Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to call for VAT to be charged on childrens books?

191 replies

ZirihePevzig · 11/04/2023 17:56

VAT is charged on things that are luxuries, so that wealthier people who can afford the extra luxuries of life pay more into the government's income for running the country than those who are just living with the bare essentials and making ends meet without luxuries. Therefore there is no VAT on basic food stuff, but more luxury foods like icecream, confectionary and crisps have VAT added, and food that is sold for eat-in in restaurants or sold heated (there was a whole thing about Greggs Pasties not being VATable if they are still hot straight from the oven, but would be VATable if reheated). In general, VAT is a good thing because wealthy people with a clever accountant can fiddle things to hide income and get away with paying less income tax than they should, but if you are leading a luxurious lifestyle you are going to pay the VAT on it.

Things that are considered to be generally "A Good Thing" don't get VAT added, such as sporting activities and physical education, education and training, and medical treatments - VAT is effectively a "brake" on spending on non-essentials and its seen as inappropriate to tax things like this that it's not a bad thing to spend money on. Books come under this category and so are zero-rated.

However, in real life, books really are a luxury - even without VAT a book is generally around £10 (sometimes it might be as low as £7) and you could feed a family for at least a day on that. Less wealthy families are going to use libraries and get access to books for free, so the main beneficiaries of the VAT exemption on books is wealthy families who can afford to throw away £10 on something they could access for free at the library. Some affluent households may own thousands of books, and that's a huge amount of luxury goods that could have been taxed. You won't find that kind of book collection in households struggling at close to poverty levels.

OK I admit it, I am not actually in favour of charging VAT on books, but the exact same argument - that only wealthier people can afford it - is used as justification for the suggestion that education should no longer be in the list of things that are VAT exempt. If this is the case and education should no longer be VAT free then books are in the same category.

So if you are voting that IABU to call for VAT on books then you should also be supporting non-profit-making schools - ones that are providing education as a service, not as a business, in regions where the state offering is inadequate - to be able to charge their fees at cost-price without adding VAT, even though not everyone can afford that.

So YANBU = yes books and education are only accessible to poor people in their "free" forms from public libraries and state schools, so anyone who can afford the extra money to access a better version privately should pay VAT on that luxury

YABU = books and education are ultimately good for society and not appropriate to be taxed, even though the available budget for spending on them will be unfeasible for many people.

OP posts:
JoyDivisionOvenGlovesx · 11/04/2023 19:06

You’re trying to argue logic and common sense (ish) to a tax which troubled the highest courts in the land as to whether a chocolate tie turned a gingerbread man from zero rated to standard rated.

Don’t be daft.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 11/04/2023 19:05

Education is not a luxury. Lots of children are send to independent schools because their local state schools do not have a suitable provision (eg very academic/sporty/musical children would not be stretched enough at lots of state schools). I’m not saying all state schools are like this, but lots are. Lots of parents with children who have special needs feel there is no option but to send their child to private school.

Of course it's a luxury. Do you not think there are plenty of very academic/sporty/musical children who attend their local state school because their parents don't have the option of sending them to private school, because they cannot afford it. Funnily enough those very able children still manage to achieve, and end up at the same universities as very able children from private schools.

Tessabelle74 · 11/04/2023 19:05

I can't vote for either of your options because they're both ridiculous! I'm not rich and I'm happy to buy my kids books when they want them, they enjoy reading and will read books multiple times. I've never paid £10 for one either, usually Asda and Tesco have 2 for £7 promotions or other discounts. Just because YOU wouldn't buy then doesn't mean only the elite are.

takealettermsjones · 11/04/2023 19:04

I sometimes feel a bit conflicted getting a free resource for my child when in reality they don't need it (for free anyway).

But you pay for it through your tax/NI, just like you "pay" for your child to go to state school. People should absolutely support their libraries! (I'm not saying that makes OP's argument make any sense)

cupofdecaf · 11/04/2023 19:03

How many private schools are really run on a none profit basis and how many are businesses? They seem to run like businesses to an outsider. My

TheCrowFromBelow · 11/04/2023 19:00

No. I’d like good education to be free for all.

WarningToTheCurious · 11/04/2023 18:59

There's nothing quite as "luxury" as separating your precious kids from the local povvos and saying it's because Petunia wants to play lacrosse.

Off topic, but we did get to play lacrosse at my spectacularly shit comprehensive in the 1970s/1980s.

mids2019 · 11/04/2023 18:59

There may be unfortunately a point to libraries and VAT exempt books.

In working class communities libraries are viewed as a middle class subsidy. The middle classes read more and the children who visit libraries are likely to have engaged educated parents and therefore reasonable salaries.

The same argument was made against sure start in that the middle classes dominated some centres and therefore diverted resources from the disadvantaged.

I sometimes feel a bit conflicted getting a free resource for my child when in reality they don't need it (for free anyway).

Would library money be better spent on supporting children who have literacy problems through one to one teaching for example?

Morph22010 · 11/04/2023 18:56

TheCrowFromBelow · 11/04/2023 18:19

ones that are providing education as a service, not as a business, in regions where the state offering is inadequate
I think the VAT charged should go towards making the state offering better, personally.
a good education for all is something to strive for. Your version Just shuts the poorest even further out.

A lot of children with the most complex needs are educated in independent schools funded by the council, these families are some of the most vulnerable in society and yet you want to make them less accessible by making them more expensive

AllotmentTime · 11/04/2023 18:55

YABU because books are one of the main steps of social mobility. In the interests of equality we should be making them as cheap as possible. Reading & access to books are key in enhancing children’s life opportunities. Private school on the other hand entrenches social position. You are literally comparing opposites.

Stillcountingbeans · 11/04/2023 18:53

Things that are considered to be generally "A Good Thing" don't get VAT added.

Where your argument falls down is that you assume private education is "A Good Thing." This is not a given.
Indeed I would argue, as many people do, that private education is always and everywhere a bad thing for society, as it entrenches class divisions.
This country is riddled with social class distinctions, to the massive disadvantage of the majority.

Private school fees should have vat added, as a gesture, because it is not (yet) practical to outright ban the sale of full-time education for under 18's.

IForgotMyUsernameAgain · 11/04/2023 18:52

The TL;DR version: "I don't want to pay extra for my children's private education and here's a tenuous reason why I'm not being unreasonable.

Another76543 · 11/04/2023 18:51

donquixotedelamancha · 11/04/2023 18:33

It's a continuum, with affordability points for every household budget.

I don't see private education on the same continuum as books.

It's purpose is to allow the wealthy to network with each other and stifle social mobility.

How is adding VAT to school fees going to stop the wealthy from networking? It won’t.

PiffleIsTakingThePiss · 11/04/2023 18:49

I can't vote because you seem to think it's ok to give only two options neither of which reflect the fact that your OP is too long, too confused and frankly rather ridiculous.

Another76543 · 11/04/2023 18:49

It’s a ridiculous idea, but no more ridiculous than adding VAT to school fees.

Education is not a luxury. Lots of children are send to independent schools because their local state schools do not have a suitable provision (eg very academic/sporty/musical children would not be stretched enough at lots of state schools). I’m not saying all state schools are like this, but lots are. Lots of parents with children who have special needs feel there is no option but to send their child to private school.

There are plenty of other luxuries which aren’t subject to VAT. Air fares and designer label children clothes for example. Air passenger duty is often a lot less than the equivalent VAT would be. People are more than happy with no VAT being charged on a £1000 child’s coat or on a £10,000 air fare but call for VAT on private education. There’s no logic to the argument.

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 11/04/2023 18:49

Yes, as above. The similarity between cheap and expensive confectionery is much greater than the similarity between books and private education.

RedToothBrush · 11/04/2023 18:48

Girasoli · 11/04/2023 18:36

Most books I buy my DC are cheaper than a return bus fare to my local library!

I think this is the post that sums up things in reality tbh.

If it costs a fiver to get to the local library but you can buy a second hand book at the charity shop down the road for a quid, which was originally £3.50 down Tesco, how exactly does the VAT help the poor person who might value a book for whom the library trip weekly isn't viable?

Let's constrict supply so that the books are more expensive at Lowplex and they push the prices up on World of Books?

Now you can't get to the library, take advantage of a 2 for £7 offer, buy a box set for a tenner or buy four for three at £3.50 a throw (£10.50) either and there's less availability of £1 books at the charity shop who make less money from book sales. The library and local schools all get less books from donations too.

And you just put a whole load of printers, publisher's and authors out of work!

Congratulations OP on your new revolution 'for the people'.

You really are down with the joined up thinking on this one about books being a luxury...

TreesAtSea · 11/04/2023 18:48

Hibbutyhop · 11/04/2023 18:28

I can’t get behind any argument that would make books less accessible to any child, regardless of family income. Books and reading open up a whole new world of opportunities. I’ve always said I’d like money donated to Booktrust when I die.

Exactly

Exasperatednow · 11/04/2023 18:47

You are comparing private education and books. It is not the same thing.

Yabu.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 11/04/2023 18:46

Well a lot of children’s books are a lot less than £10 and a lot of libraries have closed down so I don’t think it’s only the wealthy who buy books.

EyesOnThePies · 11/04/2023 18:46

Your analysis of the basis of VAT status is not accurate, I don’t buy your equivalencies, straw man arguments or logic.

So neither your YABU nor YANBU.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 11/04/2023 18:46

Hibbutyhop · 11/04/2023 18:28

I can’t get behind any argument that would make books less accessible to any child, regardless of family income. Books and reading open up a whole new world of opportunities. I’ve always said I’d like money donated to Booktrust when I die.

Yep.

There's nothing quite as "luxury" as separating your precious kids from the local povvos and saying it's because Petunia wants to play lacrosse.

Whiteroomjoy · 11/04/2023 18:45

🫤libraries and schools would then have to pay vat on all books they buy. Including the ones that they use to teach kids to read in classrooms 🤦‍♀️

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 11/04/2023 18:44

Do you think the tax system should value internal consistency above justice, compassion and the common good?

ThreeFeetTall · 11/04/2023 18:42

Maybe it should be made easier for poorer people to access books- for example private schools could open their libraries and resources up to the local community for free every weekend. And use their mini busses as mobile libraries. They are charities after all. Is that what you meant OP?