Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that private school parents are demonised?

665 replies

Imsorryyoufeelthatway · 12/04/2023 11:09

Starting this threat to vent and as an antidote to the Closing all private schools would benefit state schools thread. In short, I'm a bit fed up with private school parents being bashed for buying a better education for their children, while parents who 'don't believe in private education' and spend a fortune on homes/second homes/rental properties in catchment areas for 'good' state schools then another fortune on tutors seem to get off scot free.

I'm also fed up with private school parents all being lumped in the same category. We're not all selfish, mega-wealthy, Bullingdon Club (or female equivalent, if there was one...) alumni; many of us are ordinary people (I'm a working class lass from a council estate whose parents worked as cleaners and in warehouses) who've worked bloody hard to be able to afford a better start in life for our children than we had. We were the first people in our families to go to university (on full grants, when they existed), the first to have careers not just jobs, and the first to own our own homes. No-one has ever handed us a penny – my DH got the train to university with £4.50 in his pocket and had to get a job straight away to buy food. No bank account, no trust fund, no-one paying his rent. We've managed to achieve social mobility against the odds, yet we're not allowed to celebrate this because we've chosen to invest in our children's future rather than over-priced property in 'good' state school catchment areas.

Yes, we all know that private schools are a major cause of inequality. Parents like us have literally lived and breathed that inequality our whole lives and we'd do anything to prevent our children having to do the same. We think that all children should have access to high quality education in safe, inspirational environments where they can achieve their potential, not just ours. But most state schools in the UK just cannot meet this requirement. We also know that if catchment areas for state schools were mixed-up, and the schools in deprived areas had an influx of children from more affluent areas and vice versa, then this would likely make things more equal over time. But our children are not part of a social experiment. In short, if those of us who had difficult starts in life and went to terrible schools choose to work our arses off so our children don't have to, can't we be given some credit?

So please, the next time you're tempted to lump a private school parents into the same category and give them a bashing, take a moment to consider their reasons and background. Rant over.

OP posts:
Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:44

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 16:38

LOL. I was a child from a deprived background. I had a scholarship to one of these schools. It worked out brilliantly, and I know quite a number of kids for whom it did the same.

And, of course, you're moving the goalposts. First you say that scholarships can't cover all of the costs, so they won't work. Then, when an obvious solution is presented, you raise the nebulous "they need more help than these schools can offer".

This isn't designed to solve every problem that every child has ever had; it simply solves it for most of them, and then the focus can move onto the next largest group who need help.

The whole point is that it's a zero cost (to the taxpayer) solution which adds to the amount that can be spent per pupil in the state system, thus improving circumstances for everybody.

a) I was also a child from a poor background who went to a very very top private school on a scholarship. (I left at the end of year 11.)

b) It wasn't me who said the thing about covering all the costs. That was a different poster. I haven't moved the goalposts. I don't and have never thought that the sop of offering a few places to kids from disadvantaged backgrounds does anything at all meaningful to challenge the huge social inequalities that are deliberately perpetuated by the private school system. I think they're a distraction. A bit like Amazon Smile - huge huge company pays no tax and gives a pittance to charity as a sort of fig leaf.

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 16:43

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:36

That's also leaving aside the fact that when they have done things like this (e.g. Eton did a thing where some working-class, predominantly Black boys came to the school for a term or so) there is such a huge social and cultural gulf, and the posh kids, unsurprisingly, have inherited their parents' snobbery and social elitism. The boys who went there did not have a good time at all.

It's really really simplistic to boil a massive, long-term structure aimed specifically at perpetuating and deepening social inequality down to a simple matter of throwing a few quid at it.

Those schools exist IN ORDER to maintain and entrench the status quo. To challenge it would go fundamentally against why they were set up, and what the rich parents pay for.

It is never going to happen.

