Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child's piano lesson

103 replies

Wellthatsthatthenisntit · 11/04/2023 00:41

My DCs both do piano lessons. Age 6 and 9. Recently DC9 has begun complaining about going. It is half an hour a week (lesson) and they do two practices of about 10 mins during the week. Been going 18 months.

My view is that this is non-negotiable. It will help with their development, and future choices in life, and both doing very well with it. I gave up a musical instrument when young, which I regret, and parents never pushed me. I realise I am projecting.

For the record I am not pushy in any other way and they happily do swimming, a team sport (winter and summer) and other activities of their choosing. I don't make them do extra schoolwork or anything like that.

Family member thinks I am being horrible. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wellthatsthatthenisntit · 12/04/2023 19:33

WeeOrcadian · 12/04/2023 12:59

Jesus OP, who shit on your cornflakes?

You've asked for advise - you've been given advice. Yet you're just coming back to be a dick. Not everyone will agree with you, stop being so aggressive. Nobody forced you to post here.

No don’t twist things. I thanked people for advice, much of it actually telling me I’m unreasonable - it was you who decided to post snarky comments - and I replied. If you don’t like being stood up to, think before you post.

Again thank you to all who took time to post, I’ve taken all the comments on board. Bowing out now. 💐

OP posts:
WeeOrcadian · 12/04/2023 12:59

Wellthatsthatthenisntit · 12/04/2023 01:30

@MasterBeth So you are now saying I am wrong for listening to the advice that I am in fact unreasonable?

Or are you just upset that I am not crying in the corner after being brutalised on AIBU? Sometimes it can just be a healthy and robust discussion. Wacky I know.

Jesus OP, who shit on your cornflakes?

You've asked for advise - you've been given advice. Yet you're just coming back to be a dick. Not everyone will agree with you, stop being so aggressive. Nobody forced you to post here.

SpringBunnies · 12/04/2023 10:33

Similar to another poster. I got to grade 6 piano when I was young. I don’t see it as giving me any benefit. I play for pleasure now and I find it relaxing but I could have similarly gone for knitting or walking. I assume your life benefit isn’t about a relaxing hobby. Another benefit is I can read music well and was able to help my children with music lessons.

But similar to a PP, I believe it’s more beneficial to play a group instrument. One of mine picked violin and isn’t in any groups yet (lots of violinist around) but it’s her own choice. The other is doing trumpet and only been 6 months. The teacher at school already said she will be in the school orchestra (I assume because there aren’t many brass players).

Also, I encourage my children to play almost every day. The older between 15-20min. Younger is only 5 min. They can play old songs, improvise or listen to what they are learning. It should not be something non negotiable but encouraged.

Nooyoiknooyoik · 12/04/2023 10:31

They need a goal.
My DCs piano school has a concert at the end of each term. Each child learns a short, fun piece to play in public. That definitely motivates practice.

Also, although I never learned piano past preliminary level and they are now on grade 3 and better than me, I sit with them every few days and help them to learn a new bar. They like having someone with them, and then I sit with them again a couple of days later and I expect the bar to be learned.

Neither of them will be musicians, sadly (I would have loved their opportunity but I have to recognise that they are not me). However they do enjoy the challenge of pleasing me and of playing in the concerts and passing the exams. I’ve offered them the chance to stop after grade 3 but they’ve both said they’ll continue.

agriefobserved · 12/04/2023 10:23

**only practicing, I meant to say. The rest of the week I just used my piano as a shelf.

I regret it now! I was quite good until I stopped caring.

agriefobserved · 12/04/2023 10:22

My interest in playing the piano (I had lessons for over a decade) faded when I started practicing for half an hour before my lesson. Sounds like DC9 needs to do more practice so they can feel like they're achieving something, rather than it just being a drag.

I saw a poster talk about the Simply Piano app, give that a go and see if you can get your DC back into it.

EmilyGilmoresSass · 12/04/2023 10:17

Would never force my child to play an instrument she has no interest in. They're unlikely to go far in it if they don't even want to play twice a week. Plenty of us can't play the piano and are still alive to tell the tale. I've no words.

MathsNervous · 12/04/2023 10:13

One of my DC enjoys music residentials so he plays music with other young musicians on those. Again, it's the social elements of playing an instrument which he enjoys and makes him want to continue playing his woodwind instrument.

