Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think there's a lot drama and scaremongering around women coping as a new mum?

269 replies

imicayrp · 11/04/2023 17:00

I am open to being put in my place and told I have an easy child (so far) but I was shocked by how much pressure, stress and fear was pumped into me before birth, to find that 6 months on, I’m fine and found this pretty simple from day one. Always had that elusive hot cup of tea, always had time to speak to friends and cook my dinner. I did this all without support from my partner who had an affair 8 weeks before our child was born. I know 6 months is nothing and I’m sure there’s hard time ahead but honestly it’s been absolutely NOWHERE near what is described in the media and among colleagues (and mumsnet!). Yes the nights initially were hard but you sleep the next day? It’s a short time. Yes it can be isolating on maternity leave but keep in touch with friends? Buy yourself something nice, watch a series. I don’t understand the huge pressure and drama before women give birth and actually see it as quite a sexist thing. Women can cope, actually. AIBU to have this mentality? Does anyone feel similar?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
liondreams · 30/09/2023 15:30

@5128gap totally agree with this. everyone's situation is different - from how much support they have, how much money they have, whether their partner is helpful or not, or maybe they are a single parent. Maybe they have to juggle a stressful job around the edges, maybe they struggle with anxiety or PND. To judge everyone else because you find it easy, seems a bit short sighted to me.

FrozenGhost · 30/09/2023 12:38

I agree OP, I find it hard often but not exactly in the way people describe - it was easily possible to wash, dress and eat.

Unfortunately I've perpetuated this, I've often complained and agreed it's all terrible, so I don't sound smug.

5128gap · 30/09/2023 12:11

I'd also say OP, you're obviously doing a cracking job in tough circumstances and without support, and should feel proud of that.
Don't tarnish it by adding in a load of superiority towards other women and losing your empathy. Everyone's different, and you don't need to compare your experiences and ability to cope with other women's in order to feel good about what you're doing.

5128gap · 30/09/2023 11:59

I think its better for women to be prepared for a very tough time and be pleasantly surprised than the other way round.
There is no harm done to a mum who finds life easier than she was led to believe it would be, but plenty done to a struggling mum who feels there's something wrong with her because she's not breezing along loving every minute.

prestonlass · 30/09/2023 11:57

I actually think for me the newborn phase with my 2 wasn't the hardest bit - it got more challenging for me when they started moving, had more disrupted sleep at night (down from 3hr stretches to less than 1hr between feeds) and napping less during the day. So it could just be that like me you enjoy the tiny baby phase and your tough bit is still to come!

potatowhale · 30/09/2023 11:54

CostelloJones · 30/09/2023 11:51

For example labelling it as “drama”

patronising and makes it seem like the person struggling is making a fuss unnecessarily

Totally agree

CostelloJones · 30/09/2023 11:51

For example labelling it as “drama”

patronising and makes it seem like the person struggling is making a fuss unnecessarily

CostelloJones · 30/09/2023 11:50

I couldn’t leave the house when my youngest was 6 months, I was so crippled by anxiety. The only place I would go was hospital appointments or my mums house. Couldn’t even do the school run.

and the worst part?

thinking “I can’t go to a baby group because everyone else must be coping wonderfully and I am so ashamed that I can’t be like them” … “why can’t I be normal”… “my kids deserve a better mum”

there is nothing wrong with having a positive experience but you have to be so careful of how you phrase this. It can be belittling and as much as your positive experience is valid, so are the negative ones.

Worddance · 30/09/2023 11:42

I had easy babies and found the scaremongering ridiculously unhelpful.

The problem is, the range of possible experiences can be vast. Mum can be injured, mentally unwell, baby can be an insomniac, Dad can be a dick, Mum might hate being at home - or the opposite, in which case it is rather nice.

CostelloJones · 30/09/2023 11:37

YABVU

it’s easy to say that when you cope well but there are so many things that are a big adjustment and there is no shame in also finding it difficult. In fact, you could argue your attitude adds to women feeling like they can’t reach out for help without judgement.

I think it’s important people are prepared for it to be difficult and that it is talked about. PND for example can be very lonely and isolating and feeling as if you are the only one going through this (when it’s actually totally normal) will exacerbate that.

in the nicest way possible I hope you haven’t said this to any friends with babies because they could be internally feeling very shit and this could make it worse.

Tiredalwaystired · 30/09/2023 09:51

True. Op How are things now? Hopefully just as great x

AwaaFaeHom · 28/09/2023 07:06

Chocolatepopcorn · 28/09/2023 06:44

Your baby is only six months. Buckle up. You've got the toddler years to come. Then the tweenager back chat. Then the teen years. As someone else said: 'it's a long game'.

I reckon the baby might be a bit older by now.

Chocolatepopcorn · 28/09/2023 06:44

Your baby is only six months. Buckle up. You've got the toddler years to come. Then the tweenager back chat. Then the teen years. As someone else said: 'it's a long game'.

Sceptre86 · 28/09/2023 06:35

Honestly for every parent like you there's one asking why they weren't told the 'truth'. The 'truth' being that being a parent is monotonous, that it's tiring and hard work. It's down to everyone's experience and no two will be the same.

I have 3 kids and I have found parenting easiest with dc3. I don't know if that is due to me being more relaxed now or a combination of factors including that she was a bigger baby and has always slept well. She did have reflux so there was a certain amount of worry about her moving down percentiles and lots of extra laundry to contend with. She weaned really well though and most importantly sleeps like a dream. It helps that her sister and brother are at school so I can focus on her. She does amuse herself though which helps when i need to cook or do homework with my other two. Despite having 3 I'm less tired than when I had dc1 and dc2 who were closer in age and neither ate or slept well. I've also had 3 emergency sections and had a lot more support as dh had I week soff. I had recovered from an infection in that time and was comfortable by time he went back to work. Compare that to dc1 and he was back at work in 2 weeks leaving me with a child that didn't feed well and still in a lot of pain.

Parenting is a long game and just because you've had s straightforward experience so far doesn't mean you will always but if you take it as it comes ( which it sounds like you will) then I think that is a good approach.

notamilf · 27/09/2023 21:51

When I was pregnant with my first I was absolutely terrified of the 'baby blues'. Every day without fail my mum would tell me to prepare myself for sleepless nights, serious depression, brutal midwives, no pain relief, colic, colossal bleeding for weeks on end, losing my identity etc etc. After I had my baby I actually thought something was wrong with me because I was 'coping' so well and loving life.

karlosthekat · 30/07/2023 01:34

I agree with you OP. I have 3 dc and mine are older so I've been through older stages too. Sometimes I read the problems about parenting here and I just don't relate to them - either they didn't occur with any of my dc, or they did but I dealt with them without too much drama. No issues with childbirth, breastfeeding, pregnancy illness , PND or baby's health for any of my dc.

I had to have additional support/interventions during one of my pgs and births due to a health condition and I found it quite patronising and tedious how they would constantly assume I wouldn't cope and having parenting of a newborn painted as the most awful thing ever. Some parents find it hard, some find it easy, but from them and general society the impression for me is that people assume it will be impossibly difficult. I found that HVs almost surprised that I didnt answer any questions negatively during the PND screening check, and falling over themselves to recommend various support groups to me.

YeahOkWhatever · 30/07/2023 01:01

No, I actually felt the opposite after my first as no one was honest enough about how hard it could be. Good that you've had an "easy" time, but not the case for many, and to call it 'drama' is unhelpful.

Olderandolder · 29/07/2023 23:40

You do have an easy child. Good for you. Have another?

No it doesn’t get harder. Babies get easier with each bit of independence, crawling, walking, nursery, school, university.

If you have been lucky now then you are fine.

Indigotree · 29/07/2023 23:36

How on earth can you sleep the next day? Surely you're looking after a baby non-stop the next day?

Muthaofcats · 29/07/2023 23:24

User2538309 · 29/07/2023 09:50

@Muthaofcats -nice doubling down on your take of “I had the skills and experience so I enjoyed it, others just aren’t as good as me”.

The world is full of messages implying motherhood should be easy and natural for us all. Asking for help, or sharing challenges is massively hard.

There’s huge stigma associated with not coping, there’s huge stigma associated with not “loving every minute”. “Soak up the baby cuddles.” “They are young for such a short time, enjoy every second.” “New baby smell.” “She’s a natural mother.” “Is she a good baby?”

Your response to me suggests you come at more than just your pp experience with negativity; but I’m sorry you had a hard time and felt judged, that must be a rotten feeling and I hope you’re out the other end now. I think it’s v normal to assume everyone is judging you or putting pressure on with those comments; I agree they’re inane things to say but imagine people aren’t saying from a place of judgement and just more the random thoughtless crap people say. I think if feeling low it’s easy to be defensive and read malintent into other peoples’ anodyne comments - take your response to me as one example.

neverbeenskiing · 29/07/2023 13:49

Women can cope, actually

Actually, you don't speak for all women. Being a woman doesn't mean you inherently understand other womens struggles or circumstances, many of which will be wildly different from your own.

Your OP reads as though women who openly admit to having trouble adjusting to new motherhood are somehow betraying feminist ideals because we should all be on a mission to prove that "women can cope".

The fact that you personally have found it easier than expected to cope with your one, relatively easy baby does not mean you are in a position to generalise about the experience of all women. Nor does it mean that those who are open about their struggles are being dramatic or "scaremongering". Classic case of 'I personally haven't experienced this so it must be exaggerated'. You are lucky. That's all.

Brk · 29/07/2023 13:13

I think I get what you mean OP. You have had an easy baby and you know that. (My baby woke every hour for two years.)

BUT the constant comments while you’re pregnant about “Your life’s gonna change forever!!!” are indeed so irritating.

It was tiring having a baby, I used to fall asleep mid-conversation, but it was still the best years of my life. So fun. And no one talks about the fun, it’s fashionable to be all “😱😱 isn’t it shit being a mum” but I looooooved it.

I’m sad I didn’t have babies a decade earlier.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 29/07/2023 12:30

I certainly never found it hard at all - obviously the frequent feeds are tiring at first, but I enjoyed it. But this was before all the scaremongering on SM.

I know I was probably lucky, but I’d read nothing to make me expect that BFing would be difficult, and it wasn’t.

Going by what you read on MN, I dare say many first-time expectant mums are fully expecting it to be a painful nightmare. Which may perhaps make them tense and fearful before they even try.

lljkk · 29/07/2023 12:27

oh FFS, don't make everything into example of "sexism" imposed on poor innocent females.

For biological & cultural reasons, women usually take on a larger portion of baby care than males. They have other choices, but many women want to take that lion's share, even if it might be very tough.

Honestly I don't think how tough new parenthood is hyped enough, I know too many people who were blindsided by new parenthood, genuinely didn't realise how tough they would find it (male & female parents). That probably includes me as one of the naive, fwiw. I could have cheerfully given away my 1st baby when he was about 2 weeks old. I am also the weirdo that finds teens fairly manageable, fun even, but babies & little kids, so exhausting, madness to have them... I'll totally agree that perfectionism is pernicious in new parenthood discussion, the people who found parenthood hardest are sometimes the most idealistic, so they get the extra stress of feeling like failures because they can't live up to unhelpful preconceptions of the wonderful parents they thought they'd be.

I knew a couple who seemed to have an easy ride with their 1st baby. The universe promptly thanked & blessed them with twins for 2nd pregnancy, born <2 yrs later. The dad now cheerfully says he doesn't remember a thing about 1st 6 months of the twins' lives. Be careful what you gloat about.

Thelnebriati · 29/07/2023 12:11

Telling new mums about how things can go wrong and what to look out for so they can prepare is neither scaremongering nor drama.