Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to call for VAT to be charged on childrens books?

191 replies

ZirihePevzig · 11/04/2023 17:56

VAT is charged on things that are luxuries, so that wealthier people who can afford the extra luxuries of life pay more into the government's income for running the country than those who are just living with the bare essentials and making ends meet without luxuries. Therefore there is no VAT on basic food stuff, but more luxury foods like icecream, confectionary and crisps have VAT added, and food that is sold for eat-in in restaurants or sold heated (there was a whole thing about Greggs Pasties not being VATable if they are still hot straight from the oven, but would be VATable if reheated). In general, VAT is a good thing because wealthy people with a clever accountant can fiddle things to hide income and get away with paying less income tax than they should, but if you are leading a luxurious lifestyle you are going to pay the VAT on it.

Things that are considered to be generally "A Good Thing" don't get VAT added, such as sporting activities and physical education, education and training, and medical treatments - VAT is effectively a "brake" on spending on non-essentials and its seen as inappropriate to tax things like this that it's not a bad thing to spend money on. Books come under this category and so are zero-rated.

However, in real life, books really are a luxury - even without VAT a book is generally around £10 (sometimes it might be as low as £7) and you could feed a family for at least a day on that. Less wealthy families are going to use libraries and get access to books for free, so the main beneficiaries of the VAT exemption on books is wealthy families who can afford to throw away £10 on something they could access for free at the library. Some affluent households may own thousands of books, and that's a huge amount of luxury goods that could have been taxed. You won't find that kind of book collection in households struggling at close to poverty levels.

OK I admit it, I am not actually in favour of charging VAT on books, but the exact same argument - that only wealthier people can afford it - is used as justification for the suggestion that education should no longer be in the list of things that are VAT exempt. If this is the case and education should no longer be VAT free then books are in the same category.

So if you are voting that IABU to call for VAT on books then you should also be supporting non-profit-making schools - ones that are providing education as a service, not as a business, in regions where the state offering is inadequate - to be able to charge their fees at cost-price without adding VAT, even though not everyone can afford that.

So YANBU = yes books and education are only accessible to poor people in their "free" forms from public libraries and state schools, so anyone who can afford the extra money to access a better version privately should pay VAT on that luxury

YABU = books and education are ultimately good for society and not appropriate to be taxed, even though the available budget for spending on them will be unfeasible for many people.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HouseByTheSeaside · 14/04/2023 06:28

focuslocus · 12/04/2023 11:57

This is one of the worst ideas I have read.

Agreed.

Changingmynameyetagain · 12/04/2023 12:02

Our large suburban town of 200000 people has 4 libraries and they all only open 10-4:30. Absolutely useless for people who work and students, when I was at college the main library was open till 8pm and I spent all my time there studying for my exams. My dc haven’t been since they were tiny because it’s not open at times when they can go.
I spend a fortune on books as a result, I look on it as an investment on their education.

focuslocus · 12/04/2023 11:57

This is one of the worst ideas I have read.

AppleWax · 12/04/2023 11:33

I home educate. There is no bursary. There are no helping hands. There is no funding from government or local authority. I pay for everything. I have to source everything. I have arrange exam centres and pay for invigilators etc for International General Certificate of Education (IGCSES) and A Levels. I have to arrange travel to and from classes clubs etc. that I have sourced. I have to facilitate my daughters education whilst taking a financial hit because I cannot work at the same time and we are surviving on one wage. I accept this because we decided not to opt into the state school (free education).

Yet I still believe that VAT should not be applied to any education or educational materials, including private education. State schools need more investment etc into curriculum, teachers, buildings etc but not at the penalisation of other children. If more children leave the private sector then it just puts more pressure on state schools.

But I think the OP has picked an indefensible argument re books and children’s education. I personally don’t think any books should have VAT applied they are not luxuries but essential to creating and maintaining a well rounded, educated society.

RedToothBrush · 12/04/2023 11:19

CommanderSeven · 12/04/2023 11:02

School catchments must be a bigger deal in England. In all of Scotland I can think of maybe only 2 or 3 secondaries where families might pay a premium to make sure they can attend a certain school.

Most out of area requests are resolved quite easily

In my area there is only one secondary - so every pupil goes there.

Trafford is certainly like this and it becomes a dog fight for places between parents who put their kids through tutoring and the 11+. This is compounded by the fact that you don't need to live in Trafford to get a place if you get a good score on the 11+. So you get a lot of kids who live in Warrington, Cheshire East, Manchester and Salford also applying for the schools there.

