Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Proof of disability is fine ?

260 replies

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 17:26

My previous post was about an incident regarding daughter ( 9 in wheelchair ) being refused the wheelchair space on a bus in favour of a toddler in a stroller and a sleeping baby in a stroller.
anyway, I have tried to gain some online support regarding the company and also put in a complaint with the bus company but this has caused a debate about invisible illnesses.
apparently companies should not be allowed to ask for evidence of disability ? I find this a bit odd. There is certain things that annoy me now about this for example how anyone can buy a disabled toilet radar key, how sunflower lanyards ( I think ) are readily available for anyone so lose there authenticity I find.
now my daughter has a wheelchair - yes and has a physical medical device that is visible, however we still need to show evidence for things like blue badge / parking. Carers tickets / ride access at theme parks etc.
surely this is correct, I have never had an issue with needing to. If you took away the rights of companies or organisations being able to do this surely everything would just be abused ?

OP posts:
ShannonMcFarland · 12/04/2023 23:09

splilt · 12/04/2023 08:28

Also my various diagnosis letters are not fucking 'shiny certificates' - thats a deeply horrible thing to say. I'm sorry for the people who haven't got their diagnoses, but being nasty about those who have isn't an attractive quality.

It isn't a horrible thing to say. You projected meaning onto my comment that was never intended when I wrote it and made an incorrect assumption that I'm undiagnosed. That's not the case, but I wasn't given any formalised or written confirmation at the time. Stop being so butthurt.

Itsamission25 · 12/04/2023 12:02

@Pedestriancrossing yes I’m thinking that what I said earlier would maybe be better like lots of other people have said they don’t like showing their pip letters etc thay maybe if DLA and pip sent a basics card along with qualification

on other notes about our big shiny certificates of diagnosis’s I find a little patronising, my daughter has a life threatning disease I am pretty sure we don’t see it as a shiny certificate.

OP posts:
Pedestriancrossing · 12/04/2023 10:58

I do think that disability concessions would be abused if some sort of eligibility was not required, sadly. Then organisations would stop offering concessions so disabled people lose out. You only have to look at rates of thefts of blue badges to see that there are plenty of people willing to abuse the system. I think things like the Access Card scheme are the least worst solution, but not perfect.

grandmaintraining · 12/04/2023 09:02

I certainly don't have any big shiny certificate of diagnoses

Sirzy · 12/04/2023 08:41

Inkblue · 12/04/2023 08:19

I agree with you. I actually think one shouldn’t have to prove their disability at all and I think it is an intrusion to ask what kind of disability. I’m only saying to those that have that evidence that it should be sufficient and not have to have an access card, which is another level of intrusion. It dismays me the amount of people who feel entitled to question someone else on their disabilities or their rights to access for services and, like you, think those who will abuse the system are in the minority and would do it regardless.

So if a place offers free access for carers they are wrong to ask for evidence? If they can’t ask for evidence then people will take the piss and they will stop offering it.

often when out now Ds disability if visible by combination of wheelchair and/or feeding pump connected so in those cases we aren’t generally asked. If we are accessing somewhere that offers carers concessions when he isn’t using either then I will show a copy of carers letter or a photo of the blue badge to show.

if places end up stopping such concessions then that will make it even harder for those who need them to be able to access them

FloatingBean · 12/04/2023 08:38

splilt · 12/04/2023 07:28

And in Scotland you need 12 to get a BB for the 'planning a journey' - I have 10 so if I was in England I would get a BB automatically.

And even in England not everyone with 10 points for planning and following a journey automatically qualifies. Only those with 10 points under descriptor E i.e. Cannot undertake any journey because it would cause overwhelming psychological distress to the claimant. Not those with 10 points under descriptor D i.e. Cannot follow the route of an unfamiliar journey without another person, assistance dog or orientation aid.

splilt · 12/04/2023 08:28

Also my various diagnosis letters are not fucking 'shiny certificates' - thats a deeply horrible thing to say. I'm sorry for the people who haven't got their diagnoses, but being nasty about those who have isn't an attractive quality.

splilt · 12/04/2023 08:26

I think disabled people are, quite rightly, protective of disabled spaces.

Inkblue · 12/04/2023 08:19

ShannonMcFarland · 12/04/2023 07:46

Many people don't have any "proof". I'm ND and don't claim any benefits and never received a big shiny diagnosis certificate so there's really not much I can use to document my status. Perhaps naively, I think the majority of people can be trusted not to take advantage of disability concessions. There will always be grifters who do play the system but they'll do it whatever controls are in place.

I agree with you. I actually think one shouldn’t have to prove their disability at all and I think it is an intrusion to ask what kind of disability. I’m only saying to those that have that evidence that it should be sufficient and not have to have an access card, which is another level of intrusion. It dismays me the amount of people who feel entitled to question someone else on their disabilities or their rights to access for services and, like you, think those who will abuse the system are in the minority and would do it regardless.

ShannonMcFarland · 12/04/2023 07:46

Many people don't have any "proof". I'm ND and don't claim any benefits and never received a big shiny diagnosis certificate so there's really not much I can use to document my status. Perhaps naively, I think the majority of people can be trusted not to take advantage of disability concessions. There will always be grifters who do play the system but they'll do it whatever controls are in place.

x2boys · 12/04/2023 07:32

Inkblue · 11/04/2023 22:28

They could accept all the other pieces of evidence people have, BB, PIP, DLA awards or they could even take your word for it. Most people are pretty honest really. I don’t know about the Access card but going on what some posters have said here, it seems very intrusive and not particularly fair.

You would hope that ,but just going off the sunflower lanyard during the pandemic ,it became meaningless because everyone had one and I heard it being called the mask exemption lanyard ,the.original, purpose of it was so people with hidden disabilities in supermarkets ,airports ect could be identified if they needed, extra support ,now I'm not getting into a pointless argument about masks and I'm sure many people genuinely couldn't wear them but I don't think it was everyone .

splilt · 12/04/2023 07:29

splilt · 12/04/2023 07:21

@Morph22010

The rules for automatic BB are different for PiP and different again for ADP (Scottish disability) then they are for DLA.

Sorry this is me just half awake
.
The rules are different in Scotland to England - it doesn't matter if it's PIP or ADP you get, sorry Blush

splilt · 12/04/2023 07:28

Spikeyball · 12/04/2023 06:44

"I’m not familiar with pip as my son gets dla but for dla if you get higher rate mobility (which you need to qualify for motability) then this automatically qualifies you for a blue badge. Is it not similar for pip?"

No you can get the higher level mobility PIP and not be automatically entitled to a blue badge. DS has just switched to PIP and he isn't.
He gets 12 points for planning and making a journey which means he can have a motability car but his blue badge is dependent upon the council agreeing he fits their criteria.
He got it automatically with DLA through the severe mental impairment criteria but there is no equivalent PIP condition.

And in Scotland you need 12 to get a BB for the 'planning a journey' - I have 10 so if I was in England I would get a BB automatically.

splilt · 12/04/2023 07:21

@Morph22010

The rules for automatic BB are different for PiP and different again for ADP (Scottish disability) then they are for DLA.

DisquietintheRanks · 12/04/2023 07:09

My ds is doubly disabled. He doesn't need a blue badge, he might need a seat on the bus and he definitely needs access to to an accessible toilet at times. People are definitely more tolerant of this when his disability is visible eg when he has a feeding tube.

Spikeyball · 12/04/2023 06:44

"I’m not familiar with pip as my son gets dla but for dla if you get higher rate mobility (which you need to qualify for motability) then this automatically qualifies you for a blue badge. Is it not similar for pip?"

No you can get the higher level mobility PIP and not be automatically entitled to a blue badge. DS has just switched to PIP and he isn't.
He gets 12 points for planning and making a journey which means he can have a motability car but his blue badge is dependent upon the council agreeing he fits their criteria.
He got it automatically with DLA through the severe mental impairment criteria but there is no equivalent PIP condition.

Morph22010 · 12/04/2023 03:54

splilt · 11/04/2023 21:08

I wish our council was like that. I just got a flat no.

The irony of having a motability car but not always being able to park it isn't lost on me

I’m not familiar with pip as my son gets dla but for dla if you get higher rate mobility (which you need to qualify for motability) then this automatically qualifies you for a blue badge. Is it not similar for pip? We are other way round to you p, we get blue badge for my son but he’s only on lower rate mobility so we don’t qualify for motability

elliejjtiny · 12/04/2023 00:15

There is a trampoline park and a climbing wall place near me where they have quieter sessions for people with disabilities where they turn the music off, have less people admitted and the entrance fee is about £3 cheaper. They don't ask for proof. I know someone who openly takes their non disabled child to these sessions. Every time they mention it they get the Paddington bear hard stare from me and a reminder that those sessions are for disabled people, many of whom can't access the other sessions because they are too busy. They don't care though, they only think about what's best for them and saving £3.

Itsamission25 · 12/04/2023 00:07

@theWarOnPeace that is the exact issue once people realise they could do it - they would.
then the issue is the access lines would be rammed and the people who genuinely need it no longer have the benefit.
same as carer tickets, people started booking carers tickets because they could then they would soon stop !

OP posts:
Whapples · 11/04/2023 23:54

Not going to lie, I think it would be way easier if there was a government or singular organisation that provided cards to show people were disabled (eg they’d show that place the proof of pip/blue badge/medical evidence) and you could just show that. I hate carrying my pip
letter as it’s either quite in depth on my medical diagnosis or has my financial bit on. My blue badge often has to be in the car so can’t then take it to purchase attraction tickets… it would just be easier imo.

theWarOnPeace · 11/04/2023 23:42

I have a blue badge but think things like access cards are a good idea because I don’t think the threshold for a BB should be the criteria for deciding someone’s needs and/or disability.

Whilst I don’t appreciate being quizzed, I wouldn’t mind if it’s for a one off card which then once that’s shown you’re done explaining. I literally argued with a man in the street when I was parking the other day and showed him my face on my blue badge and told him to ring the council to see what criteria I bloody met. I know in my borough that abusing blue badges is rife, and think there’s a fine line between protecting our dignity and giving piss takers an open field to falsely claim disability. There should be some kind of ID card or number that links with your identity for people who have disabilities, chronic illnesses and additional needs and SEN etc but that does also bring up the question of who has the right to be requesting this, how is dignity respected and GDPR and more?

In the Orlando theme parks they now aren’t allowed to ask for proof of disability, so despite me coming prepared with paperwork they didn’t need it. I was telling a friend this and their friend was there, just in the context of me saying there’s no way we could have done the queues in Florida, and they asked the process for access etc and the friend of friend mentioned they had Florida booked and jokingly said that if they don’t ask for proof she may have to try it. Friend said a few months later that’s what they did, lied at the desk and just said disability and they had no choice but to approve the pass as again they are not allowed to ask for proof. It’s seen as or under the law as a violation of medical privacy etc so they can’t ask. Here in the UK at Chessington and Lego etc they do ask for proof and also ask questions about the nature of the condition.

re things like radar keys, I asked at.I don’t know how many official channels from council to GP how to get one until I asked someone coming out of a disabled loo and she said errr I just buy them off Amazon? So I got one off Amazon.

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 23:21

There’s lots of things wrong with disability access which caused the debate in the first place. It would only get worse for disabled if it became un checked.

OP posts:
Inkblue · 11/04/2023 23:10

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 22:53

What do you mean I don’t have any issues accessing things ?

I didn’t mean it in a negative way but you say you use the card and it’s working for you.

Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 22:53

What do you mean I don’t have any issues accessing things ?

OP posts:
Itsamission25 · 11/04/2023 22:52

This is an example of an access card
the squares at the Bottom is all that is shown about your health / disability.

AIBU Proof of disability is fine ?
OP posts: