Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Proof of disability is fine ?

260 replies

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 17:26

My previous post was about an incident regarding daughter ( 9 in wheelchair ) being refused the wheelchair space on a bus in favour of a toddler in a stroller and a sleeping baby in a stroller.
anyway, I have tried to gain some online support regarding the company and also put in a complaint with the bus company but this has caused a debate about invisible illnesses.
apparently companies should not be allowed to ask for evidence of disability ? I find this a bit odd. There is certain things that annoy me now about this for example how anyone can buy a disabled toilet radar key, how sunflower lanyards ( I think ) are readily available for anyone so lose there authenticity I find.
now my daughter has a wheelchair - yes and has a physical medical device that is visible, however we still need to show evidence for things like blue badge / parking. Carers tickets / ride access at theme parks etc.
surely this is correct, I have never had an issue with needing to. If you took away the rights of companies or organisations being able to do this surely everything would just be abused ?

OP posts:
splilt · 11/04/2023 18:53

I once tried to use the accessible toilet at a train station and I had to ask the cleaner because it was cordoned off and she asked me 'why?'

It infuriated me to the point I complained the the station management, so while I don't have an issue providing proof I absolutely do not want to explain myself to a cleaner. Particularly when I am at risk of wetting myself.

ValleyClouds · 11/04/2023 18:50

I unlocked a RADAR toilet once in a Spoons to find a drunk lying on the floor

Sirzy · 11/04/2023 18:48

Lippydoody · 11/04/2023 18:38

Be really careful with the radar keys. Sometimes, the internal lock doesn’t work properly and anyone can open the door with a key whilst you’re on the loo. It’s happened countless times and I’ve had it happen to me. Sadly, I will only use it when I have someone with me to hold the door. It creates a huge barrier for me as I do need to use the disabled toilets but it’s a hidden disability

I was somewhere with ds last week which has a secondary lock which was a big touch pad on the inside which locked/unlocked it which I thought was a good improvement

(it said it automatically unlocked after 30 minutes or when the emergency cord was pulled)

splilt · 11/04/2023 18:46

@Lippydoody

Be really careful with the radar keys. Sometimes, the internal lock doesn’t work properly and anyone can open the door with a key whilst you’re on the loo.

Thank, I have had this happen in the past. If the lock looks at all dodgy I leave now. Hope for the best with the others and 90% of the time I'm not alone, thankfully. There was one time I was in my own and mid pee when an alarm started going off (I hadn't touched anything) and I was terrified the attendant was just going to come in but couldn't stop seeing. It also is a bit of an effort for me to get 'back together' after a wee Blush I was fortunate that no one came in but it left me quite concerned for anyone who actually needed help in the loo.

GeneHuntsCowboyBoots · 11/04/2023 18:45

DidyouNO · 11/04/2023 18:41

My foster child has been through hell, he is severely disabled, blind, non verbal, has severe complex needs in all areas born very early addicted to heroin and methodone, he cannot feed himself, he cannot talk or communicate in any way. But he's 3yrs old, still travels in a pushchair and looks normal unless people notice his shaky eyes or he has a spasm episode. If people were to question me on him then if tell them to mind their business. You need to at some point just trust that the majority of people are good and ho eat and I am not disrespecting my boy and airing his private issues for all to hear. Its would feel far to disrespectful!

That’s not what OP was saying though. So, using my Alton Towers example. If you were having a family day out (assuming your foster son could be included) at a theme park and you wanted to get carer’s entry, would you be happy to show the relevant proof then?

ValleyClouds · 11/04/2023 18:45

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/registering-as-disabled/

This is the info @SquareRootOfAllEvil

Was done away with in 95 or 96

DidyouNO · 11/04/2023 18:41

My foster child has been through hell, he is severely disabled, blind, non verbal, has severe complex needs in all areas born very early addicted to heroin and methodone, he cannot feed himself, he cannot talk or communicate in any way. But he's 3yrs old, still travels in a pushchair and looks normal unless people notice his shaky eyes or he has a spasm episode. If people were to question me on him then if tell them to mind their business. You need to at some point just trust that the majority of people are good and ho eat and I am not disrespecting my boy and airing his private issues for all to hear. Its would feel far to disrespectful!