Weirdly, it has worked at the two local private schools (one for girls, one for boys) for well over 50 year, and I speak from experience when I say that the cultural gulf in normal private schools - ie not the ultra-elite ones like Eton - is much smaller than you're suggesting. In fact, since the scholarship kids are generally the smartest, they tend to be guaranteed a way in to most social groups due to the collaborative atmosphere that the schools encourage. Actual class-based tension is minimal - far less than between the kids at state schools whose parents prioritise designer-label clothes and the ones who can't afford it, in fact (as demonstrated by my daughter's experience at the state school in the same town).

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 16:38

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:33

It's not remotely 'easily solved'.

Like I said: A scholarship wouldn't touch the sides of what these children need. It's not just the financial costs, but the additional pastoral care and the development of all-round skills and personal development. Children from these backgrounds need far, far more help, and of a different type, than these schools can or will offer.

I think some of you have very little idea of what life is actually like for children from backgrounds like this. It's not solved with a bus ticket and a uniform fund.

LOL. I was a child from a deprived background. I had a scholarship to one of these schools. It worked out brilliantly, and I know quite a number of kids for whom it did the same.

And, of course, you're moving the goalposts. First you say that scholarships can't cover all of the costs, so they won't work. Then, when an obvious solution is presented, you raise the nebulous "they need more help than these schools can offer".

This isn't designed to solve every problem that every child has ever had; it simply solves it for most of them, and then the focus can move onto the next largest group who need help.

The whole point is that it's a zero cost (to the taxpayer) solution which adds to the amount that can be spent per pupil in the state system, thus improving circumstances for everybody.

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:36

That's also leaving aside the fact that when they have done things like this (e.g. Eton did a thing where some working-class, predominantly Black boys came to the school for a term or so) there is such a huge social and cultural gulf, and the posh kids, unsurprisingly, have inherited their parents' snobbery and social elitism. The boys who went there did not have a good time at all.

It's really really simplistic to boil a massive, long-term structure aimed specifically at perpetuating and deepening social inequality down to a simple matter of throwing a few quid at it.

Those schools exist IN ORDER to maintain and entrench the status quo. To challenge it would go fundamentally against why they were set up, and what the rich parents pay for.

It is never going to happen.

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:33

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 16:31

So...include it - the scholarships should include all costs above that of attending a state school (excluding the optional trips etc).

Easily solved, when you're setting the rules.

It's not remotely 'easily solved'.

Like I said: A scholarship wouldn't touch the sides of what these children need. It's not just the financial costs, but the additional pastoral care and the development of all-round skills and personal development. Children from these backgrounds need far, far more help, and of a different type, than these schools can or will offer.

I think some of you have very little idea of what life is actually like for children from backgrounds like this. It's not solved with a bus ticket and a uniform fund.

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:32

AskMeMore · 18/04/2023 16:28

Means tested scholarships do not reach the poorest. They would have to be 100% and include travel and uniform and equipment.

Yes. This.

A scholarship wouldn't touch the sides of what these children need. It's not just the financial costs, about which you are correct, but the additional pastoral care and the development of all-round skills and personal development. Children from these backgrounds need far, far more help, and of a different type, than these schools offer.

Children from chaotic homes and/or in the care system also tend to be moved around a lot through no choice of their own.

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 16:31

AskMeMore · 18/04/2023 16:28

Means tested scholarships do not reach the poorest. They would have to be 100% and include travel and uniform and equipment.

So...include it - the scholarships should include all costs above that of attending a state school (excluding the optional trips etc).

Easily solved, when you're setting the rules.

AskMeMore · 18/04/2023 16:29

There were quite a few children who passed the 11 plus in the past who did not go to grammar school as their families could not afford the usually more expensive uniform and extra travel.

AskMeMore · 18/04/2023 16:28

Means tested scholarships do not reach the poorest. They would have to be 100% and include travel and uniform and equipment.

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 16:21

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:08

It's definitely NOT by blind recruitment. It's by beginning to acknowledge the massive inequities and the fact that very mediocre people from privileged backgrounds have far greater success in life than very talented and intelligent people from deprived or chaotic backgrounds.

There is plenty of interesting and important work being done on social mobility right now. But I don't think most of the posters on this thread want it to be addressed.

And, as I said earlier, the best way to handle those talented people from deprived backgrounds is not to bring everybody down to the level of education the state deems cheap enough to get away with, but to enforce mandatory means-tested scholarships for 20-30% of the places they offer, paid for by the schools' charitable endowments, but keep the total level of funding the same for state schools.

That means some 20% increase in the per-pupil funding for state schools, and an immediate increase in social mobility for the genuinely bright and talented, at zero cost to the taxpayer.

Of course, that's the kind of policy that the political right would never implement, so it would require the ultra-left to relinquish their ideological stance for the good of all...which means it won't happen.

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:08

AutomaticRepliesTurnedOff · 18/04/2023 14:02

True. I am not sure how you design a system that does away completely with advantage.

It's definitely NOT by blind recruitment. It's by beginning to acknowledge the massive inequities and the fact that very mediocre people from privileged backgrounds have far greater success in life than very talented and intelligent people from deprived or chaotic backgrounds.

There is plenty of interesting and important work being done on social mobility right now. But I don't think most of the posters on this thread want it to be addressed.

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:04

Dobby123456 · 18/04/2023 14:58

The best way to make everything fair would be to do away with families altogether. They give children far too many advantages.

Is this supposed to be funny?

Yes, children raised within the care system or children who suffer major adverse childhood experiences are significantly disadvantaged throughout their lives. Why does this amuse you?

I'm sorry that this truth is inconvenient for you.

Dulra · 18/04/2023 15:56

The best way to make everything fair would be to do away with families altogether. They give children far too many advantages

I know you are being sarcastic but the point is it is a well researched area and the evidence demonstrates that early intervention is key if a state really wants to reduce the gap between the haves and have nots. Properly funded good quality early learning care and education, family support, parenting support, timely access to therapeutic supports, and so on. There is a lot that can be done to counteract the impact of poor parenting, abuse, poverty and so on but it is sporadic and not funded properly because the will with governments is simply not there and the rewards take too long for a government to benefit from. No use telling a politician invest in infants and the prison service will save money in 20 years time! By the time a child gets to secondary school it is often too late the gap is too wide. Supports need to be put in place when the child is born.

Dobby123456 · 18/04/2023 14:58

justasking111 · 18/04/2023 14:35

You can use blind recruitment but the children who are nurtered within a family unit of course have an advantage. They're taken to sports clubs, music tuition, rainbows, cubs, other hobbies, they're tucked up in bed at night with a story. As teenagers they're driven to weekend jobs at the oddest hours to encourage independence financially. They eat well are loved by parents, grandparents. Everyone cares about them. They will stand out on job applications.

The best way to make everything fair would be to do away with families altogether. They give children far too many advantages.

justasking111 · 18/04/2023 14:35

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 14:01

Blind recruitment isn't equitable though.

Those young people you describe have had every advantage. It's not as simple as tutoring or hothousing. They've had stable home lives, never had to worry about food on the table, they haven't had to become young carers, they haven't been moved around from one area to another within the care system, they haven't been chucked out of the care system aged 18 with no support network, they have money for interview outfits, flexibility to attend interviews whenever, confidence in themselves and the way they interact with people, they understand professional jobs and how to speak to people in those environments

The advantages that they have are HUGE. HUGE.

You can use blind recruitment but the children who are nurtered within a family unit of course have an advantage. They're taken to sports clubs, music tuition, rainbows, cubs, other hobbies, they're tucked up in bed at night with a story. As teenagers they're driven to weekend jobs at the oddest hours to encourage independence financially. They eat well are loved by parents, grandparents. Everyone cares about them. They will stand out on job applications.

Xenia · 18/04/2023 14:08

Automatic, I agree. Whether recruiting university blind the best people from whatever sector seem to come through.
I don't think the MN comments about law are always particularly fair. If you are recruiting an undergrade before they start very difficult law exams where 50% fail them and you will be paying for 1.5 years of more of very expensive law courses and exams and then train them for 2 years whilst paying them £40k a year you are probably putting about £250k on each student - quite a punt if you were betting on someone very likely to fail the law exams which is why looking at not only A level grades but first year exams in every module etc is required before they get offers. Same with medicine - the exams are very hard so you only want to admit to university courses those who are likely to pass.

