Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay for my dad's losses?

106 replies

DaughterLaFontaine · 12/04/2023 06:50

NC, as this is potentially outing:

My father and I have not been close since my parents got divorced (I was around 12). I do know he loves me on some level - but he's a grand master in being hurtful and dismissive above all.

Some years, he will remember my birthday or call on Christmas. Most, he won't.

So imagine my surprise when he rings out of the blue. I assumed some relative must have died or something!

As it turns out, no! Dad has always been into new-age woowoo stuff and conspiracy theories - turns out the latest and greatest one, something or other all banking is about to collapse, was, in fact a crypto scam.

My dad is in his 60s and about to retire. He will now do so without any savings. And because I'm a high-earner he was hoping his losses of around 50k might be affordable for me to cover ...

What I HAVE offered: you retain my personal solicitor and we try to see if there's any chance of success if you sue. I pay any legal fees upfront but want my money back if you do win.

What I have said I wouldn't do: give 50k to my father so he has some savings. Let the scammers keep his original money.

I feel like a horrible human being for saying no to a father who wouldn't even pay child support for me! But: this is not his first major loss. If I do, he'll just think he has a full guarantee from the "Bank of Daughter" and may lose it all again.

AIBU not to give him the money?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
theGooHasGone · 13/04/2023 13:54

What a bloody idiot. Well done for both recognising it and for growing up as such a smart, competent person in spite of his shitty attitude.

Daffodilwoman · 13/04/2023 13:45

No I wouldn’t give him a penny.
With all due respect he did not care a damn about you. What if your mother had refused to support you too? You could have ended up on the streets, drugged, raped, in the care system.
Hell you are very forgiving towards someone who does not care for you. I don’t believe in the afterlife so it’s a no from me.

prettybird · 13/04/2023 13:40

Your (not so dear) dad needs a) to report this to the police and b) to his bank.

There is a very faint possibility that if the bank didn't provide sufficient warnings before he transferred the money, then he might be able to reclaim some of it from them.

Also, as others have pointed out, if the scammers do try to charge him for anything else, that might give the police and/or the bank a biscuit crumb trail to follow to find them.

Above all, do not give your dad any money.

Wishawisha · 13/04/2023 12:38

Oh God no!

I wouldn’t even give it to my parents even if we did get on and they were nice people and consistently in my life (which yours isn’t). What I WOULD do for good parents is of course do things like hosting them, taking them out for meals or days out and paying, maybe getting them weekends away or paying for things they need for birthdays and Christmasses.. so their life would be enjoyable despite the low income / lack of savings. But as your father isn’t in your life, this doesn’t apply.

Gothambutnotahamster · 13/04/2023 12:35

YANBU at all Op - he's a disgrace to behave as he has done and then ask you for £50k! Stay strong and continue to say no!

Cc1998 · 13/04/2023 10:29

I've lost my money to stupidity, I'll just call my child and ask them for £50k of their hard earned money.
He sounds vile.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 13/04/2023 10:21

You have handled this very well. Stay strong.

purplecorkheart · 13/04/2023 09:45

I would not give him a penny nor would I pay legal fees at all. I mean who exactly do you think can be sued and even if you did win (highly unlikely) do you think they will actually pay. Most likely the scammers are based out of the UK and are hidden well by many sham businesses etc. Honestly, your lawyer will be wasting their time and your money trying to find a person to sue. You cannot sure the bank as your father gave the money willingly.

Whatever you do make sure you father has actually been scammed and is not just trying to boost his savings for retirement from the bank of his high earning child.

Catwithbigfeet · 13/04/2023 09:38

Solicitors are a waste of time and money when it comes to scammers.
Although a generous offer, don’t feel you have to please him after many years of him being absent from your life.
He just turns up asking for money, therefore, to him, money is more important than you are.
He didn’t care about you or your mum when he didn’t pay child support.

It is a classic abuser tactic to blame others for any shortcomings, thus he’s blamed his ex partner for not paying the child support.
What he should have done, as any decent parent would do, is put the money aside for you every month before he spends on himself and the partner.ie, make you a priority.
He refuses to take responsibility for himself.

Its up to you, OP but dad or not, I wouldn’t pay him a penny.

LIZS · 13/04/2023 09:18

Once he has been scammed it is likely he will be targeted for future ones, just as his call has indicated. They rely on embarrassment of the victim, meaning it goes unreported. How did he transfer the money, for example were there safeguards at the bank flagging the transactions which he overrode?

Wishitsnows · 13/04/2023 09:08

So he can’t be bothered to call you on your birthday or Christmas but certainly remembers your number and gets in contact when he wants money! He didn’t bother with child support and left that to your mum. Don’t give him a penny. The cheek of him calling asking for a significant amount of money just shows how self serving he is. Let him deal with his own mess as it doesn’t sound like he would help you if you were in need.

Fraaahnces · 13/04/2023 08:37

Did you witness him speaking to anyone or is he just making up excuses? He sounds like a gambler to me.

Thingamebobwotsit · 13/04/2023 06:48

determinedtomakethiswork · 12/04/2023 06:53

I wouldn't give him the money, but I certainly wouldn't be paying for legal fees either. That could cost an absolute fortune. And I wouldn't feel any responsibility for him. He was a rubbish father to you and he's only in touch with you now for money. Really sorry you didn't have a better father.

^This.

DaughterLaFontaine · 13/04/2023 06:41

He did NOT, also as per my advice, speak to CAB, mind. I told him he had to. Again.

OP posts:
DaughterLaFontaine · 13/04/2023 06:41

So ... update! It's worse!

I somehow did get my dad to at least call these people and ask to withdraw the very little money remaining.

As was to be expected, that's "not possible" - I was expecting them to cite some T&C, but they are bolder than that: simply told him "we would, unfortunately, you now have 0.00 left, oh, also: we're afraid you will have to pay an administrative fee from the broker; we will bill you for it".

In that sense: my dad might be a CF, but oh man are professional scammers ever even worse!

On the upside: for me, it was an easy out. Told him I could not give him a penny as all it would do would be to expose me to these criminals and put me on their radar. Somehow, even my crazy father understands this!

I also told him: dad, 1st thing in the morning you march straight into the next police station and file a report. Because this is no longer your money problem, this is organised crime! Also: you will want to have that case number handy because: whatever bill they send you: you are NOT paying this (not that he could), and depending on how they plan on getting their money, the evidence of a crime may come in handy then.

OP posts:
furryfrontbottom · 12/04/2023 12:53

If you give people like this an inch, they will take a mile, or waste a lot of your time trying to.

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 12/04/2023 12:33

No win no fee cases involve an insurance policy being taken out to cover fees and I don't think an underwriters going to go for anyone trying to sue a scammer. You might as well just give the solicitor £400.

I wouldn't give him money, I wouldn't pay his fees and I wouldn't give him a second thought either.

DaughterLaFontaine · 12/04/2023 12:14

@TheLurpackYears, sort of, yes, they would be.

I always describe them as "quite possibly a psychopath, as in: very analytical, ice cold, noone's feelings considered - but luckily for me, I won't need to pay for legal services ever again if I'm dead, they won't murder me, they definitely underwent that same thought process before me!". They're also calculating enough to know you make more money in the long run by advising against proceeding with minor or hopeless matters.

Basically, if it's a non-starter from their POV, it'd be one from mine.

OP posts:
TheLurpackYears · 12/04/2023 12:02

I hope the reson your solicitor is absolutely brilliant is that she will only take a moment to point out that neither of you should spend another moment wasting your time or even solving problem that isn't yours.
Be strong, write to your dad an make it clear that you have taken advice and will not be funding and legal help.
You owe him nothing, honestly.

gamerchick · 12/04/2023 12:00

Sounds like it'll better he doesnt have a huge chunk of savings handy. So definitely not. Some people never learn.

user1471538283 · 12/04/2023 11:56

A fool and his money ...

I would direct him to a lawyer for a half hour free and that's it.

We could all spend like no tomorrow if we could rely on someone else covering our losses!

Pixiedust1234 · 12/04/2023 11:54

I feel like a horrible human being for saying no to a father who wouldn't even pay child support for me!

But he's not a father is he? He's as close to you as a random man your mother had an affair with for a couple of years. There's no bonding, no real love, no concern or support in any way, just nothing.

You owe this man absolutely zilch so don't be guilted by him otherwise he will mess with your head, your heart and your savings.

EveryWitchWaybutLoose · 12/04/2023 11:32

YANBU.

I was in a similar situation with my father a few years ago - not as bad, but he'd retired early and made some decisions about pursuing training/education for a new career. He was hit with a bill for tuition fees - it was predictable, but he'd chosen to ignore it, and then rang around all his DC (there are a few of us) to split the £15,000 cost between us.

We did it, from filial duty, and at least it paid for his postgrad degree, although he never took up the new career.

But in your situation, I would say No.

backinthestoneage · 12/04/2023 11:30

No don't do it.

If you bail him out this time you will be on the path of continually bailing him out for all sorts of stuff - get-rich-quick schemes, utility bills, cars, holidays, and care homes.

My parents started asking me for money when I was at university. I was gobsmacked and said I didn't have a couple of grand to give them. They took all the money from Grandma's inheritance including my share. I didn't want to rock the boat being young and naive but I made it very clear that they were never to ask me for money ever again. They frittered everything on booze and tat.

I have done well financially and I have kept to my word. I never offer them money. They make the odd hint which I ignore and say my money is for my kids. Karma and all that stuff.

DaughterLaFontaine · 12/04/2023 11:27

Just to clarify a few points: no, he doesn't have dementia or anything of the sort. He's just an A grade idiot who has a tendency to fall for any old conspiracy theory and now, apparently, also scams. Last time I physically saw him, he happened to be in the area, having paid some dodgy "medium" insane fees for some "initiation".

And, no, I am not planning to finance any "no hope" lawsuit. I was thinking "pay for an hour with a solicitor, elicit whether there is any hope of any such thing on a no win, no fee type of model".

OP posts: