Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Proof of disability is fine ?

260 replies

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 17:26

My previous post was about an incident regarding daughter ( 9 in wheelchair ) being refused the wheelchair space on a bus in favour of a toddler in a stroller and a sleeping baby in a stroller.
anyway, I have tried to gain some online support regarding the company and also put in a complaint with the bus company but this has caused a debate about invisible illnesses.
apparently companies should not be allowed to ask for evidence of disability ? I find this a bit odd. There is certain things that annoy me now about this for example how anyone can buy a disabled toilet radar key, how sunflower lanyards ( I think ) are readily available for anyone so lose there authenticity I find.
now my daughter has a wheelchair - yes and has a physical medical device that is visible, however we still need to show evidence for things like blue badge / parking. Carers tickets / ride access at theme parks etc.
surely this is correct, I have never had an issue with needing to. If you took away the rights of companies or organisations being able to do this surely everything would just be abused ?

OP posts:
davegrohll · 11/04/2023 21:02

Off topic but I often get death stares off old ladies on the bus when they can't put there shopping trolleys in the buggy area as I've got the pushchair lol

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 21:00

@nokidshere thats very rare !
most people defo have to send evidence

OP posts:
nokidshere · 11/04/2023 20:57

What?! We haven't even managed to apply for a blue badge yet (despite dc needing it) because the application is so complicated and the evidence they ask for is manifold! We certainly haven't been given the option of a chat with someone on the phone, send payment and bingo!!

I called the council blue badge team. She asked me what my mobility problems were, I told her. She said I could have a blue badge and the payment would be £10. This was 4yrs ago. She also told me about PIP (I'd not heard of it before then) and suggested I should apply, which I then did (and got) but I got the blue badge first.

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 20:54

@Morph22010 in they instance it might work but considering in our country a paramedic did not get any jail time for attempting to rob a dead lady whilst on duty I really doubt we would do much about someone getting a ride access pass at legoland for pretending to be disabled.

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 11/04/2023 20:46

Morph22010 · 11/04/2023 20:30

I’ve not been but apparently Disney in Florida you don’t have to show proof to get the ride access pass like you do at the theme parks here, in fact I heard it’s illegal for the parks to ask. Apparently how it works well is because impersonating a disabled person is a crime for which someone can be imprisoned so people tend not to

The Americans with Disabilities Act has teeth. As does the requirement for federal buildings to be accessible.

It's not perfect, but it's less of a joke than the UKs half hearted lip service.

difficultdifficultlemondifficult · 11/04/2023 20:46

TheOriginalEmu · 11/04/2023 20:38

What ‘proof’ is there? I have multiple disabilities but I don’t have a certificate that says ‘I am disabled’?

Whenever I had booked a carer ticket for something a letter from DWP with mine/my sons name on has been fine. I haven't been asked often, most places just take your word for it in my experience.

drawingmaps · 11/04/2023 20:45

I agree with the idea of issuing an access card with the PIP letter. I don't like having to carry the letter around, and it is stressful that everything seems to have different requirements. e.g. to get theatre discounts/ take a carer in Wales you need a Hynt card, which is different to what you need for other access cards. They all cost too, and even if it's only a few quid it adds up. A simple wallet card in the PIP letter would solve it, given that you need to show proof of PIP/DLA to get it in the first place usually, not a diagnosis letter. This could also have a note to allow free carer entry, as currently a lot of places ask for a specific carers card. As a disabled adult I do usually need someone to go with me to access the world, but it's not just one specific carer - it's as likely to be a friend as it is my dad. They don't all have cards. I've usually managed to argue the point though, but it's stressful.

OP, I actually think Radar keys are overall a good thing. Yes, they are readily available, but most non-disabled people wouldn't buy them, or even know they could. Whereas they are more likely to just use an accessible loo when they don't need it if there isn't a Radar lock. In my experience Radar loos tend to be cleaner, less likely to be abused, and the key just lives in my wheelchair bag. There are some downsides, such as for visitors to the UK, and the problem that there's often not a latch on the inside so anyone else with a key could just walk in.

EsmeSusanOgg · 11/04/2023 20:44

pinkpip100 · 11/04/2023 20:18

What?! We haven't even managed to apply for a blue badge yet (despite dc needing it) because the application is so complicated and the evidence they ask for is manifold! We certainly haven't been given the option of a chat with someone on the phone, send payment and bingo!!

I'm also confused. I had to fill in forms on GOV.UK, then send additional evidence to the council.

I also didn't have to send payment.

difficultdifficultlemondifficult · 11/04/2023 20:43

I have shrunk down and photocopied my sons DLA letter and my carers allowance letter and keep them folded up inside my purse so they are always there if I need them. I also have digital copies on my phone.

I think proof should be asked for otherwise things will be abused by people who just want a cheap or free ticket or a 'perk' of being disabled.

I know someone who purchased their whole family sunflower lanyards for their journey through the airport so they could fast track and avoid queues, board first etc. nobody has a disability or reason to use a lanyard. The worry of potentially being asked for proper evidence would stop twats like this.

EsmeSusanOgg · 11/04/2023 20:41

@Itsamission25 sorry! Wasn't the clearest. I think you are in the right and YANBU at all.

TheOriginalEmu · 11/04/2023 20:38

What ‘proof’ is there? I have multiple disabilities but I don’t have a certificate that says ‘I am disabled’?

Playingchesswithpigeons · 11/04/2023 20:36

I agree with OP. Countless, COUNTLESS times I have witnessed disabled toilet's permanently left open in the last 12 months ( radar key no longer needed ) Trafford Centre/Cheshire Oaks/Shopping malls. When it's eventually my turn and the person using has come out 9/10 its a group of girls.
I went to a show and had to wait 15 minutes for the disabled loo. When the door finally opened, 4 friends, middle aged women/laughing/drinks in hand all left the loo together.
There was another at least 10 women behind me queuing because. the " normal " toilet's queue was too long.

I fully understand there are " invisible" disabilities, but get a RADAR KEY then, like I had too.
Don't start leaving all the disabled toilets unlocked, because THERE ARE hidden disabilities, because they are being abused.

People ARE abusing the system. A system originally designed to help disadvantaged/vulnerable & disabled people. A card, letter, badge, doesn't breach confidentiality, I'm happy to show anyone.

An 'invisible' disability shouldn't equal no medical evidence required

BlackeyedSusan · 11/04/2023 20:34

We have these threads regularly. Always the same...

Every time I say we need to redesign the buses to make them more flexible for buggies and wheelchairs to fit more on. Good examples on the continent.

Augend23 · 11/04/2023 20:33

itsgettingweird · 11/04/2023 20:23

In my council you'd just take the letter with your diagnosis to the council offices and they'd issue you the radar key.

Yup, so I have to get a GP to write a diagnosis letter (essentially the same as the point I made, because it still requires an appointment/the GPs time) and the council still has to employ a person who spends at least a portion of their time giving out radar keys. Still not actually a good use of public funds.

Or I could buy one for £2 on Amazon. (Or abolish the whole thing entirely as the OP suggests.)

x2boys · 11/04/2023 20:33

Morph22010 · 11/04/2023 20:27

I’m the opposite, we have a blue badge for ds but I try and not use blue badge space if I can park elsewhere and there isn’t loads of disabled spaces as Ds doesn’t use a wheelchair so we don’t need a larger space

We don't either but my son has severe mental impairment,so if the blue badge p!aces are nearer the shop we use them or the parent and child places whatever r is safer for him watch mumsnet implode,though if you suggest you would use a parent and child place ! My son is nearly 13 but looks about nine so nobody questions it ,I'm not going to.put my child at risk though I need to.keep.him.safe .

Morph22010 · 11/04/2023 20:30

I’ve not been but apparently Disney in Florida you don’t have to show proof to get the ride access pass like you do at the theme parks here, in fact I heard it’s illegal for the parks to ask. Apparently how it works well is because impersonating a disabled person is a crime for which someone can be imprisoned so people tend not to

Morph22010 · 11/04/2023 20:27

x2boys · 11/04/2023 18:12

Yes that would make perfect sense ,my child has a blue badge obviously we have to display it to park I n a blue badge space ,although there was a thread a while ago where some posters thought they should just get to.decide they can use a blue badge space if they felt they had a need for it(
Even though they were not a blue badge holder ,but that's a while different thread!🙄

I’m the opposite, we have a blue badge for ds but I try and not use blue badge space if I can park elsewhere and there isn’t loads of disabled spaces as Ds doesn’t use a wheelchair so we don’t need a larger space

itsgettingweird · 11/04/2023 20:23

Augend23 · 11/04/2023 20:08

Another one saying I don't think asking for proof for radar keys is helpful.

Yes, it might prevent a few chancers who order a radar key on Amazon. But it would also prevent people like me, with IBS. Bad enough my work concluded it was a disability when they assessed me via occy health. Currently pretty well managed. Certainly not eligible for PIP or a blue badge or anything like it. But also sometimes it's not well managed, or it hits me while I'm out. And then I need a cubicle with a sink inside, and I need to use the loo urgently or I will end up shitting myself.

I guess we could come up with some form of bureaucracy where we come up with a form and then I go and have (another) GP appointment at my short staffed GP and then they send the form off to the council who then send me a radar key. But that would probably cost an absolute minimum of £50 per person to administer and that's probably massively underestimating is. So for a problem I don't think really exists (vast numbers of non disabled people buying and using radar keys) it seems like a massively excessive solution.

In my council you'd just take the letter with your diagnosis to the council offices and they'd issue you the radar key.

GeneHuntsCowboyBoots · 11/04/2023 20:22

pinkpip100 · 11/04/2023 20:18

What?! We haven't even managed to apply for a blue badge yet (despite dc needing it) because the application is so complicated and the evidence they ask for is manifold! We certainly haven't been given the option of a chat with someone on the phone, send payment and bingo!!

I think it’s council dependent. That’s what happened with me too. Though at subsequent renewals, once I had to take my PIP letter and the second time (last year), I just had another phone call, said I still received PIP and that was it!

pinkpip100 · 11/04/2023 20:20

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 20:13

@Augend23 i just think the radar keys are pointless and a mission !
my daughter will never be able to access one independently where as if there was no radar key she probably could …. The radar key is so readily available that removing the radar key might make it more accessible for Lots considering they readily available and anyone can buy one.

I agree

pinkpip100 · 11/04/2023 20:18

nokidshere · 11/04/2023 19:54

the answer to the blue badge comment though is exactly you do show proof because you have to show prof when applying for a blue badge so that is your proof

I didn't show any proof to get my blue badge, I just had a conversation on the phone with a really nice lady who granted it to me then I sent my payment.

What?! We haven't even managed to apply for a blue badge yet (despite dc needing it) because the application is so complicated and the evidence they ask for is manifold! We certainly haven't been given the option of a chat with someone on the phone, send payment and bingo!!

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 20:17

@elliejjtiny this is not a dig in anyway more of have your tried this.
you say that it’s obvious to anyone that speaks to him for more than 10 minutes does that include school and other services ?
you don’t need to have a diagnose to apply to DLA but school reports etc help and a letter from them that know him. Even letters from say a general paediatric doctor you have voiced your concerns to or GP. Access cards do not base it on DLA etc either but accept reports from others with or without diagnosis x

OP posts:
elliejjtiny · 11/04/2023 20:14

I always carry my eldest's PIP letter and younger 2's dla letters in my handbag at all times, it's just part of the standard kit we always take everywhere along with inhaler and spare hearing aid batteries. I'm absolutely fine with showing that to anyone official like a bus driver or someone on the admissions gate at a theme park.

However my middle son, despite being obviously autistic to anyone who speaks to him for longer than 10 minutes, has no proof of any disability at all. It's getting more and more difficult to manage and although I know there will be some people who abuse it and I hate that with a passion, I'm also very grateful to the attractions/facilities that offer help for disabled people with no proof required because it means that my child can do something that he might not have been able to do otherwise.

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 20:13

@Augend23 i just think the radar keys are pointless and a mission !
my daughter will never be able to access one independently where as if there was no radar key she probably could …. The radar key is so readily available that removing the radar key might make it more accessible for Lots considering they readily available and anyone can buy one.

OP posts:
GeneHuntsCowboyBoots · 11/04/2023 20:12

grandmaintraining · 11/04/2023 19:46

I'm sorry but I'm feeling really anxious about being expected to show my pip letter. It has my name and address and details of the points awarded in each section.

Am I really expected to do this? It seems like a gross invasion of privacy compared to the blue badge which doesn't have any details on display and even on the back doesn't have details of the points I'm awarded in each section.

Most places accept your yearly update letter which I don’t think has all of your personal information on. I believe it only has your level of entitlement. That’s what I used when I went to Alton Towers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread