Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is one more child really such a terrible idea?

141 replies

JustOneMore3 · 11/04/2023 12:20

Our children are 9 and 7. DH and I have always wanted 3 children but have waited as the time hasn’t seemed right. I’m now mid 30’s and it’s now or never for us. We are not home owners, but have £30k in the bank. I’m a part time student and also working part time, hoping to boost my income once I finish my degree in 2025. I’m entitled to full pay for 6 months for maternity pay with my current employer so a decent deal there.

Deep down I do really want to try for another baby but anyone I’ve mentioned it to seems to think it’s a bad idea, either due to the age gap and days out being tricky, or taking attention away from our other children.

So…

YABU - one more kid is a silly idea
YANBU - it’s fine, have one more

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JustOneMore3 · 12/04/2023 07:16

Thanks everyone. The votes are definitely going in favour of stopping at 2.

One thing I want to make clear is, I would never have another because my children ask me to. I thought I made it clear that I would not let that influence my decision, but some posters seemed to suggest I would.

It is useful for me to hear all the arguments against having another. Having a baby with disabilities is an outcome I hadn’t given much thought to, but really it’s important to consider all eventualities. I will have a chat with my husband and make a decision from there. Thanks again.

OP posts:
ganvough · 11/04/2023 19:15

Honestly, I think having 3 kids is only an option for those who are comfortably well off (with assets/pension/contingency fund) or have a LOT of family support. We live in such a different world to previous generations where there's a lot less security around future earnings/pensions/job security. You don't even own a property yet or have an established career and are approaching 40 when everything does become a little less possible than when you're 30.

Have you ever thought about your future post kids, your retirement, what you want from life at 50/60/70 and what you need to get there? Women have never been taught to or encouraged to future plan, like men have. We get told to just give into hormones and broodiness like we aren't capable of rational thought. Atm you have a nice life with all the options/opportunities for a career, buying a home, having enough savings and enough time/energy for your existing kids.

You have no idea what having a third would be like. It could be a difficult pregnancy, once the hormones die down you could realise what a hard slog awaits you, the child could be born with additional needs, you could get divorced, the career may not take off the way you planned - all of which will make life a million times harder for you and not be the dream "third child makes my life complete" vision you have. And the benefits you get from having a third won't be any different to having two, other than a romantic notion and hormones and social conditioning making you believe you MUST have this child to be happy.

My DP is one of three. His parents got divorced when he was 11 and his mum struggled to cope financially - life went from being fairly comfortable to needlessly hard. My friend has just had a third, and unlike her first two, this child is very difficult and she's had to delay her return to work even more as a result. She's approaching 40 now and knows it will be difficult to ever return to the level she was at. She'll never admit it out loud, but looks harried and exhausted in a way she never did before. So you should be practical (because it's 2023 and you can) rather than purely emotive about a decision that affects not just you, but your DH and your other kids too.

sunshineandshowers40 · 11/04/2023 18:55

I have 3DC but personally for me the age gap between your youngest and a baby would be too big for me but I had 3 in 4 years (which comes with its own issues).

1AngelicFruitCake · 11/04/2023 18:51

I desperately wanted 3 but we are comfortable but not high earners. I therefore prioritised being able to give the two we have a good standard of living over having another child. I’m glad we did, I feel that we are able to give them our attention and have enough money to enhance W their life with clubs and extras where needed.

Cherryblossoms85 · 11/04/2023 18:49

It's really hard to say. I wouldn't be without my third, but the age gap between each was o ly two years, and even then she gets really upset about activities she can't do yet. It has also really limited our career decisions because childcare is impossible - we don't even struggle to pay for it, we just struggle to find anyone willing to do just wraparound and school hols, which is the only affordable way of doing it with three. You have the advantage of soon having latchkey kids with the older ones if you want to.

