Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My Dh bruised my arm during a fight I front of our children

217 replies

OrchidArcade · 10/04/2023 20:24

Obviously it sounds unreasonable written down like that but as any situation is, it feels far more nuanced. It's been a really rainy bank holiday Monday so we stayed in with our two sons all day. They are full on Mummy's boys and don't really have all that much time for their Dad.

After our dinner and a few drinks, I decided I'd get to bed and the boys followed me up wanting to snuggle in the big bed. Of course I let them but dh came up and demanded that he could get in and they had to get to their bed and that he'd compromise by sleeping in their room in the spare bunk. Neither of them wanted to shift so he shouted at me to get out and sleep in their room which set the youngest off crying.

QThey both wanted to follow me but he physically restrained them which I hate. I returned to the big bed and curled up at the foot of the bed saying I wasn't leaving. Our eldest got a nervous fit of the giggles and started giggling which enraged Dh who wrongly assumed I was tickling their feet and shouted at me that I was an interfering bitch and needed to leave the room.
When I refused to leave without boys (feeling they were getting very uncomfortable) he grabbed me by the arm and pushed me of the bed telling me to fuck off and twisting my arm.

Obviously I wasn't leaving the boys at this point so I got back on the bed and told them to follow me and them he pushed me and grabbed me again

I'm now sharing a single bunk with two boys and just saw some pretty impressive bruises on my upper arm. What the fuck!!

OP posts:
Over40Overdating · 12/04/2023 08:44

@OrchidArcade a decent person would be overcome with guilt whether he could remember it or not. He knows what he did - he is telling you he doesn’t care.

The fact you think one nice day - where he insisted you covered your bruises - makes it all worth it means he knows you are going to stay no matter what.
And it’s your children who are paying the price for your decisions.

They are not unscathed. They have already been damaged by watching their mother show them that it doesn’t matter if someone scares or hurts them as long as they are nice afterwards.

If they tell someone at school or a trusted relative, they won’t tell them it’s fine for daddy to hurt you all because mummy says it’s worth it.

Dwrcegin · 12/04/2023 08:18

but they seem relatively unscathed.

Wrong. You need to protect your kids.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 12/04/2023 08:10

How were you kids laughing during those interactions? My kids would have been terrified. You MUST already know that is not acceptable behaviour from your DH...

Fantasmagoricalan · 12/04/2023 08:02

OrchidArcade · 11/04/2023 23:10

It's all okay @Blort. He didn't remember any of it so he found it hard to feel guilty but was obviously embarrassed as he wanted me to put a jumper over the marks when I got a bit hot today. I know it's bad but we had such a gorgeous day as he was so lovely and was obviously trying to make it right without raising the issues. The boys asked why Daddy was bring such an idiot last night but they seem relatively unscathed. I know exactly how it sounds and I'm not naive but to have such a nice day after makesup for it all I'm a fucked up way.

Oh Jesus. 😞

FiledAwayInABox · 12/04/2023 07:46

What happens in the future OP? How do you see this panning out? Are you planning trying to manage every situation in future to minimise the risk of it happening again?
I hope the kids never end up being testing.

4eyesbigthighs · 12/04/2023 07:42

The sun might be shining, but your future is bleak OP.

4eyesbigthighs · 12/04/2023 07:40

So in conclusion. He was so drunk he backs a danger to you and your children? Doesn’t feel guilty, blames that on not remembering?

then to top it off, you’re uncomfortably hot but he likely had demanded you not show anyone else what a abusive piece of shit he is?

you need to watch sleeping with the enemy🥰

hallodarknessmyoldfriend · 12/04/2023 06:16

Of course he was nice to you the day after. He is acting like a textbook abuser. Please, OP, take this seriously for your sake and more importantly for your kids sake. You don't want them to grow up in a household where abuse is normalized.

Can you talk to someone in real life and tell them what happened?

MrsTerryPratchett · 12/04/2023 01:40

He didn't remember any of it so he found it hard to feel guilty

This implies he was either black-out drunk or he does remember and is lying.

If it's the first, and he doesn't want a repeat, and he's actually a good person, I assume he has promised to never drink again. Like, never ever, even a drop. OR he's lying and he does remember.

The shame with the jumper is him not wanting OTHER people to know he's abusive. He's fine with you and your children knowing. And living with it. He doesn't feel bad about that. And you've told him what happened. So he believes you but doesn't feel bad? Sounds bad to me.

You can choose to stay. But I suggest you have a little think about when your boys tell someone at school, or a friend, and social services want to know why you stayed and allowed them to be abused. How will you feel then? Or will they have to lie and hide it too?

Starseeking · 12/04/2023 00:10

OrchidArcade · 11/04/2023 23:10

It's all okay @Blort. He didn't remember any of it so he found it hard to feel guilty but was obviously embarrassed as he wanted me to put a jumper over the marks when I got a bit hot today. I know it's bad but we had such a gorgeous day as he was so lovely and was obviously trying to make it right without raising the issues. The boys asked why Daddy was bring such an idiot last night but they seem relatively unscathed. I know exactly how it sounds and I'm not naive but to have such a nice day after makesup for it all I'm a fucked up way.

He didn't remember yet wanted you to cover up the marks he made Confused

There will be a next time OP, you've just given your H the green light that as long as you have a nice day the next day, he can abuse you however he likes the previous day.

I feel very very sorry for your DC having to witness this situation.

Good luck.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 12/04/2023 00:08

I'm really hoping the OP is not real.... those poor DC Sad

monsteramunch · 11/04/2023 23:20

So no plans to do anything about this OP?

Your poor boys 😞

takealettermsjones · 11/04/2023 23:18

OrchidArcade · 11/04/2023 23:10

It's all okay @Blort. He didn't remember any of it so he found it hard to feel guilty but was obviously embarrassed as he wanted me to put a jumper over the marks when I got a bit hot today. I know it's bad but we had such a gorgeous day as he was so lovely and was obviously trying to make it right without raising the issues. The boys asked why Daddy was bring such an idiot last night but they seem relatively unscathed. I know exactly how it sounds and I'm not naive but to have such a nice day after makesup for it all I'm a fucked up way.

Oh lord. This is textbook.

OrchidArcade · 11/04/2023 23:10

It's all okay @Blort. He didn't remember any of it so he found it hard to feel guilty but was obviously embarrassed as he wanted me to put a jumper over the marks when I got a bit hot today. I know it's bad but we had such a gorgeous day as he was so lovely and was obviously trying to make it right without raising the issues. The boys asked why Daddy was bring such an idiot last night but they seem relatively unscathed. I know exactly how it sounds and I'm not naive but to have such a nice day after makesup for it all I'm a fucked up way.

OP posts:
CheriseNuland · 11/04/2023 15:44

He is clearly abusive.

All of this sounds really unhealthy though tbh.

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 11/04/2023 15:34

Flip that was horrendous enough reading before he injured you.

leave this abusive asshole. Get your stuff in order and get out. This sounds like he’s escalating and he will get dangerous.

Blort · 11/04/2023 15:28

How are you and the kids today @OrchidArcade ?

Nanaof1 · 11/04/2023 10:54

monsteramunch · 10/04/2023 22:15

Explain to us how she has weaponised the kids?

Maybe her loving them and letting them have some snuggle time with her is "weaponizing them to hurt the MFCDH". The fact that the kids didn't move over to make room for daddy and instead were fearful of him is only more proof to me of how he treats his family in general. This was not the first time something like this has happened. The OP needs to stop pretending to be an ostrich and get her head out of the sand.

Nanaof1 · 11/04/2023 10:48

Rosula · 10/04/2023 22:04

Where does OP say he wasn't allowed in his own bed? At the point when OP's husband came to bed, the children didn't want to shift. Any normal parent would work with the other parent to persuade them quietly to move so that they could have a peaceful bedtime, they wouldn't resort immediately to shouting and issuing orders, let alone physical manhandling. It must have been really early anyway given that OP posted at 8.24 pm, so he's hardly likely to have been tired and desperate to sleep.

On the other hand, OP's husband did order her to sleep in the children's room. How is she not allowed in her own bed?

I truly think that there are just "people" out there who would and could think of an excuse for any poor behavior by a man.

"If you were wearing that outfit, you were asking for the wrong type of attention".
"If you had appeased him immediately, he wouldn't have gotten so frustrated that he needed to hit you."

Those people make me as angry as the OP's MFCDH has gotten me.

Nanaof1 · 11/04/2023 10:37

takealettermsjones · 10/04/2023 20:43

"Beyond fuming"? If the kids are snuggling in a bed with their other parent? It's hardly a crime.

If I found my kids in bed with DH and no room for me I would smile because it's cute, agree with DH what time we move them into their own beds (i.e. "ok you can have ten more minutes/until the end of the film" etc) and then leave them to it.

What I wouldn't do is physically and verbally assault my DH and/or terrify my children.

Or everyone scrunches over, the kids can go on the lap or sitting on Mom's/Dad's legs. Unless it was a twin bed, there was room for them all.

I think the MFCDH is jealous that he isn't the center of the universe and this is not the first time he has been abusive. Nor will it be the last time if she stays.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 11/04/2023 10:28

takealettermsjones · 10/04/2023 23:02

You seem desperate for a ruck

Not at all. The amount of reaching you're doing here is astounding, though. You've assumed a lot that isn't there.

They were having a family day - not necessarily. OP just said they stayed in. One of the parents could have been locked away in the bedroom playing FIFA all day for all we know.

DC and OP were excluding the H - eh? Was this written in invisible ink at the end of the post?

OP does not express any sadness/problem with this - so? It's a forum post of limited length. She didn't express much sadness over the bruises on her arm either.

Suggests that she is enjoying excluding DH from family dynamic - hope you had a crash mat for that leap.

