Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that private school parents are demonised?

665 replies

Imsorryyoufeelthatway · 12/04/2023 11:09

Starting this threat to vent and as an antidote to the Closing all private schools would benefit state schools thread. In short, I'm a bit fed up with private school parents being bashed for buying a better education for their children, while parents who 'don't believe in private education' and spend a fortune on homes/second homes/rental properties in catchment areas for 'good' state schools then another fortune on tutors seem to get off scot free.

I'm also fed up with private school parents all being lumped in the same category. We're not all selfish, mega-wealthy, Bullingdon Club (or female equivalent, if there was one...) alumni; many of us are ordinary people (I'm a working class lass from a council estate whose parents worked as cleaners and in warehouses) who've worked bloody hard to be able to afford a better start in life for our children than we had. We were the first people in our families to go to university (on full grants, when they existed), the first to have careers not just jobs, and the first to own our own homes. No-one has ever handed us a penny – my DH got the train to university with £4.50 in his pocket and had to get a job straight away to buy food. No bank account, no trust fund, no-one paying his rent. We've managed to achieve social mobility against the odds, yet we're not allowed to celebrate this because we've chosen to invest in our children's future rather than over-priced property in 'good' state school catchment areas.

Yes, we all know that private schools are a major cause of inequality. Parents like us have literally lived and breathed that inequality our whole lives and we'd do anything to prevent our children having to do the same. We think that all children should have access to high quality education in safe, inspirational environments where they can achieve their potential, not just ours. But most state schools in the UK just cannot meet this requirement. We also know that if catchment areas for state schools were mixed-up, and the schools in deprived areas had an influx of children from more affluent areas and vice versa, then this would likely make things more equal over time. But our children are not part of a social experiment. In short, if those of us who had difficult starts in life and went to terrible schools choose to work our arses off so our children don't have to, can't we be given some credit?

So please, the next time you're tempted to lump a private school parents into the same category and give them a bashing, take a moment to consider their reasons and background. Rant over.

OP posts:
Wenfy · 21/04/2023 16:05

Jonei · 21/04/2023 14:45

Resources, yes. Teachers? How are you concluding that? Surely if they were that good, they'd be in a comp on a run down estate working miracles

I don't think teachers are any better in private education. Their job is probably easier if they don't need to deal with classroom management. Which doesn't make them any better, but in some ways makes them less skilled, including being less able to teach a variety of children with very different learning needs.

The best public and private schools keep an eye on results in other schools (including state schools) and head hunt teachers and support staff who are specialists in their area. The computer science teacher at DD’s school is an IT consultant with 20 years experience in finance - she works at the school for lowish pay (and 10% fee discounts) because they’re sponsoring her work permit and teaching qualification.

Hobbi · 21/04/2023 15:59

@Blondewithredlips

If you think state schools are not 'results driven', then you really have no knowledge of education in England. The point remains, you cannot have any reason to think the teachers in private are better, other than a need to justify the ridiculous fees. To fulfil their 'charitable' status they could easily go and demonstrate their superior skills in Friday afternoon double maths, in a local comp.

Wenfy · 21/04/2023 15:53

Blondewithredlips · 21/04/2023 13:32

I saw an article years ago that argued that privately educated children are more likely to struggle at university as they have had so much help at private school.
I would be reporting that academic.

The data set you’re referring to, I think, actually says private school kids are more likely to go to university and get accepted at the top universities / top jobs than State kids (including State grammar kids) even with lower grades.

Blondewithredlips · 21/04/2023 15:48

Hobbi · 21/04/2023 14:57

@Blondewithredlips

"Why would a good teacher work in a run down comp as a choice? Better pay and conditions at private school and cheaper fees for their children"

Again, then how on earth are you concluding that they're better teachers?

Because private schools are results driven. No way would a bad maths teacher be tolerated as it would impact on results.

Hobbi · 21/04/2023 15:01

Jonei · 21/04/2023 14:45

Resources, yes. Teachers? How are you concluding that? Surely if they were that good, they'd be in a comp on a run down estate working miracles

I don't think teachers are any better in private education. Their job is probably easier if they don't need to deal with classroom management. Which doesn't make them any better, but in some ways makes them less skilled, including being less able to teach a variety of children with very different learning needs.

Correct. Any research done with this in mind finds that teachers from 'ordinary' schools can teach comfortably in private whereas teachers in private find the classroom management, differentiation and pastoral requirements of state school overwhelming. They often don't have QTS so haven't even proved themselves in more than one school against the teacher standards.

Hobbi · 21/04/2023 14:57

@Blondewithredlips

"Why would a good teacher work in a run down comp as a choice? Better pay and conditions at private school and cheaper fees for their children"

Again, then how on earth are you concluding that they're better teachers?

Labraradabrador · 21/04/2023 14:51

Dobby123456 · 21/04/2023 13:59

This type of thread is very revaling. What it shows is the number of people who simply see education as a means of getting grades, which are a ticket to success. Anybody who pays for it is 'buyin an unfair advantage'. Not much idea of education being of any value more broadly, or desire to improve it for everybody. Says a lot about why Britain is so behind in education compared to other countries.

Totally agree with this

Jonei · 21/04/2023 14:45

Resources, yes. Teachers? How are you concluding that? Surely if they were that good, they'd be in a comp on a run down estate working miracles

I don't think teachers are any better in private education. Their job is probably easier if they don't need to deal with classroom management. Which doesn't make them any better, but in some ways makes them less skilled, including being less able to teach a variety of children with very different learning needs.

Blondewithredlips · 21/04/2023 14:21

Hobbi · 21/04/2023 14:15

@Blondewithredlips
"There is no equal playing field. Privately educated get the best teachers and resources."

Resources, yes. Teachers? How are you concluding that? Surely if they were that good, they'd be in a comp on a run down estate working miracles?

Why would a good teacher work in a run down comp as a choice? Better pay and conditions at private school and cheaper fees for their children.

Hobbi · 21/04/2023 14:15

@Blondewithredlips
"There is no equal playing field. Privately educated get the best teachers and resources."

Resources, yes. Teachers? How are you concluding that? Surely if they were that good, they'd be in a comp on a run down estate working miracles?

Dobby123456 · 21/04/2023 13:59

This type of thread is very revaling. What it shows is the number of people who simply see education as a means of getting grades, which are a ticket to success. Anybody who pays for it is 'buyin an unfair advantage'. Not much idea of education being of any value more broadly, or desire to improve it for everybody. Says a lot about why Britain is so behind in education compared to other countries.

Dobby123456 · 21/04/2023 13:48

Blondewithredlips · 21/04/2023 13:35

There is no equal playing field. Privately educated get the best teachers and resources.
My children came out with A* AA with no extra tuition.

I didn't say it was level, that's why top universities weight excellent results from schools that don't normally get students through at that level. But you can't buy the grade, any more than paying for music lessons can buy you a musical child.

Blondewithredlips · 21/04/2023 13:35

Dobby123456 · 20/04/2023 11:11

You do realise that private school can't actually buy you the grade, right? The kid still has to do the work.

A friend of mine is a teacher at secondary private and says the most annoying thing is the parents who think they are buying an A grade. Just won't accept that their child just doesn't have the motivation or ability in that subject.

There is no equal playing field. Privately educated get the best teachers and resources.
My children came out with A* AA with no extra tuition.

Blondewithredlips · 21/04/2023 13:32

faffadoodledo · 20/04/2023 13:10

DS had an interview at an Oxbridge college where he was asked which school he went to. When he replied (an unknown comp in the back end of beyond) the interviewer visibly rolled his eyes and asked how on earth DS thought he would cope with the work.
He was interviewed elsewhere too and got a place. But there was an academic who very definitely had a problem with the sort of education DS had received. Fortunately DS was pig headed and knew his worth!
Sadly sh2t like that still happens. Hopefully less frequently these days. And of course the system of getting interviewed at more than one college is helpful.

I saw an article years ago that argued that privately educated children are more likely to struggle at university as they have had so much help at private school.
I would be reporting that academic.

Dobby123456 · 20/04/2023 17:10

Bamboux · 20/04/2023 17:04

OK then. What exactly is it that you meant when you said that @Xenia 's post 'had some truth to it'?

OK. Maybe she wasn't joking! But what she says has some truth to it

Which was in relation to this post:

I am happy for people to make choices. If people as said above think less of those who pay schools but themselves could afford to pay there is an argument the other way - that 500,000 children's parents (fee paying number) save the state £8k a year or whatever a state palce costs they are heroes of the nation who should perhaps get free university education in return as they have saved the state and the less well off so much money. They shgould get prizes for their good citizenship.

Which part of that is it that you think is true?

The bit about saving the state money, obviously. The source of her annoyance seems to be that she doesn't think the state is spending her taxes very well, or providing good services. Not entirely unreasonable.

Bamboux · 20/04/2023 17:04

Dobby123456 · 20/04/2023 15:44

Have you seen the tweets coming from academics at Cambridge recently? And Oxbridge isn't the only top university, you know ....

But this isn't really a conversation. It's just you expressing your prejudices and sneering at everybody who suggests the picture might not quite be the way you paint it.

OK then. What exactly is it that you meant when you said that @Xenia 's post 'had some truth to it'?

OK. Maybe she wasn't joking! But what she says has some truth to it

Which was in relation to this post:

I am happy for people to make choices. If people as said above think less of those who pay schools but themselves could afford to pay there is an argument the other way - that 500,000 children's parents (fee paying number) save the state £8k a year or whatever a state palce costs they are heroes of the nation who should perhaps get free university education in return as they have saved the state and the less well off so much money. They shgould get prizes for their good citizenship.

Which part of that is it that you think is true?

Dobby123456 · 20/04/2023 15:44

Bamboux · 20/04/2023 15:29

What is it you think I'm 'bitter' about?

It's very sweet that you think Oxbridge dons are 'very left wing' and 'not impressed by posh schools'. Haha. No one is that naive, are they?

Have you seen the tweets coming from academics at Cambridge recently? And Oxbridge isn't the only top university, you know ....

But this isn't really a conversation. It's just you expressing your prejudices and sneering at everybody who suggests the picture might not quite be the way you paint it.

Bamboux · 20/04/2023 15:29

Dobby123456 · 20/04/2023 13:02

No, that is not what I actually think at all, which I've made quite clear. You want that to be what I think so that you can feel justified in your own bitterness and self-righteousness.

What is it you think I'm 'bitter' about?

It's very sweet that you think Oxbridge dons are 'very left wing' and 'not impressed by posh schools'. Haha. No one is that naive, are they?

Dobby123456 · 20/04/2023 14:25

faffadoodledo · 20/04/2023 14:05

He did, thanks @Dobby123456
Strangely my DH was an undergrad there in the 80s and says he felt his route in was far smoother than DS's (from a similar educational background). He says his entry was definitely a case of raw talent being spotted and grabbed. I don't know what the figures for state/private say from 2015 compared with 1980. That's just his impression. I think though the figures need proper definition because state school can denote a whole range - from highly selective (and tutored) grammar to the boggest of bog standard!

And anyway, Oxbridge isn't necessarily a marker of success. DD is doing far 'better' than DS, and she was a reject!

Perhaps a change has occurred because the grammar school educated old guard have retired and been replaced with more private school? Just a guess. I've no idea. Would be a pity.

faffadoodledo · 20/04/2023 14:05

He did, thanks @Dobby123456
Strangely my DH was an undergrad there in the 80s and says he felt his route in was far smoother than DS's (from a similar educational background). He says his entry was definitely a case of raw talent being spotted and grabbed. I don't know what the figures for state/private say from 2015 compared with 1980. That's just his impression. I think though the figures need proper definition because state school can denote a whole range - from highly selective (and tutored) grammar to the boggest of bog standard!

And anyway, Oxbridge isn't necessarily a marker of success. DD is doing far 'better' than DS, and she was a reject!

Dobby123456 · 20/04/2023 13:54

faffadoodledo · 20/04/2023 13:31

I should have. But he was 18. It was up to him to do so. i wouldn't have dreamt of interfering. When he got home from the 3 night stay he was rattled. But I think he felt he'd given a good enough account in his other interview. It's hard. You think you ought to step in. But I may even have worried that would have been counterproductive. But that first interviewer was certainly old school, old tie, and had a problem with students with a less than cut glass education. And in retrospect it would have been a disaster if he had gotten into that college and had to share tutorials with that man!

Must have been a total dinosaur! When I was there for a masters nobody I met was impressed by polish - it was sheer raw talent they were after. Of course, there were quite a few odd 'characters' who'd been through the private school system, but they'd got in because of their obvious passion for their subject, not what school they'd been to! That was over 30 years ago. Perhaps different subject, different college. Glad your DS did well in the end.

faffadoodledo · 20/04/2023 13:31

I should have. But he was 18. It was up to him to do so. i wouldn't have dreamt of interfering. When he got home from the 3 night stay he was rattled. But I think he felt he'd given a good enough account in his other interview. It's hard. You think you ought to step in. But I may even have worried that would have been counterproductive. But that first interviewer was certainly old school, old tie, and had a problem with students with a less than cut glass education. And in retrospect it would have been a disaster if he had gotten into that college and had to share tutorials with that man!

Dobby123456 · 20/04/2023 13:26

faffadoodledo · 20/04/2023 13:10

DS had an interview at an Oxbridge college where he was asked which school he went to. When he replied (an unknown comp in the back end of beyond) the interviewer visibly rolled his eyes and asked how on earth DS thought he would cope with the work.
He was interviewed elsewhere too and got a place. But there was an academic who very definitely had a problem with the sort of education DS had received. Fortunately DS was pig headed and knew his worth!
Sadly sh2t like that still happens. Hopefully less frequently these days. And of course the system of getting interviewed at more than one college is helpful.

You should have complained. The interviewer should not have needed to ask what school they went to (they've got a reference from the school, so they know what school it is!) and certainly shouldn't have suggested that he couldn't cope with the work. If he got the grades to be called for interview this should not have been in question. I'm very sorry this happened to your DS.

faffadoodledo · 20/04/2023 13:10

DS had an interview at an Oxbridge college where he was asked which school he went to. When he replied (an unknown comp in the back end of beyond) the interviewer visibly rolled his eyes and asked how on earth DS thought he would cope with the work.
He was interviewed elsewhere too and got a place. But there was an academic who very definitely had a problem with the sort of education DS had received. Fortunately DS was pig headed and knew his worth!
Sadly sh2t like that still happens. Hopefully less frequently these days. And of course the system of getting interviewed at more than one college is helpful.

Dobby123456 · 20/04/2023 13:07

Kets27 · 20/04/2023 11:33

This.. I see repeatedly around me high performing kids both from private and state schools going places and doing well. The kids who sadly suffer the most are from broken families, disinterested parents, and of course special needs kids lacking support due to poverty or circumstances. There is always going to be a state and private education system. The real wins are when prestigious universities and colleges are made to give equal treatment to all students applying and offer full scholarships to deserving kids who need it the most

Why would universities need to be forced to give equal treatment to all applicants? Why would academics (a very left wing profession) be at all impressed by what school you went to?