Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mothers are competitive and jealous

116 replies

cornfleurs · 11/04/2023 06:46

I saw this study mentioned in the news and it really resonated with some of my own experiences since becoming a mother - as well as situations I've witnessed on the school run, problems my friends have encountered with other women and even threads on Mumsnet!

The researchers found that mothers responded more negatively to other women who had desirable assets (be that material or social) that they themselves didn't possess. In other words, women are programmed to be jealous of other women.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-31816-0

AIBU to think this sounds pretty accurate?

Married women with children experience greater intrasexual competition than their male counterparts - Scientific Reports

Human males are considered to be more competitive than females. However, females must also compete for resources necessary for their own and their offsprings’ survival. Since females use more indirect forms of competition than males, comparing observab...

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-31816-0

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 11/04/2023 09:27

You see it all the time on here. An OP can post about feeling insecure in comparison to X, but instead of encouraging OP to work on herself to become confident in her own right and quit comparing herself, plenty of posters will rip X apart for daring to have a good income/good looks/happy relationships.

People get really elaborate in their fantasies about how miserable/awful/unintelligent complete strangers must be.

CurlewKate · 11/04/2023 09:22

"It's not just mothers, I’ve long felt that one of the main reasons why we’re not as equal with men as we could be is that women do such a great job of pulling each other down."

Do we really though? I do think this is on a par with "women have shrill voices" and "women have no sense of humour"

EggyBreads · 11/04/2023 09:10

I very rarely feel jealousy and I don't feel in competition with my friends. Im lucky to have great friends and I put a lot into those relationships. I stay away from people who are materialistic and this seems to help.

purpledalmation · 11/04/2023 09:10

Total bollox. Not all women are competitive. We all know from our own experiences how wonderful most women can be when it comes to supporting one another. Of course we all know the twats who are competitive and annoying, but it's not the majority.

Devoutspoken · 11/04/2023 09:09

And the fathers?

boobot1 · 11/04/2023 09:07

CalpolDependant · 11/04/2023 08:30

If my husband and I were sent a list of questions to answer about our feelings on this, or any other subject matter, it would go like this:

Day 1: I thoughtfully complete my questionnaire. Husband puts his on top of the microwave.

Days 2-29: Husband’s questionnaire sits on top of microwave undisturbed

Day 30: I remind husband that I am posting the questionnaire today. He says I’ve “hidden it”. He finds it exactly where he left it. He fills it in half-arsedly with most of his answers being “don’t care”, “don’t know” or “N/A”

Day 120: The results of the questionnaire are published and men are found to be less concerned with all discussion points.

To summarise: I propose this is bad data. 😂😂

I think we have the answer!

RudsyFarmer · 11/04/2023 09:05

cornfleurs · 11/04/2023 07:00

This resonated for me:

Women attempt to obtain physical and social resources, including allies and mates, to support themselves and their children using a number of tactics including self-promotion; disguised or indirect competition such as reputation derogation or social exclusion, which do not require directly confronting a rival; and scramble competition in which individuals attempt to do better for themselves, without directly interfering with another’s success

So we’re not dissimilar to meerkats then.

SunhatsAndFlipFlops · 11/04/2023 09:04

I don’t agree we are ‘programmed’ to be jealous.

I think people can subconsciously compare, but it’s not necessarily from a place of jealousy or envy.

If there is jealousy/spite in real life amongst mothers, it must be well hidden, as I personally haven’t come across it.
The only time I see it blatantly, is on MN.
Some of the comments on here are very vicious & petty.

An example I see often on mn is when every breastfeeding thread ends up being turned into something else. We can’t just have a nice simple thread saying ‘well done, keep it up’ or posters showing support in some way, it almost always ends up turning into a ff v bf debate with people getting upset/defensive/nasty.
No one I know is like that in real life.

Sickoffamilydrama · 11/04/2023 09:02

So the study asked participants to predict how others would react well what they would be feeling. The problem with this is that it's a poor measure of how people actually behave.

They even discuss this:
Empirical evidence consistently shows that self-reports do not correspond well to actual behavioral patterns 86. An alternative and more accurate method consists of asking for others’ reports based on their own experiences. Evidence demonstrates that individuals develop accurate models of others’ behavioral reactions 87,88.

I looked at the studies they used to say individuals are good at predicting others behavior and it's based on adolescents so maybe different in women.

The problem with anything like this is how do there's emotions actually translate into behavior? Humans are capable of many different things and thoughts of feelings but they don't act on them all the time and it's context specifc.

During a Zombie apocalypse yes resource competition would be fierce but the most likely time you'd see this manifest is on sports day parents race of something random like that.

You also have to remember humans have always co-operated in fact I read something that believed that's why we out competed Neanderthals and Women's social networks are a key part in building this co-operation and community.

MeinKraft · 11/04/2023 09:02

It comes from a deep seated fear that you're not providing enough for your children.

RemoteControlDoobry · 11/04/2023 09:02

Competition for what though? I’ve always seen women compete for men and that’s why they wear tiny clothes (they don’t admit this of course). But once you’ve had children then I don’t really understand what women would be competing for.

A place to be on Amanda’s table? I’d have always chosen the toilet table so don’t understand this rubbish.

LordEmsworth · 11/04/2023 08:58

What a load of bollocks.

proppy · 11/04/2023 08:54

of course I’m jealous of women who have a bigger, nicer home, more money, better jobs, nicer cars, better looks, more friends.
Do I give them any negativity? No. What’s the point? Be cruel to make myself feel better? That just doesn’t make sense.

I'd say this was envy though. I'm envious that my friend can eat crap everyday & stay slim but I like her so still want to be around her.

ThatshallotBaby · 11/04/2023 08:50

Interesting. I have experienced jealously from other mums when dc were younger. It took me a while to realise that’s what it was. I think it was more to do with the relationship I had with my children than anything else.
I have quite low self esteem, no career, not a lot of family support. I’m not a game player, and I think this is what I was resented for.

GraysPapaya · 11/04/2023 08:48

This isn’t my experience, but I quickly distance myself from very material people at the making friends stage.

IlIlI · 11/04/2023 08:44

There are jealous women about for sure, but I don't know if it's as this study says. It just reminds me of those "studies" that say all women are either bi or gay but never really hetero. Men definitely get jealous too, probably the same amount of women that do. Sometimes it's just jealous of different things. A woman might be jealous of a woman with a nice figure, great partner, nice family, nice home, job etc. A man might be jealous of a man with a nice body, lovely partner, good job, nice car etc.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 08:43

SwordToFlamethrower · 11/04/2023 08:03

Lack of emotional maturity and internalised misogyny.

There is absolutely loads of that on here.

Yep.

MzHz · 11/04/2023 08:38

But it’s not just mothers, I’ve long felt that one of the main reasons why we’re not as equal with men as we could be is that women do such a great job of pulling each other down.

we all know stories about how a female boss makes it harder for us to progress. Men help each other, work as a team to help each other. Where as many women (certainly ones I’ve worked with) will have the approach that “it was hard for me rising up the ranks, why would I make it easy for you?”

i think this is changing. I hope so, but I fundamentally don’t automatically trust women in the workplace because of the experiences I have.

Even the trans issue has support from women, campaigns and movements to allow access of males to female spaces, those who don’t want this forced on them are too militant/all number of insults and are cancelled/attacked/fired from their jobs if they stand up for women’s rights and spaces.

#BeKind too is very much a mechanism to tell women to Pipe Down. Men don’t tell other men to #BeKind. And let’s not forget that the person who made the phrase take off into celebrity land was someone who used violence against her partner.

even on MN. There’s always someone hiding behind a keyboard ready to pull someone down.

my own mother and sister turned out to be extremely jealous of me, fuck knows why, I’d only ever been there for them.

whatever drives this has to stop. We’re never going to be equal or have the choices men automatically have if we keep taking ourselves out.

4eyesbigthighs · 11/04/2023 08:37

I see it. But it’s so bloody boring and exhausting competing with each other.

of course I’m jealous of women who have a bigger, nicer home, more money, better jobs, nicer cars, better looks, more friends.
Do I give them any negativity? No. What’s the point? Be cruel to make myself feel better? That just doesn’t make sense.

If anything I’d be more likely to befriend someone who has what I want 😂

I can’t think of anything worse than spending a life subconsciously, or consciously going out of my way to make someone else feel crap out of jealousy.

WandaWonder · 11/04/2023 08:34

In real life I have not felt it from pre pregnancy through to having a teenager, on here all the time

Personally I think I missed that memo

Tarantullah · 11/04/2023 08:32

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:51

Yes, I don't see how it really relates specifically to being a mother thing.

The OP posted a link to the study. They studied married couples with children. There was significantly more competitiveness shown between the women on these issues than the men.

That scenario is clearly heavily weighted to women though, if the same with tweaks to consider factors that affect men the answer would be different. I know that's true of all research but it's glaringly obvious in that example. If it was along the same lines ie big house with a nice garden, healthy with a good body and access to decent food etc I'm sure a hell of a lot of men would be jealous.

potniatheron · 11/04/2023 08:32

Research suggests that our brains have evolved in a way to compete for resources and status. We see this throughout the mammalian kingdom; I think it's very arrogant to assume that humans would be any different as if we weren't mammals ourselves!

Anyone who's seen a group of men (especially young men) interacting knows that they compete for status, in a different way to women, but both sexes still do it.

However, 'civilisation' (whatever that is) and the centuries-long conditioning of the Abrahamic religions teaches us to believe that we should keep overt competition to a minimum or only do it in certain carefully proscribed and ritualised ways eg playing sport, competing for promotions at work, etc. That's a good thing as it helps society to be cohesive.

I do agree that some men and some women seem to find it impossible to do anything without turning it into a competition. They are normally poorly socialised individuals or hiding low self-esteem. In women, I'm talking about things like competitive undereating, slagging off other women's bodies, boasting about children's and one's own achievements. It's very tedious but fortunately such people can usually be safely ignored.

CalpolDependant · 11/04/2023 08:30

If my husband and I were sent a list of questions to answer about our feelings on this, or any other subject matter, it would go like this:

Day 1: I thoughtfully complete my questionnaire. Husband puts his on top of the microwave.

Days 2-29: Husband’s questionnaire sits on top of microwave undisturbed

Day 30: I remind husband that I am posting the questionnaire today. He says I’ve “hidden it”. He finds it exactly where he left it. He fills it in half-arsedly with most of his answers being “don’t care”, “don’t know” or “N/A”

Day 120: The results of the questionnaire are published and men are found to be less concerned with all discussion points.

To summarise: I propose this is bad data. 😂😂

IcedPurple · 11/04/2023 08:13

Marchforward · 11/04/2023 06:50

Programmed by who?

I started to read that article and I couldn’t get past the sexist bollocks of the first line.

Same here. The 'research' seems a bit dodgy and not terribly scientific to me.

saraclara · 11/04/2023 08:11

tinyblackcat · 11/04/2023 08:04

A study that asks how people would react, ie hypotheticals? Hardly scientific!

It clearly has been carried out in a scientific manner, or it would not have been accepted for publication in the world's most important science journal.

Social science is a difficult area for study, but all the same, this would have been thoroughly peer reviewed to ensure that the scientific method was secure, and the conclusions accurately arrived at.

Swipe left for the next trending thread