Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is one more child really such a terrible idea?

141 replies

JustOneMore3 · 11/04/2023 12:20

Our children are 9 and 7. DH and I have always wanted 3 children but have waited as the time hasn’t seemed right. I’m now mid 30’s and it’s now or never for us. We are not home owners, but have £30k in the bank. I’m a part time student and also working part time, hoping to boost my income once I finish my degree in 2025. I’m entitled to full pay for 6 months for maternity pay with my current employer so a decent deal there.

Deep down I do really want to try for another baby but anyone I’ve mentioned it to seems to think it’s a bad idea, either due to the age gap and days out being tricky, or taking attention away from our other children.

So…

YABU - one more kid is a silly idea
YANBU - it’s fine, have one more

OP posts:
Woodandsky · 11/04/2023 14:32

I think it's quite common to miss the baby stage when your kids are getting older, but no matter how many you have at some point you will have to accept that you can't have any more.

I was persuaded out of having another one by my husband when the youngest was 5ish and I'm really glad now; my 2 Ds's are adults now and I don't regret there not being any more. I now have a grandchild as well and I'm glad I don't have younger children do deal with as well as helping with my grandchild.

Bunnyhair · 11/04/2023 14:32

GalindaArduenna · 11/04/2023 14:23

As someone who was the oldest child in a scenario like this... it was awful. Sibling was born with severe additional needs and will need lifelong care, which will soon fall to myself and DSis to do/ organise as our parents are approaching their 70s.

Our family took a big hit financially, house was a state as we couldn't afford essential repairs, we went from a two-wage family to one wage for years until my sibling was at a specialist school.

Sorry OP but I think you need to factor this in to your considerations - your DC may want a sibling but they have no idea what effect this will have on the time/ attention/ money available to them, it's your job to think of these things on their behalf.

Yes yes. This absolutely needs thinking about.

Meandfour · 11/04/2023 14:30

I have absolutely nothing against more than 2 children; I have 4 of my own and love it.

However; with your situation I’d say don’t do it. The gaps are too big for them to have a proper sibling relationship and you’d be starting all over again 8 years later.

Peanutbutter7 · 11/04/2023 14:28

I can’t comment on your financial situation but I don’t understand people saying the age gap is too big. I was 10 when my sibling was born, having a baby in the house was an amazing experience for me.
now many years down the line we’re best friends as is my other sibling who is close in age to me.

Tootsweets84 · 11/04/2023 14:27

I disagree about the age gap. I have 4 and they are 1, 6, 7 and 15 so big gaps and small and so far it works really well. If anything the two with the small gap bicker the most. I also found it easier starting again after a big gap than with a toddler. I didn't plan it this way, it's just how our lives panned out, but I wouldn't change a thing. If you really have your heart set on a 3rd baby then you really shouldn't care what outsiders think.

Pilgit · 11/04/2023 14:26

Go with your gut. We had an accident baby last year and have a 13 and 9 year age gap between our older 2 and our baby. It's been incredible. The older 2 adore him and take care of him. There doesn't seem to be any jealousy or resentment - we've worked hard to ensure they still get the same attention and consideration (baby went to a prize giving at 10 days old and ballet concerts at 3 weeks!). He went to skateboarding lessons and out on treat days for their birthdays.

Having him has enriched all our lives

GalindaArduenna · 11/04/2023 14:23

As someone who was the oldest child in a scenario like this... it was awful. Sibling was born with severe additional needs and will need lifelong care, which will soon fall to myself and DSis to do/ organise as our parents are approaching their 70s.

Our family took a big hit financially, house was a state as we couldn't afford essential repairs, we went from a two-wage family to one wage for years until my sibling was at a specialist school.

Sorry OP but I think you need to factor this in to your considerations - your DC may want a sibling but they have no idea what effect this will have on the time/ attention/ money available to them, it's your job to think of these things on their behalf.

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 14:22

Jap26 · 11/04/2023 14:18

I'd think of logistics, the world is set up for families of 4.

I hear this a lot. I still have no idea what it's supposed to mean though.

