Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think there's a lot drama and scaremongering around women coping as a new mum?

269 replies

imicayrp · 11/04/2023 17:00

I am open to being put in my place and told I have an easy child (so far) but I was shocked by how much pressure, stress and fear was pumped into me before birth, to find that 6 months on, I’m fine and found this pretty simple from day one. Always had that elusive hot cup of tea, always had time to speak to friends and cook my dinner. I did this all without support from my partner who had an affair 8 weeks before our child was born. I know 6 months is nothing and I’m sure there’s hard time ahead but honestly it’s been absolutely NOWHERE near what is described in the media and among colleagues (and mumsnet!). Yes the nights initially were hard but you sleep the next day? It’s a short time. Yes it can be isolating on maternity leave but keep in touch with friends? Buy yourself something nice, watch a series. I don’t understand the huge pressure and drama before women give birth and actually see it as quite a sexist thing. Women can cope, actually. AIBU to have this mentality? Does anyone feel similar?

OP posts:
Hubblebubble · 29/07/2023 12:02

Mine had two types of tongue tie, do I pumped around the clock trying to make as much milk as I could for him. Sleep when baby is sleeping doesn't work when you're almost exclusively pumping. I was exhausted

WandaWonder · 29/07/2023 12:01

If find if people speak of positives labels just as bragging, unicorn child it is not possible your lying, only speaking of the good

When people speak of negatives it is scaremongering and people can't cope because of their anxieties

If people need help they need to ask but people discuss things about their children people don't have to take it on to themselves if they don't want to listen dont

liondreams · 29/07/2023 12:00

yes the post is a bit stealth-boasty, IMO. Anything that makes new mothers feel their difficult experience is more normal helps them. And with any warnings usually go "it will get better in time, don't worry". I don't think people set out to make mothers scared - they are 99% of the time just relaying their own experience, which in many cases is brutal (can testify!).

Herecomestreble1 · 29/07/2023 11:59

Ooh very divisive post. Nothing to be sorry about if you didn't struggle, not everyone does and it's not a race to the bottom. Your version of coping and my version are very very different because we clearly had different babies. You mention the mantra of women "coping" to be sexist yet also mention that buying yourself something nice would cheer women up, which sounds equally sexist to me, as if all women need is some retail therapy and we'll be right as rain.

I don't even think that view is your fault, it's misogyny and it catches us all at points! Mum to mum though, im actually genuinely thrilled to see you are enjoying your time with your new baby, and long may they be a easy baby! 😊

Zanina · 29/07/2023 11:55

jessnoah · 29/07/2023 07:53

YABU - I assume all these issues below don't apply to you?

  • PND
  • horrible births leading to physical issues
  • birth trauma
  • colicky babies who scream non stop
  • living far away from friends/family leaving you isolated
  • having other children meaning you can't just sleep the next day or relax
  • medically complex children
  • breastfeeding issues
  • money issues/workplace issues surrounding maternity

I experienced most of these

Zanina · 29/07/2023 11:55

Whilst I was pregnant people around me so positive and said ot would he amazing sp when it wasn't I felt I was lied to. On the other hand, my MIL leaned into my ear and told me "you need to do this alone" . And subsequently he daughters were telling me not to ask for help but tell my mum to travel 400 miles to come down and help me. I'd helped my MIL perform a strenuous pilgrimage and had always tried to be good to my SILS. I later realised they have always been throwing me under the bus. The damage of emotional abuse has ruined my life for me, and all this came to the forefront after giving birth.

Zanina · 29/07/2023 11:48

I had a high needs baby (suspected autism) no family support and surrounded by unhelpful selfish people who had been meddling in my life. Experienced abuse as a child and it all came to the forefront. PND hit me pretty instantly. Baby woke every 20 mins and fed every 40 mins through the day. Difficult birth. Every day I wished I was dead. I went on to have a second and she was a breeze. Got mastitis 2 times. Episiotomy still hurts 5 years on. I feel like I got lucky the second time otherwise I think if it happened again I would have harmed myself. I love my kids but I never want children again. I put my life and welfare at risk for it, i still dont feel happy as i should. never again.

TwoShades1 · 29/07/2023 11:26

I agree in that i was really only told bad things. Not one person said it will fine. The difficulty of having a new born was really stressed to me. I think it would be more useful to present things as something that could happen not a guarantee.

riotlady · 29/07/2023 11:20

I think it’s really hard to strike a balance, tbh. It can be really hard and it’s cruel to send mothers into that unprepared but at the same time I DID find all the negativity and warnings really got me down during my first pregnancy. Second time around people seem to chill as they assume I know what I’m doing!!

ClemFandango1 · 29/07/2023 10:16

Fwiw I think you have to be pretty bloody resilient to make it out the other side when you are fighting battles in your head every second of every day.

I'm glad you are finding it easy OP. I do fundamentally disagree with your original point - I don't think the challenges are discussed enough sometimes.

ClemFandango1 · 29/07/2023 10:08

youshouldnthaveasked · 11/04/2023 17:05

Have you had any PND at all? That almost killed me

Same.

User2538309 · 29/07/2023 09:50

@Muthaofcats -nice doubling down on your take of “I had the skills and experience so I enjoyed it, others just aren’t as good as me”.

The world is full of messages implying motherhood should be easy and natural for us all. Asking for help, or sharing challenges is massively hard.

There’s huge stigma associated with not coping, there’s huge stigma associated with not “loving every minute”. “Soak up the baby cuddles.” “They are young for such a short time, enjoy every second.” “New baby smell.” “She’s a natural mother.” “Is she a good baby?”

Pip1402 · 29/07/2023 08:48

@Lavender14 would you mind sharing those coping strategies for ppa please? I'm currently pregnant and have a strong tendency towards anxiety so am expecting I could struggle with it.

jessnoah · 29/07/2023 07:53

YABU - I assume all these issues below don't apply to you?

  • PND
  • horrible births leading to physical issues
  • birth trauma
  • colicky babies who scream non stop
  • living far away from friends/family leaving you isolated
  • having other children meaning you can't just sleep the next day or relax
  • medically complex children
  • breastfeeding issues
  • money issues/workplace issues surrounding maternity
MissesMorkan · 29/07/2023 07:44

AnneLovesGilbert · 28/07/2023 21:05

@MissesMorkan 💐💐💐

I hope things got easier over time.

Thank you, @AnneLovesGilbert — they did. He’s now a delightful 11 year old looking the beginnings of puberty in the eye!

Muthaofcats · 28/07/2023 22:19

User2538309 · 28/07/2023 20:19

Plenty of people with stressful jobs have high needs babies, and/or babies with medical needs, and/or PND. This is just another mother-shaming post wrapped up in a self-congratulatory “I must be more resilient than others.” and it’s toxic BS.

Some babies are easier. Some parents have an easier time for various reasons. Didn’t find it difficult? Great, but don’t assume that you are special.

Sorry, but this response is what is toxic.

Saying that motherhood wasn’t as negative as the horror stories people portrayed is not toxic or self congratulatory or smug. It also doesn’t mean your baby was easy or that you had more support or privilege or haven’t suffered from health issues.

The OPs post was clearly about how many people focus on the negatives rather than the positives, and with replies like yours who can blame them. If it’s ‘smug’ to be positive about your experience then people fear being attacked, like you are doing and think the only way to connect is to talk in negative terms.

You have zero idea of anyone’s story. I have experienced severe trauma and hardship during my life, that could have gone two ways, it could have made me more vulnerable to the stresses of motherhood, and that would not be a reflection on me as a person or parent, but it meant I have a profound gratitude because I’ve seen and experienced such suffering. This still isn’t a reflection on me as a person or mother either but it’s also ok to have a lower bar for happiness even during the hardest of times.

And sorry but it’s true, if you have experience prolonged sleeplessness and an unbelievable amount of pressure at work then the newborn stage just isn’t as shocking, so even 1-2 hours a night with a baby seemed survivable to me in comparison and I didn’t see it as a negative even when I felt deranged with exhaustion.

it’s ok for people to be positive and that not be an attack or judgement on those who aren’t able to be.

AnneLovesGilbert · 28/07/2023 21:05

@MissesMorkan 💐💐💐

I hope things got easier over time.

Scrumptiousspongecake · 28/07/2023 21:03

Yabu. Your baby sleeps. Mine used to wake every 45 minutes 24/7 as he had reflux. It was nothing like you describe.

MissesMorkan · 28/07/2023 20:58

Well, good for you. Genuinely.

But I’m a together, sane, confident individual, used to babies, eldest of a big family, with a supportive husband, plenty of money, a straightforward pregnancy and healthy baby etc etc, and I had PND, was hallucinating, the floor was talking, I thought people were trying to take my baby so I couldn’t put him down, my CS scar got infected, my milk never came in, and I was on the floor for months, googling adoption services, desperately trying to figure out a way of turning back time. And I faked sanity so well, no one noticed — not my HV, not my GP, not my DP, not even me, really.

Not all the reading I’d done, not all my experience of babies, not all the advice I’d taken — nothing approached the sheer clusterfuck of new motherhood.

Lavender14 · 28/07/2023 20:43

There are so many factors that go into this.

Firstly how you actually experience your birth is so important. I had a wonderful birth and felt very empowered which set me and ds up for a great start. My mum nearly died in labour with me and was left with severe ptsd and lifelong mental health challenges as a result of that.

I didn't have ppd but I have had ppa. I also work in mental health and have excellent coping strategies and know how to manage it because of that which makes me more resilient. Not every mum knows ppa is even a thing and ppd is a black hole that can be extremely difficult to get yourself out of.

Every baby is different. My ds would have slept any time any place until 6 months. My friends little one had to be in his bed in silence from about 3 months making it much harder for her to get out and socialise.

My ds had colic and screamed from 7-11 every single night without fail for the first 4.5months. I have a really hands on dh and we just swapped every hour or whenever it got too much for the other. Dealing with that alone every night would have been much much harder.

I'm lucky enough to be on mat leave from a supportive employer. I had some savings to tide me over and we've been able to save while I've been on a reduced wage. Many mums are now reliant on food banks etc.

I was very lucky in that my bf journey has (while definitely not without its challenges) been a really positive experience for me and ds. My friend was triple feeding and pumped for months after a very difficult start for baby and it really affected her mental health.

Every single experience is different and while I don't think it's about 'scaring' new mums I do think that there is a lack of awareness of the bits that can be hard, so when you're the only one you know going through it- that's a very lonely place to be. And lonely is not what new mums need.

I also think in a wider context there needs to be greater social awareness especially in the employment sector that pregnancy and maternity leave are big deals. Sure some of us really love it. But others really struggle and that's normal. We need to be honest about that so we can do away with the toxic idea that mat leave is a 'holiday' instead of recovery time. That everyone is ready to leave their baby to return to work. That mums should snap back and be able to get out and about. That they should be back and fully rearing to go when they return from mat leave even if maybe they're realistically still in physio, still struggling mentally, still not feeling ready to leave baby, still struggling getting out the door with multiple kids, still feeling misplaced guilt that they really like being back, still struggling to work out how to afford petrol AND formula so they can get to work. Until we recognise the reality and the wide spectrum that post partum is then we're actually doing women a disservice and furthering those toxic norms.

It's wonderful you have had a great experience and have felt confident and capable, but don't think that your experience is THE experience.

Mamai90 · 28/07/2023 20:29

YABU and sound a but smug.

I actually found it easier than expected but I had a supportive partner, family etc. My baby didn't sleep til she was 1 year old but thanks to support I didn't lose my mind. I had friends, family and baby groups to go to so we spent all day out of the house. But I wouldn't downplay anyone else's experience just because it wasn't mine.

The same goes for other women's birth experiences and recovery. Just because I was lucky doesn't mean I expect everyone else to have had the same experience, I know it's not like that.

User2538309 · 28/07/2023 20:19

Muthaofcats · 28/07/2023 18:34

Agree / so many horror stories and trauma that I was expecting the same and genuinely didn’t experience that, regardless of sleepless babies and no family help. Was much much less stressful than my intense job so had perhaps built up a level of resilience.

Plenty of people with stressful jobs have high needs babies, and/or babies with medical needs, and/or PND. This is just another mother-shaming post wrapped up in a self-congratulatory “I must be more resilient than others.” and it’s toxic BS.

Some babies are easier. Some parents have an easier time for various reasons. Didn’t find it difficult? Great, but don’t assume that you are special.

Muthaofcats · 28/07/2023 18:35

mycoffeecup · 11/04/2023 17:19

You can't see how 'I coped so I don't understand how other people don't' is offensive?

Why on earth are people ‘offended’ that someone disagreed with them and didn’t find having a baby a massive trauma ?

Muthaofcats · 28/07/2023 18:34

Agree / so many horror stories and trauma that I was expecting the same and genuinely didn’t experience that, regardless of sleepless babies and no family help. Was much much less stressful than my intense job so had perhaps built up a level of resilience.

LimePi · 19/07/2023 19:01

Everyone has different experiences. I found it much better than portrayed (it started getting super busy from 6m when weaning started and just eased up around 3.5!).
however my baby ate well, i had no issues with BF, no colics/reflux and baby slept well too. And I didn’t have PND. I had anxiety when Covid started but was able to get a bit of therapy through work insurance. And my husband is great as partners and was hands on.
if my baby wasn’t sleeping like I know some friends’ haven’t I would have gone nuts very quickly.
or if baby had colic etc.
so I consider myself lucky rather than everyone who finds it hard unreasonably scared.