Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is one more child really such a terrible idea?

141 replies

JustOneMore3 · 11/04/2023 12:20

Our children are 9 and 7. DH and I have always wanted 3 children but have waited as the time hasn’t seemed right. I’m now mid 30’s and it’s now or never for us. We are not home owners, but have £30k in the bank. I’m a part time student and also working part time, hoping to boost my income once I finish my degree in 2025. I’m entitled to full pay for 6 months for maternity pay with my current employer so a decent deal there.

Deep down I do really want to try for another baby but anyone I’ve mentioned it to seems to think it’s a bad idea, either due to the age gap and days out being tricky, or taking attention away from our other children.

So…

YABU - one more kid is a silly idea
YANBU - it’s fine, have one more

OP posts:
2bazookas · 11/04/2023 14:01

With an age gap like that, at least you won't have three tinies competing for the use of your two knees to sit on, two arms to hold them and two hands to feed them.

But there will be a serious conflict of childrens ages, interests, diet, energy etc when it comes to family outings and entertainment. As baby enters the terrible twos, your 12 yr olds hormones will be revving up for the teenage years. One of them wants to go to soft play then early bed, the other wants to be taxi-ed to a football match /have their pals to a sleepover.

Bunnyhair · 11/04/2023 14:01

Something I recognise now that I’m firmly post-fertile is that broodiness is a kind of insidious madness. It’s obsessive and irrational. You become possessed. It’s all you can think about. If you put your broodiness in the driving seat of your life you have about as much control over your future stability as an addict.

You will wake up from this trance, migrainous and full of perimenopausal rage, and wonder why you have indentured yourself to all these children, and the revolting ogre you somehow married (as he will appear to you once when oestrogen has left the building), and now you can never retire because you’ve sold your future happiness in exchange for 9 years of nursery fees.

Resist. The future you will thank you for it.

KittyAlfred · 11/04/2023 14:00

Peppadog · 11/04/2023 13:55

To me it is a no-brainer, you really want another baby, your other children want a sibling so clearly don't feel they are lacking in attention.
I personally could never regret a child I have, I adore them so much, the joy I get from them and the strong bond that forms in babyhood far exceeds any additional work/drudgery.
I love the baby and toddler years and don't see it as something I need to get 'out the way'.

Imagine in 5 years time, your eldest two want to be with friends more and are becoming independent and you suddenly realise it's too late for you to have another baby, now that is something I would regret.

Look at the thread I started called 'to think parents with 4+ kids must be run ragged' theres some lovely posts from parents of larger families there.

Mine are 17 and 14 and I'm waiting for the independent stage when they'll be with mates and supposedly I'll be bored. Yes they want to be with friends but teens are still very very needy in a multitude of other ways. As well as being a therapist, chef, educational advisor and UCAS expert, I'm also a taxi driver on call almost 24-7.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 11/04/2023 14:00

Similar age gap for me and my sibs - Me the oldest, then my sister, then my brother. Me and sis are in a whole different generation it almost feels like. The age gap really isn't ideal.

Doing stuff with three is so much harder than with two.

Personally, in your shoes I wouldn't. I do have three kids of my own - but I had my third less than three years after my twins, and I had an overwhelming biological urge to do so. I literally could not stop thinking about babies.

I think if you're fairly ambivalent about it, then don't. Why upset the apple cart?

FreddiesTeeth · 11/04/2023 14:00

What are you hoping that a third child will bring to your lives that you don't already have?

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/04/2023 13:57

My children both beg me for another sibling not sure any teenager really relishes a toddler round their feet and in their stuff.
To me not having your own home is a huge risk to add a third. Another lot of childcare to pay for, your other two children will soon need help starting secondary, navigating important exams, I would no way bring a newborn/ toddler/ preschooler to that.

KittyAlfred · 11/04/2023 13:57

I wouldn't do it.
In 10 years your older kids will be off to university and you'll still be doing primary school nativities and sports days.

Peppadog · 11/04/2023 13:55

To me it is a no-brainer, you really want another baby, your other children want a sibling so clearly don't feel they are lacking in attention.
I personally could never regret a child I have, I adore them so much, the joy I get from them and the strong bond that forms in babyhood far exceeds any additional work/drudgery.
I love the baby and toddler years and don't see it as something I need to get 'out the way'.

Imagine in 5 years time, your eldest two want to be with friends more and are becoming independent and you suddenly realise it's too late for you to have another baby, now that is something I would regret.

Look at the thread I started called 'to think parents with 4+ kids must be run ragged' theres some lovely posts from parents of larger families there.

Creepyrosemary · 11/04/2023 13:53

Can you also afford it if you divorce or your partner dies? I always feel that this is a bit overlooked but it happens plenty.

How do you feel about overpopulation and climate change? I'm ok with you having more children, just don't have children and then lecture us not to have more kids because it impacts on the future of yours.

Other than that, do what you wish.

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 13:49

Isthisexpected · 11/04/2023 13:46

I wouldn't. You don't even own your own home. Your existing kids don't have security.

You don't know what security they have. It's not like only homeowners are allowed to have children

Isthisexpected · 11/04/2023 13:46

I wouldn't. You don't even own your own home. Your existing kids don't have security.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 11/04/2023 13:42

I have 3 (12, 6, 4). Our third was an accident. What I would say is that while my youngest two generally get on quite well and have similar interests, it is very hard to come up with activities/days out/holidays that please all three kids. A 12 year old has very different interests and needs compared to a 4 year old, and for this reason we often divide and rule with one of us doing something with the younger two and the other doing something with the eldest.

I don't regret it at all, but in practical terms it can be quite tricky. Even just going to the cinema is a minefield!

diflasu · 11/04/2023 13:41

I'm one of three and had three - so I don't think three is an odd number and 4 bed houses are at least common enough they are possible to find if you do want separate rooms as they get older.

However the age gap here would be too much for me - but then I chose them close together for ours. I think it would be harder than usual gap but I know people who managed it.

You also not that far off teenage years - which we did start to find more expensive. You may have issue with cars and hotel rooms with three- they aren't universal or beyond getting around.

MN is odd about children numbers - 2 is seen as some kind of ideal whereas it often seem to have worse sibling rivalry in our families - DH is a very happy successfully only and MN is odd about those as well. Ultimately though it's down to you and your DH.

BrieAndChilli · 11/04/2023 13:39

my biggest concern would be housing. What gender are your exisiting children? if they are a boy and a girl then you are realistically going to need a 4 bed house. the two older ones wont be able to share once in teens and neither will want to share with a small child. Will you be able to afford to rent or buy a suitable house?
We bought quite late and my then 14 and 11 year old sons shared a room previously. There were not a lot of options for 4 bed in our price range within commuting distance of thier school. We did end up getting lucky but we would have had a much better selection to choose from if only needed a 3 bed eg hundres of 3 beds in our budget as opposed to about 5 x 4 beds!

RudsyFarmer · 11/04/2023 13:39

I wouldn’t but I understand your desire.

TroublesomeTrucks · 11/04/2023 13:38

DH and I have boys aged 10 years, 8 years and 11 weeks. I absolutely love it and so do the big boys. Admittedly DS3 is an easy baby but it feels so straightforward compared to the complete shock of number one and the difficulties of managing a toddler and baby with number two. Their needs are very different and I think that makes it easier in someways to do both - DS3’s needs are mostly physical - food, sleep, nappy changes and cuddles - whereas DS1&2 don’t have physical needs, more verbal/emotional in terms of support advice and guidance, so doing both at once feels very possible. Maybe it will be different when I’m back at work or as they all get older, but at the moment I absolutely would recommend it. Definitely no number 4 for me though.

marrymeadam · 11/04/2023 13:36

I had a 3rd when mine were 8 and 5 so a similar gap. the 2nd and 3rd get on well, they are all older now and no regrets

Hankunamatata · 11/04/2023 13:33

Its personal preference. For me the age gap would be too big and no way would I want a toddler while studying and working.

Creativityisold · 11/04/2023 13:33

Questions are: can you justify damage to the environment from extra child? You get no extra money from the government for a third child if you or DH can't work could you cope,? Would you be better putting 30k into a house deposit given you could get thrown out of rented property and there is a shortage? Could you cope if the new baby had disabilities?

I think there are pros and cons to all gaps. Some of the no third people aren't child centric which you are. I know families with a similar gap which seems to have worked fine

TeenLifeMum · 11/04/2023 13:32

Finish your degree then reassess. I have 3dc but close in age. I think 2 is much easier but 3 is fun however your age gap will be like having an only dc. Only you know what’s right though.

Kennykenkencat · 11/04/2023 13:29

My biggest regret is that I didn’t start sooner and have more children.
Even when financially it looked like it wouldn’t have on paper been feasible.

As it happened the sensible approach led me down a path which has caused untold problems.

Listening to other people stopped me doing what I intuitively knew was the right thing to do

Listen to what your gut is saying and ignore the noise

Wetnwindy · 11/04/2023 13:27

We had our third when my two were 6 and 4 …have never regretted having our son and they are all adults now . Have a great relationship and son is definitely the wise member of the family. Si I personally think that you should go with your heart .

ShowUs · 11/04/2023 13:27

JustOneMore3 · 11/04/2023 13:09

If you wanted a 3rd child you would have had one already.

Finances wouldn’t allow. Up until a couple of years ago, we were in a small amount of debt. A change in circumstances means we have the £30k savings now. This is the first time it’s felt doable.

I would use that £30k to have a holiday with your existing kids and put down a deposit to buy your own home.

What are the reasons you want 3 kids instead of 2?

What will having 3 bring you that just 2 wouldn’t?

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/04/2023 13:26

Farmgirl12 · 11/04/2023 12:29

someone once told me that you’ll never regret having another baby, but would regret not having another.

I’d go with your heart x

I think this is nonsense. Obviously it’s your decision and only you know what you want but my perspective is that so many people get blinded by “broodiness” which is largely socially constructed and brought about by a combination of peer envy and lack of direction in their lives and many end up bitterly regretting it. I would understand if you didn’t have any children but I really struggle to understand why people with multiple kids convince themselves that having more will give them something the existing ones didn’t.

Another child will set back your economic freedom by a decade and limit you massively. Enjoy the children you already have.

JustDudeIt · 11/04/2023 13:25

I don’t think you’d be mad to have another. Plenty of people do and if you decide to go for it, you’ll make it work In sure!

Having said that, I personally wouldn’t. You’ve got junior school kids, you’re working on your career, saving for a deposit. I wouldn’t want to rock that path to more freedom and more security with another child. Im risk averse, though, and also a bit selfish! Grin. Once my kids were that age there was no way I was going back to sleepless nights and nappies and paying for childcare again.