Inkblue · 11/04/2023 18:40

Viviennemary · 11/04/2023 18:24

I didn't agree with mask exemption lanyards being available for anybody to download on the internet. I think your DD should have had priority on the bus. This has been discussed a lot on MN in the past. I think proof should be needed for a blue badge.

Proof is needed for a blue badge. Either your PiP entitlement or an assessment from the council.

ValleyClouds · 11/04/2023 18:40

@SquareRootOfAllEvil

I also hate Registered Disabled as a term

There actually WAS a register at one time but it was done away with in the 90s for being creepy, unhelpful and a bit fascist

GeneHuntsCowboyBoots · 11/04/2023 18:38

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 18:29

@GeneHuntsCowboyBoots yes
the radar key thing is just a bit of a weird one
I don’t really care who comes out of a disabled toilets but what is the point in the radar key situation ? Like what are the doors locked with a lock that anyone can actually purchase haha they may as well just take the radar Key away.

I know! However, I don’t think they’re abused as much as it might seem and that there’s probably only a very small percentage of people who have one that don’t need it. That said, that’s only my experience of it. If disabled loos (I’m thinking of the Alton Towers ones as an example) were just open then I can see them being abused. I’m sure there’s one at the entrance inside the park that doesn’t need a key and it seems to have a steady stream of users at busy times, whereas the one near Rita which needs a key hardly has anyone in it, regardless of busyness. And I know that the people in the one near the front could have an invisible disability but when you see people in the regular queue then go into the disabled loo because they don’t want to wait, it’s natural to question it!

Lippydoody · 11/04/2023 18:38

splilt · 11/04/2023 18:28

They are not pointless for me. I am a semi regular disabled toilet user. I have a radar key and use it depending on the location of the ladies and what kind of day I'm having generally. That other people may have bought one they don't need has no impact.

Be really careful with the radar keys. Sometimes, the internal lock doesn’t work properly and anyone can open the door with a key whilst you’re on the loo. It’s happened countless times and I’ve had it happen to me. Sadly, I will only use it when I have someone with me to hold the door. It creates a huge barrier for me as I do need to use the disabled toilets but it’s a hidden disability

ValleyClouds · 11/04/2023 18:37

Before I became a full time wheelchair user and instead was extremely prone to falls, I got asked for "Proof Of Disability" at a National Express.

This was 20 years ago or so

I replied with : "Would You Like Me To Walk Up And Down?"

He said "No, like a Blue Badge"

I said "If I had a car would I be getting a coach?"

He got a supervisor in the end

I heard someone at Alton Towers got declined an Access Pass because they failed to bring proof of disability. The person had no legs.

Make a copy of any official letter you have and present that.

BooksAndHooks · 11/04/2023 18:36

Many places are now switching to access card. This is assessed separately and your needs highlighted on the card. You then don’t need to show personal information to strangers and they can see at a glance from the symbols what your access requirements are. As it also has a photo it stops people using PIP or DLA letters fraudulently.

postapesto · 11/04/2023 18:33

PuttingDownRoots · 11/04/2023 18:05

Its been suggested before that bus companies provide "Treat as Wheelchair" passes for disabled children in SN buggies or standard buggies for babies/toddlers so that this debate doesn't happen.

But on what basis would they provide them? With proof or without?

splilt · 11/04/2023 18:33

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 18:31

@splilt sorry what I meant was that the radar system itself is pointless they don’t need the radar key not that disability toilets were pointless in general.
you would have access either way.

But less people have access than if there was no key.

pinkpip100 · 11/04/2023 18:33

OP I completely understand what you were asking and not quite sure how so many posters have misconstrued your post. I agree that if you are expecting an additional concession such as free carer access, reduced entry fee or access passes at a theme park/attraction etc etc, then it should continue to be acceptable for the business offering the concession to ask for proof of disability. If that is stopped, then it's likely that businesses would simply stop offering those concessions.
Nowhere did the OP suggest that someone sitting in a priority seat on public transport should have to show any proof of disability. The radar key thing is an odd one like you said - I think it would be better just to leave disabled toilets unlocked. As my dc becomes more independent, they are likely to need to use the disabled toilets, but having to negotiate using a radar key to open the door (or having to ask for the door to be unlocked by a member of staff) might well make it much more challenging than if the doors were just unlocked to start with.

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 18:31

@splilt sorry what I meant was that the radar system itself is pointless they don’t need the radar key not that disability toilets were pointless in general.
you would have access either way.

OP posts:
splilt · 11/04/2023 18:31

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 18:29

@GeneHuntsCowboyBoots yes
the radar key thing is just a bit of a weird one
I don’t really care who comes out of a disabled toilets but what is the point in the radar key situation ? Like what are the doors locked with a lock that anyone can actually purchase haha they may as well just take the radar Key away.

There are millions of people who haven't bought one though, so the key works. Not as strictly as you may want it to; not it definitely works.

GeneHuntsCowboyBoots · 11/04/2023 18:30

splilt · 11/04/2023 18:28

They are not pointless for me. I am a semi regular disabled toilet user. I have a radar key and use it depending on the location of the ladies and what kind of day I'm having generally. That other people may have bought one they don't need has no impact.

Not pointless for me either and it sounds like I use it in a similar way to you. Sometimes I’m fine to use a non accessible loo, sometimes I’m not and it’s extremely handy when I do need to use it.

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 18:29

@GeneHuntsCowboyBoots yes
the radar key thing is just a bit of a weird one
I don’t really care who comes out of a disabled toilets but what is the point in the radar key situation ? Like what are the doors locked with a lock that anyone can actually purchase haha they may as well just take the radar Key away.

OP posts:
splilt · 11/04/2023 18:28

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 18:20

radar keys are a bit of a weird one I think in theory they just should exist
public toilets do now have locks on Main door that need opening.
the whole key on door is off when you don’t have to apply for them you just order one for like 2.00
they just really not needed and a bit pointless.

They are not pointless for me. I am a semi regular disabled toilet user. I have a radar key and use it depending on the location of the ladies and what kind of day I'm having generally. That other people may have bought one they don't need has no impact.

GeneHuntsCowboyBoots · 11/04/2023 18:27

I understand what you’re saying OP and I agree with you, though I also understand why some people might find it intrusive, depending on their condition so it’s a tough one.

However, I don’t mind showing the necessary information when applying for a carer’s pass at Alton Towers, or when we recently went to Beamish for example. I also use a radar key, though can sometimes manage without and will use the non accessible loos.

I do think it’s dependent on the circumstances of who’s asking for proof as well. Like the Alton Towers and Beamish examples are entirely understandable as my husband is essentially gaining access free of charge. Other circumstances, like using the disabled loos in Tesco, then no, you shouldn’t be asked. I was someone who bought my radar key off Amazon before I got my blue badge (which was for unrelated issues)..I got it for my IBS as there are/were times I literally cannot/couldn’t wait but I’d have had nothing to prove this at the time either.

But you’re correct in saying (well I think it’s what you were saying) that there shouldn’t be a blanket ban on all organisations being able to ask for proof.

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 18:27

@Viviennemary I think it’s so hard to find a balance like the lanyards you are talking about. It’s like relying on people to be completely honest because people think people won’t take advantage and pretend to be disabled but unfortunately they do.
many concern with removing any companies right to ask for proof is a lot of companies would just take the accessible stuff they provide away .

OP posts:
Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 18:25

Sorry for the typos, my phone screen keeps doing something dodgy ! Need to switch to laptop.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 11/04/2023 18:24

I didn't agree with mask exemption lanyards being available for anybody to download on the internet. I think your DD should have had priority on the bus. This has been discussed a lot on MN in the past. I think proof should be needed for a blue badge.

Swipe left for the next trending thread