H...is relegated to the DCs room - wasn't this his own suggestion?

Of course I let them,' suggests a pattern of the OP using/allowing the DC to push her H away - no, she said of course she let them come in before the husband got there. And plenty of parents let their kids in the bed without some hidden spouse-blocking agenda.

... I could go on, but there's no point. None of this is relevant to the fact that her husband is an abuser. Victim blaming is a very bad look.

This.

However the day went there is never an excuse for violence. It’s doubly disgraceful that this took place in front of his own dc. The above justification for abuse is an absolute fucking disgrace. No wonder domestic violence is so accepted when people will go to any lengths to blame the abused partner and protect the abuser by trying to validate their behaviour with ‘reasons’. There is no good reason to bruise your partner. Ever.

Op you are not safe with this man and neither are your dc. I would call the police right now and make plans to leave. If he thinks this is acceptable he will only get worse.

Nanaof1 · 11/04/2023 10:20

OrchidArcade · 10/04/2023 20:41

I know it sounds naive but I think his feelings were hurt by the usual 'mummys boys' antics and that he was acting out of anger and frustration rather than calculated abuse. Not an excuse obviously but I don't think he's mean to hurt me especially in front of the boys.

That last sentence says it all, "especially in front of the boys".
His behavior is abusive. If you stay with him, you nor your sons are guaranteed to remain safe.

I would bet quite a tidy sum that this isn't the first time he has been abusive towards you, even if it wasn't in front of the children.
Verbal, mental, emotional and physical abuse...each one carries its own damaging life-long effects on you and your children. Whether you think they've seen it before or not, they KNOW. What's more, YOU know.

fUNNYfACE36 · 11/04/2023 10:06

Fantasmagoricalan · 10/04/2023 22:16

Ah that’s ok then, his physical assault on his wife was totally justified. It was even her own fault…

What do the first 2 lines of the post you have quoted say? Do you have difficulty with reading comprehension (genuine question)

monsteramunch · 11/04/2023 09:13

@PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog

If OP had gone out, the DC would have followed and she'd be in the same situation as now without the physical altercation.

Except they wanted to follow but he physically restrained them...

Neither of them wanted to shift so he shouted at me to get out and sleep in their room which set the youngest off crying. They both wanted to follow me but he physically restrained them which I hate.

Why are you making stuff up?

Rosula · 11/04/2023 08:12

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 10/04/2023 22:39

You seem desperate for a ruck but I'll try and explain (again) how the OP reads to me:

It's been a really rainy bank holiday Monday so we stayed in with our two sons all day. They are full on Mummy's boys and don't really have all that much time for their Dad.

They were having a family day, DC and OP were excluding the H. OP does not express any sadness/problem with this. - Suggests that she is enjoying excluding DH from family dynamic.

I decided I'd get to bed and the boys followed me up wanting to snuggle in the big bed. Of course I let them but dh came up and demanded that he could get in and they had to get to their bed and that he'd compromise by sleeping in their room in the spare bunk.

Op decides to go to bed, DC follow her up. Fine. H wants to go to bed, tries to get in his bed, not unreasonable, but is relegated to the DCs room. 'Of course I let them,' suggests a pattern of the OP using/allowing the DC to push her H away.

Neither of them wanted to shift so he shouted at me to get out and sleep in their room which set the youngest off crying. -- Suggests that DC do not have to listen to their father. OP set up the wanting to lie in the 'big bed' so she should move the DCs rather than allowing the Dc to dictate where their father sleeps. If the Op was not creating barriers she should say ' this is daddy's bed too, budge up and we can all cuddle together' or similar.

I returned to the big bed and curled up at the foot of the bed saying I wasn't leaving. --- escalating rather than deescalting. If OP had gone out, the DC would have followed and she'd be in the same situation as now without the physical altercation.

I refused to leave without boys (feeling they were getting very uncomfortable) Escalating again, as above. This also reads like the DC are a rope in tug of war.

There is nothing that suggests OP enjoys excluding her DH from the children.

OP didn't relegate her husband to the children's room, he was the one who suggested that. Letting your children into your bed doesn't amount to pushing their father away, most men in that situation would just get in anyway or would join forces amicably with the mother in taking the children to bed. You've also missed out that it's a little odd that the husband was so keen to go to be before 8 pm.

No wanting to shift doesn't automatically equate to not having to listen to their father. Children the world over regularly don't want to do what their parents ask. I would be more worried if they automatically obey without thought, like robots. It's interesting that your quote "Of course I let them is out of sequence - OP says she let them before their father came up, you put it afterwards, and it makes a substantial difference.

Why can't OP's husband tell the children to budge up for a cuddle together, rather than shouting at them and swearing at OP?

How were the children going to follow OP? Did you not see where the father physically prevented it?

Do you really think that, having been shouted and sworn at, with the children reduced to tears by their father and physically prevented from following, OP should just have left them there?

Your interpretations are very odd.

Swipe left for the next trending thread