Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mothers are competitive and jealous

116 replies

cornfleurs · 11/04/2023 06:46

I saw this study mentioned in the news and it really resonated with some of my own experiences since becoming a mother - as well as situations I've witnessed on the school run, problems my friends have encountered with other women and even threads on Mumsnet!

The researchers found that mothers responded more negatively to other women who had desirable assets (be that material or social) that they themselves didn't possess. In other words, women are programmed to be jealous of other women.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-31816-0

AIBU to think this sounds pretty accurate?

Married women with children experience greater intrasexual competition than their male counterparts - Scientific Reports

Human males are considered to be more competitive than females. However, females must also compete for resources necessary for their own and their offsprings’ survival. Since females use more indirect forms of competition than males, comparing observab...

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-31816-0

OP posts:
proppy · 11/04/2023 08:08

There's a lot of pressure on social media to have a beautiful home & it's a marker of success but I don't think men buy into it as much. I have very helpful parents & inlaws re childcare & am often told I'm lucky, DH never gets told that though.

tinyblackcat · 11/04/2023 08:04

A study that asks how people would react, ie hypotheticals? Hardly scientific!

proppy · 11/04/2023 08:04

The study says no, not to the same extent.

Tbf I don't know any women who tick all those boxes but I reckon it's more plausible for a women to tick them all vs a man! 😆

SwordToFlamethrower · 11/04/2023 08:03

Lack of emotional maturity and internalised misogyny.

There is absolutely loads of that on here.

Beezknees · 11/04/2023 07:53

Never experienced this myself. I don't feel jealous of anyone really. I don't envy material things.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:51

Yes, I don't see how it really relates specifically to being a mother thing.

The OP posted a link to the study. They studied married couples with children. There was significantly more competitiveness shown between the women on these issues than the men.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:48

proppy · 11/04/2023 07:43

In order of descending order of total negative reactions, significantly more female than male participant-observers reported that women would feel more negatively towards another same-sex individual with a powerful position at work, who is physically attractive, has helpful parents, is an influential member of the community, is highly energetic, experiences excellent health, lives in a beautiful house with lovely gardens, gets along with a supportive spouse, is cool, calm, and collected, and serves high quality food.

Would males not feel negatively towards other males in the above circumstances?

The study says no, not to the same extent.

Tarantullah · 11/04/2023 07:47

proppy · 11/04/2023 07:43

In order of descending order of total negative reactions, significantly more female than male participant-observers reported that women would feel more negatively towards another same-sex individual with a powerful position at work, who is physically attractive, has helpful parents, is an influential member of the community, is highly energetic, experiences excellent health, lives in a beautiful house with lovely gardens, gets along with a supportive spouse, is cool, calm, and collected, and serves high quality food.

Would males not feel negatively towards other males in the above circumstances?

Yes, I don't see how it really relates specifically to being a mother thing.

Tarantullah · 11/04/2023 07:46

I've found a lot of it online but fortunately in real life haven't encountered it really. I met some good friends at baby groups, a real mix of high flyers, SAHMs, married, single, and generally everyone got on, if people were jealous and competitive of eachother then it didn't show. I can well imagine it happens as it does with any groups, but most mums I know don't base their lives around solely being a mother so maybe that makes a difference.

CurlewKate · 11/04/2023 07:44

I haven't read the thread yet-but I'm predicting a lot of competitive I'm not competitive-inf!

proppy · 11/04/2023 07:43

In order of descending order of total negative reactions, significantly more female than male participant-observers reported that women would feel more negatively towards another same-sex individual with a powerful position at work, who is physically attractive, has helpful parents, is an influential member of the community, is highly energetic, experiences excellent health, lives in a beautiful house with lovely gardens, gets along with a supportive spouse, is cool, calm, and collected, and serves high quality food.

Would males not feel negatively towards other males in the above circumstances?

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:38

I think most people do override it though, feeling a twinge of jealousy is fine - eg you may be jealous of the other mother's pram but you don't take it off her.

And that's not really what I meant by "not overriding it", refraining from stealing! I meant being capable of genuine friendships with other women where you genuinely feel happy for their successes, sad for their struggles, and that although you may each have things the other does not, genuinely not feeling jealous of each other or resenting it (rather than hiding or "controlling" such feelings, let alone impulses to steal someone else's stuff!!).

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 11/04/2023 07:38

It isn't what I recognise. I think its more about a mother's new place in a male focused world, and how society looks down on women with young children. When women have children they often have to take a career break, then once the children start school the pressure is usually on the woman to take a usually lower paid job that is local and flexible. I've known so many well educated women who have had to take part time minimum wage jobs to fit around school. We are easy targets for ridicule, we are lazy for needing to drive to school, jealous and competitive for wanting the best for our children, and spongers for not being able to work full time and earn decent pay.

ImAvingOops · 11/04/2023 07:36

Yeah, just kill that bitch now Grin

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:35

The graph is quite shocking.

Mothers are competitive and jealous
Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:33

According to this they mostly don't @maddening . It's a very depressing read.

In order of descending order of total negative reactions, significantly more female than male participant-observers reported that women would feel more negatively towards another same-sex individual with a powerful position at work, who is physically attractive, has helpful parents, is an influential member of the community, is highly energetic, experiences excellent health, lives in a beautiful house with lovely gardens, gets along with a supportive spouse, is cool, calm, and collected, and serves high quality food.

maddening · 11/04/2023 07:28

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:22

Yes, of course. But a rational and decent answer to that is to focus on your own life and try to find ways to improve it, not tear down other women who you perceive to have more resources in whatever capacity.

What's always so interesting (to me) with these sorts of studies is that of course humans follow the typical mammalian behaviour patterns, but that one would hope that at least to a small extent, with intelligence and culture and societies and education and rationality such impulses would be overridden just a little bit. And yet, it seems that for many people they are not at all.

I think most people do override it though, feeling a twinge of jealousy is fine - eg you may be jealous of the other mother's pram but you don't take it off her.

IsolatedWilderness · 11/04/2023 07:28

I can't say I relate at all. I just do my own thing. I do have values over issues like breast vs. bottle, but it's something I apply to my choices, not compete over. I haven't got the energy to be competitive.

If we were in a dystopia then everyone would be competitive as survival might depend on it.

maddening · 11/04/2023 07:25

cornfleurs · 11/04/2023 07:00

This resonated for me:

Women attempt to obtain physical and social resources, including allies and mates, to support themselves and their children using a number of tactics including self-promotion; disguised or indirect competition such as reputation derogation or social exclusion, which do not require directly confronting a rival; and scramble competition in which individuals attempt to do better for themselves, without directly interfering with another’s success

Tbh I think that exert is true of all humans and if you take the specific emotion of "twinge of jealousy" out then many animals -animals are genetically programmed to ensure that their young have sufficient resources, whatever "emotion" or innate drive that creates that behaviour the result is the same, only humans are able to express it and study and conceptualise it.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:22

KvotheTheBloodless · 11/04/2023 07:12

If you read the actual study, it says that women are concerned about attributes that would help or improve the lives of their own offspring - which is completely normal maternal behaviour, I think. Most mothers want the best for their children, and it's normal to feel a twinge of envy when you see someone who can provide their DC with better opportunities than you can afford to.

Yes, of course. But a rational and decent answer to that is to focus on your own life and try to find ways to improve it, not tear down other women who you perceive to have more resources in whatever capacity.

What's always so interesting (to me) with these sorts of studies is that of course humans follow the typical mammalian behaviour patterns, but that one would hope that at least to a small extent, with intelligence and culture and societies and education and rationality such impulses would be overridden just a little bit. And yet, it seems that for many people they are not at all.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:18

Tinybrother · 11/04/2023 07:12

Certainly a lot of people seem very invested in the idea of school gates drama.
I haven’t experienced it myself

That's a really strange one isn't it? Who would have the time?! 🤣

KvotheTheBloodless · 11/04/2023 07:12

If you read the actual study, it says that women are concerned about attributes that would help or improve the lives of their own offspring - which is completely normal maternal behaviour, I think. Most mothers want the best for their children, and it's normal to feel a twinge of envy when you see someone who can provide their DC with better opportunities than you can afford to.

Tinybrother · 11/04/2023 07:12

Certainly a lot of people seem very invested in the idea of school gates drama.
I haven’t experienced it myself

saraclara · 11/04/2023 07:09

For a study to be published in Nature, it has to have been extremely thoroughly peer reviewed, and subject to careful and intensive checks, so it doesn't matter what knee jerk reactions we might have, this conclusion hasn't been pulled out of thin air.

Probably worth reading thoroughly with a clear head before ranting.

proppy · 11/04/2023 07:09

I don't think it's jealousy of others just that society heaps so much pressure & blame on women & mothers. Many are insecure or not 100% confident in their choices so I think that's why the bottle v breast, parenting style etc are so divisive.