Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child's piano lesson

103 replies

Wellthatsthatthenisntit · 11/04/2023 00:41

My DCs both do piano lessons. Age 6 and 9. Recently DC9 has begun complaining about going. It is half an hour a week (lesson) and they do two practices of about 10 mins during the week. Been going 18 months.

My view is that this is non-negotiable. It will help with their development, and future choices in life, and both doing very well with it. I gave up a musical instrument when young, which I regret, and parents never pushed me. I realise I am projecting.

For the record I am not pushy in any other way and they happily do swimming, a team sport (winter and summer) and other activities of their choosing. I don't make them do extra schoolwork or anything like that.

Family member thinks I am being horrible. AIBU?

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 11/04/2023 14:56

Womanofcustard · 11/04/2023 00:45

I don’t think you are being unreasonable, but a half hour lesson and 2 10minute practises - that’s less than an hour a week! You are wasting your money, unfortunately. Need to practise at least half an hour nearly every day.

Correct.

This is a waste of time and money, in my opinion (my partner is a pianist and trained music teacher).

orangesandlemonsthebellsofstc · 11/04/2023 14:53

Apologies a sentence seems to have disappeared. I was trying to say sometimes weekends are the best fit for the things that require the most concentration. I have a couple students who only do bowing exercises at the weekends b/c they find to do them well they need their best concentration, otherwise they rush them b/c they are tired. In their home they do music practice Sat/Sun mid-morning and tackle harder things than they do during the week with the school rush.

One last thing - try and remember you are all learning. You are learning how to be the parent of 9 and 6 year old music students, they are learning the dedication it requires to be music students. It will be trial and error, things that worked will stop working and vice versa, but with creativity and a good teacher, you will get there! Best wishes.

orangesandlemonsthebellsofstc · 11/04/2023 14:45

@Wellthatsthatthenisntit I teach music to children as one of my two jobs. I agree there are massive benefits to learning an instrument and unless there are other factors at play, I'd say it's a good thing to commit to as a family. A few things jump out at me:

  1. Work with your dc teacher. See if they can help you and them devise a practice plan that includes enough of what your children enjoy about the instrument. Do they really love certain songs or practice games? Use those as the beginning and end of practices.
  2. FInd music they like listening to. Some of my students love The Piano Guys and their antics. It makes it fun and lets them see what can happen as they learn more and more skills. Also ensure they are listening to the music they are learning. Building that confidence by using and developing their ear, has massive benefits.
  3. I think what is hard about piano is that it is a more isolated instrument. Strings for example often include group lessons. To help the social aspect, could they teach you what they are learning? Have concerts at home or over zoom for family? Where they dress up, make tickets etc etc etc. Do their friends play instruments and you could do a concert together? To love something kids often need it to be playful!
  4. I don't think the practicing is enough. It's a funny one, parents often think less means that their children won't resent it. My finding is that it can send a message of 'I will only make you do this twice a week' which isn't exactly the undertone you want. Take the broadest scope with practicing - listening, games, playing, make that all part of learning. ' Run and play C, D, A, C, D' how fast can you do it? Lets pick a number out of a jar and see how many times we are going to practice that tricky bar, I bet you'll master it by the end. (This is important as it allows them to see how their 'work' allowed them to master something hard and then makes their overall piece sound better which helps encourage them too. It isn't just endlessly playing there's a skill to practice.) Another thing to make it fun is hiding the songs they need to practice around the house and they go on a scavenger hunt to find them. Or sit at the piano and play the song they are learning terribly, usually that gets laughter followed by "no, Mummy, this is how you play it". At this age the more positive associations they can make with music, the more likelihood they will enjoy it while they aren't yet at that stage where mastering a song brings that enjoyment at the same level it does for older children.
  5. Use this as a teachable moment that things will be hard and we don't just give up. Learning to walk/read/do multiplications is hard. What would happen if we gave up each time? Let them know that your family will evaluate each summer what activities are for the year and everyone will get to share their feelings, thoughts and reasons.
  6. Be realistic about whether the teacher is a good fit. There's a large school near me where there's no real personal attention, teachers musicians and music post grad students who are only teaching b/c they can't earn enough as musicians without it. I've had many students from that school there are some things I notice - there's no real joy after a few months, turnover is high, some of the teachers are teaching without the real skills that are needed to work with children in a way that brings reward for them. Kids need teachers who want to make this a good experience for them, not just teach them music. I have kids each year who stretch me, who make me seek out podcasts and books about how to be what they need in a teacher. Many of my students are neurodiverse, most arrive because this is their parents last attempt at making music work. I also charge a fraction of what the larger school does.
  7. Make music a part of your family life - music concerts - if you live near a University many have very reasonable ones featuring their music department, various styles playing at home (fiddle, cello, bands, show tunes etc etc etc). Have other instruments around the home. Nothing pushy but increase that enjoyment.
  8. Find the best time to practice - for some it's in the morning, for others it's after snack right after school, other's still it's later. Your 6 and 9 year old may need different times of the day. Use the weekend for