I know a fair few parents who have gone down the private route even though all the local schools are well rated too. Again they would say they were ordinary, but they live in nice areas, can afford a lot of holidays and STILL have the money to put multiple kids through private school. They go on about how they have to cut back on lots of things but thats REALLY not true when you look at their lifestyle. What it means is they don't have skiing holidays, have slightly fewer branded clothes and shop at Aldi rather than buying branded - but still will have a Jamie Oliver level of understanding of 'cheap' in what they buy. Their budget still includes ciabatta and olives as essentials...

JoyDivisionOvenGlovesx · 12/04/2023 11:09

Comefromaway · 12/04/2023 09:34

I've voted YABU because you clearly don't understand VAT rules.

VAT is not payable on luxury items. It is payable on luxury food items, bothing to do with how much they cost.

VAT is not payable on education or educational items which is why books are exempt as books are seen as educational.

Yep, this.

VAT is chargeable on all supplies of goods and services made in the UK - unless a specific zero rating or exemption applies.

Tax authorities don’t choose what to put VAT on. They choose (as allowable) what NOT to put VAT on.

CommanderSeven · 12/04/2023 11:02

Blankscreen · 11/04/2023 20:55

I wonder if the op is written by one of the idiots currently working on the Labour adverts.

Yep charge VAT on school fees but only if you also get rid of faith schools, state grammar schools and school catchments and allocate all places on a lottery system.

Otherwise the parents that have been paying £2k a month in school fees out of already taxed income might just decide to just buy a nicer houses near to the best state schools.....

Probably also need to charge VAT on private tutoring.

School catchments must be a bigger deal in England. In all of Scotland I can think of maybe only 2 or 3 secondaries where families might pay a premium to make sure they can attend a certain school.

Most out of area requests are resolved quite easily

In my area there is only one secondary - so every pupil goes there.

Comefromaway · 12/04/2023 09:34

I've voted YABU because you clearly don't understand VAT rules.

VAT is not payable on luxury items. It is payable on luxury food items, bothing to do with how much they cost.

VAT is not payable on education or educational items which is why books are exempt as books are seen as educational.

ManxRhyme · 12/04/2023 09:33

OP I think the majority voted YABU meaning your argument is unreasonable for equating books to private school fees. Not that they are agreeing with you. I doubt anyone waded through your thesis.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 12/04/2023 09:25

Several of our friends who send their kids to private school are starting to bleat about this... I can see why they're p'd off about it but they're far from struggling even though they'd class themselves as middle class and 'ordinary' they are far from it.
I think they've genuinely lost perspective because they all come from MC/ well off families, they see that their parents generation seemed to have more money, or private school cost less or something whereas even though we probably are around they same as them financially it wouldn't occur to us to send our kids to private school.

They made their choices, and we've made ours but there's no way families who can afford between £15k-£20k per kid for schooling per year are 'ordinary'.

Our mate estimated that sending their 3 to secondary school until 6th form will cost them around £500k all in - over the next 7 year. Half a million quid! We live in a naice area with good schools. There's no private school worth half a million more than our state secondaries.

RedToothBrush · 12/04/2023 09:08

BlusteryLake · 12/04/2023 06:41

Putting Vat on private education makes it marginally more exclusive than it already is. The OP sounds like the bleatings of someone who will be caught on the wrong side of the line if this happens, making it apparent to her that this is indeed what private education is like for the vast majority who couldn't afford it regardless of VAT or no VAT.

Exactly.

Wah wah wah

Pass me the tiny violin.

Newnamefor2021 · 12/04/2023 08:47

Yours comparing apples to oranges in four attempt to make your defend your privilege. Private education is clearly a luxury, books are not anywhere in the same category of books. The point is I am sure all of us would love to give our children the same advantages as having a private education but the reality is it's not about priorities, it's simply not in the ability for many, no matter how much they would like to.

It's fantastic you are able to give your children that opportunity and you should feel proud you're able to prioritise that for them, but insisting it's the same as buying a book occasionally is a ridiculous argument. Also it would have a profound impact on authors and the ability to make a living from their profession.

sashh · 12/04/2023 08:23

Books should never be a luxury. And the prices you quote - where are you buying your books?

Kokeshi123 · 12/04/2023 08:00

It's not about the product or service per se, but about the kind of people using the product or service. Private schooling is seen as a luxury good in a way that books are not.

Even though the UK has more middle class people than ever before and children stay on at school longer than ever before, the number of children being educated at private school has fallen to lower levels than 50 years ago, at just 6% of all kids (and bear in mind that a large chunk of those are sixth formers who go to a private SF college for a couple of years).

This is partly because state schools have improved, but also because PS fees have risen far above inflation for 30 years or more, pricing most families out. There is therefore no longer enough of a constituency to really fight for private schooling access. It used to be that a huge % of the middle class, including opinion-makers such as journalists, tended to use private schools. Now they don't, for the most part.

