Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go NC as well as our kids

114 replies

mumofgirls87 · 12/04/2023 07:58

Name changed as outing.
Massive backstory as to why BIL and future SIL don't like me due to my husband showing off when we were still dating. FSIL took it the wrong way thinking I was flirting with BIL.

Relationship has been strained despite me being civil but they make it obvious they don't like me whenever family events are on. FSIL has obviously said to BIL to not talk to me directly However I get the odd thank you or hello but he will only talk to me through my DH if that makes sense but will phrase it to both of us.
I've decided I can no longer be bothered and to just let them get over their problem with me. However I don't want them to see our kids when they can't even be bothered to be nice to me. I've said to DH he can carry on seeing them and their kids but I don't want to and neither will our girls.
MIL is upset but why should I always be the one to suck things up at the expense of my MH?
I know I haven't explained it properly but the atmosphere is awful.

OP posts:
Highlyflavouredgravy · 12/04/2023 10:37

What does FSIL mean?

MarieRoseMarie · 12/04/2023 10:34

But he must have been sending the pic to brag otherwise he doesn’t make sense. You said he was winding your husband up and in response he sent the photo. And that only works if DH is implying you are hotter than FSIL. Otherwise there would be nothing to brag about about.

If someone were winding me up and I angrily sent over a picture of my new car saying “well, look at my car”, it wouldn’t make sense if they had the same or a nicer car. It only makes sense if they have a crappy banger.

I think you’ve been vague because you’re being dishonest. Your BIL was winding your DH up so he sent a sexy (clothed) selfie to him bragging about that he had a hot girlfriend (implying SIL is not). SIL then probably spotted the selfie on his phone and went crazy assuming you were texting him behind her back. Your DH explained that he sent it “for no reason” which probably makes no sense to her in the way it makes no sense to half the thread. I think you should go NC with them because you and your DH sound awful and given how many horrible things you’ve said about SIL on this thread (she trapped him into pregnancy, your DH implies she’s ugly), she’s better off away from you both.

CurlewKate · 12/04/2023 10:33

I can understand why you want not to see them, although I don't understand the back story. But why not let your dh arrange his own ant the children's contact with his family? You don't have to be involved.

ThreeRingCircus · 12/04/2023 10:31

Brother probably sees the pic, and says to his partner, "look, brother's new girlfriend is really hot / nice / pretty". Sister in Law will now hate you FOR EVER. Not only is she not the only one any more, her boyfriend has also dared to say you look nice. It's all her... and to do with her insecurities

Exactly this. You need to stop apologising, because you haven't done anything wrong so you have nothing to apologise for! Just back away. I don't think you necessarily need to go NC but you do not have to be best mates and go on holidays with them.

It does sound very juvenile, I can't believe the parents in law are intervening and having to call up their children to say stop winding one another up. It's so petty and embarrassing.

mumofgirls87 · 12/04/2023 10:28

Beautiful3 · 12/04/2023 10:25

I'd honestly forget the photo thing, because its really nothing. She got jealous and angry about it because she's very insecure. She knows that you didn't send it, because it's self explanatory it came from your husbands phone. Stop apologising for it. I went nc with my sil 10 years ago, because she was ignoring me too, only talking to me through my husband (her brother). I've known her for 23 years and she became a problem 13 years into it. I tried everything, being nicer, talking to her, inviting her over. But it never got better. I went no contact and I feel.better now. However it does mean that when we go to a family wedding/party, that she's there. It's obvious that she doesn't like me. My eldest has commented on how much she looks like she hates me. It's truly bizzare. I get how you feel and makes you look in front of your children. Personally I think its best to go nc, but be aware there will be times you see each other e.g. funerals/weddings etc.

Thank you 😊

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 12/04/2023 10:25

I'd honestly forget the photo thing, because its really nothing. She got jealous and angry about it because she's very insecure. She knows that you didn't send it, because it's self explanatory it came from your husbands phone. Stop apologising for it. I went nc with my sil 10 years ago, because she was ignoring me too, only talking to me through my husband (her brother). I've known her for 23 years and she became a problem 13 years into it. I tried everything, being nicer, talking to her, inviting her over. But it never got better. I went no contact and I feel.better now. However it does mean that when we go to a family wedding/party, that she's there. It's obvious that she doesn't like me. My eldest has commented on how much she looks like she hates me. It's truly bizzare. I get how you feel and makes you look in front of your children. Personally I think its best to go nc, but be aware there will be times you see each other e.g. funerals/weddings etc.

EmilyGilmoresSass · 12/04/2023 10:22

I gave up reading a few posts in. What a load of nonsensical drama.

itsgettingweird · 12/04/2023 10:22

I came back to ask if it was possible she felt her place in the family would be threatened. Her narrative will be secured by FIL etc all trying to tell her she's wrong. In her mind that proves to her you're the favourite.

If she is anything like people I've met like her before it'll wind her up more if when at family events DH says "oh no DW and kids couldn't make it. They are off doing X".

Best way to bother her is not to be bothered by her behaviour.

mumofgirls87 · 12/04/2023 10:21

Comfies · 12/04/2023 10:18

I kind of relate. When I first met my husband's sister and her then boyfriend, (now DH), he loved me in a platonic way. Husband's sister really didn't like this and whatever happened, her boyfriend started being quite dickish to me. This has continued for many years and it isn't the whole story but this is what started it.

I don't see my sil or her husband unless completely unavoidable (weddings and funerals).

But, I like that my DCs still see her occasionally as she is their auntie and she is nice to them. She is more sensible now and I bet if we met now we wouldn't have had the same issues, but the damage is done now really.

My dcs will sometimes run into her and her DCs at PILs' house or they will get together for a walk in the woods with DH and his sister and her DCs or they will go to sil's house, but not very often. I don't have them at my house because of the history. We tried for years to get along, but it hasn't worked out. My DCs don't see the husband much as he works a lot, but I don't mind them being around him if he happens to be there. DH doesn't have much of a relationship with his sister, but that isn't down to me and I'm glad it isn't down to me as I'd feel terrible about that. She doesn't like me but in all honesty I'm not fond of her either so...meh.

So, if I were you I'd attempt to let the kids maintain a good relationship with her and any DCs they have if possible. But you certainly don't have to have a relationship with her. Men don't have this sort of pressure to participate in every in-law get together IME. You are allowed to opt out

I think that's the problem. The damage has already been done.

OP posts:
JoelyJoe · 12/04/2023 10:20

So your husband sends a nice pic of you to his brother, "showing off" his new girlfriend.
Brother probably sees the pic, and says to his partner, "look, brother's new girlfriend is really hot / nice / pretty".
Sister in Law will now hate you FOR EVER. Not only is she not the only one any more, her boyfriend has also dared to say you look nice.
It's all her... and to do with her insecurities. She has probably made up the bit about thinking you sent it, to make her dislike seem justified.
You are not being unreasonable to want to avoid her as much as possible. I would just try to stay out of her way. (But would maybe be more flexible with regard to the kids, if they get on with their grandparents / cousins etc).

Comfies · 12/04/2023 10:18

I kind of relate. When I first met my husband's sister and her then boyfriend, (now DH), he loved me in a platonic way. Husband's sister really didn't like this and whatever happened, her boyfriend started being quite dickish to me. This has continued for many years and it isn't the whole story but this is what started it.

I don't see my sil or her husband unless completely unavoidable (weddings and funerals).

But, I like that my DCs still see her occasionally as she is their auntie and she is nice to them. She is more sensible now and I bet if we met now we wouldn't have had the same issues, but the damage is done now really.

My dcs will sometimes run into her and her DCs at PILs' house or they will get together for a walk in the woods with DH and his sister and her DCs or they will go to sil's house, but not very often. I don't have them at my house because of the history. We tried for years to get along, but it hasn't worked out. My DCs don't see the husband much as he works a lot, but I don't mind them being around him if he happens to be there. DH doesn't have much of a relationship with his sister, but that isn't down to me and I'm glad it isn't down to me as I'd feel terrible about that. She doesn't like me but in all honesty I'm not fond of her either so...meh.

So, if I were you I'd attempt to let the kids maintain a good relationship with her and any DCs they have if possible. But you certainly don't have to have a relationship with her. Men don't have this sort of pressure to participate in every in-law get together IME. You are allowed to opt out

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 12/04/2023 10:17

I can't express how many times we have said sorry both me and dh

Not sure what you are apologising for, but stopping the kids from seeing each other is petty.

And your brother in law's future wife, is not your sister in law. She just your brother in law's wife, so you don't have to feel obligated to have a relationship because you think she's some kind of relation. She isn't.

Hankunamatata · 12/04/2023 10:17

I would actually take great joy in trying to talk to fsil. If she is rude just shows her to be the ass she is

mumofgirls87 · 12/04/2023 10:11

smizing · 12/04/2023 10:07

THIS. The situation is quite simple. The short and end of it is SIL is jealous of OP. She's very insecure. It's not your fault OP.

Honestly the only thing I can think of is that they preferred it when it was just bil, fsil and their kids. Dh and his other brothers had no girlfriends and the other 2 brothers still don't and they liked it when they got all the attention. When I first met her face to face she was rude and obviously in a strop...arms crossed and face like thunder.

OP posts:
mumofgirls87 · 12/04/2023 10:08

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 12/04/2023 10:07

There’s got to be more to it, did DH actually write something along the lines of you being hotter than FSIL? Because there is no logic in DH sending a photo, them thinking it’s from you and then thinking you’re flirting with him.

YABU to involve the kids in this but disengage yourself if it’s this confusing

Nope it was like look at my girlfriend heart eyes or whatever but nothing to say I'm better looking etc. I don't think I'm better than anyone.

OP posts:
smizing · 12/04/2023 10:07

itsgettingweird · 12/04/2023 10:06

Why are people making shit up to try and justify the behaviour?

It's very simple.

Her DH sent a nice picture of her to his brother to show off his partner.

Brothers wife took offence and decided with no evidence that OP herself sent the photo. So now treat OP like crap.

I guess it's easy to decide there must be 100 other different narratives if you've never met batshit jealous people before - but sadly they do exist. They can also twist any situation into being a victim of some perceived slight and so trying to explain is futile.

OP just refuse to see them. I'd tell your DH you'd rather your children weren't exposed to people that have bullied you but sadly you'll need his support with this as you can't stop him.

Oh and STOP trying to make amends. It's what these people like. Everyone tiptoeing around them trying to appease them and them having the power because it'll never be enough.

THIS. The situation is quite simple. The short and end of it is SIL is jealous of OP. She's very insecure. It's not your fault OP.

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 12/04/2023 10:07

There’s got to be more to it, did DH actually write something along the lines of you being hotter than FSIL? Because there is no logic in DH sending a photo, them thinking it’s from you and then thinking you’re flirting with him.

YABU to involve the kids in this but disengage yourself if it’s this confusing

mumofgirls87 · 12/04/2023 10:07

itsgettingweird · 12/04/2023 10:06

Why are people making shit up to try and justify the behaviour?

It's very simple.

Her DH sent a nice picture of her to his brother to show off his partner.

Brothers wife took offence and decided with no evidence that OP herself sent the photo. So now treat OP like crap.

I guess it's easy to decide there must be 100 other different narratives if you've never met batshit jealous people before - but sadly they do exist. They can also twist any situation into being a victim of some perceived slight and so trying to explain is futile.

OP just refuse to see them. I'd tell your DH you'd rather your children weren't exposed to people that have bullied you but sadly you'll need his support with this as you can't stop him.