MasterBeth · 12/04/2023 08:25

Wellthatsthatthenisntit · 12/04/2023 01:30

@MasterBeth So you are now saying I am wrong for listening to the advice that I am in fact unreasonable?

Or are you just upset that I am not crying in the corner after being brutalised on AIBU? Sometimes it can just be a healthy and robust discussion. Wacky I know.

Neither.

I am suggesting that if you only consider the advice of professional committed adult musicians, you are indulging in a kind of success bias. You cannot reverse engineer their experience and assume that repeating their behaviours will give your children the same outcome.

Your children don't enjoy playing the piano. I am suggesting making them play the piano more may not have the outcome you intend.

Muddays · 12/04/2023 06:56

Not exactly sure what you were expecting on this forum. Most MNs have a problem with bullying, that's why they're so good at it. Thank your kids for giving it a go and ask them what they're really interested in. If you force a child to do something they don't want to you will kill any potential love of it. I hated my forced piano lessons, I was too young and clearly not the Mozart prodigy expected. It took me decades to return to something I would have loved if I wasn't forced to.

Wellthatsthatthenisntit · 12/04/2023 01:30

MasterBeth · 11/04/2023 20:26

But there’s every possibility your children won’t be musicians.

Would you think it healthy if a dad who wished he had been a professional footballer was taking advice from elite sports coaches about how to increase the training schedule for his kids, who didn’t like playing football?

@MasterBeth So you are now saying I am wrong for listening to the advice that I am in fact unreasonable?

Or are you just upset that I am not crying in the corner after being brutalised on AIBU? Sometimes it can just be a healthy and robust discussion. Wacky I know.

OP posts:
MyDarlingClementine · 11/04/2023 22:08

How will it enhance life a choices of they want to do something else you won't let them try..
I would make a deal. Get to grade blah and if you hate it drop it.
. There are so many lessons out there for dc to try.

Soproudoflionesses · 11/04/2023 22:04

My mum forced me to do music lessons....l used to cry walking home from school. Taught me absolutely nothing - just that my parents didn't listen to me. Was 40 years ago and l still resent them.

Listen to your child op.

Whatthefnow · 11/04/2023 21:49

I play the piano so does my daughter. I love, love, love playing it. If your children don't have a passion for it there's no point sadly.

melj1213 · 11/04/2023 21:39

Did your children choose to play the piano or did you decide for them? With DD, learning a musical instrument was non negotiable but which one she played was up to her.

I wanted her to play the piano as everyone in my family can play the piano but she hated it and wanted to play a woodwind instrument instead so she chose the flute. If I'd have made her keep playing the piano then she would never have progressed and probably have given up altogether as she didn't hate music, she just hated the piano. Instead, I let her play the flute and she has been playing for 8 years now and still loves it. It also helped that when she complained about the flute (usually because she didn't want to practice) I reminded her that she chose the instrument and she could stop playing it at any time, she just had to tell me which other instrument she wanted to play instead.

DD was born in Spain and she went to school there from the age of 1 until she was 9. I worked at a private school that had a guardería (nursery) for children up to age 3, Infantil (Kindergarten) for children 3-6 and then compulsory school (Primary/Secondary/6th form) from the age of 6-18.

In the guardería and infantil they just introduce instruments and music through play -singing songs and letting the babies bash a xylophone or tambourine to their hearts content, having the toddlers shake a maraca and tap a triangle to the beat of a song etc - to let the children get used to instruments and music.

Once they start Primary they have more structured compulsory music lessons at least once a week and DDs school had every child playing a melodica as it is the perfect instrument for small children to learn the basics on - it's a cheap instrument, they start with a long pipe to blow into so they can put the instrument on the table and look at the keys as they play, and get used to it and as they get more proficient then they can shorten the tube to just a mouthpiece and they play it like a recorder.

Also extra curricular music lessons at the music school in our neighborhood were cheap as it was run by the Ministry of Education so everything was subsidised (I think I paid about €15 a month for DDs weekly class) so when DD started school music lessons I asked her what instrument she wanted to play and signed her up to flute lessons.

MasterBeth · 11/04/2023 20:26

Wellthatsthatthenisntit · 11/04/2023 19:40

ODFOD I know you probably get your kicks out of snarky comments on AIBU and love it when OPs get a kicking but most of the comments that are insightful are from actual musicians or parents of musicians. If you’d bothered to read the bulk of them are telling me I’m unreasonable for not practising enough.

But there’s every possibility your children won’t be musicians.

Would you think it healthy if a dad who wished he had been a professional footballer was taking advice from elite sports coaches about how to increase the training schedule for his kids, who didn’t like playing football?

TMess · 11/04/2023 19:57

I’m a music teacher, and when a child is practicing that little it’s either because they hate it and won’t or because the parent isn’t taking responsibility to make sure it happens. Honestly, when a student comes in routinely with obviously barely any practice done, I’d rather their parents let them quit as it’s difficult for them to progress and I feel a little guilty for taking the money! Either let them quit or help them to learn so they can enjoy it. The fumbly stage is nobody’s favorite; they tend to have much more fun when they’re confident and making steady progress.
fwiw, my 8yo practices 30-45m a day (broken into different time slots) five days a week, but I don’t make him take lessons, they were his choice and we discussed the time commitment before beginning and he’s been happily at it for two years.

Wellthatsthatthenisntit · 11/04/2023 19:40

WeeOrcadian · 11/04/2023 13:27

"Too many helpful comments to mention individually but thanks - I’m again grateful for the insight. Thinking about it now we used to practise more, which I hadn’t really thought about until now."

Read: thanks for the people agreeing with me, it makes me feel like I'm right

ODFOD I know you probably get your kicks out of snarky comments on AIBU and love it when OPs get a kicking but most of the comments that are insightful are from actual musicians or parents of musicians. If you’d bothered to read the bulk of them are telling me I’m unreasonable for not practising enough.

OP posts:
turnthebiglightoff · 11/04/2023 18:35

They definitely won't thank you. Can't remember the last time my clarinet got me a pay rise at work / bought my shopping / parented my child.

Seriously some of these responses 😂

londonmummy1966 · 11/04/2023 15:51

MasterBeth · 11/04/2023 07:54

They will never become proficient musicians with just one instrument and 30 minutes practice a day.

You are their parent. Insist they choose at least one instrument from each of the main orchestral sections (woodwind, brass, strings, percussion) and enforce 45 minutes to an hour of practice every day on each. They will definitely thank you for this in later life.

😂

LakeTiticaca · 11/04/2023 15:27

If they wish to become accomplished musicians ( which they clearly don't!) they need to do more than 10 mins practice a week. Don't force them to go. Someone gave my dad an old piano and my parents decided I should start piano lessons.
The piano teacher was horrible and I used to dread going, my parents were sooo proud and told everyone what a great pianist I was, and made me play for guests, like a performing monkey. I wondered whether my parents were deaf because I was a terrible pianist.
Every week I was told by my parents how expensive the lessons were and how lucky I was to have them.so I just sucked it up and endured years of misery with a horrible nasty female teacher

CheriseNuland · 11/04/2023 15:18

Agree op definitely strongly encourage as long as possible, pushing within reason.

It’s well documented that not learning/ giving up a musical instrument is one of the most common regrets of adults. Surprisingly universal actually.

Encourage them to improvise and make up their own music as well.

mummyoffourminimes · 11/04/2023 15:09

It's definitely unreasonable to force them. Do they prefer a different instrument? Maybe an orchestral one which comes with more social possibilities?

I'm with all the others who've said practise should be daily too. My 7yo started piano in September, she does 15mins daily plus some theory now and her teacher is thrilled with her progress as is the DC!

neslop · 11/04/2023 15:02

I had piano lessons as a child, got to grade 6 and then gave up. Really wish I'd had the chance to choose my own orchestral/band instrument instead, so much more sociable and so many more opportunities than piano. I encouraged my DC to all play at least one instrument of their choice, they persisted throughout school years with levels of enthusiasm waxing and waning and some changing of instruments. Between them they cover piano, saxophone, trumpet, cello and guitar ranging from grades 4 to 8. At the moment none of them (in 20s) are really playing, but the instruments at least get a yearly airing for family Christmas carols/songs, which I absolutely love! And they all have a skill they could resume when older if they wish.

TheRookie · 11/04/2023 15:01

I gave up piano lessons at 11, never gave me fewer chances in life or affected my development!!!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread