Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mothers are competitive and jealous

116 replies

cornfleurs · 11/04/2023 06:46

I saw this study mentioned in the news and it really resonated with some of my own experiences since becoming a mother - as well as situations I've witnessed on the school run, problems my friends have encountered with other women and even threads on Mumsnet!

The researchers found that mothers responded more negatively to other women who had desirable assets (be that material or social) that they themselves didn't possess. In other words, women are programmed to be jealous of other women.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-31816-0

AIBU to think this sounds pretty accurate?

Married women with children experience greater intrasexual competition than their male counterparts - Scientific Reports

Human males are considered to be more competitive than females. However, females must also compete for resources necessary for their own and their offsprings’ survival. Since females use more indirect forms of competition than males, comparing observab...

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-31816-0

OP posts:
Echobelly · 11/04/2023 11:04

Not been my experience at all, but then I tend to read the best into interactions. Tbf, I don't really have any 'mum friends', I have friends who are mums, but I never made friends through any network of mums so there's doubtless sides I haven't seen at all.

Somebodiesmother · 11/04/2023 11:01

CascaChan · 11/04/2023 10:21

By biology, I think. It makes sense from an evolutionary psychology perspective.

It absolutely does not. Cooperation and altruism make much more sense in respect to raising children

Eastersundayname · 11/04/2023 10:35

I think it is possible to get to a place where you don't play these competitive/ envy games at the School gates. You have to be very self aware, mature and self assured. These things take internal work. It is possible, but you do see a lot of screaming skulls on here acting out from a place of envy....so I do believe the general finding of the study is true.

(Now.... I need to go and work out how to finance a Range Rover and a three week family holiday Disney Land Florida. I'll show Izzys mum I'm no poorper)

Ireolu · 11/04/2023 10:34

BlueJellycat · 11/04/2023 10:15

I have found the opposite to be true. Mums generally at the school gate are more popular the more they have. It seems if your rich, nice car, lots of money, amazing house, desirable career ( husband is minted) then you will be the most popular. People do like to socaily climb and aligning yourself with someone beautiful and rich seems to be the norm.

I have had people be lovely to me when they think they can get something that I have that they want. The moment it becomes obvious they can't get that thing or another better socially standing mum comes along, they ignore me. 4 kids, so being school runs for 15 years. One was who I considered a best friend. Her kids moved to a private school, and she told me repeatedly how another mums house was big. The kids could scoot around the rooms. Then, after two years she started ignoring me, saying she was always too busy to meet up. Then I bumped into her having lunch with minted mum.

It's sad that this has been your experience but I have found similar.
I refuse to befriend anyone on anything more that a superficial level as I am concerned that relationships are agenda driven. Not for me at least for now.

IcedPurple · 11/04/2023 10:31

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:51

Yes, I don't see how it really relates specifically to being a mother thing.

The OP posted a link to the study. They studied married couples with children. There was significantly more competitiveness shown between the women on these issues than the men.

Competitiveness between women was not 'shown'.

It was reported. Not the same thing.

IcedPurple · 11/04/2023 10:23

CascaChan · 11/04/2023 10:21

By biology, I think. It makes sense from an evolutionary psychology perspective.

In what way does jealousy 'make sense'?

CascaChan · 11/04/2023 10:21

Marchforward · 11/04/2023 06:50

Programmed by who?

I started to read that article and I couldn’t get past the sexist bollocks of the first line.

By biology, I think. It makes sense from an evolutionary psychology perspective.

BlueJellycat · 11/04/2023 10:15

I have found the opposite to be true. Mums generally at the school gate are more popular the more they have. It seems if your rich, nice car, lots of money, amazing house, desirable career ( husband is minted) then you will be the most popular. People do like to socaily climb and aligning yourself with someone beautiful and rich seems to be the norm.

I have had people be lovely to me when they think they can get something that I have that they want. The moment it becomes obvious they can't get that thing or another better socially standing mum comes along, they ignore me. 4 kids, so being school runs for 15 years. One was who I considered a best friend. Her kids moved to a private school, and she told me repeatedly how another mums house was big. The kids could scoot around the rooms. Then, after two years she started ignoring me, saying she was always too busy to meet up. Then I bumped into her having lunch with minted mum.

fairywhale · 11/04/2023 10:12

Did you even read this very flawed study? Or just saw or heard the headline and are using this to spread misogynistic views?
Just so you know, you'll find confirmation of whatever you set out to find. Most studies will. There is "scientific" proof of very opposite claims.

lljkk · 11/04/2023 10:08

There is no end to what MNers can blame men for...

Oh no, women aren't inherently competitive. How we dress, "judge" each other's appearance, "judge" the behaviour of each other's children, sharpen elbows to make sure our kids get into best schools, appraise each other's shoes / make up / handbags / house-proudness , our kids' GCSE results, whether kids got in to an RG Uni, compare how our babies were born or got fed. Snobbery about (not) cooking from scratch, UPVC windows and too much screen time. Not possibly hardwired: all those things that men profoundly do not even talk about because they simply don't care that much .... couldn't possibly be hardwired that women (or at least MNers) care so much about these things & incessantly compare and compete on them.

One of my faves on MN is bra cup size. Plenty delighted proclamations on here about G, H & J size chests reported as "revelation" after a bra intervention. Nobody says "What a pisser now I found out this is my real bra size and that's it, I'm saving up to get a reduction ASAP these norks are so annoying I hate the attention they'll get me".

ssd · 11/04/2023 10:08

I guess if it wasn't true. Mn wouldn't be so interesting...

fairywhale · 11/04/2023 10:06

The study is small, not representative and the differences are small. Promoted to the sheeple that blindly consume and believe anything on the news.
Mothers can be envious of women who parent better than them, the study finds. A bear can shit in the woods, Sherlock.
Girls from birth and even while still in utero are conditioned with the expectations to parent and to parent well. Almost universally. Boys very often are conditioned to be free agents, even despite the nature of many, nurturing traits are erased out of them, starting in the family, subtly or even directly and none of the above expectation is placed on boys. No shit some feel less jealous about things they don't care about.

Iwasafool · 11/04/2023 10:05

I have 3 kids, two happy healthy kids who did fine at school, one who was academically very ahead of all the other kids but useless at physical stuff, it was like all their development had been channeled in one direction. We had issues with school mums who would do things like invite my child round for playdate and proceed to get them to do an 11plus paper to compare with their own child. You could "hear" these women in things their kids said and by the end of primary school my child was being really badly bullied.

The nicest, kindest mums I met at that time were mums at a group for children with learning difficulties learning a sport, as my child was so awkward and lacking in coordination it was suggested we go along. The mums were so inclusive and they would compare notes about schools and specialists and so on. When a new child joined their would be lots of talk about diagnosis/treatment etc and eventually the new mum would look at my child and say, "What is Xs diagnosis." The other mums would chorus, "That's what we want to know." and laugh. I never once felt any resentment when my child was sitting reading a book or doing a maths puzzle or something like that which we would get so much of with the mums at school. I honestly think it was the most positive experience I had as a mum.

dottiedodah · 11/04/2023 10:03

I read somewhere that men are more competitive! They find it harder to be friends with other guys as they compare homes ,style of living, cars and so on. My friend said she had read that when women have DC they become calmer and more settled.

OMGitsnotgood · 11/04/2023 10:02

I think it's natural to feel envious of others, it's how much you allow those feelings to consume you and what you do as a result. For example, I'm not ashamed to say i was envious of a friend who lived in a massive house, went on several foreign holidays a year, didn't have to work yet still had a cleaner because she had a high earning husband, who she was incredibly Hapoy with. I'll confess I had to work hard on appreciating what I did have, which was more than many people could ever hope for, and not wishing I could have her life.

ThefourseasonsFrankie · 11/04/2023 10:00

Likewise the study isn’t saying fathers are not competitive vis-a-vis fathers. So you could go off and find a video of competitive fatherhood and it matters not.

ThefourseasonsFrankie · 11/04/2023 09:58

manontroppo · 11/04/2023 09:51

You clearly have no experience of the ultra competitive mothers of East Asian countries…

Do you understand the difference between all, some, likelihood, etc? There will be competitiveness all over the world across all genders and races. Western societies are by their very construct and outlook, more competitive and individualistic. That is not to say you will find no such behaviour in other cultures.

ThefourseasonsFrankie · 11/04/2023 09:56

whumpthereitis · 11/04/2023 09:27

You see it all the time on here. An OP can post about feeling insecure in comparison to X, but instead of encouraging OP to work on herself to become confident in her own right and quit comparing herself, plenty of posters will rip X apart for daring to have a good income/good looks/happy relationships.

People get really elaborate in their fantasies about how miserable/awful/unintelligent complete strangers must be.

And this is seen in how they tear down women in the public eye who they know nothing about but will tell you how that person thinks, how much of a narcissist they are, etc. They use the vilest of sexist stereotypes. I never understand why women are so much more abusive to other women. It’s okay to have an opinion and criticise but the extreme ways some women behave is utterly frightening and it always betrays their deep insecurities.

I just don’t understand where they get the energy and brain space for all that junk thinking and behaviour.

KimberleyClark · 11/04/2023 09:55

manontroppo · 11/04/2023 09:51

You clearly have no experience of the ultra competitive mothers of East Asian countries…

Of which this is a perfect example

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=3N7F-5zNVFI

Goodness Gracious Me Competitive Mothers

Goodness Gracious Me Competitive Mothers

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=3N7F-5zNVFI

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 11/04/2023 09:54

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 07:00

It's not my experience at all with my friends, thankfully. We all have different struggles and support and champion each other. However, I choose friends very carefully.

There is a thread running here about an OP who had fallen out of love with her bf. He does no housework and leaves everything to her, won't even make a cup of tea or make the bed. Because she mentioned that she out-earns him significantly and he was also proposing to go part time so he could be an even lazier cocklodger, endless posters filled her thread telling her she should be "grateful" that he life is so easy because she doesn't have children, and that he is magnanimous enough not to be "fussed" that she earns more than him, and must be "blissfully unaware" that she's fed up with the situation. It was clear spite and jealousy about her salary.

Another thread that's running has similar comments because a woman was negged about being too independent and told this made her "unlovable" and because she described her situation posters piled on to tell her she was "arrogant".

It's eye opening reading things on here because it is a window into how some women think and the bitterness and spitefulness is quite shocking sometimes. Sadly it seems to support what the study says. I'm just very glad the people I am close to are not like this!!

I saw that thread and felt sad for the OP. There was such a feeling of spite and envy from some posters and it's clear that there are (presumably) women on this board who enjoy taking other 'down a peg', warranted or not.

I don't experience people like this in real life either, I wouldn't choose to be around them. I also don't believe that mumsnet is an accurate representation or spectrum of women. It's like any other chatboard; women with time on their hands. Some have pockets of time, some have a lot or even too much. If that's a demographic then perhaps it explains the bitterness/envy. Who knows?

manontroppo · 11/04/2023 09:51

ThefourseasonsFrankie · 11/04/2023 09:48

Because you don’t like it’s conclusion?

Is it that difficult to see the conclusion reached makes sense? Just look at social media - a reflection of what’s deep within the hearts and minds of people, who provide a nice veneer of respectability in person but deep down jealous and resentment reigns supreme.

That said, not all societies are like that. It is probably more a Western thing where cooperating on a deep level as a commune has not been part of the culture for centuries, if ever.

You clearly have no experience of the ultra competitive mothers of East Asian countries…

ThefourseasonsFrankie · 11/04/2023 09:48

IcedPurple · 11/04/2023 08:13

Same here. The 'research' seems a bit dodgy and not terribly scientific to me.

Because you don’t like it’s conclusion?

Is it that difficult to see the conclusion reached makes sense? Just look at social media - a reflection of what’s deep within the hearts and minds of people, who provide a nice veneer of respectability in person but deep down jealous and resentment reigns supreme.

That said, not all societies are like that. It is probably more a Western thing where cooperating on a deep level as a commune has not been part of the culture for centuries, if ever.

Naunet · 11/04/2023 09:47

Not All Women

manontroppo · 11/04/2023 09:44

Entirely my experience from living in a naice middle class village. Also manifests itself in group othering - middle classes look down on the lower class/people who opt out of it, so they can feel superior.

Lots of house envy and school place envy - some are better than others but all it takes is a couple of people to really change the dynamics.

StagsLeap · 11/04/2023 09:32

Summerhillsquare · 11/04/2023 06:48

We're not 'programmed', that makes it sound inevitable. Women are socialised to be competitive, to fight over scarce resources in the hope we won't notice who's hoarding all the resources - men.

This, exactly.