Oh and STOP trying to make amends. It's what these people like. Everyone tiptoeing around them trying to appease them and them having the power because it'll never be enough.

THANK YOU. I've screenshot this to remind myself.

OP posts:
isitjustmey · 12/04/2023 10:06

mumofgirls87 · 12/04/2023 10:03

This was explained 3 years ago when it happened. And yes you have it right.

Ok in that case there's nothing more you can do.

Just go NC if she continues to be nasty.

itsgettingweird · 12/04/2023 10:06

Why are people making shit up to try and justify the behaviour?

It's very simple.

Her DH sent a nice picture of her to his brother to show off his partner.

Brothers wife took offence and decided with no evidence that OP herself sent the photo. So now treat OP like crap.

I guess it's easy to decide there must be 100 other different narratives if you've never met batshit jealous people before - but sadly they do exist. They can also twist any situation into being a victim of some perceived slight and so trying to explain is futile.

OP just refuse to see them. I'd tell your DH you'd rather your children weren't exposed to people that have bullied you but sadly you'll need his support with this as you can't stop him.

Oh and STOP trying to make amends. It's what these people like. Everyone tiptoeing around them trying to appease them and them having the power because it'll never be enough.

mumofgirls87 · 12/04/2023 10:05

DivorcedAndDelighted · 12/04/2023 10:04

FSIL is probably on Mumsnet, posted about the picture and was advised how to handle it...
Mistakes and misunderstandings happen, especially when we're constantly advised to "trust your gut", but frankly guts aren't always that clever! It must feel very unjust to you, that they've taken against you when you're not at fault.
HOWEVER, it is not reasonable to deny your children a relationship with their family if the children are being treated well. That is controlling, and leaves no room for the possibility that anyone here has made an error of judgement which might be recovered from. The Quaker saying is, always h hold in your heart the possibility that you might be mistaken.
I'd let DH take them to see his family, BUT be clear with him that if they criticise you in front of the children, that is a whole different matter.

Ah that's a good idea actually. Thank you 😊 they wouldn't dare in front of inlaws.

OP posts:
DivorcedAndDelighted · 12/04/2023 10:04

FSIL is probably on Mumsnet, posted about the picture and was advised how to handle it...
Mistakes and misunderstandings happen, especially when we're constantly advised to "trust your gut", but frankly guts aren't always that clever! It must feel very unjust to you, that they've taken against you when you're not at fault.
HOWEVER, it is not reasonable to deny your children a relationship with their family if the children are being treated well. That is controlling, and leaves no room for the possibility that anyone here has made an error of judgement which might be recovered from. The Quaker saying is, always h hold in your heart the possibility that you might be mistaken.
I'd let DH take them to see his family, BUT be clear with him that if they criticise you in front of the children, that is a whole different matter.

mumofgirls87 · 12/04/2023 10:03

isitjustmey · 12/04/2023 10:02

I hope I'm getting this right.

OP - YOU DH sent his brother a picture of her (that's when they were dating)

It was just a normal picure not nudes

DH's brother's wife thought and still thinks that it was OP that sent teh pic and not OP's DH.

Can't your BIL show his wife his phone with his brother's number and show her that it really was your DH that sent the pic?

If that was already done and she still doesn't want to believe then she's just a jealous insecure cow that needs to move on.

This was explained 3 years ago when it happened. And yes you have it right.

OP posts:
isitjustmey · 12/04/2023 10:03

your DH sent his brother a picture of you*

isitjustmey · 12/04/2023 10:02

I hope I'm getting this right.

OP - YOU DH sent his brother a picture of her (that's when they were dating)

It was just a normal picure not nudes

DH's brother's wife thought and still thinks that it was OP that sent teh pic and not OP's DH.

Can't your BIL show his wife his phone with his brother's number and show her that it really was your DH that sent the pic?

If that was already done and she still doesn't want to believe then she's just a jealous insecure cow that needs to move on.