Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that private school parents are demonised?

665 replies

Imsorryyoufeelthatway · 12/04/2023 11:09

Starting this threat to vent and as an antidote to the Closing all private schools would benefit state schools thread. In short, I'm a bit fed up with private school parents being bashed for buying a better education for their children, while parents who 'don't believe in private education' and spend a fortune on homes/second homes/rental properties in catchment areas for 'good' state schools then another fortune on tutors seem to get off scot free.

I'm also fed up with private school parents all being lumped in the same category. We're not all selfish, mega-wealthy, Bullingdon Club (or female equivalent, if there was one...) alumni; many of us are ordinary people (I'm a working class lass from a council estate whose parents worked as cleaners and in warehouses) who've worked bloody hard to be able to afford a better start in life for our children than we had. We were the first people in our families to go to university (on full grants, when they existed), the first to have careers not just jobs, and the first to own our own homes. No-one has ever handed us a penny – my DH got the train to university with £4.50 in his pocket and had to get a job straight away to buy food. No bank account, no trust fund, no-one paying his rent. We've managed to achieve social mobility against the odds, yet we're not allowed to celebrate this because we've chosen to invest in our children's future rather than over-priced property in 'good' state school catchment areas.

Yes, we all know that private schools are a major cause of inequality. Parents like us have literally lived and breathed that inequality our whole lives and we'd do anything to prevent our children having to do the same. We think that all children should have access to high quality education in safe, inspirational environments where they can achieve their potential, not just ours. But most state schools in the UK just cannot meet this requirement. We also know that if catchment areas for state schools were mixed-up, and the schools in deprived areas had an influx of children from more affluent areas and vice versa, then this would likely make things more equal over time. But our children are not part of a social experiment. In short, if those of us who had difficult starts in life and went to terrible schools choose to work our arses off so our children don't have to, can't we be given some credit?

So please, the next time you're tempted to lump a private school parents into the same category and give them a bashing, take a moment to consider their reasons and background. Rant over.

OP posts:
Lapland123 · 18/04/2023 20:36

Xenia · 18/04/2023 20:31

I am happy for people to make choices. If people as said above think less of those who pay schools but themselves could afford to pay there is an argument the other way - that 500,000 children's parents (fee paying number) save the state £8k a year or whatever a state palce costs they are heroes of the nation who should perhaps get free university education in return as they have saved the state and the less well off so much money. They shgould get prizes for their good citizenship.

I would like to sign that petition, free uni if you paid school fees!

Xenia · 18/04/2023 20:31

I am happy for people to make choices. If people as said above think less of those who pay schools but themselves could afford to pay there is an argument the other way - that 500,000 children's parents (fee paying number) save the state £8k a year or whatever a state palce costs they are heroes of the nation who should perhaps get free university education in return as they have saved the state and the less well off so much money. They shgould get prizes for their good citizenship.

danesch · 18/04/2023 19:52

@Nimrode Fair enough.

I can assure you I don't despise my friends. I think it's possible to hold different values and maintain a friendship.

I may not be expressing myself terribly well. I think it's possible to disagree with private education without being a horrible judgemental person, as I do. I think it's possible to choose private education without being a horrible person, as some of my friends have. I wouldn't/haven't done so myself because it doesn't align with my values (or tbf, financial priorities).

Nimrode · 18/04/2023 19:30

danesch · 18/04/2023 19:08

@Nimrode - I actually think we're agreeing with each other in a way. I'm saying they can do what they like, and I can think what I like! I think it's possible to coexist as friends and not approve of all each other's choices. I was saying it's possible to disagree with private schooling without demonising anyone.

I don't think we are. You are saying you think 'a little less' of your friends for choosing private schools. You've also said There's often a, 'why this made sense in our particular circumstance' justification for choosing private education, as you've given, OP which implies, you are not buying it or their reasons are not compelling enough in your opinion.

In a way, you are looking down / eye rolling (for want of a better word) at their reasons and choices. Why are you even friends with these people whom you seem to despise, even though you say, you only judge them 'a little'?

Margrethe · 18/04/2023 19:17

The only problem with private schools is that not everyone can access then. Perhaps some sort of voucher scheme would widen parent choice?

There is nothing immoral about spending money on one’s children’s education. It’s much better than buying most other expensive things. Education is a positive good and it is a parent’s responsibility.

It’s expensive, and that why we make a good version available for free funded by the tax payer. If a parent wants something else and is prepared to pay that’s their shout.

danesch · 18/04/2023 19:14

@Lapland123 Maybe 'judge' is too harsh a word for it in day to day life - see what other people are doing and how that reflects on their values (as you see it) and how their (perceived) values chime with your own. And people tend to adopt stronger positions/more extreme versions of their own views on an anonymous forum such as this. To be fair, that's probably what the OP was doing by talking about feeling 'demonised', which was the thing that grated for me about the post.

danesch · 18/04/2023 19:08

@Nimrode - I actually think we're agreeing with each other in a way. I'm saying they can do what they like, and I can think what I like! I think it's possible to coexist as friends and not approve of all each other's choices. I was saying it's possible to disagree with private schooling without demonising anyone.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 18/04/2023 19:08

team Private school

🙄

GloriousSunshine · 18/04/2023 19:04

Just to say, I’m team Private school and agree 100% with you OP!

Lapland123 · 18/04/2023 19:00

danesch · 18/04/2023 18:15

You're entitled to send your child to private school. I'm entitled to judge you for it. Which I do - in the same mild way that I judge all sorts of choices people make (I definitely would describe it as demonizing).

I have friends who've chosen to send their kids to private schools, and I do honestly think a little bit less of them for it. But only a bit - it doesn't mean I dislike them.

There's often a 'why this made sense in our particular circumstance' justification for choosing private education, as you've given, OP. We all make choices which we think make sense for our circumstances every day. We make those choices according to our options and our values. For many people, private school wouldn't be an option and/or would go against their values.

This reads like such nonsense.
Do you judge anyone for buying a nicer car, more exotic holiday, sharper haircut than you?!!!
What a bore you sound, judging people spending their own hard earned post tax income in whatever way they like

Nimrode · 18/04/2023 18:57

danesch · 18/04/2023 18:15

You're entitled to send your child to private school. I'm entitled to judge you for it. Which I do - in the same mild way that I judge all sorts of choices people make (I definitely would describe it as demonizing).

I have friends who've chosen to send their kids to private schools, and I do honestly think a little bit less of them for it. But only a bit - it doesn't mean I dislike them.

There's often a 'why this made sense in our particular circumstance' justification for choosing private education, as you've given, OP. We all make choices which we think make sense for our circumstances every day. We make those choices according to our options and our values. For many people, private school wouldn't be an option and/or would go against their values.

Why on earth do your 'friends', have to justify their reasons to you. Their reasons are their reasons, it's irrelevant what you or anyone else thinks of it.

Dobby123456 · 18/04/2023 18:43

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:04

Is this supposed to be funny?

Yes, children raised within the care system or children who suffer major adverse childhood experiences are significantly disadvantaged throughout their lives. Why does this amuse you?

I'm sorry that this truth is inconvenient for you.

Your attempts to make me feel guilty just aren't going to work. I know that I and the other parents work very long hours doing our best to make sure people get the best health care, education, welfare etc. that we can offer. We also pay very high taxes. Knowing our own kuds and getting the best care possible while we get on with our jobs helps us to do well at work. It's not an ideal system, and not how I'd like it, but we're doing nothing wrong.

Dobby123456 · 18/04/2023 18:24

Dobby123456 · 18/04/2023 18:17

Well, yes that's why families exist and try to do the best for the children they have or have adopted or fostered. The result for the children who don't get that is often grim. But there's only a certain amount 'what ifing' an employer can do. If a candidate doesn't have the background and skills to make them suitable for the job, the employer isn't going to be able to make up fir the lack of parenting.

Oops sorry! Quoted the wrong poster! Yes, I entirely agree. As I said upthread, this country needs to invest in early years. Early intervention is the key, as opposed to trying to fix the problem later at job recruitment stage.

Dobby123456 · 18/04/2023 18:17

Dulra · 18/04/2023 15:56

The best way to make everything fair would be to do away with families altogether. They give children far too many advantages

I know you are being sarcastic but the point is it is a well researched area and the evidence demonstrates that early intervention is key if a state really wants to reduce the gap between the haves and have nots. Properly funded good quality early learning care and education, family support, parenting support, timely access to therapeutic supports, and so on. There is a lot that can be done to counteract the impact of poor parenting, abuse, poverty and so on but it is sporadic and not funded properly because the will with governments is simply not there and the rewards take too long for a government to benefit from. No use telling a politician invest in infants and the prison service will save money in 20 years time! By the time a child gets to secondary school it is often too late the gap is too wide. Supports need to be put in place when the child is born.

Well, yes that's why families exist and try to do the best for the children they have or have adopted or fostered. The result for the children who don't get that is often grim. But there's only a certain amount 'what ifing' an employer can do. If a candidate doesn't have the background and skills to make them suitable for the job, the employer isn't going to be able to make up fir the lack of parenting.

danesch · 18/04/2023 18:15

You're entitled to send your child to private school. I'm entitled to judge you for it. Which I do - in the same mild way that I judge all sorts of choices people make (I definitely would describe it as demonizing).

I have friends who've chosen to send their kids to private schools, and I do honestly think a little bit less of them for it. But only a bit - it doesn't mean I dislike them.

There's often a 'why this made sense in our particular circumstance' justification for choosing private education, as you've given, OP. We all make choices which we think make sense for our circumstances every day. We make those choices according to our options and our values. For many people, private school wouldn't be an option and/or would go against their values.

faffadoodledo · 18/04/2023 17:48

Absolutely @user68901 !
All the kids I know who go or went to private school had lovely houses and holidays and often ponies too! And gosh, shock, some were tutored.

Really OP - just bloody own the fact that that's how you want to spend your money!

In fact OP hasn't come back so is either a troll or a journalist!

user68901 · 18/04/2023 17:41

Keep seeing this nonsense said over and over …..
people who send their kids to private school live in the cheap houses in rubbish area and those who go to good state schools are living in the ££££ house next to the school 😂
where i am the private kids are definitely in the best houses !!! Even ones near the good comp. Anyway op can spend her cash however she wants i dont care but this argument about houses bugs the shit out of me

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 17:31

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 17:22

Yes, that's exactly what I'd call it.

It's interesting that you state so confidently that private schools could never be abolished. That tells you a lot about how integral they are to maintaining the class system and the class divide in this country- the fact that abolishing them is unimaginable.

I'm saying they could never be abolished because a) any such law would have such massive and wide-reaching consequences for extracurricular tutoring, private training courses ( like coding bootcamps) etc that it would be completely unworkable, and b) if the government wanted to convert those schools to state schools, they wouldn't be able to afford to buy the properties or the staff back. As an example, I know of at least five private schools within 40 miles of here which own significant portions of the land in and around the towns they occupy, and have done so for hundreds of years.

The sheer logistics are simply beyond the reach of any non-authoritarian government at this point. Hence my suggestion of using their existence to improve everybody's lot, instead of sticking to an ideological proposition and benefiting nobody.

PauseTheRain · 18/04/2023 17:30

OP, I don't think parents should be demonised. I do think state schools need to be improved. I'm grateful to those who do send their kids private as state schools are already creaking and held together with sellotape.

I think parents who send kids to private school should get tax relief on fees as they are directly saving the state money, same as I think those who pay for private healthcare should get relief. Given where we are with state schools, I'm more for decreasing the chasm between who can afford it and who can't, rather than increasing it. Many parents want the best education/school they can get for their kids, otherwise everyone would not give a toss which school choice they got. My kids are not in private school.

moomoomoo27 · 18/04/2023 17:23

Namechanger355 · 12/04/2023 13:47

@moomoomoo27 this is a bit of a generalisation! Rishi went to Winchester which is one of the best boys schools in the country - and a public school

most private schools are not like this! They have working parents who can afford to pay a little extra per month

everyone I've ever met from a private school has been like that.

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 17:22

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 17:16

Well, I'm sorry that your school dealt with it very poorly.

The difference between us, though, is that your experience appears to say "Don't do scholarships, they never work because of my limited experience, in fact, abolish that whole system so nobody else can ever have the advantage of opportunity that I had".

On the other hand, I'm saying "It can and does work for a lot of people, even if it's not all of them, so let's try it and in the process improve state schools for everyone else".

Evidence tends to support one of those, but not the other.

What I'm suggesting would result in a 15-20% increase in per-pupil spending in the state system at zero cost to the tax payer; in fact it's explicitly taking that increase from the private school system (which will never be abolished anyway, no matter how much you want it to be). I wouldn't call that a fig leaf, would you?

Yes, that's exactly what I'd call it.

It's interesting that you state so confidently that private schools could never be abolished. That tells you a lot about how integral they are to maintaining the class system and the class divide in this country- the fact that abolishing them is unimaginable.

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 17:20

Xenia · 18/04/2023 17:15

The xyx scheme was the assisted places scheme Labour abolished so in a sense already tried. Labour felt it did not work as middle class people would pretend to be self employed with low wages to nab all the places on the schemes.
We could certaily start by equality in the state system - eg Newcastle where I am from abolished grammar schools in about 1970. Some other areas still have them. We could ensure "state education" meant the same thing in all parts of the UK for starers.

On being poor at fee paying schools do children really know? My daughters had a horse each (horses mentioned above on thread) but it was utterly irrelevant if a friend at school had very little.
Also designer labels are surely something the new rich show off about and that is not the done thing for most people in private schools - although I am not saying no class has class identifiers in the UK as they certainly do.

It's absolutely not irrelevant (and I think I remember from previous threads that your daughter attended the same school I did).

I'm sure it suited you to think it was all lovely and everyone equal and it was "utterly irrelevant" that your daughter had horses and no doubt expensive holidays, clothes, etc. It's not irrelevant if you're on the other end of it.

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 17:16

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:48

I speak from experience when I say that the cultural gulf in normal private schools - ie not the ultra-elite ones like Eton - is much smaller than you're suggesting. In fact, since the scholarship kids are generally the smartest, they tend to be guaranteed a way in to most social groups due to the collaborative atmosphere that the schools encourage.

My experience, as one of those very smart, not well-off, scholarship kids was that the cultural gulf was huge. And it wasn't Eton or anywhere like that - it's a top all-girls London independent school, very academic.

I agree that the scholarship girls were the brightest, and also the poorest. It was glaringly obvious who had money and who didn't. There were girls in my class who had tennis courts, swimming pools, ponies, etc.

My own kids are at state schools (one primary, one secondary) and I haven't encountered any of the 'prioritising designer labels' that you describe. Funnily enough, several of my daughter's schoolmates are the children of women who went to my school, who have also decided to opt out of the private school system, for a variety of reasons.

In any case, like I say, even if it worked brilliantly for a tiny number of working-class kids, it's a fig leaf to cover up the far greater inequalities that the system is designed to entrench.

Well, I'm sorry that your school dealt with it very poorly.

The difference between us, though, is that your experience appears to say "Don't do scholarships, they never work because of my limited experience, in fact, abolish that whole system so nobody else can ever have the advantage of opportunity that I had".

On the other hand, I'm saying "It can and does work for a lot of people, even if it's not all of them, so let's try it and in the process improve state schools for everyone else".

Evidence tends to support one of those, but not the other.

What I'm suggesting would result in a 15-20% increase in per-pupil spending in the state system at zero cost to the tax payer; in fact it's explicitly taking that increase from the private school system (which will never be abolished anyway, no matter how much you want it to be). I wouldn't call that a fig leaf, would you?

Xenia · 18/04/2023 17:15

The xyx scheme was the assisted places scheme Labour abolished so in a sense already tried. Labour felt it did not work as middle class people would pretend to be self employed with low wages to nab all the places on the schemes.
We could certaily start by equality in the state system - eg Newcastle where I am from abolished grammar schools in about 1970. Some other areas still have them. We could ensure "state education" meant the same thing in all parts of the UK for starers.

On being poor at fee paying schools do children really know? My daughters had a horse each (horses mentioned above on thread) but it was utterly irrelevant if a friend at school had very little.
Also designer labels are surely something the new rich show off about and that is not the done thing for most people in private schools - although I am not saying no class has class identifiers in the UK as they certainly do.

Bamboux · 18/04/2023 16:48

xyxygy · 18/04/2023 16:43

Weirdly, it has worked at the two local private schools (one for girls, one for boys) for well over 50 year, and I speak from experience when I say that the cultural gulf in normal private schools - ie not the ultra-elite ones like Eton - is much smaller than you're suggesting. In fact, since the scholarship kids are generally the smartest, they tend to be guaranteed a way in to most social groups due to the collaborative atmosphere that the schools encourage. Actual class-based tension is minimal - far less than between the kids at state schools whose parents prioritise designer-label clothes and the ones who can't afford it, in fact (as demonstrated by my daughter's experience at the state school in the same town).

I speak from experience when I say that the cultural gulf in normal private schools - ie not the ultra-elite ones like Eton - is much smaller than you're suggesting. In fact, since the scholarship kids are generally the smartest, they tend to be guaranteed a way in to most social groups due to the collaborative atmosphere that the schools encourage.

My experience, as one of those very smart, not well-off, scholarship kids was that the cultural gulf was huge. And it wasn't Eton or anywhere like that - it's a top all-girls London independent school, very academic.

I agree that the scholarship girls were the brightest, and also the poorest. It was glaringly obvious who had money and who didn't. There were girls in my class who had tennis courts, swimming pools, ponies, etc.

My own kids are at state schools (one primary, one secondary) and I haven't encountered any of the 'prioritising designer labels' that you describe. Funnily enough, several of my daughter's schoolmates are the children of women who went to my school, who have also decided to opt out of the private school system, for a variety of reasons.

In any case, like I say, even if it worked brilliantly for a tiny number of working-class kids, it's a fig leaf to cover up the far greater inequalities that the system is designed to entrench.