I don't believe there is a set amount or 'perfect' practice time. I have some students who mark one day a week as a non-practice day, others who mostly practice daily unless something crops up and others who are realistic that it will only be 4/5 days/week. I'd say trying to ensure they practice at least 4/5 days/week - again taking that widest scope of what practice is. If on a weekday it includes listening to the pieces they are learning (as I mentioned that's really important imho - build that ear skill!), practicing a tricky bar 5 x and practicing 1-2 review songs twice each, playing their current piece a few times (or parts of it that need working on), with mostly a smile on their faces, then that's success for that day. None of that should take longer than 15-20 minutes for your 9 year old. For your 6 year old they should be able to do most of that, perhaps 1 review piece, but their pieces are usually shorter.

It's a great thing you are doing @Wellthatsthatthenisntit and I really hope it works out for you and your dc! Happy playing!

herlightmaterials · 11/04/2023 14:36

They're not practicing enough for it to be worthwhile doing it.

You need to sit beside them daily while they practice. One day off a week.

If you can't be bothered to do that then they should definitely stop. But they would probably on balance have a different attitude if you put the effort in.

Don't do it when they are cold, hungry or just when they know it would be time for screen time if they didn't have piano.

mondaytosunday · 11/04/2023 14:33

That's not enough practise.
But anyway, why push it? How does it help with their development and future choices?
My daughter gave up piano at a similar age. Then four years later asked to take it up again. This time she was self motivated and I didn't have to remind her to practise.
If they aren't pestering you to let them do something then why waste your money?

IfYouLikePinaCoIadas · 11/04/2023 14:21

I was forced to do piano lessons as a child, til I was 14. I absolutely hated it. I got to grade 5, still hated it. I never play now

zingally · 11/04/2023 14:16

Music was a non-negotiable for me as well. I started off on the recorder, and moved to the violin, doing that from age 8-16.
I didn't enjoy the practicing, and can't say I especially enjoyed the lessons, but I DID enjoy playing in youth orchestra etc, and going to Saturday morning music school.
I stopped doing the exams after grade 4, because I HATED the pressure of them, but kept up with lessons and music school just for fun. I was probably a low grade 7 standard at my absolute best.

Whiteroomjoy · 11/04/2023 14:13

i do think the way music is taught does make it more difficult or less than enjoyable for most kids.

Years ago I listened to an eminent musician and teacher talking about this on a Radio 4 programme. He made the point that children learn to talk through listening not reading. Reading comes much later when they’ve grasped the basics of talking, understood how to put sentences together and can express themselves. Reading enables children to then expand their vocabulary and understand how others express themselves
he advocated music is no different. Children should be taught to play first by ear only- forget written music and notation. Teach them to listen to music recognising the language in different rhymes and chords that relate to different types of music. That made so much sense to me.

both my kids started learning woodwind instruments . Traditional music teaching, notation, grades etc. they did find it difficult and I did find I had to make them practice ( see my earlier post on why I wanted them to persist). But once they got to secondary they had a chance to switch to guitar. They had a fantastic teacher who used method advocated in the programme I listened to. Their teacher got them to listen to music, different types, to learn to pick out the chord, rhymes etc by ear and copy back. They’d come back from lessons with having covered stuff like “ jazz” “ Latin” “ R&b” and I had never realised in all my childhood music lessons that certain chords, scales etc are associated with certain types of music 🤦‍♀️ but they were being taught this by actually listening. Yep, they still had to practice, but it was all now based on copying sounds. And that made a massive game changing difference. My sons eventually could go online to find random music being played, stuff they liked, and then slowly dissect it through listening and then copying it