I think this will come in, if we get a Labour government, which looks quite likely.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 12/04/2023 07:50

Twatty indeed. Not exactly enhancing the reputation of people who send their kids to private school while wailing that they aren’t privileged

SweetSakura · 12/04/2023 07:29

What a twatty way to try and manipulate the answers to a vote

SuperSange · 12/04/2023 07:23

You've not addressed the public library situation, OP.

HouseByTheSeaside · 12/04/2023 07:19

Don't be silly.

Endlesssummer2022 · 12/04/2023 07:08

I agree with you OP. Most people who wish for VAT to be added to private education aren’t thinking it through. The state system won’t benefit from VAT on private education at all. What little money collected won’t be ringfenced.

All that will happen is that many wealthier families move to the catchment of great state schools, pushing up house prices and locking out poorer kids. In addition the freed up private school places will go to the superich only as well as wealthy foreigners. It’s not like the schools will close down so it won’t support equality, it will exacerbate exclusivity.

Meanwhile because the VAT precedent has been set, they will start to add it to healthcare and other things.

Labour made a strategic error announcing this intention as people like me see it as the thin end of a new tax hike wedge and a culture war issue. They should be focusing on things which will really support a stronger economy enabling more investment in schools such as getting us back into the Single Market or investments into innovation hubs which kick start productivity.

Just continually calling for more money to be taken from individuals doesn’t help anyone.

nettie434 · 12/04/2023 07:05

So if you are voting that IABU to call for VAT on books then you should also be supporting non-profit-making schools - ones that are providing education as a service, not as a business, in regions where the state offering is inadequate - to be able to charge their fees at cost-price without adding VAT, even though not everyone can afford that.

I don't think the two are comparable at all. The controversy about VAT exemption for private schools is because Eton is treated the same way as a local food bank. Books - digital and print - are excluded from VAT because reading is seen as a public good from which everyone benefits.

BlusteryLake · 12/04/2023 06:41

Putting Vat on private education makes it marginally more exclusive than it already is. The OP sounds like the bleatings of someone who will be caught on the wrong side of the line if this happens, making it apparent to her that this is indeed what private education is like for the vast majority who couldn't afford it regardless of VAT or no VAT.

Purplehyena · 12/04/2023 06:33

I haven’t voted as I don't agree with either of your options, and I think your interpretation of the case for VAT chargeable items is simplistic and flawed. (Although that said, I don’t agree with a lot of the rules within that)

A handful of the people who have actually posted on the thread (much fewer than those who have voted) have tried to argue that there's a qualitative difference between buying an additional educational advantage that they choose to buy vs buying an additional advantage

I think the above is the crux of it for me, the VAT is for the ‘additional advantage’ of the private educational service. I know you have done so, but I don’t believe books can be defined as an ‘additional advantage’. Most research would show how essential books are to development in a way that private education is not.

(For full disclosure I’m speaking as someone who was privately educated and whose family own a private school as a business and have done so all my life. We feel that VAT should be charged on fees, although obviously that not happening has business advantages).

Tibtilkobkob · 12/04/2023 06:20

ZirihePevzig · 11/04/2023 20:44

97% of 417ish voters agree with me.

(as you can see if you can read my posts, my own position is that it's unreasonable to charge VAT on educational benefits generally, including books - I was clear in the OP that "YABU" was a vote to agree with that POV)

A handful of the people who have actually posted on the thread (much fewer than those who have voted) have tried to argue that there's a qualitative difference between buying an additional educational advantage that they choose to buy vs buying an additional advantage that they don't or can't, but have not made any rational reason for drawing this difference other than that they want to. I can only imagine that these people abstained from the voting as they didn't agree with the fundamental premise - still a massive minority.

The reason why you have the majority agreeing is because you've pushed them into a corner by putting private education in the same category as books. No one is ever going to vote that books should have vat. If you asked on private education only then you'd probably get a very different response but I suppose it's more important that you feel you're right so you've made a false equivalency to push your agenda.
Anyway, books should never have vat obviously. I actually don't think that private education should have vat either but you're so insufferable you've almost made me change my stance on that.

TheFrenchLady · 11/04/2023 22:53

I can afford to buy lots of books and I do. I also subscribe to Amazon Audible.

I also use the local library on a very regular basis: right now, I have 15 books out on my ticket and two Borrow Box audible books. That is because as a community we use use this valuable resource or we will lose it.

It is a valuable resource because books and reading are not luxuries. They will become so though if we close libraries and make books even more expensive. They will be for the well off only and that is a pretty good way of keeping knowledge from the poor.

Hands off our books!

blacksax · 11/04/2023 22:51

Words fail me.