Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents' evening at nursery...

142 replies

User154871 · 11/04/2023 22:39

It's a tick box and a fairly unhinged one at that.

At the last one, I was told my ten month old had a 'target' of walking. I shrugged that sentence off because the rest of it was good and they are a nice nursery with lovely staff and activities.

This time, they said the 17 month old likes playing with others but 'we can tell she's an only child because she can't share'.

I don't know whether I'm being oversensitive because I has a MC in Nov and I hated the phrasing (they knew at the time but I don't expect them to remember)... but I thought that struggling with sharing was normal at 17 months?

The other target is to talk more as she only says five words clearly although she understands a lot more than that.

OP posts:
ChocHotolate · 12/04/2023 14:51

I started a similar thread very recently, about a report from nursery about my daughter

LSSG · 12/04/2023 14:42

Hardbackwriter · 11/04/2023 22:47

I actually think that is a bit shit, and not totally par for the course. The comment about being an only child was pretty horrible and also weird. Both comments suggest that they're not very clear on what's normal child development - and even if they don't know any theory on it (surely they should a bit?) then they're surrounded by children all day! I've always found nursery parents evening a bit unnecessary but the 'targets' they've set have always been age appropriate and at least vaguely tailored to the child in question!

Yep I agree. And yes op it's totally fine and normal not to want to share at this age and there is no need to 'teach' this. Just help them to manage any toy disputes where needed.

emmylousings · 12/04/2023 14:41

It's a bit daft - I agree with you OP. But you won't find a nursery that doesn't do this - they are forced to set silly targets and monitor / report 'progress' against them because OFSTED make them. It's a waste of taxpayers money and nurseries time. OFSTED needs totally overhauling.

shivawn · 12/04/2023 14:38

Can confirm that my 17 month old does not like to share. Of course he is an only child so that must be why......

Kanaloa · 12/04/2023 14:36

To be fair it’s not like we’re chomping at the bit to stay an extra two hours and more after a nine/ten hour day to read you the extra paperwork we had to fit into our lives either! At least for you it isn’t compulsory. I’ve said that I’m happy not to attend if there are no problems. You can just say ‘as long as there’s no concerns then I’m happy with how they’re getting on here, thanks though.’

CurlyhairedAssassin · 12/04/2023 14:36

Saltired · 12/04/2023 11:32

My daughters nursery did parents evenings and they were FAB! They set up activities like they would for the kids, and the kids went round playing with their parent(s); with key workers on hand to discuss any concerns. They then had their learning journals set up where their team leader showed us what they had been doing.

Ours were like this (although mine only went from aged 2.5 yrs). That's really all you need. To have the staff on hand for a longer informal chat, to have the parents there to watch their child play and for staff to be able to observe and comment to parents stuff like "oh yes, she loves anything like that, she's got really good fine motor skills. It's good because it will help with pencil grip when she's older", or "have you noticed how he's avoiding the drawing table? He really doesn't enjoy drawing usually, is he the same at home?" etc. There doesn't need to be anything written down at all if the staff know the children well, and staff development well.

There is a plethora of information out there free available on child development. Most parents in my experience know where their child is compared to where they should be. I really don't think that most parents need any targets for their child, unless there are serious concerns about development, and then that would be a separate meeting to discuss possible SEND. But for very young children for whom "normal" is a very wide range I think that setting targets is at best laughable and at worst anxiety-inducing for the parents.

Bloody Ofsted.....honestly.

PinkPlantCase · 12/04/2023 14:34

I like them.

It’s good to have time to discuss what DS is working towards at the moment. They tell us what they’re working on with the children and we tell them what we’re working on at home.

Sometimes there isn’t much to say, other times it can be so useful.

The main issue with yours OP seems to be the delivery. They could have said we’re working on sharing at the moment, perhaps working on using certain words in different situations or understanding different concepts to do with sharing, giving, taking and ownership. Not your DC can’t do this because they’re an only child. That’s just rude.

Scuttlingherbert · 12/04/2023 14:34

Hazelnuttella · 12/04/2023 11:37

We had to perch on tiny children’s chairs and look up at DS key worker who sat on a normal chair.

6ft4 DH was too big for the toddler chair so sat cross legged on the floor. Bizarre experience all round.

The image of this has really tickled me

Margot78 · 12/04/2023 14:34

I work in early years and I’ve yet to meet a child (or adult!) who expects to hand over something they’re using just because someone else thinks they’re entitled to it. All children have to learn to wait their turn if they want something and not to snatch. At 17 months they certainly wouldn’t be expected to understand the concept of sharing resources. Being an only child has nothing to do with it as the staff should well know.

I work with children 2 years and older. We have to have “next steps” planned for children and we have to keep an eye on development milestones. Some parents want to meet up and discuss their child, other parents don’t feel the need to. I would say parents meetings at this age are not essential unless there is a problem but it’s good to have the option there for parents who want them. If you don’t find them helpful, and I don’t blame you in this instance, then I wouldn’t worry about attending.

jannier · 12/04/2023 14:33

WaltzingWaters · 12/04/2023 14:10

It’s ridiculous. The children would actually gain so much more without all this unnecessary admin childcare staff have to do as they’d have more time to actually do activities/play with them, rather than documenting it all.
My mum used to love childminding until it all had to be ofsted regulated and a tonne of paperwork came into the mix.

It doesn't have to be documented as such but if your using a setting with 30 children and several staff coming and going it would be hard to keep track of children who are falling behind or showing issues without some system ....most nurseries now have door handover so no chance to talk to anyone who knows your child or for them to find out why a child has suddenly changed because of things that may have happened at home.

FlounderingFruitcake · 12/04/2023 14:31

17MO not sharing 🤣 Because they’re an only 🤣
It’s well known that under 3s have no concept of sharing. And won’t at least half the class be only children? A younger sibling, if there even is one yet, will probably be a newborn so no sharing there. There could be older siblings but speaking from experience if they’re 3+ which would be a far more typical age gap, their toys probably involve choking hazards for the youngest so things are kept separate. Oh and most importantly siblings don’t make kids good at sharing!! That would have really pissed me off too, mostly because I think it shows a real lack of understanding of age appropriate behaviour but also because it’s negative stereotyping of only children.

I’d want to know if they are meeting age appropriate milestones but that’s it.

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 12/04/2023 14:28

FFS. Nurseries can't win, can they?

This is not a "pointless tick box" exercise and I'm horrified that even some nursery staff appear to be saying it is.

These are not random targets plucked from thin air. They are part of the early years curriculum and are supposed to track normal progress and highlight any areas where a child struggles in order to target early intervention.

Someone said any real issues wouldn't be highlighted at a parents evening but when people have received feedback that there's a minor concern they roll their eyes and say the whole thing was ridiculous and staff don't know what they're talking about.
Struggling to share is normal at 17mths but is the child in question acting particularly aggressive or defiant when asked to share?

If there was no parents evening I can guarantee there'd also be a contingent complaining that they have no idea what their child does all day, handovers are rushed, and they don't understand the online learning journey so no idea if their child is progressing well.

Sounds like many nurseries could do with delivering this information in a clearer, more parent-friendly way.

jannier · 12/04/2023 14:27

Morningcoffeeview · 12/04/2023 14:00

Is it only a waste of time for the majority because the majority of children do hit their milestones. For those that don’t isn’t early intervention helpful?

Exactly and research has shown intervention at 2 impacts a child's performance at school aged 16. Hence 2:year funding.

FlowerTink · 12/04/2023 14:26

We have to do it for OFSTED and each child gets graded against the EYFS in terms of everything from speech to social ability, fine/gross motor movements, the world around them and so on. It seems pointless and for some children who develop "normally" its a tick box as such, but if there's SEN or something going on we can pinpoint it, and often then we have evidence to show you or to send on to relevant professionals eg. speech therapy, pediatrician to help get that early intervention as needed.

Personally, my eldest was premature and as a result behind in many areas, with the help of her pre-school and the observations/grading they do, we were under play therapy, a pediatrician and had evidence to get further support such as speech therapy, hearing tests, medications. Pre-school did an awful lot of 1-2-1 work with her and go her to where she is now. She's 7 now and thriving, all because of the early intervention she had.

WindUpPenguin · 12/04/2023 14:25

The sharing thing strikes me as silly, because I have definitely seen children become more reluctant to share when they have a younger sibling who has suddenly started wanting whatever their older sibling has! Fair enough to say that they need to work on sharing (sensible feedback) but very unfair to attribute it to something out of your control, which may or may not be a factor...

jannier · 12/04/2023 14:24

User154871 · 11/04/2023 22:39

It's a tick box and a fairly unhinged one at that.

At the last one, I was told my ten month old had a 'target' of walking. I shrugged that sentence off because the rest of it was good and they are a nice nursery with lovely staff and activities.

This time, they said the 17 month old likes playing with others but 'we can tell she's an only child because she can't share'.

I don't know whether I'm being oversensitive because I has a MC in Nov and I hated the phrasing (they knew at the time but I don't expect them to remember)... but I thought that struggling with sharing was normal at 17 months?

The other target is to talk more as she only says five words clearly although she understands a lot more than that.

They are not targets but next steps and they are supposed to discuss and agree with you so everyone is working together on the same things so how to promote walking the games you can play, equipment etc.

Bettyboop3 · 12/04/2023 14:23

User154871 · 11/04/2023 22:39

It's a tick box and a fairly unhinged one at that.

At the last one, I was told my ten month old had a 'target' of walking. I shrugged that sentence off because the rest of it was good and they are a nice nursery with lovely staff and activities.

This time, they said the 17 month old likes playing with others but 'we can tell she's an only child because she can't share'.

I don't know whether I'm being oversensitive because I has a MC in Nov and I hated the phrasing (they knew at the time but I don't expect them to remember)... but I thought that struggling with sharing was normal at 17 months?

The other target is to talk more as she only says five words clearly although she understands a lot more than that.

It's not obligatory to attend.

Skinnermarink · 12/04/2023 14:22

FFF3 · 12/04/2023 13:45

Also, isn’t it really daycare and not nursery so to speak?

Why? I don’t think we commonly call it daycare in the U.K.?

jannier · 12/04/2023 14:21

Providers have to demonstrate working with parents and agreed next steps that they discuss with you that's an EYFS requirement some use Apps but most parents don't contribute, some daily diaries but again parents lose them or don't comment.

Natsku · 12/04/2023 14:21

I liked 'parents evening' (wasn't an evening as such, just made an appointment at a time that suited me and the teacher), nice chat about how DS is getting on, how he interacts with other children, how his language skills are improving (bilingual, nursery are putting in extra effort to improve his language skills), what he likes and dislikes about nursery (then went through this with him before the meeting) and an opportunity to ask questions that wouldn't normally have time to ask at pick up.

Topseyt123 · 12/04/2023 14:18

Fortunately, parents' evenings were not a thing when my "children" (who are all now in their twenties) were at nursery.

Sounds like bullshit to me, and I don't think I'd have been inclined to go to them. Not at that age. I'd have already discussed any issues arising with staff at drop-off and pick-up.

I went to all school parents'evenings, but see no need for them at nursery or preschool. Are preschools doing it too? Is Ofsted also requiring it of them?:

moomoomoo27 · 12/04/2023 14:18

I'm 28 and sometimes I wonder how I made it this far in life when my mum just dropped me off at nursery school and picked me up and that was it. None of these daily/hourly updates (unless something medical had happened like you'd fallen over and banged your head or something), let alone parents' evenings 😂

Sunnydays60 · 12/04/2023 14:16

I would have thought it's just a communication breakdown between staff and parent. I can see why a parent might think this is being too pushy (and to be honest, the wording with the sharing target was appalling) and I also get that having to record/report all of this can be labour intensive and seen as a bit of a waste of staff time... But, taking the concept of targets, imagine a nursery that didn't have any in mind. They'd literally do nothing with the children and never interact. Many people are saying that the children shouldn't have targets and just be able to play and have fun but as I understand it, the whole point is for these things to happen simultaneously and all these meetings are doing are just making you aware of that.

maybein2022 · 12/04/2023 14:12

Sorry that should say early intervention is really important.

maybein2022 · 12/04/2023 14:12

@Morningcoffeeview absolutely, early intervention is really useful and that’s why documentation of certain things is so important- hence why I said some of it IS useful- but often it’s a box ticking exercise without any real meaning for the child, which is when I’d rather see good quality interactions over paperwork. When done properly, targets are good. But often, in my experience anyway, there can be a lack of training and staff with not much experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread