Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to call for VAT to be charged on childrens books?

191 replies

ZirihePevzig · 11/04/2023 17:56

VAT is charged on things that are luxuries, so that wealthier people who can afford the extra luxuries of life pay more into the government's income for running the country than those who are just living with the bare essentials and making ends meet without luxuries. Therefore there is no VAT on basic food stuff, but more luxury foods like icecream, confectionary and crisps have VAT added, and food that is sold for eat-in in restaurants or sold heated (there was a whole thing about Greggs Pasties not being VATable if they are still hot straight from the oven, but would be VATable if reheated). In general, VAT is a good thing because wealthy people with a clever accountant can fiddle things to hide income and get away with paying less income tax than they should, but if you are leading a luxurious lifestyle you are going to pay the VAT on it.

Things that are considered to be generally "A Good Thing" don't get VAT added, such as sporting activities and physical education, education and training, and medical treatments - VAT is effectively a "brake" on spending on non-essentials and its seen as inappropriate to tax things like this that it's not a bad thing to spend money on. Books come under this category and so are zero-rated.

However, in real life, books really are a luxury - even without VAT a book is generally around £10 (sometimes it might be as low as £7) and you could feed a family for at least a day on that. Less wealthy families are going to use libraries and get access to books for free, so the main beneficiaries of the VAT exemption on books is wealthy families who can afford to throw away £10 on something they could access for free at the library. Some affluent households may own thousands of books, and that's a huge amount of luxury goods that could have been taxed. You won't find that kind of book collection in households struggling at close to poverty levels.

OK I admit it, I am not actually in favour of charging VAT on books, but the exact same argument - that only wealthier people can afford it - is used as justification for the suggestion that education should no longer be in the list of things that are VAT exempt. If this is the case and education should no longer be VAT free then books are in the same category.

So if you are voting that IABU to call for VAT on books then you should also be supporting non-profit-making schools - ones that are providing education as a service, not as a business, in regions where the state offering is inadequate - to be able to charge their fees at cost-price without adding VAT, even though not everyone can afford that.

So YANBU = yes books and education are only accessible to poor people in their "free" forms from public libraries and state schools, so anyone who can afford the extra money to access a better version privately should pay VAT on that luxury

YABU = books and education are ultimately good for society and not appropriate to be taxed, even though the available budget for spending on them will be unfeasible for many people.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 11/04/2023 22:46

I always see this argument on MN that the family paying for a fee paying school is doing so because they make enormous sacrifices by not having new cars and holidays, without understanding that most people don't have new cars and holidays and still have no hope of ever being able to afford a private school. We also have autistic children and failing state schools and still would never be able to afford full or partial fees.

If you can afford it, good for you, but I would call it a luxury as it is not something the average family could ever afford.

I don't believe luxuries are discrete classes of items and anything of that thing from cheap to expensive are just a continuum of luxury/not luxury.

A handbag from Primark I wouldn't call a luxury. A designer handbag is a luxury. They are still both bags.

mids2019 · 11/04/2023 22:44

@MissGroves

Personally I agree.

However some may view books as source of entertainment such as a video game or film, it's just that the entertainment is much more likely to be engaged in by the middle class. In a working class community I think the issue is encouraging literacy and we should definitely be providing more free books to school libraries and possibly ensuring schools in poorer areas receive a disproportionately large number.

a book may be given as a present and one purpose (hopefully) is that the book brings entertainment. The question is should one form of entertainment be taxed and not another?

wigywhoo · 11/04/2023 22:40

donquixotedelamancha · 11/04/2023 18:05

So if you are voting that IABU to call for VAT on books then you should also be supporting non-profit-making schools

I voted YABU because your long-winded argument is fatuous. Kids books do not cost the same as going to Eton.

Most private schools are nothing like Eton. I f do I think the comparison is flawed though.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 22:19

Nimbostratus100 · 11/04/2023 20:47

well, I voted YABU becasue you are being completely unreasonable, and if you think you have set it up so the vote means something, else then I disagree many people are following your post so closely as to even see that.

I would say voting YABU means YABU, rather than agreeing with you

Because YABU and 97% of voters think so

Agreed.

And I think you set up the vote deliberately like that, so that yabu actually looked like people agreed with you.

I voted yabu because you are bu. I didn't agree with either of the options that you presented.

RedToothBrush · 11/04/2023 22:18

Are you happy that The Guardian and The Daily Mail (pick your own pet hate) are zero rated for VAT?

well given that a lot of the purpose of newspapers is to hold power to account, and that's a cornerstone of democracy, yes I'm happy for all news based publications whether left or right wing be vat free.

MissGroves · 11/04/2023 22:02

Books are not and should never be considered a luxury. Books even “fun” ones are educational - children who read especially for pleasure are more likely to do well in education and be more likely to avoid a life of poverty as they grow. Why would anyone want to take that away. Many libraries are are closing thanks to government funding cuts at local levels so books are not as freely available as they ought to be.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 11/04/2023 22:00

Thank goodness you aren’t homeschooling OP, you’re kids wouldn’t stand a chance being taught your kind of logic… still, could be an option if you can’t afford the fees, eh
anything better than, yuk, state school
i suppose…

Flamingogirl08 · 11/04/2023 21:55

Your original post is so unclear and hard to follow that I doubt most people who have voted actually agree with what you are trying to say. Which is what? Your kids are in an independent school and you don't want to pay VAT?

I assume that's because although right now your kids have an advantage over kids poorer than them that advantage may be taken away?

TheGoogleMum · 11/04/2023 21:52

If I follow your argument then yes vat on both.
But actually we'd rather not discourage reading so let's not put vat on books. I don't have any reason to want to encourage private schools, perhaps richer parents would do more to help out state schools if they didn't exist.

tigger1001 · 11/04/2023 21:51

"Taking away charitable status doesn’t mean that VAT would be payable on fees anyway. Lots of independent schools aren’t charities."

That's true. However labour want to put a vat charge on private school fees as well as removing the charitable status. The flip side is that the schools can then reclaim input vat.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 11/04/2023 21:45

Q‘Personally I would not be that bothered if books attracted VAT. ‘

okay, it if books go up by 20% - that’s a huge jump for people on lower incomes.

Ans what about schools buying them for their library and as resources and textbooks?
And what about children’s centres and charities and other places that buy books for children, and staff, to use, borrow, access?

State schools are already struggling with the huge cuts imposed upon them by the Tories over 13 years ( the Tories who send their children to private schools) and now we should make books
Orr expensive for them?

MammaMacgill87 · 11/04/2023 21:44

As a household on the poverty line, we certainly do have a home collection of books, hundreds of them. They are a priority in my budget because my children love to read, and its one of the best ways to educate and expand their minds. So no we absolutely do not need to be making them cost even a penny more. We don't have access to a library (not without two buses and dragging four kids there for a tatty copy of a book they can't keep).
Of all the things books?

KarmaStar · 11/04/2023 21:35

Don't be ridiculous.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 11/04/2023 21:32

‘It is unreasonable to link private schools/VAT to VAT on books’

its unreasonable because private schools are making use of charity tax
status while being very profitable private businesses that benefit the very few.

It needs to be taken away because it’s wrong and unfair.

jcyclops · 11/04/2023 21:27

It is unreasonable to link private schools/VAT to VAT on books. They should be dealt with separately.

The other thing about VAT is that it does not have to be applied at 20%, but can be charged at any rate you want. You may be shocked that Child Car Seats and Boosters have VAT applied at 5% - surely these are more deserving of a zero rating than books!

One other point is that e-books are standard (20%) rated. I believe that VAT should be charged equally on paper and e-books.

Personally I would not be that bothered if books attracted VAT. The same goes for maps, magazines and newspapers which are all zero rated. Are you happy that The Guardian and The Daily Mail (pick your own pet hate) are zero rated for VAT?

RedToothBrush · 11/04/2023 21:27

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 11/04/2023 21:17

‘Why would you want to make books less accessible to people? ‘

OP is upset that the business she uses may charge her more for their services, and somehow taking away more opportunities for
less well off children than hers will
somehow ease the pain of this.

Translation:

OP has a massive chip on shoulder and wants to take it out on everyone else cos it's just not fair.

So is lashing out with nonsensical arguments because they lack the capacity to make a coherent one.

Toomucho · 11/04/2023 21:24

Private schools help to enforce intergenerational inequality in the UK, they are a benefit to only those who attend them and a disbenefit to society.

potatowhale · 11/04/2023 21:23

Oranges don't have vat but Orange juice does

Ilovemydoggie · 11/04/2023 21:22

I don’t think there should be VAT on education full stop; a well educated population benefits the country as a whole. Education is a charitable purpose in its own right.

I also think that the law of unintended consequences would apply if VAT were to be added to school fees. The result would be more DC needing state school places and fewer resources to go round for everyone. It would increase inequality, rather than reduce it.

Toomucho · 11/04/2023 21:22

You've given a false dilemma. A reasonable alternative is that books should be VAT free and private schools should not because books are good for society and private schools are not.

Notjustabrunette · 11/04/2023 21:18

I actually see VAT as a tax on poorer people. Reason being income tax is obviously directly related to income, but everyone has to buy clothing, furniture pay for a plumber, electrician etc. Poorer households spend a larger portion of their income on VAT compared with more affluent households.
No I don’t think taxing children’s books is a good idea.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 11/04/2023 21:17

‘Why would you want to make books less accessible to people? ‘

OP is upset that the business she uses may charge her more for their services, and somehow taking away more opportunities for
less well off children than hers will
somehow ease the pain of this.

Saniflo · 11/04/2023 21:10

Don't be a knob. I came from a very poor, working class background and we had loads of books. Why would you want to make books less accessible to people? You sound like a loon.

takealettermsjones · 11/04/2023 21:09

It's irrational to say that one end of the range is a luxury and the other end isn't.

No it isn't. There are basic versions and luxury versions of most everything. There is basic food and luxury food items. Basic apartments and luxury apartments.

You seem to be labouring under the delusion that national tax law should be based on your narrow comparison of your own and your neighbours' incomes. Fortunately the government has to take into account everyone in the country, including the vast majority who could never afford private education for their kids no matter how many pipe dreams of skiing they gave up and how talented little Ophelia is with the piccolo.

If you're right that your kids absolutely need their independent school because of the SEN provision, then surely the answer is to tax private schooling but let parents of children with SEN apply for a tax break on their fees.

Another76543 · 11/04/2023 21:07

tigger1001 · 11/04/2023 21:00

Rather than the poor argument re books and education, why not argue that taking away the charitable status isn't likely to actually save the amount that labour claim and in fact could be at best cost neutral.

Look at the arguments instead of trying to create a daft comparison.

Taking away charitable status doesn’t mean that VAT would be payable on fees anyway. Lots of independent schools aren’t charities.