in the same category. We're not all selfish, mega-wealthy, Bullingdon Club (or female equivalent, if there was one...) alumni; many of us are ordinary people (I'm a working class lass from a council estate whose parents worked as cleaners and in warehouses) who've worked bloody hard to be able to afford a better start in life for our children than we had. We were the first people in our families to go to university (on full grants, when they existed), the first to have careers not just jobs, and the first to own our own homes. No-one has ever handed us a penny – my DH got the train to university with £4.50 in his pocket and had to get a job straight away to buy food. No bank account, no trust fund, no-one paying his rent. We've managed to achieve social mobility against the odds, yet we're not allowed to celebrate this because we've chosen to invest in our children's future rather than over-priced property in 'good' state school catchment areas.

Yes, we all know that private schools are a major cause of inequality. Parents like us have literally lived and breathed that inequality our whole lives and we'd do anything to prevent our children having to do the same. We think that all children should have access to high quality education in safe, inspirational environments where they can achieve their potential, not just ours. But most state schools in the UK just cannot meet this requirement. We also know that if catchment areas for state schools were mixed-up, and the schools in deprived areas had an influx of children from more affluent areas and vice versa, then this would likely make things more equal over time. But our children are not part of a social experiment. In short, if those of us who had difficult starts in life and went to terrible schools choose to work our arses off so our children don't have to, can't we be given some credit?

So please, the next time you're tempted to lump a private school parents into the same category and give them a bashing, take a moment to consider their reasons and background. Rant over.

OP posts:
xyxygy · 17/04/2023 23:43

Labraradabrador · 17/04/2023 22:40

The real trend is towards blind hiring not ‘anti-private schooling’. Increasingly that means removing all school detail off of resumes, and as someone who regularly interviews for entry level consulting roles, I have never asked (or even wondered) about where they went to school before university. Increasingly we are also being asked to keep university names blind so you just focus on the candidate in front of you.

most people aren’t paying for private because of ‘status’ - we genuinely believe our children are getting a better education. That might not always mean top grades - as long as I feel my child is achieving to the best of their potential then it is money well spent. I believe a supportive, challenging, well rounded education confers benefits in and of itself regardless of later educational or professional pathways

Exactly - even if those details are present, I'm not about to go and look up their school to see if it's posh enough.

If I'm hiring, I want to know a) that they're not a dick, and b) what they know. Where they learned it is completely irrelevant to me, because it'll never be remotely useful to me.

Inthebathagain · 17/04/2023 23:16

I've always thought that private schools should be abolished.

If those in power had no option but to send their own children/grandchildren to state schools, then they would work far harder to make sure that every state school was at a high standard.

thing47 · 17/04/2023 23:06

as someone who regularly interviews for entry level consulting roles, I have never asked (or even wondered) about where they went to school before university

There was a long thread on the education boards about this recently. The general consensus was very much what you are saying here @Labraradabrador in that most recruiters of young graduates weren't interested in what school the applicant went to, or what grades they got at A level (law firms seeming to be the main exception).

FWIW the vast majority of universities also do not ask for A level grades when you apply for a Masters. They are only interested in your most recent academic qualification, namely your degree.

Labraradabrador · 17/04/2023 22:44

@Notellinganyone completely agree - we felt the same about our local (‘outstanding’) state option. The non selective private achieves similar results (slightly better, but would put it down to demographics), but offer a much more balanced, well-rounded whole-child education

Labraradabrador · 17/04/2023 22:40

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 21:59

I think it's important for those deciding to go private to weigh up all the pros and cons - and cons that weren't there before. Will your privately educated kids be 'discriminated' against more and more. Yes.
Do you care? The really wealthy won't, they'll use their money, connections to bulldoze every obstacle out of their children's way. But MC may want to think about whether or not it's really worth the 'investment'.

The real trend is towards blind hiring not ‘anti-private schooling’. Increasingly that means removing all school detail off of resumes, and as someone who regularly interviews for entry level consulting roles, I have never asked (or even wondered) about where they went to school before university. Increasingly we are also being asked to keep university names blind so you just focus on the candidate in front of you.

most people aren’t paying for private because of ‘status’ - we genuinely believe our children are getting a better education. That might not always mean top grades - as long as I feel my child is achieving to the best of their potential then it is money well spent. I believe a supportive, challenging, well rounded education confers benefits in and of itself regardless of later educational or professional pathways

xyxygy · 17/04/2023 22:02

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 20:38

'What I do query reading this thread is are your state schools really as bad as your making out? '

No. They aren't as good in general I think as Irish schools or even Scottish ones but I think it's because they are much bigger, and generally not academically selective ( in N.Ireland for example there are still loads of grammars) so it really is all ability.
But what you do get is brillant teachers, diverse people and experiences and a wealth of talent and ability.
All the secondaries, bar one are rated the same - Good by Ofsted - but people are clamouring for private school places mainly I think because of the status for many MC, UMC families.

You say that, but...when our daughter was taking her GCSEs, she needed maths at grade B or above to get the scholarship to the local private school (there is no other sixth form provision in our area). Her government-predicted grade (which we discovered was based entirely on demographics, and nothing to do with her work) was a D. She got a C, and asked if she could retake it. The answer, from all the teachers, the deputy head and the head was, "No. Our job is to get her to the government predicted grade, and we've exceeded that target.".

Basically, a slippery-shoulders "not our problem" from every single member of staff at her school. The same school that had a 32% A-C pass rate at GCSE level, yet was judged to be satisfactory...because the demographic-based predicted grades were even lower than that. Far from being brilliant teachers and a wealth of talent, that school was staffed almost exclusively by teachers who just didn't give a damn.

The argument that school has always put forward is that the private school is wrecking their pass rates by taking 20 scholarship kids out of every year based on academic ability, so effectively the top 20. Almost all of those kids get 100% A-C, year in year out. Fair enough, except...there are roughly 140 kids in each year in this town. Even if you assumed that those kids would also get 100% pass rates at the state school, the 32% pass rate would only climb to roughly 42%. Would you send your kids to a school which can't even get half of the exam results to a passing level?

Even worse, they can't even claim lack of funding. They had millions poured into the school to outfit the place with all the latest tech so it could transition to being a "technology college". The result was a ton of computers with an over-complicated network that none of the teachers had the skills to use, despite going on endless training courses...and it didn't even move the needle on the pass rates. They also hired year group managers, year mentors, wellbeing managers...and behaviour and bullying at the school got worse.

Basically, the focus was on anything but the teaching, and the teachers couldn't give a shit and were just phoning it in. I was actually going to work there as a combined network admin and IT and maths teacher - I sat in on their best classes, and I was shocked at the poor knowledge and quality of the teaching. The three maths teachers had to refer to the book solutions to solve simple statistics problems, and the IT teachers were a PE teacher and a music teacher looking to earn a bit of extra cash by doubling up and just telling kids to fire up a CBT course at the beginning of the lesson and browsing the web until the bell went.

No, there were no brilliant teachers or talent of any kind on display. I don't live in an inner city, mind. This is one of the most affluent small towns in the country.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 21:59

I think it's important for those deciding to go private to weigh up all the pros and cons - and cons that weren't there before. Will your privately educated kids be 'discriminated' against more and more. Yes.
Do you care? The really wealthy won't, they'll use their money, connections to bulldoze every obstacle out of their children's way. But MC may want to think about whether or not it's really worth the 'investment'.

Dobby123456 · 17/04/2023 21:57

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 20:39

In my city, that is. My kids go to 'good' state schools and are thriving. The schools not perfect but it pretty good giving they take kids from every kind of background

I don't really understand the obsession on thus thread with 'status'. I don't know any patent who chooses a school thinking it's going to guide their child 'status' just by going there!

Notellinganyone · 17/04/2023 21:49

@ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom - I disagree. You can’t guarantee grade 9s unless you are just hugely selective like some of the very competitive grammars. I’ve been teaching for 27 years both state and independent and my perspective is that in recent years with Ofsted, MATs and an obsession with league tables it is the state schools that have become exam factories.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 20:42

Our friends who have gone private have done so because the schools almost guarantee 9's in every subject as GCSE - it's buying grades.
But because private schools have that reputation and everyone is realising that these kids are not extraordinary, just being tutored to death and trained to pass exams - along with a healthy dose of being given +++ marks whenever the school is involved in grading anything - it's not worth what it was anymore.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 20:39

In my city, that is. My kids go to 'good' state schools and are thriving. The schools not perfect but it pretty good giving they take kids from every kind of background

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 20:38

'What I do query reading this thread is are your state schools really as bad as your making out? '

No. They aren't as good in general I think as Irish schools or even Scottish ones but I think it's because they are much bigger, and generally not academically selective ( in N.Ireland for example there are still loads of grammars) so it really is all ability.
But what you do get is brillant teachers, diverse people and experiences and a wealth of talent and ability.
All the secondaries, bar one are rated the same - Good by Ofsted - but people are clamouring for private school places mainly I think because of the status for many MC, UMC families.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 20:34

'Would you really automatically exclude that whole group from being considered for employment '

We're stuffed at the seams with generations of privately educated and their offspring, so would absolutely take a state candidate over a privately educated one any day of the week.
So long as they fit the criteria - and they will.

Dulra · 17/04/2023 20:29

I'm from and living in Ireland married to an English man and have a sister with kids in a private school in the UK and my husband's nephews in private UK schools. I could not believe the private school fees my sister was paying. We have fee paying schools here but the fees would average €5 to 10k a year no where near your fees. Most are also in the cities so very little option for fee paying outside the cities unless they're boarding schools.

What I do query reading this thread is are your state schools really as bad as your making out? The difference in education between our state and fee paying is really down to smaller classroom size but not by much and maybe better sports facilities but educationally there's very little difference so it is often imo chosen for status rather than much else. Studies here have shown that kids from middle class and affluent areas will do just as well in their local state school as their privately educated peers living in the same area. In other words both have an advantage over their peers from disadvantaged communities and the school they go to has very little to do with it.

I was also wondering do you have "grind" schools? They have become very popular here and they are basically exam factories. You may send them for one or two years leading up to their Leaving cert (A levels). They do academics and nothing else and basically train kids to do exams from what I can see. Good option if you have a kid that needs high grades for their career choice but extremely academic. Again appear really unfair but are a more affordable option than paying school fees for 6 years which is the length of secondary school cycle

Dobby123456 · 17/04/2023 17:29

IAmTheWalrus85 · 17/04/2023 16:43

I’m grateful to families who choose private school - it’s because of them that we got our son into the outstanding local state comprehensive from the waiting list. We wouldn’t have got a place if people who were offered places hadn’t declined them in order to go private.

Also, I don’t see the issue with people who can afford it paying for services.

This was an issue for me. I began to genuinely feel a level of guilt at taking up a place in our outstanding local primary school when I knew we were going to go private at some point. If you have the money, why mess the state schools about?

thing47 · 17/04/2023 17:12

Around 20% of sixth formers go to private school so it’s not that niche

Lies, damned lies and statistics, though. If you were at state schools from 5-16 and then at a private school for less than 2 years to do your A levels, you are state-educated really, aren't you? I think the 7% figure is a more accurate one regarding the percentage who are privately educated.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 17/04/2023 16:43

I’m grateful to families who choose private school - it’s because of them that we got our son into the outstanding local state comprehensive from the waiting list. We wouldn’t have got a place if people who were offered places hadn’t declined them in order to go private.

Also, I don’t see the issue with people who can afford it paying for services.

Tabby87 · 17/04/2023 16:26

I went to a state school in a deprived area that I dropped out of at 16 when I developed a serious, long term illness. I'm on a relatively high salary now in a professional career (never been on benefits) and just spent £280K alone on my first house.

I've dated a few former private school boys and they all seemed bitter they hadn't achieved a lot. Not saying that's true for all, but they definitely felt like failures. One was on benefits and constantly repeating years at uni.

You get the IQ, drive and resilience you're born with. Throwing money at it is just nepotism - everyone knows including the student.

EssexMan55 · 17/04/2023 16:19

Mushroo · 12/04/2023 11:31

I agree with you OP. Inequality exists, it’s stupid to pretend otherwise.

Where I live, the choices for middle class families are move to an area where houses are £900k and aim for a state grammar.

Or stay where the houses are £500k and pay for private.

Both have privilege, and in some ways the £900k option more so as they retain equity in the house.

However, the £500k option is jumped on and demonised.

Both are highly privileged but treated differently.

In my experience many in the 900k camp are opposed to private schools and vote labour, without realising the hypocrisy.

xyxygy · 17/04/2023 16:14

Circe7 · 17/04/2023 15:59

@ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom
Around 20% of sixth formers go to private school so it’s not that niche. In Edinburgh 1 in 4 pupils are at private school. Would you really automatically exclude that whole group from being considered for employment because your perception is that they haven’t had a tough enough life to be employable (which is a strange criterion for employability).

I’m not sure about defining living in the real world as being only about going to state school. In my class at a selective girls’ day school, one student immigrated to the UK and had parents who spoke very little English so had to translate for them and work in their business; one tragically lost her mum at 15; one lived with her mum who worked in a supermarket and lived in relative poverty with a dad who funded school fees; one was adopted and was in care until age 14, 2 were on bursaries from families on under 30k household income; many more went through difficult life events like parents divorcing etc. Of course many girls were from very privileged backgrounds but I don’t think many fitted the stereotype you clearly have in your head. Standard was one parent who was a doctor/ dentist/ pilot and other who was teacher / social worker / lecturer etc.

Most people were smart at least in purely IQ terms (they IQ tested everyone at the school once and the average was 125).

The majority had completely normal Saturday jobs like working in shops or waitressing too.

Of course if you were looking at Eton the picture would be different.

Exactly. There's also another case which doesn't really get talked about - those like mine, for whom the state school environment is entirely unsuitable. I'm autistic, undiagnosed while at school, and I was bullied to hell at primary school; there is no evidence this would've been any different at secondary level in a state school (in fact, our local state schools had a habit of excluding anybody outside the norm as quickly as possible). The private school I went to on a scholarship, however, provided a safe and rich environment for me to discover myself both socially and academically. The teachers there were incredible, and had both the time and the resources (as well as the experience) to know that I was a bit different and help me figure out how to navigate the world, without ever using the word "autism" or trying to palm me off on the local "special school".

I'm not the only one, either - I know of many others who had the same experience, both at my school and elsewhere.

Had I gone to either of the state schools, there would have been precisely zero chance for me to have the life I have now. I was incredibly lucky to have had the opportunity, yes - but then, so are a lot of other kids these days, who'd be completely left behind by the system supposedly designed to help them.

Am I a private school snob? No, not at all. I've never once taken advantage of the name of my school or its background or its network, just the education it provided, and despite earning six figures and having a great life I'm basically seen as a bundle of wasted potential compared to most of my friends from there. Am I happy? Yes. Am I glad to have gone there? Absolutely.

Circe7 · 17/04/2023 15:59

@ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom
Around 20% of sixth formers go to private school so it’s not that niche. In Edinburgh 1 in 4 pupils are at private school. Would you really automatically exclude that whole group from being considered for employment because your perception is that they haven’t had a tough enough life to be employable (which is a strange criterion for employability).

I’m not sure about defining living in the real world as being only about going to state school. In my class at a selective girls’ day school, one student immigrated to the UK and had parents who spoke very little English so had to translate for them and work in their business; one tragically lost her mum at 15; one lived with her mum who worked in a supermarket and lived in relative poverty with a dad who funded school fees; one was adopted and was in care until age 14, 2 were on bursaries from families on under 30k household income; many more went through difficult life events like parents divorcing etc. Of course many girls were from very privileged backgrounds but I don’t think many fitted the stereotype you clearly have in your head. Standard was one parent who was a doctor/ dentist/ pilot and other who was teacher / social worker / lecturer etc.

Most people were smart at least in purely IQ terms (they IQ tested everyone at the school once and the average was 125).

The majority had completely normal Saturday jobs like working in shops or waitressing too.

Of course if you were looking at Eton the picture would be different.

Tuftytail · 17/04/2023 13:17

Also need to bear in mind that only a small percentage of that 7percent are from the top schools where nepotism may play a part in future careers. Kids from local private day schools are not necessarily more advantages than their neighbours kids in leafy suburbs who go to local comps and have parents with social and monetary capital.

Tuftytail · 17/04/2023 13:15

Absolutely agree but inclusion has to mean everyone and the best people for the job regardless of background.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 17/04/2023 11:58

'D and I policy means diversity and inclusivity i.e. everybody in. Whilst work needs to be done on breaking the public school stranglehold in some areas, to automatically exclude privately educated pupils is just another form of discrimination.'

Approx 93% of the population aren't going to be losing any sleep over any perceived 'discrimination' against public school grad. Not a single minute.
And as there IS a stranglehold that needs to be loosened, DE&I means NOT having the same old-same old faces, classes, schools anymore.

We need talent, not nepotism and privilege.

justasking111 · 17/04/2023 10:59

In our area there were three primary schools. They built a big one so shut two down. Unfortunately the New school wasn't big enough so they've divied up the children between the two remaining schools. The class sizes are pushing 40 because the catchment area has also increased. The education authority who had assured the head that new classrooms would be built, more teachers employed have reneged due to the cut backs .

They're looking to close another three schools to save money. So I can see the attraction of taking your kids out when despite a 10% rise in our council tax this year our school system in our county is in such dire straits financially.

Swipe left for the next trending thread