Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is one more child really such a terrible idea?

141 replies

JustOneMore3 · 11/04/2023 12:20

Our children are 9 and 7. DH and I have always wanted 3 children but have waited as the time hasn’t seemed right. I’m now mid 30’s and it’s now or never for us. We are not home owners, but have £30k in the bank. I’m a part time student and also working part time, hoping to boost my income once I finish my degree in 2025. I’m entitled to full pay for 6 months for maternity pay with my current employer so a decent deal there.

Deep down I do really want to try for another baby but anyone I’ve mentioned it to seems to think it’s a bad idea, either due to the age gap and days out being tricky, or taking attention away from our other children.

So…

YABU - one more kid is a silly idea
YANBU - it’s fine, have one more

OP posts:
Abraxan · 11/04/2023 13:25

I don't think the age gap is as big an issue as others tbh. I'm 9.5 years older than my sister, and my brothers only a year younger than me. Whilst we didn't play together as children, etc we did have a good loving relationship and have a great relationship now as adults.

However the financial side of having another child does need considering, as well as practicalities - would you need a new car, would your current children's life's be negatively affected, etc.

Lcb123 · 11/04/2023 13:23

I wouldn’t, in your situation. It will really change the lifestyle you have with your existing children in terms of days out, holidays etc. I imagine they’d find it quite disruptive. I’m one of 3, and I would NEVER have more than 2 myself

Switchwitch · 11/04/2023 13:21

I wouldnt purely because the family activities you can do are severely limited with a pram in tow. Your existing DC are at such a good age they can do everything and want to do it with you. I'd treasure that until they turn into grumpy teenagers. Go swimming, rock climbing, roller skating etc with them without having to watch from afar with a screaming baby.

PollyAmour · 11/04/2023 13:20

I would have another baby. No contest. I would hate to look back in 10 years and think 'if only...'

cloudonego · 11/04/2023 13:19

I think you've missed the boat and the gap is too big now personally, I'm also a firm believer in thinking about existing children and believe in a lot of circumstances the existing children will benefit more from the parental time and finances shared between the 2 of them than they would benefit from an additional sibling. As my children get older the more I believe in this, don't underestimate how much your kids will continue to need you as they get to pre teen/teen years.

Jeannieofthelamp · 11/04/2023 13:17

@JustOneMore3 I know it's easier said than done but I would try to take the effect it will have on your existing children out of the equation, because you just can't know how it will go - they might adore a younger sibling and be very close or they might not be very bothered or they might not get on at all. As a parent you just have to manage whichever situation the universe gives you! You and your DH have to want to do it for yourselves, if you do then go for it.

JustOneMore3 · 11/04/2023 13:09

If you wanted a 3rd child you would have had one already.

Finances wouldn’t allow. Up until a couple of years ago, we were in a small amount of debt. A change in circumstances means we have the £30k savings now. This is the first time it’s felt doable.

OP posts:
ShowUs · 11/04/2023 13:05

For me personally I wouldn’t.

I’ve always thought 3 kids is a weird number to have anyway.

It sounds as though your life is starting to improve because you’re doing training and planning to buy a home etc and I would be looking forward to having a nice life without going right back to the beginning.

I’m early 30s and my DD is becoming much more independent now and I am able to have hobbies, go to the gym and meet up with friends much more easily.
I couldn’t imagine having to go through it all again.

When you are mid 40s your other children will have left secondary school whilst your 3rd would still be in primary.

I wouldn’t judge you for choosing to but I just think what’s the point.
I think you are just panicking because you know you’ll soon struggle to conceive as you get older.

If you wanted a 3rd child you would have had one already.

Fifthtimelucky · 11/04/2023 12:58

Farmgirl12 · 11/04/2023 12:29

someone once told me that you’ll never regret having another baby, but would regret not having another.

I’d go with your heart x

Most people will not regret having had an additional child because by then they have one. It's impossible for them to separate a theoretical third child from the actual third child that they have. Regret would be tantamount to wishing that child had never been born.

We discussed having a third and decided against it for a number of reasons, including our ages and finances. I would have loved a third (and fourth) and had we had them I'm sure we'd have been glad that we did. As it is, I have absolutely no regrets that we didn't.

Mumma · 11/04/2023 12:58

If go for it. Another little one to love and bring joy 🥰🥰

FfeminyddCymraeg · 11/04/2023 12:55

No, I wouldn’t.

I think most DC have begged for a sibling at some point, you don’t just give them one thought! They’ll soon be in secondary school and you’ll be restarting reception and primary. On that basis alone I just couldn’t face starting again.

We originally wanted 3DC but stopped at 2. With the current cost of living, a third would be stretching us to breaking point and from a practical perspective, cars, holidays, trips away are just easier with 2DC, in my experience.

And what if it’s twins?! (This just happened to a friend of mine - she went from 2 to 4 DC 😬🙈)

Felixss · 11/04/2023 12:54

My friends just had a baby almost 10 year age gap and she does regret it. She says it's nothing like the first time when it seemed new and interesting it's drudgery especially looking after a moody pre teen as well. She's had PND because of it she feels the loss of independence. It's put me off because I know I'd be exactly the same no more DC for me.

Ohhmydays · 11/04/2023 12:53

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 12:32

Does it matter if MN thinks two is enough, or that the gap is too big? No. If youn both want one and can afford it, do it.
It isn't anyone elses business.

Exactly this. I have 3 now. Had my 2nd when my 1st was nearly 15yrs and going back to it was a lot more easier than everyone said it would be. If you can afford to do it, and dh is 100% as well i would or you will always wonder if

Climbingthelaundrymountain · 11/04/2023 12:51

I absolutely would.

Lordofmyflies · 11/04/2023 12:50

Being the 'Best Mum' to your children doesn't always mean giving them what they want at this moment in time. Teenage years are HARD, my Dc need me now more now emotionally and for ferrying around than ever before. I would not be able to help financially or spend time with my teenage Dc the way I do with a baby in tow. I wouldn't!

DorotheaHomeAlone · 11/04/2023 12:47

I have 3 but wouldn’t have another in your shoes. I think your existing children will benefit much more from you working in your financial security than they would from another sibling. And that age gap would make it hard to meet everyone’s needs.

DDivaStar · 11/04/2023 12:45

Emotionally you may always regret not having number 3 but....
There are many practical reasons many people stop at 2. Add in the large age gap, your current dc may struggle with a new baby and it may well be tough going back and starting a whole new round of parenting just as dc 1&2 are gaining some independence.

You say you have savings and a good maternity package but a new baby will impact the time you are able to devote to progressing your career and earning potential. So any progression may be delayed.

It sounds like you could manage but don't underestimate the impact of starting parenting all over again.

CeciNestPasUnPipi · 11/04/2023 12:44

JustOneMore3 · 11/04/2023 12:40

I mean this as a genuine question, why are other people's opinions bothering you? You sound like you have thought it through, you say it's what you want, you're reasonably well placed to do it, so what is making you hesitate? It might help you to think about why what others think is so important - what aspect of it is making you think twice? Once you've got to the bottom of that you might find it easier to make a clear decision.

I had a really tough childhood with a very unloving mum. For that reason, it’s so important to me to be the best mum I can be to my own children. I know how important it is to prioritise existing children over the thought a future one and so peoples negative opinions are giving me a fear that I’ll somehow be letting my existing children down by having another. My children both beg me for another sibling. They have lots of little cousins and are great with them. However, they are only kids so can’t possibly know how having another sibling might impact them. I’m definitely an over thinker, so that’s probably not helping here.

I'd be careful of over-compensating for a tough childhood by letting your children's preferences sway your decision.

Also: the rush of hormones as you near peri-menopause will often be compelling in terms of the urges it creates.

JustOneMore3 · 11/04/2023 12:40

I mean this as a genuine question, why are other people's opinions bothering you? You sound like you have thought it through, you say it's what you want, you're reasonably well placed to do it, so what is making you hesitate? It might help you to think about why what others think is so important - what aspect of it is making you think twice? Once you've got to the bottom of that you might find it easier to make a clear decision.

I had a really tough childhood with a very unloving mum. For that reason, it’s so important to me to be the best mum I can be to my own children. I know how important it is to prioritise existing children over the thought a future one and so peoples negative opinions are giving me a fear that I’ll somehow be letting my existing children down by having another. My children both beg me for another sibling. They have lots of little cousins and are great with them. However, they are only kids so can’t possibly know how having another sibling might impact them. I’m definitely an over thinker, so that’s probably not helping here.

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 11/04/2023 12:38

It will effect the children you have, what do they think?

VivaVivaa · 11/04/2023 12:37

I wouldn’t in your situation. But I’m relatively pessimistic. I would want housing security, to finish my studies and definitely see that income boost post degree, not just hope for it. You may be more optimistic and spontaneous than I am though! I don’t think I’d let age gap hold me back in your situation, it’s more the practicalities.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 11/04/2023 12:36

I've got a 9 year age gap and it's been fine for us. DS2 has been a bloody hard baby and it's actually helped with ds1 being older tbh.

We've still done everything we would have done with just 1, DS has his hobbies, we've been on holidays - it's hasn't impacted the older one having a sibling so much younger and they adore each other.

They both get 1/1 time with both of us and we do stuff all together. Not sure how it can be "too big" a gap.

toastofthetown · 11/04/2023 12:35

Farmgirl12 · 11/04/2023 12:29

someone once told me that you’ll never regret having another baby, but would regret not having another.

I’d go with your heart x

Lots of people regret having children. Many people who wanted another child at one point and don’t have the baby feel glad several years down the line they didn’t have the extra child.

BananaSpanner · 11/04/2023 12:35

Your life will be much more comfortable if you don’t. More money, less stress, less delays to career progression, more space, easier life all round with current kids getting older. I would only sacrifice all that if it was going to make me really unhappy to not have a third.

Jeannieofthelamp · 11/04/2023 12:35

I mean this as a genuine question, why are other people's opinions bothering you? You sound like you have thought it through, you say it's what you want, you're reasonably well placed to do it, so what is making you hesitate? It might help you to think about why what others think is so important - what aspect of it is making you think twice? Once you've got to the bottom of that you might find it easier to make a clear decision.