Whiteroomjoy · 11/04/2023 13:58

For those saying it’s a waste of time to force children to learn to play an instrument…my view is that for many children it provides a valuable experience of learning in a different way

much of what kids learn in school is either down to memory or deduction/comprehension skills. There aren’t that many opportunities in schools to learn through repetition or muscle memory. In fact in subjects like maths and language that would benefit from repititous learning there ain’t time on curriculum . Children who take advanced sports may well learn this, think gymnastics where you have to repeat skills over and over….learning an instrument is like that…even the best natural professional musicians have to study and repeat the piece over and over to perfect it and acquire that muscle memory.

my 2 kids were both bright and academically sound. But my eldest particularly liked to learn through observing, he’d watch, read, listen until he was happy he could do something then just do it. He never, left to his own devices, learnt anything through repeating, making mistakes, repeating etc etc.

im not a natural musician and didn’t get further than grade 3, but even as a youngish person I realised that learning an instrument made me learn in different ways than I was used to, and a bit out of my comfort zone, and in life you just sometimes have to learn through practice makes perfect. I’m 60 and since retiring and taking up a specific handicraft activities I’ve come to really value again the benefits of practice as a skill and tool to learn, and have confidence to know I can learn this way

i made my kids have instrument lessons solely for this point. I didn’t expect to turn them into great musicians but at very least it would give them experience and skills to learn something in a different way. It’s an added bonus that my eldest particularly kept up with his instrument ( not through grades mind) and as an adult still plays it now. He got some great social experiences and friends as a result of his music and participation in performing,

DiscoBeat · 11/04/2023 13:40

We did it the other way around - strongly encouraged practice for the music lessons they wanted but didn't force it. But we did insist on swimming lessons for a year or so.

WeeOrcadian · 11/04/2023 13:27

"Too many helpful comments to mention individually but thanks - I’m again grateful for the insight. Thinking about it now we used to practise more, which I hadn’t really thought about until now."

Read: thanks for the people agreeing with me, it makes me feel like I'm right

WeeOrcadian · 11/04/2023 13:25

"I gave up a musical instrument when young, which I regret, and parents never pushed me. I realise I am projecting."

Yes, you certainly are. Your DC don't enjoy it - would you force them to do a sport they don't enjoy? Or attend a club they dislike? Stop forcing this onto them, they won't thank you for it

YABVU.

Newusernameaug · 11/04/2023 13:22

I’d also highly recommend YOU learning and practising to inspire them and show them that they can achieve anything they want at any age and there’s never any excuse.

Noduckpicsplease · 11/04/2023 13:20

Music teacher here.
Personally I think learning an instrument should definitely be encouraged for all children, but saying it's non-negotiable just seems like it's going to end up with them resenting you.
You need to get to the bottom of why they aren't enjoying it. Is it the pieces, what they are learning? Talk to the teacher about it. Would they rather try a different instrument? I've taught kids who really struggled when they had to do two hands but moved onto a single line instrument instead and progressed well.
Is it that they don't want to do exams? Really genuinely believe kids should never be forced to do exams in music unless they want to. They are also very expensive!
I was very goal oriented so it worked for me and pushed me to practice. But I have several pupils who hate the idea, hate the pressure and instead practise when they find a new piece they love and want to learn.

CurlewKate · 11/04/2023 13:13

I don't know about the piano, but my dd learned to play the clarinet to a reasonably high standard and her teacher was very relaxed about practising. He would ask her if she'd practised. If she had, they'd move on. If she hadn't, they'd play together for the 45 minute lesson. She never wanted to give up lessons, always wanted to go and had fun. He was a fantastic teacher.

Kolakalia · 11/04/2023 12:31

And good point by PP. If you regret your quitting piano OP, why don't you start lessons? If one of your kids really wants to stop then you can take up their slot?

I'm being genuine, lots of adults return in adulthood, or even start from scratch. What better way to process your regret than taking ownership of continuing?

twoshedsjackson · 11/04/2023 12:00

Sorry, DC9!

twoshedsjackson · 11/04/2023 11:58

As so many other teachers have said, regular practice is vital; if you ask for an easily achievable target, even if it's just five minutes a day, you might find that, once actually on the spot, they carry on for longer......in other words, initially less but more frequent. I think it's five times to set a mini neural pathway, or something like that; build up muscle memory.
The best practice they will do is the practice soonest after the lesson, when it is fresh in their minds, rather than later on during the week when they have had time to forget what they were taught.
Going back after a week for groundhog day is as excruciating for the teacher as it is for your DC.
If the teacher is agreeable, a brief note being specific about exactly what they should practice could give you a steer.
When they are fresh back from their lesson, get then to show you something new they have done, or an improvement they have made, and be enthusiastic. Maybe DC0 would enjoy teaching you what they have just learned?

HappiestSleeping · 11/04/2023 11:02

Womanofcustard · 11/04/2023 00:45

I don’t think you are being unreasonable, but a half hour lesson and 2 10minute practises - that’s less than an hour a week! You are wasting your money, unfortunately. Need to practise at least half an hour nearly every day.

This 👆

With the added bonus that you are probably putting them off music completely.

GabriellaMontez · 11/04/2023 10:06

I'd give them the option to change instrument if they get to the end of the year and want to do something else.

SophiaSW1 · 11/04/2023 09:58

You're being sooo unreasonable. What a waste of everyone's time.

MathsNervous · 11/04/2023 09:39

Agree with a few others here, pick up lessons yourself on the piano OP. Realise your dreams and leave your children to realise their own. It's wasted time forcing them to learn an instrument they don't enjoy.

nomoredriving · 11/04/2023 09:35

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 11/04/2023 00:42

YABVU,

If you regret quitting an instrument, why don't you take lessons instead of forcing it on your kids?

Excellent idea!

Iwasafool · 11/04/2023 09:29

Trivium4all · 11/04/2023 07:05

Musician here. I agree that to make good progress, almost daily practice (15 mins at this point would probably be reasonable, though it depends on the child, the instrument, and the progress desired). Once the progress is happening, then hopefully the practice will seem less unpalatable. However, it's important to learn how to practise.

I disagree with letting children quit things as soon as they get bored/find it a bit hard, because most things that are worth doing require practice. Getting through the boring bits of the process, and learning how to do that, is an important skill in itself, quite apart from the specific instrument or skill etc. being learned. Apart from the piano playing and music reading itself, which can hugely enhance enjoyment of music later in life, the discipline will useful to transfer to other activities, e.g. studying or learning anything a bit difficult.

Learning how to practise is something the teacher can hopefully address, initially by writing out a little plan for that week's practice sessions. For example, for many people, it's a good idea to begin and end with something that's comfortable and enjoyable, e.g. a short familiar piece or a section of a favourite piece. Then whatever technical exercises have been assigned, and then whichever portions of pieces should be worked on. Here, it's important to establish the discipline straight away of slow accurate work and of zeroing in on the specific passages that are problematic, rather than just endlessly repeating the whole piece. The teacher should be able to show you how to supervise this initially.

It is interesting how people view practice. My DD started piano and 3, she got to grade 8 and stopped, circumstances as her teacher was ill and had to give up and DD was starting exams and it just sort of stopped. One thing her teacher always said was never refer to practicing, it isn't practicing it is playing and should have the recognition and respect that it is playing music.

I never had an issue with her playing her pieces between lessons. I wonder if there is a psychological element to it.

For the OP I can't see the point of forcing kids to do something like music/sport/dancing if it doesn't interest them. Can't he do something he wants to do?

Outandup · 11/04/2023 09:27

I was forced to learn the piano from ages 9-13 and absolutely hated it. The teacher said I had to practice for an hour a day and it made me loathe it even more. I was also forced to learn ballet for nearly 3 years and disliked it, although not to the same extent as the piano. I really wanted to learn karate like my childminders children did (and I had to go and sit and watch their lessons x2 per week) but my DM said karate wasn’t ‘ladylike.’

My point is if your child persistently dislikes a hobby for a few months + then let them finish it once the payment period has finished. Life is short and would you, as an adult, like to be forced to learn something new when you could potentially choose something for yourself and give it a go? This is what we follow with DS(8).