Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To rewrap his present from last year

243 replies

rockpoolingtogether · 11/04/2023 09:59

My DH birthday is coming up in one months time. I enjoy thinking about gifts and gifting something I think the recipient will like. For the last few years, the gifts I have given him have been left unused or put in a drawer. Last year, I specifically asked him what he wanted and bought that. Once again, it's nearly his birthday, and the gift I gave him last year isn't used. The worst thing is, it is a time specific thing. He wanted to make kombucha. So I bought him a decent kit and it had the scoby (the live ingredient) included. Don't ask me much about all this as I'm not really into that sort of thing!! Anyway, it is still sat in a cupboard and when I mentioned it once, he got all defensive so I've not said anything since. I don't feel like going to the effort of choosing something nice, for it not to be appreciated or used. To add insult to injury, he doesn't do gift giving. It was my birthday recently and he hadn't bought me a present but took my son to choose some chocolates. Maybe I'm over thinking this but I'm offended and hurt by his attitude. So Aibu to regift what I gave him last year?

OP posts:
ObiWanKanobi · 12/04/2023 10:55

Another vote for chocolate and use the money you saved to treat yourself instead x

Fraaahnces · 12/04/2023 10:54

I’d start telling him that YOU don’t like buying HIM presents. Fuck! He sounds exhausting. He’s the ultimate fun vampire!

seratoninmoonbeams · 12/04/2023 10:47

VickyEadieofThigh · 11/04/2023 10:24

Another vote for chocolates - the same ones as he got you. Just do this every year and take the weight off your mind.

💯

IsaiditwasLighthearted · 12/04/2023 10:45

rockpoolingtogether · 11/04/2023 14:08

@PousseyNotMoira no. He is a covert narcissist. It is not possible to converse with him. He is very defensive. He doesn't ask questions about my day, but if I initiate a simple how was your day? He simple mumbles or grunts a one word response. If my parents are here, he takes himself off into another room and is constantly shushing us. So no, I can't. I would love to have a normal conversation without feeling like I have to dig to get more than a one word response. Would be lovely to have a bit of banter or laugh. He is pretty much in the defensive and often sarcastic. Just

Why aren't you giving the gift of divorce to yourself?

He sounds utterly awful and the gifts is just the tip of the iceberg. He's manipulating you all over and you're accepting it.

Seriously, why are you putting up with this?
I'm not a regular LTB MN er at all, but this just sounds utterly miserable and a terrible example for your son.

supersop60 · 12/04/2023 10:34

NoTouch · 11/04/2023 10:32

It is fair enough not to do gifting not everyone does. Where it becomes a problem is if one person in a couple is a gifter and the other isn't.

The gifter doesn't respect the others choices and buys gifts that are not wanted, or pressures for ideas that would be wanted and the receiver needs to come up with something.

The gifter gets pissed off when they don't get gifts from someone who "doesn't do gifts".

It is the gifter that causes the issues! But always the non-gifter that gets the blame!

What happened to the pleasure is in giving not receiving!

Where's the pleasure in your gift being shoved in a drawer? It's rude and unfeeling.

JudgeRudy · 12/04/2023 10:32

FlatWhiteExtraHot · 12/04/2023 10:18

Since when was having ADHD also an excuse for having no basic manners?

In fairness I'd not read all the replies until now but what I was offering was a suggested reason for his behaviour

rockpoolingtogether · 12/04/2023 10:31

Tirednursemumwifeslave · 12/04/2023 10:01

I get you. I tend to buy my husband something we can do as a family for example a game we can all play - then me and my son both get some use out of it. If I really can’t be bothered I would just get some chocolate from the supermarket paying from the joint account 😆

Another great idea. So I could go plant, gin (because I like it!) or a game. Thanks. That's why I started the thread for gift ideas .

OP posts:
FlatWhiteExtraHot · 12/04/2023 10:21

paulthepython · 12/04/2023 09:58

I genuinely don't think most guys care that much about birthday presents. As adults with children it's pretty typical that if you really want something you would discuss, budget and purchase it no matter what time of year it is so birthdays become a bit meaningless. I love them and love investing time and effort to make them special for people I love that care about them but for my partner he prefers doing things to getting things so we always just go out somewhere nice instead and I get him chocolates from the kids. If that's what he got you then that's all he's expecting so just do that. I wouldn't dwell on the beer set, I've had big plans to learn to paint and draw, start cycling more often, learn a language, start skateboarding, brew my own wine, plant a vegetable garden and put up photo frames...doesn't mean of someone got me the raw requirements I would actually be motivated to do it...don't make him miserable over a gift he's not got the energy to do, don't be passive aggressive about it either- thats really mean and surely completely against the spirit of gift giving. If he's hurt your feelings with the lack of effort for your birthday just tell him that calmly and kindly and tell him it would mean a lot if some time he could do something special for you that he's thought about and you would like (but be realistic that this might not meet your expectations either as he's still just a bloke 🤣) x

So why is her husband asking for specific gifts then? Were you too busy mansplaining to us to read the OP?