CamoFlamingo · 11/04/2023 18:31

Bunnyhair · 11/04/2023 14:01

Something I recognise now that I’m firmly post-fertile is that broodiness is a kind of insidious madness. It’s obsessive and irrational. You become possessed. It’s all you can think about. If you put your broodiness in the driving seat of your life you have about as much control over your future stability as an addict.

You will wake up from this trance, migrainous and full of perimenopausal rage, and wonder why you have indentured yourself to all these children, and the revolting ogre you somehow married (as he will appear to you once when oestrogen has left the building), and now you can never retire because you’ve sold your future happiness in exchange for 9 years of nursery fees.

Resist. The future you will thank you for it.

Best comment ever.

CandleInTheStorm · 11/04/2023 17:55

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 17:43

It might be common amongst certain people. Still pretty sad though. I've got from 4 to adult, and I would never talk about any of them in such a disparaging and rude way.

Little cuntlets is a no no then when they're playing up and you're wits end... 🫣😆

cloudonego · 11/04/2023 17:48

@IamKlaus and I'm sure your medal will be waiting for you at the pearly gates, us lesser mothers can only look on in awe....

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 17:43

cloudonego · 11/04/2023 17:31

If you think you can't chat or play or have fun with children under the age of 6, definitely don't have more (or any really). Luckily very few parents have such a terrible attitude to their children. How sad for yours you dislike them so much.

Nearly all my friends feel this way, as do my own parents, always remember mum saying she'd have another if they were born at 5! Wind your neck in, it's not an unusual opinion at all.

It might be common amongst certain people. Still pretty sad though. I've got from 4 to adult, and I would never talk about any of them in such a disparaging and rude way.

cloudonego · 11/04/2023 17:31

If you think you can't chat or play or have fun with children under the age of 6, definitely don't have more (or any really). Luckily very few parents have such a terrible attitude to their children. How sad for yours you dislike them so much.

Nearly all my friends feel this way, as do my own parents, always remember mum saying she'd have another if they were born at 5! Wind your neck in, it's not an unusual opinion at all.

Snoken · 11/04/2023 17:31

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 17:25

What a sad outlook. And if your 5 year old is in nappies and having tantrums and naps, you have bigger problems.

If you think you can't chat or play or have fun with children under the age of 6, definitely don't have more (or any really). Luckily very few parents have such a terrible attitude to their children. How sad for yours you dislike them so much.

As someone who has kids who are much older now (late teen/early 20s) I agree that they do become much more fun as they age. I enjoyed the years when they were small too, but I had no idea just how much nicer it is when they are older. I wouldn't have wanted two tweens/teens and one toddler for example as that would have taken away and limited so much of the fun years with my older kids.

Jap26 · 11/04/2023 17:29

Yes please to the PM. Thanks

IhearyouClemFandango · 11/04/2023 17:28

I wouldn't. You have an insecure income at this stage and don't own. And regardless of that, it will be hard to.juggle both ends of the age spectrum. We have 5.5 years between our #2 and #3 and while it was easy when #3 was a baby, it is more challenging now he is nearly 6.

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 17:25

Mariposista · 11/04/2023 17:22

Sure, if you enjoy planning your days around naps, nappies, tantrums, not being able to walk far, being too young to do things, early bedtimes, not being able to chat or play fun games.

What a sad outlook. And if your 5 year old is in nappies and having tantrums and naps, you have bigger problems.

If you think you can't chat or play or have fun with children under the age of 6, definitely don't have more (or any really). Luckily very few parents have such a terrible attitude to their children. How sad for yours you dislike them so much.

Mariposista · 11/04/2023 17:22

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 17:19

I don't get this. You think children under the age of, what 6 or 7, are not at a nice age, you can't enjoy them or do things as a family? How very odd. Is there an upper age limit where they are not nice again and you can't do family things?

Sure, if you enjoy planning your days around naps, nappies, tantrums, not being able to walk far, being too young to do things, early bedtimes, not being able to chat or play fun games.

Rightsaidmargot · 11/04/2023 17:19

Most people have 2 kids so they're always going to vote for stopping at 2. I have 4 so I say go for it!

Love the business and bustle of having a big family.

IamKlaus · 11/04/2023 17:19

Mariposista · 11/04/2023 16:35

Yes. Your children are now at the 'nice age' where you can enjoy them and do things as a family.

I don't get this. You think children under the age of, what 6 or 7, are not at a nice age, you can't enjoy them or do things as a family? How very odd. Is there an upper age limit where they are not nice again and you can't do family things?

cloudonego · 11/04/2023 17:19

It's important to consider the impact on your family if the child has additional needs or isn't born healthy, or if life gets more complicated; divorce, health concerns etc. It's all well and good saying "go with your heart" but part of being a parent is using your head too and considering your existing children. I put my hands up to not thinking it through to that extent when I had my 2 in my 20s, but I'm older and wiser now and have my older 2 to consider, so I did think a 3rd through very differently to how I thought 1&2 though.

Meandfour · 11/04/2023 17:17

Jap26 · 11/04/2023 17:09

This is really helpful, which tour operators do you use for abroad, so far we have stuck to self catering a hotel sounds blissful?

We tend to use Jet2.
If you want I can send you a PM with some of the hotels we have stayed in. I too worried about finding hotels for us but honestly there are so many places now that sleep 5 and even 6. The list I gave of the UK attractions are just ones we’ve stayed at but I’m sure there will be more. It tends to be premier inns etc that limit to 4 IME but family attractions do usually accommodate most family sizes.

drpet49 · 11/04/2023 17:10

Farmgirl12 · 11/04/2023 12:29

someone once told me that you’ll never regret having another baby, but would regret not having another.

I’d go with your heart x

This. Go for it.

Jap26 · 11/04/2023 17:09

This is really helpful, which tour operators do you use for abroad, so far we have stuck to self catering a hotel sounds blissful?

Lordofmyflies · 11/04/2023 17:07

It's not the age gap I would worry about in your case, but the lack of financial stability. You're mid 30's. Don't own a house. You still have another 2 years before you finish your degree which may or may not increase your salary. Even then, you will probably be 40 before your income has increased.
With two children, I'm guessing you'll need at least a 3 bed house. With 3 kids, you'll need more. Honestly £30,000 is peanuts when it comes to raising children. Use the money towards a deposit for a house instead.

beerandpoles · 11/04/2023 16:47

I would if I were you. My biggest regret is not having another baby when I had the chance. Now I don't have the chance and the age gap would be too big anyways for me to start all over again.

Meandfour · 11/04/2023 16:45

Jap26 · 11/04/2023 16:19

I think to say wrong is unfair. I have three children and these are things I experience daily. I didn't say no rooms ever sleep 5 just these are things to consider. I'd love to know where the plenty of rooms and attractions are please as we've not found them yet?

Of course. I had a family of 5 until recently when baby number 4 arrived so have lots of experience buying for 5.
We go abroad at least 3 times a year and we’ve recently had family rooms to sleep all 5 in;
Cala D’or, Majorca
Rhodes
Mexico
Fuerteventura
Crete
Lanzarote
Menorca

Most caravan parks in the UK have 3 bedroom caravans for 4 single beds + a double bed so you can sleep 6.

Attractions that can sleep 5 -

Legoland Windsor - their rooms sleep 5 children; a bunk bed and trundle in one room and a double bed in the main room.

Alton Towers hotel & CBeebies land hotel - variety of rooms sleeping upto 7.

Splash Landings hotel sleeps 6 in their beachcomber rooms

Chessington - wanyama view room sleeps 5. Haven’t tried other rooms with them as we’ve only stayed over once.

Nancy155 · 11/04/2023 16:43

Totally agree with this, we have an eight year age gap between our first and third and it’s been lovely. Their relationship is just wonderful and it hasn’t stopped us doing anything at all.