Jap26 · 11/04/2023 14:18

I'd think of logistics, the world is set up for families of 4.

nopenotplaying · 11/04/2023 14:17

I have that age gap between my second and third children. They get along great and it a joy to see them together. Go with your heart

MyrrAgain · 11/04/2023 14:17

You can list out all the pros and cons, but ultimately if you want another baby they will mean nothing. They shouldn't get in the way.

Also free childcare will be changing in the next few years and FINALLY the government has realised working parents feel it's pointless going to work for 12p an hour after childcare expenses. So it might not be as costly.

Darkernights · 11/04/2023 14:16

Farmgirl12 · 11/04/2023 12:29

someone once told me that you’ll never regret having another baby, but would regret not having another.

I’d go with your heart x

I do wish people would not present these trite statements as profound universal truths.

Its like that 'You don't regret the things you do. Only the things you don't do'. Utter shit. You can feel wistful about something you never did. And its a safe wistfulness as you will never actually know how things would have turned out if you had taken that path. But you can live the rest of your life in painful regret at the thing you did do that imploded your life.

CandleInTheStorm · 11/04/2023 14:16

It depends what you want in the future I guess. When you're mid 40s they'll be 17 and 19, by 50 they will be nicely into adulthood. If you have one now, you'll be 50 when the new child is just starting their teen years and mid - late 50s by the time they are an adult.
I'd choose the ease of enjoying the rest of the primary years and get through what the secondary years bring whilst your dc are of similar age, similar level of activities and have similar age related problems. Then enjoy it when you're late 40s having older teens/young adults going off to do their own thing whilst you can focus on a career and enjoy childfree breaks away. The alternative is your older dc going off to do their thing whilst you are still saddled with a younger child doing the same old boring shit you've been doing for donkeys years (school runs/kids activities/baby sitter if you want adult time away) then having to deal with a teen during your menopause years. Sod that!

I know some absolutely love it though and could have babies forever but for me, I've enjoyed my kids younger years and currently going through the teens. Then it's my time to enjoy after the hard work of bringing up 2 kids!

HermioneHerman · 11/04/2023 14:15

I have 3 with an age gap of 6 and 9 years between the elder two and baby. Little one is adored and I've had no worries with the big ones not being interested, they've been wonderful. But #3 is an incredibly difficult child, very high needs, poor sleeper and intense all the time. I don't regret having her but had I known it would have been so so hard (much harder than 0-1 or 1-2 for me personally) I may have thought twice. As it was, I think I panicked about getting older and didn't feel 'done' but certainly life has now changed a lot. I now feel a bit guilty that she won't have a close in age sibling like the older ones do but there is no chance I could do this again now. I hope I don't sound horrible but just trying to be realistic. She's added a lot to our family for sure but it's come at a cost, especially to my sanity! And the older ones do get less of me at the moment because their sister takes most of my energy! I'm sure it will shift again though in time. It comes down to personality in short and you just won't know unless you try it.

ShimmeringShirts · 11/04/2023 14:14

I have similar age gap between my two oldest and my youngest. Youngest is spoilt for attention, older two get plenty of 1-1 time and mostly things tick along pretty nicely. There’s a 14 year age gap between me and second youngest Dsis and 20 years with me and youngest Dsis. Fuck all wrong with it, we love each other, we’re close, we support each other etc. Not sure why any of that is an issue…

MoggyMittens23 · 11/04/2023 14:14

Do the children fully understand the impact it would have on their lives? I'm thinking not. No way would I do it.

Goldbar · 11/04/2023 14:13

Bunnyhair · 11/04/2023 14:01

Something I recognise now that I’m firmly post-fertile is that broodiness is a kind of insidious madness. It’s obsessive and irrational. You become possessed. It’s all you can think about. If you put your broodiness in the driving seat of your life you have about as much control over your future stability as an addict.

You will wake up from this trance, migrainous and full of perimenopausal rage, and wonder why you have indentured yourself to all these children, and the revolting ogre you somehow married (as he will appear to you once when oestrogen has left the building), and now you can never retire because you’ve sold your future happiness in exchange for 9 years of nursery fees.

Resist. The future you will thank you for it.

😂. I think there's some truth/good sense in this.

Though personally OP, I'd go for it if you think you can afford it. As someone with a 5 year age gap not due to choice (unexplained secondary infertility, took us almost 3 years to conceive DC2), I'm coming to the conclusion that small age gaps are overrated and large age gaps underrated. The best argument in favour of smaller age gaps imo is getting the whole blardy baby/toddler stage out the way as quickly as possible, but if you actually enjoy this stage and are willing to interweave it into your existing family life, it will be tough, yes, but not necessarily unenjoyable.

mum2three48 · 11/04/2023 14:12

We always knew we wanted 3 but kept making excuses ( needed a bigger house/car) was it the right thing to do for the boys. Eventually we had DS when ds's were 8 and 12. We kept the boy's routine the same and did just fitted in. Dd was at her first football tournament weekend away at 11 days old after a c section. It was hard work juggling everything but it was the best decision we ever made. Dd is 12 now and DS are 21 and 25 and they all have a great relationship. DS 25 and dd idolise each other. I would definitely say go for it. My philosophy was to try and if it happened it was meant to be. Good luck

Fundays12 · 11/04/2023 14:11

I have 3 kids. Eldest is 11, middle one 6 and youngest 3. The gap between the oldest and youngest (even middle one) is to big on my opinion. They have nothing in common with my oldest. The younger 2 get on fine but the oldest is at a very different stage. It's very tying having a much younger child and we often tag team so DH takes them younger ones to things while I take the eldest or vice versa . A bang may end up feeling quite left out if your older kids are close.

VioletCharlotte · 11/04/2023 14:10

I found myself longing for another baby when I was 36, DC were 10 and 8. I'm 47 now and really relieved I didn't have one, having older DC means I've been able to progress my career and do so much more for myself. I can't imagine having an 11 year old now and having to deal with the teenage years again while perimenopausal.

Codlingmoths · 11/04/2023 14:10

Go for it. The age means you can juggle a toddler between you and keep up with the older ones, plus you can drop them at sports and activities without having to get baby out of the car. So much easier than a 4 year old you have to get everyone out of the car and go in with them! My 7yo has said he has the best seat in the car because it’s next to his baby sister 😍

MinBins · 11/04/2023 14:06

It's only something you can decide, OP. You're still young, and plenty of time ahead of you. My younger bro and I have a 7 year age gap, and now we're best buds. If the reason is age gap, or age, then I'd say go with your gut ultimately.

Studies seem like a drain of time and headspace, so would be affected. So being pragmatic about what will have to be deprioritised is key.

Good luck on whatever you decide.

Unicorn2022 · 11/04/2023 14:06

Didn't you ask exactly the same thing on here a few weeks ago? I remember the majority of people were saying it was a really big age gap and you would be better finishing your degree and getting a good job and hopefully on to the property ladder.

If you weren't happy with the responses last time you are obviously desperate for another child so the opinions of strangers on the internet shouldn't even matter.

Miloticc · 11/04/2023 14:04

I’d say YANBU, I feel similar. DC are 10 and 7 but I always wanted three. For the same reasons as you (age gap, starting school again, my age, money, etc) I’m considering never having another. But genuinely feel like I’m meant to have one more.

The positives are that older children can entertain themselves more while you care for a baby, if I’d had a 3rd while DC7 was little I couldn’t have coped. Plus no baby is easy but as parents we are a bit wiser and well versed into how to get through the toddler phase now.

Also my eldest Dsis is 8 years older than me and we weren’t close as kids but are very close as adults so it all turns out the same in the end.

You sound like a really sensible and good mum to be thinking it through, so I think if anyone else can do it, so can you, good luck! X

UpendedPineapple · 11/04/2023 14:04

DorotheaHomeAlone · 11/04/2023 12:47

I have 3 but wouldn’t have another in your shoes. I think your existing children will benefit much more from you working in your financial security than they would from another sibling. And that age gap would make it hard to meet everyone’s needs.

Also have three and had 3rd at 36 but completely agree with this.