FlatWhiteExtraHot · 12/04/2023 10:18

JudgeRudy · 12/04/2023 01:58

I bet he has ADHD. He won't mind if you dont get him a gift. He won't mind if you re-wrap last years present. He might even make it up that night (before it goes off)...he will mind though if you're arsey about it. I get you're disappointed but I bet he would gladly have no gifts ever if you weren't then disappointed.

He just doesn't think his birthday is important. Or your birthday ( or Xmas, Valentines etc) unfortunately He knows you do though so he tries....and fails.

My sister buys me nice gifts. I don't really want them. I loath people asking me what I want when I don't want anything right now, so now I have to research something and be specific or end up something I don't want. I'm not bothered getting a meh pressie, I am bothered when I'm asked if it's tasty/interesting/the right size.
If you think He's so ungrateful....actually he might be...but that's OK. Its the present he's ungrateful for, not you. He might even feel guilty because he's not as thrilled as you had hoped. This has nothing to do with how much he cares.
Buy him some socks/aftershave that he'll enjoy then just do something nice for him another time.

Since when was having ADHD also an excuse for having no basic manners?

sillysmiles · 12/04/2023 10:18

rockpoolingtogether · 11/04/2023 14:08

@PousseyNotMoira no. He is a covert narcissist. It is not possible to converse with him. He is very defensive. He doesn't ask questions about my day, but if I initiate a simple how was your day? He simple mumbles or grunts a one word response. If my parents are here, he takes himself off into another room and is constantly shushing us. So no, I can't. I would love to have a normal conversation without feeling like I have to dig to get more than a one word response. Would be lovely to have a bit of banter or laugh. He is pretty much in the defensive and often sarcastic. Just

Sorry I missed this post.

Life is too short. I'd try have a serious conversation about the state of your relationship and then if he is not willing to engage start looking at what you need to be happy. Because being with someone like this does not sound like a route to happiness.

RealHousewifeofExhaustion · 12/04/2023 10:16

the irony of it is, a lot of people stay together ‘for the kids sake’ it’s an absolute joke

This is so true. Then the kids have this huge baggage on them knowing that if they dont say their upbringing was the best ever, they will be "at fault" for not appreciating the "sacrifice" 2 selfish miserable people made to stay together.

DS19 and I were talking about this the other day. It makes him feel queasy the thought of his dad and me still being together just for him and his siblings. He knows how awful it would have been for everyone.

But it takes guts to separate and put the children first. It would have been much easier to stay together and put up with his crap in the short-term. But the long-term? Doesn't bear thinking about tbh.

I think getting a plant or something you actually want for the house or garden is a great idea! Win-win - he gets a gift, so can't sulk, and you benefit 😃

DeflatedAgain · 12/04/2023 10:13

Just do the chocolate thing

sillysmiles · 12/04/2023 10:12

NoTouch · 11/04/2023 10:32

It is fair enough not to do gifting not everyone does. Where it becomes a problem is if one person in a couple is a gifter and the other isn't.

The gifter doesn't respect the others choices and buys gifts that are not wanted, or pressures for ideas that would be wanted and the receiver needs to come up with something.

The gifter gets pissed off when they don't get gifts from someone who "doesn't do gifts".

It is the gifter that causes the issues! But always the non-gifter that gets the blame!

What happened to the pleasure is in giving not receiving!

I disagree. Being a non-gifter isn't an ideology or political statement. It is a statement of I don't care enough about the people in my life to consider them worthy of any extra effort. I'm not considering them beyond the day to day life.
Because someone who is a "non-gifter" is equally not a person to pick up a random item/card/gift on a non occasion day because they saw it and thought their partner would like it.

If you are non-gifter - how to you demonstrate "specialness" for your partner or loved ones?

Princesspeach31 · 12/04/2023 10:03

Isittimeformynapyet · 11/04/2023 10:08

Get him a bunch of lilies and a nice casket - for his scoby

This cracked me up 😂

Tirednursemumwifeslave · 12/04/2023 10:01

I get you. I tend to buy my husband something we can do as a family for example a game we can all play - then me and my son both get some use out of it. If I really can’t be bothered I would just get some chocolate from the supermarket paying from the joint account 😆

paulthepython · 12/04/2023 09:58

I genuinely don't think most guys care that much about birthday presents. As adults with children it's pretty typical that if you really want something you would discuss, budget and purchase it no matter what time of year it is so birthdays become a bit meaningless. I love them and love investing time and effort to make them special for people I love that care about them but for my partner he prefers doing things to getting things so we always just go out somewhere nice instead and I get him chocolates from the kids. If that's what he got you then that's all he's expecting so just do that. I wouldn't dwell on the beer set, I've had big plans to learn to paint and draw, start cycling more often, learn a language, start skateboarding, brew my own wine, plant a vegetable garden and put up photo frames...doesn't mean of someone got me the raw requirements I would actually be motivated to do it...don't make him miserable over a gift he's not got the energy to do, don't be passive aggressive about it either- thats really mean and surely completely against the spirit of gift giving. If he's hurt your feelings with the lack of effort for your birthday just tell him that calmly and kindly and tell him it would mean a lot if some time he could do something special for you that he's thought about and you would like (but be realistic that this might not meet your expectations either as he's still just a bloke 🤣) x

Ithurtsthebackofmyeyes · 12/04/2023 09:53

sandyhappypeople · 12/04/2023 09:47

My ex BIL was exactly like this in many ways, no friends, didn’t make an effort with anyone or anything, hated my sister being anywhere but with him, and would play the victim ALL THE TIME, which she allowed and made excuses for. They would make plans for day trips with the kids, then he would cancel the morning of, would completely ignore us if we came round, not even say hello or goodbye, feign illness last minute to get out of anything my sister wanted to do. He did exactly the same to the children except he’d belittle them or play down any achievements the had, call them thick etc, interrupt them when they we’re trying to speak, so they had no confidence at all.

Basically a right ignorant, controlling prick.. I never understood how she could possibly put up with it all. I think because he wasn’t physically abusive she didn’t think it was abuse?

the kids were older school aged when she finally left him, she was instantly happier and has been for years now, but guess what.. they are just like him now in so many ways.. they can’t help it, much like he couldn’t help becoming like his father, BUT in a lot of cases there seems to be a meek woman on the sidelines making excuses and allowing history to repeat itself, it’s horrible.

the irony of it is, a lot of people stay together ‘for the kids sake’ it’s an absolute joke.

This is a wake up call. I hope the OP reads it and takes it on board.

Your poor sister.

sandyhappypeople · 12/04/2023 09:47

My ex BIL was exactly like this in many ways, no friends, didn’t make an effort with anyone or anything, hated my sister being anywhere but with him, and would play the victim ALL THE TIME, which she allowed and made excuses for. They would make plans for day trips with the kids, then he would cancel the morning of, would completely ignore us if we came round, not even say hello or goodbye, feign illness last minute to get out of anything my sister wanted to do. He did exactly the same to the children except he’d belittle them or play down any achievements the had, call them thick etc, interrupt them when they we’re trying to speak, so they had no confidence at all.

Basically a right ignorant, controlling prick.. I never understood how she could possibly put up with it all. I think because he wasn’t physically abusive she didn’t think it was abuse?

the kids were older school aged when she finally left him, she was instantly happier and has been for years now, but guess what.. they are just like him now in so many ways.. they can’t help it, much like he couldn’t help becoming like his father, BUT in a lot of cases there seems to be a meek woman on the sidelines making excuses and allowing history to repeat itself, it’s horrible.

the irony of it is, a lot of people stay together ‘for the kids sake’ it’s an absolute joke.

ChimChimely · 12/04/2023 09:42

I just wouldn’t bother at all, too much effort compared to what he does for you

Mirabai · 12/04/2023 09:42

Chocolates.

If he moans that no-one cares about him point out that’s what he gave you.

FabFitFifties · 12/04/2023 09:40

I wouldn't cause an argument on his birthday. Just don't bother anymore, other than a token from DC. Then think about if he's right for you, if you are going to be upset by his lack of generosity or thought on these special occasions. He's unlikely to change.

WilsonMilson · 12/04/2023 09:31

So he can only be arsed to get you some poxy chocolates, and you’re spending even a second on wondering what to get him. Why?

What a mean sod. I’d honestly just get him a chocolate orange for a quid at this point. Two can play at that game.

Wheresthebeach · 12/04/2023 09:28

He's not bothered about gifts for you so I don't see why you're fussing about stuff for him. I'd explain that as he didn't bother with a gift for you, you aren't doing one this year.

potatowhale · 12/04/2023 09:22

Just give him a tenner?

Theydontknowthatweknowthattheyknow · 12/04/2023 09:22

OP you have way bigger problems than the gift giving and you know it. Your options are

  1. give him a big gift and get no appreciation for it

  2. Give him a small gift and piss him off

  3. Regift last year's gift and piss him off even more

  4. Consider this relationship deeply and come to the realisation that you deserve better than a narcisist who you get nothing positive from and take action to change this.

I know which I'd be choosing ...