Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mothers are competitive and jealous

116 replies

cornfleurs · 11/04/2023 06:46

I saw this study mentioned in the news and it really resonated with some of my own experiences since becoming a mother - as well as situations I've witnessed on the school run, problems my friends have encountered with other women and even threads on Mumsnet!

The researchers found that mothers responded more negatively to other women who had desirable assets (be that material or social) that they themselves didn't possess. In other words, women are programmed to be jealous of other women.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-31816-0

AIBU to think this sounds pretty accurate?

Married women with children experience greater intrasexual competition than their male counterparts - Scientific Reports

Human males are considered to be more competitive than females. However, females must also compete for resources necessary for their own and their offsprings’ survival. Since females use more indirect forms of competition than males, comparing observab...

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-31816-0

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cornfleurs · 11/04/2023 23:57

sorry, quote fail in the first sentence of my post

OP posts:
cornfleurs · 11/04/2023 23:56

*Maybe it changes once children get to school, but in my personal experience, mums are incredibly supportive towards one another rather than competitive.

I started to notice some jealousy most when my children were pre-teens and an increasing disparity emerged between the lifestyles/circumstances among the people we knew/ families my dc had grown up with.

A lot of people's careers really take off in their late 30s/early 40s, and they are gradually able to afford much bigger houses, private school etc, while others stay put. Mothers are often at the coal face of this due to the way they socialise/school runs/playdates etc, so they may see what others have relative to themselves more clearly. Social media is also a factor now.

But I picked up on resentment towards some women in particular, and sometimes noticed quiet attempts to bring the more fortunate-seeming mothers down a peg or two, sometimes by excluding them or their dc, saying nasty things behind their backs etc.

It was striking to me, which is why this study struck a chord I suppose

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 11/04/2023 22:15

EvelynBeatrice · 11/04/2023 15:24

Motherhood is the biggest success story of the human race. The overwhelming majority of everyday normal mothers would not only take a bullet for their own kids, possibly grandkids too but also step in front of other children to protect them from perceived dangers. So I'm not particularly interested in a continuing and escalating attempt both in academia and elsewhere to denigrate mothers. We rock !

Can you share around what you are on?

RockGirl · 11/04/2023 21:24

We should clarify between 'women' and 'mothers' as they are not the same thing.

Chamelion · 11/04/2023 19:19

We see this everyday here on mumsnet.
someone’s got a cleaner: lazy and disorganised
married to a wealthy man: they’re abused and unhappy
children wear Boden: tacky new money because old money wear rags
well dressed moms at school gates: miserable cows because surely they have an awful self esteem

Oblomov23 · 11/04/2023 16:53

Nope. Bullshit. I'm not like that naturally, nor are most of the mums I know.

Fantasmagoricalan · 11/04/2023 16:23

EvelynBeatrice · 11/04/2023 15:24

Motherhood is the biggest success story of the human race. The overwhelming majority of everyday normal mothers would not only take a bullet for their own kids, possibly grandkids too but also step in front of other children to protect them from perceived dangers. So I'm not particularly interested in a continuing and escalating attempt both in academia and elsewhere to denigrate mothers. We rock !

Um.

EvelynBeatrice · 11/04/2023 15:24

Motherhood is the biggest success story of the human race. The overwhelming majority of everyday normal mothers would not only take a bullet for their own kids, possibly grandkids too but also step in front of other children to protect them from perceived dangers. So I'm not particularly interested in a continuing and escalating attempt both in academia and elsewhere to denigrate mothers. We rock !

potniatheron · 11/04/2023 13:37

Somebodiesmother · 11/04/2023 11:01

It absolutely does not. Cooperation and altruism make much more sense in respect to raising children

Only up to a point. The modern evolutionary science around inclusive fitness, parental investment theory and especially the so-called 'Cinderella effect' all point to a preponderance of altruism and generosity to ones one kinship / close familial / tribal ethnic group.

Kennykenkencat · 11/04/2023 13:15

I used to laugh at those “competitive” mums. Some were quite ridiculous. I never got involved with their one upmanship as Dd and Ds would always “fail” as they were both on the SEN table. (Dd loved being on that table as you got a chocolate button each day for writing your name😂 her reasoning was why try too hard as you would just miss out on the chocolate buttons)

It’s when you watch them trying to outdo each other on what their child can do or which schools, tutors, universities they were looking at.

It starts at birth, my child can sit up, walk, talk. Given virtually every child can do these sort of things by the the time they are 5 years old then I didn’t think it mattered
The knots they tied themselves into when Ds walked at 9 months.

Was once told that I should stop dc’s ECAs and concentrate on school work as otherwise they would end up with no qualifications and fail to get into university and I was condemning them to a lifetime of minimum wage jobs

Dd has gone through the grades in her ECA’s and has so many at a top level she has enough UCAS points for university even though she only got 4 GCSEs

I found that these mums lacked any sort of awareness that there was more than one path their children could take. None seemed to have any awareness of what their children actually liked or wanted.

I always felt sorry for the children as what they wanted or liked never came into their parents vision.

IcedPurple · 11/04/2023 12:51

That doesn’t sound like they’ve measured competitiveness at all, but rather perceptions of competitiveness.

Exactly.

And given that jealousy is such a stereotypical female trait, it's hardly surprising that people would perceive women to be more jealous and competitive than men. It doesn't mean it's true however.

Surveys based on self reporting always need to be taken with a pinch of salt, especially when it comes to 'gendered' behaviour. It's like how, when asked how many sex partners you have had, it's well known that men will overstate and women understate, because promiscuity is still much more acceptable, even admirable, in men than in women.

StagsLeap · 11/04/2023 12:45

CurlewKate · 11/04/2023 12:33

It's also important to remember that "she's jealous" is a default response for many of us. It's something that's said to little girls to explain bad behaviour/bullying from other girls.

I’m always taken aback at how often it’s the default response on Mn from actual adults, to any situation described by an OP that involves any kind of behaviour that suggests anything from lack of warmth to actual hostility, when there’s no evidence whatsoever jealousy is involved.

I find it deeply juvenile. It’s a very face-saving way of not considering whether you’ve done anything to contribute to a difficult dynamic, or of not dealing with the reality that not everyone will like you. It’s also very self-aggrandising, because it posits the person as having something other people are perceived to want.

I seem to have missed out on having that said to me in childhood, probably because we were so visibly poor that there was no basis conceivable for anyone to be ‘jealous’.

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 11/04/2023 12:44

I think that it’s because it’s particularly the mothers who are thrown in to a whole new peer group of strangers the minute that the school gates open.
The school runs etc are still dominated by mothers and it’s a long haul with a group of people that you wouldn’t necessarily want to know.
Men are to an extent at arm’s length from this and retain their original peer group.

SunshineAndStorms · 11/04/2023 12:38

This is such an interesting thread.

I'm not sure if it's competitiveness alwats or more women trying to be self righteous or big themselves up when they're actually insecure about their choices.

I have an ex friend who approaches life with her way is the best way - breastfeeding, vegan, home schooling, etc. She's quite judgemental to others.

I don't have anything to compete with. If I did it would probably be the bad stuff like my birth experiences being the worst out of my friends or having the most disorganised house out of everyone I know as dc1 has adhd and so do I!

CurlewKate · 11/04/2023 12:33

It's also important to remember that "she's jealous" is a default response for many of us. It's something that's said to little girls to explain bad behaviour/bullying from other girls.

ThefourseasonsFrankie · 11/04/2023 12:30

manontroppo · 11/04/2023 11:54

Citation needed. China has had to ban tutoring for profit, Korean kids spend hours after school every day going to tutoring/study classes and it’s pretty much the same in Japan. Western Europe is far more covert about competitiveness and there are at least strands in society who do try for inclusion.

And for all of those mums who are lovely to your face, I can guarentee some of them will be gleefully feeling smug to their husbands and some friends behind your back.

You are missing the point aren’t you? The competition you are talking about in terms of educational attainment is very different to the jealousy and negativity being spoken about in the article.

You can somersault as much as you like, Western mums are comparatively more individualistic and negatively competitive.

China is a communist country and is built on a very different mindset - all for one and one for all type approach and excelling for collective dominance.

Everywhere had competition and ethos and mindset are not the same across cultures.

riotlady · 11/04/2023 12:18

“We asked 596 married participants, 25–45 years of age with at least one child from three different countries to evaluate how same-sex individuals they know would react to a target individual who had a valuable resource that the same-sex individuals did not have. Half the participants evaluated reactions to same-sex targets, while the other half evaluated reactions to other-sex targets. Participants reported that women would react more negatively than men to resource asymmetry with same-sex targets, but not other-sex targets.”

That doesn’t sound like they’ve measured competitiveness at all, but rather perceptions of competitiveness. Participants have stated that they think women would be more jealous of other women with valued resources, but that doesn’t mean they actually are?

Emmalj65 · 11/04/2023 11:56

It's women in general, not just mums.

Yellowdays · 11/04/2023 11:54

@malificent7 That's not competition, surely? That's difference in opinion and choice.

manontroppo · 11/04/2023 11:54

ThefourseasonsFrankie · 11/04/2023 09:58

Do you understand the difference between all, some, likelihood, etc? There will be competitiveness all over the world across all genders and races. Western societies are by their very construct and outlook, more competitive and individualistic. That is not to say you will find no such behaviour in other cultures.

Citation needed. China has had to ban tutoring for profit, Korean kids spend hours after school every day going to tutoring/study classes and it’s pretty much the same in Japan. Western Europe is far more covert about competitiveness and there are at least strands in society who do try for inclusion.

And for all of those mums who are lovely to your face, I can guarentee some of them will be gleefully feeling smug to their husbands and some friends behind your back.

Winterday1991 · 11/04/2023 11:52

Boringcookingquestion · 11/04/2023 11:35

Before I had children I thought competitive mums would be an issue because you often hear about how common it is.

Nothing could be further from my experience so far. The vast majority of mums (and dads) I have met have been supportive and lovely. I’m genuinely amazed by the amount of times I have heard strangers offering reassurance to a worried mum about some milestone or another, or reminding each other that all toddlers throw tantrum/snatch toys/knock over things so ‘don’t worry, it’s fine!’.

Maybe it changes once children get to school, but in my personal experience, mums are incredibly supportive towards one an other rather than competitive.

Echoing this, it's my experience too

Inthedarkagain · 11/04/2023 11:46

I have avoided some people who might appear more well off than me and have a better lifestyle, as I did not want my kids to get involved with that level of competitiveness. It's harder now they are older, but when they were small I did. I was happy with my shit buggy and flat, but just didn't want to get into all that. I worked full time and many of the wealthy mums were SAH and it felt like they occupied a different world to me at the time. They were nice enough, but we had differing priorities. I wasn't jealous as such, just didn't manage to click with them as I wasn't around much.

The wealthy parents I avoided turned out to be in massive debt! I hope the top of the range baby stuff was worth it.

Boringcookingquestion · 11/04/2023 11:35

Before I had children I thought competitive mums would be an issue because you often hear about how common it is.

Nothing could be further from my experience so far. The vast majority of mums (and dads) I have met have been supportive and lovely. I’m genuinely amazed by the amount of times I have heard strangers offering reassurance to a worried mum about some milestone or another, or reminding each other that all toddlers throw tantrum/snatch toys/knock over things so ‘don’t worry, it’s fine!’.

Maybe it changes once children get to school, but in my personal experience, mums are incredibly supportive towards one an other rather than competitive.

ThreeLocusts · 11/04/2023 11:23

Having glanced the paper over, I note that they do very little to define 'competitive' - they seem to be focused mostly on jealousy, arguably quite a different thing than trying to beat others at stuff - and rely heavily on hypotheticals in the questions they ask. The guiding assumptions of the study are very cliched.

In my experience sharp glances and put downs at the school gates are a very real thing. But not equally everywhere - the worst I've seen was in Cambridge, a very stratified place.

It's a social dynamic, and a function of the way women are taught to think that they are always failing at something, if it's not reproduction then it's career. Trying to make this into a psychological constant is letting the patriarchy off the hook.

Commonsensitivity · 11/04/2023 11:09

It depends how much they flaunt it. I have a very wealthy friend who is very down to earth. I'm happy for her and not jealous.
There are other smarmy mums on the school run who flaunt their privilege like a badge. They make me slightly jealous.