I don't think most parents pay school fees for "status". I certainly never did. I just wanted a good school as did my parents for me and my siblings

The suggestion irish school fees are up to £10k - well yes, in England I have a sibling in Yorkshire and those fees are about £12k, not too different. Not eveyrone is at expensive London fee paying day schools or £40k a year boarding schools - although of course even £10,000 a year is a vast and impossible sum for most families.

Nor would most private school parents say a parent who could pay but chooses not to is damaging or taking the wrong decision for their child. Even our late Queen did not go to private school - she was educated at home - her parents' choice and a choice plenty of UK parents take too.

AutomaticRepliesTurnedOff · 18/04/2023 14:02

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 14:01

Blind recruitment isn't equitable though.

Those young people you describe have had every advantage. It's not as simple as tutoring or hothousing. They've had stable home lives, never had to worry about food on the table, they haven't had to become young carers, they haven't been moved around from one area to another within the care system, they haven't been chucked out of the care system aged 18 with no support network, they have money for interview outfits, flexibility to attend interviews whenever, confidence in themselves and the way they interact with people, they understand professional jobs and how to speak to people in those environments

The advantages that they have are HUGE. HUGE.

True. I am not sure how you design a system that does away completely with advantage.

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 14:01

AutomaticRepliesTurnedOff · 18/04/2023 05:01

I have no issue with blind recruitment. The kids I know here (London) who went to private day and grammar schools are phenomenally bright. Genuinely so, not just tutored and hothoused as some
like to think.

They have taken up places at magic circle firms anyway, regardless of their private school ‘disadvantage’, blind recruitment etc. So perhaps the bright and best will continue to get the top jobs regardless of their school, which is a good thing. We do need a level playing field though.

Blind recruitment isn't equitable though.

Those young people you describe have had every advantage. It's not as simple as tutoring or hothousing. They've had stable home lives, never had to worry about food on the table, they haven't had to become young carers, they haven't been moved around from one area to another within the care system, they haven't been chucked out of the care system aged 18 with no support network, they have money for interview outfits, flexibility to attend interviews whenever, confidence in themselves and the way they interact with people, they understand professional jobs and how to speak to people in those environments

The advantages that they have are HUGE. HUGE.

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 13:54

Dulra · 18/04/2023 13:50

The real trend is towards blind hiring not ‘anti-private schooling’. Increasingly that means removing all school detail off of resumes

I have never put my secondary school on any CV as an adult (over 18), possibly as a teenager looking for summer jobs. I have also sat on countless interview panels and never saw secondary school listed, maybe exam results and further education but not the actual school name. The fact that this was or is a thing in the UK does explain a lot about the obsession with private schooling. Our third level institutions also don't interview for courses, places are accessed solely by exam results so they do not know what schools their students were in.

To my knowledge, it was only ever really a thing in case anything needed to be verified with the school. Same for university. No different to the employment history, really.

Dulra · 18/04/2023 13:50

The real trend is towards blind hiring not ‘anti-private schooling’. Increasingly that means removing all school detail off of resumes

I have never put my secondary school on any CV as an adult (over 18), possibly as a teenager looking for summer jobs. I have also sat on countless interview panels and never saw secondary school listed, maybe exam results and further education but not the actual school name. The fact that this was or is a thing in the UK does explain a lot about the obsession with private schooling. Our third level institutions also don't interview for courses, places are accessed solely by exam results so they do not know what schools their students were in.

Dobby123456 · 18/04/2023 07:14

rowanoak · 18/04/2023 05:54

I agree. Everyone has opinions; who cares what someone else thinks??

We don't pay for private school for our children even though we could afford to, as we don't believe it's what's best for them or for society and because we're not ultra rich, we prefer to use our money to travel and have real world learning experiences and spend time with them.

I have had people tell me that I'm not caring about my children's future or educations enough. To those people I say, "Who the F asked you?"

Because it's not of their business and their opinion means about as much to me as the next person's or maybe even less if they rudely offer it unsolicited or in obvious judgment of me.

You choose to give your children a private education and that's your prerogative so I'm fine with that and even if I wasn't, I would never butt in and tell you my useless opinion unless maybe you asked, because then I'd be the one looking like an idiot. But really who am I to say how other people should educate their own children? Why would I care unless I wasn't comfortable with my own choice?

So, I too wonder why OP would care so much. It seems to me they are not truly comfortable with their choice like you are.

Some parents are really good at getting the best out of their kids themselves. Get them into reading, take them places, get them to do their homework etc. I would never tell somebody they didn't care about their kids education because they didn't use private school. How rude!

rowanoak · 18/04/2023 05:54

I agree. Everyone has opinions; who cares what someone else thinks??

We don't pay for private school for our children even though we could afford to, as we don't believe it's what's best for them or for society and because we're not ultra rich, we prefer to use our money to travel and have real world learning experiences and spend time with them.

I have had people tell me that I'm not caring about my children's future or educations enough. To those people I say, "Who the F asked you?"

Because it's not of their business and their opinion means about as much to me as the next person's or maybe even less if they rudely offer it unsolicited or in obvious judgment of me.

You choose to give your children a private education and that's your prerogative so I'm fine with that and even if I wasn't, I would never butt in and tell you my useless opinion unless maybe you asked, because then I'd be the one looking like an idiot. But really who am I to say how other people should educate their own children? Why would I care unless I wasn't comfortable with my own choice?

So, I too wonder why OP would care so much. It seems to me they are not truly comfortable with their choice like you are.

AutomaticRepliesTurnedOff · 18/04/2023 05:01

I have no issue with blind recruitment. The kids I know here (London) who went to private day and grammar schools are phenomenally bright. Genuinely so, not just tutored and hothoused as some
like to think.

They have taken up places at magic circle firms anyway, regardless of their private school ‘disadvantage’, blind recruitment etc. So perhaps the bright and best will continue to get the top jobs regardless of their school, which is a good thing. We do need a level playing field though.

AutomaticRepliesTurnedOff · 18/04/2023 04:57

Dulra · 17/04/2023 20:29

I'm from and living in Ireland married to an English man and have a sister with kids in a private school in the UK and my husband's nephews in private UK schools. I could not believe the private school fees my sister was paying. We have fee paying schools here but the fees would average €5 to 10k a year no where near your fees. Most are also in the cities so very little option for fee paying outside the cities unless they're boarding schools.

What I do query reading this thread is are your state schools really as bad as your making out? The difference in education between our state and fee paying is really down to smaller classroom size but not by much and maybe better sports facilities but educationally there's very little difference so it is often imo chosen for status rather than much else. Studies here have shown that kids from middle class and affluent areas will do just as well in their local state school as their privately educated peers living in the same area. In other words both have an advantage over their peers from disadvantaged communities and the school they go to has very little to do with it.

I was also wondering do you have "grind" schools? They have become very popular here and they are basically exam factories. You may send them for one or two years leading up to their Leaving cert (A levels). They do academics and nothing else and basically train kids to do exams from what I can see. Good option if you have a kid that needs high grades for their career choice but extremely academic. Again appear really unfair but are a more affordable option than paying school fees for 6 years which is the length of secondary school cycle

If you read any thread about the teachers’ strike, the state sector is in big trouble. No money for stationery, school roofs leaking, class sizes unmanageable and unhappy teachers leaving in their hundreds. It’s odd that that narrative disappears in threads about private school.

SmartHome · 18/04/2023 00:10

Yep, same here. Institution blind is the way to go. Then we can really assess people on their character, knowledge and skill without and ridiculous preconceived notions about how what their parents did or did not do to try and do their best for thier kids makes them automatically a dick. Unlike, say, Kier Starmer who lies about being privately educated.