Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask whether a child with few clothes is neglected?

244 replies

mosepray · 10/04/2023 20:17

I’ve really been trying to cut down on the numbers of clothes we buy for a few years now and this has left my children (under 10) with 3-4 outfits each per season— obviously way more underwear. I’ve sewn them up smocks/overdresses/pinnies to wear if they’re playing. The expectation is that everything is worn twice and we do a wash once a week.

I remember my grandmother telling me about the flannel dress she wore every day but Sunday when she was 7/8 and it made me think that maybe we don’t need that many clothes.

My friend recently came round and we got onto the topic. She thinks that it’s neglectful to have so few clothes, because I can afford more so why not get more and leave the kids miserable. AIBU to think that’s silly?

OP posts:
LostAtTheCrossRoad · 10/04/2023 22:26

Other than school and sixth form uniform, my two 15 & 17 yo sons have about eight t shirts each, about 6 pairs of trackie bottoms and a pair of jeans, and three hoodies each. Plus season appropriate coats. Both have two pairs of causal trainers, a pair of school shoes, a pair of proper walking boots, and a pair of wellies. It's plenty for them as neither is at all bothered about fashion. Oh and three or four pairs of trackie shorts.

xprincessxjanetx · 10/04/2023 22:26

I'd probably double the amount but I wouldn't say what you're doing is neglectful. As long as the clothes are weather appropriate, fit well and are clean then their basic needs are being met. I do admit I buy far too many clothes for my children but not intentionally. I just always assume they'll need them (even though we do washing every day! - I have 6 children). I may begin to reduce the amounts too now.

ramanw · 10/04/2023 22:26

I wouldn't say it's neglectful but it might be pretty crap for the kids.

My parents barely brought me any clothes so I was constantly wearing the same things. All of my friends had the newest fashion, whereas I was wearing trainers from Lidl's. I was really, really embarrassed. My parents said I didn't need any extra clothing (I mean no, technically I didn't. But I did have the bare minimum).

As a result, I felt inferior to everyone else. I also now have a massive issue with buying clothes and spending money that I don't have on them. It's a desperate need to keep getting more and more clothes. I mean perhaps my case is nothing like what your kids are experiencing but just for thought.

artimesiasfootsteps · 10/04/2023 22:24

My mother was like this. I hated it. I had extremely beautiful clothes for church and ‘going out’ (my family are upper class), but for home, leisure time and school I had a very small and limited wardrobe of tired and unfashionable clothes. In fact in middle school in my year book, the girls making it ‘wrote we all got sick artimesiasfootsteps peddler pusher jeans’ . I was never bullied thankfully and I know the girls that wrote that would be mortified now if they knew how much it upset me. However it was so painfully obvious to everyone I wore the same things constantly. I was lucky and went to a kind little school, but kids are mean. For the love of gosh, buy your kids some clothes, and some ones they won’t look like dorks in.

I’m sure on penny pinching mumsnet everyone will say well done on you, but the truth is, your kids will resent you for it. Show them some kindness and get them some clothes they will feel good about themselves in. You don’t need to be a rampant consumer, but everyone should feel good about themselves and take pride in how they present themselves.

(I’ll add I’m not a big consumer, I wear a lot of second hand and vintage etc, but enjoy buying clothes that make me look chic. You don’t need to break the bank or ruin the environment to look good)

MrsMitford3 · 10/04/2023 22:23

Sorry was meaning to quote @Saschka here but was on the top

MrsMitford3 · 10/04/2023 22:22

FlounderingFruitcake · 10/04/2023 21:37

We went to Bluebird this week and 6YO DD wore joggers and a sweatshirt and had wet hair because she’d just been to swimming lessons round the corner. She’s been there in her ballet uniform too and various other weird get ups. Granted she has far more clothes than OP would necessary but that’s because I hate laundry and her smock lives on her peg at school so sometimes she gets mucky.

This seems such a humble brag

There are clothes between trackies and a suit.

I would never take my DC to a "nice" restaurant in joggers.
It's not different with DD's.

Bibbetybobbity · 10/04/2023 22:21

Nah, the smocks are a bridge too far. I think it’s cruel to wait until your children say they don’t want to wear them- they might not. Children can be amazingly compliant if they realise it’s going to cause a massive fuss (or if they think it will) but that won’t take away their embarrassment. A basic capsule wardrobe is one thing- although I agree with PP it’s pretty joyless- but the smocks are too much.

sladys · 10/04/2023 22:20

mosepray · 10/04/2023 20:26

@DedicatedFollowerOfFashion84 I agree! Everything is clean, always.

I wouldn’t let them go out dirty and everything fits them well, to everyone who’s asking. I just don’t feel we need quite so many clothes as we’ve been told.

You clearly know yours kid aren't neglected so it comes across as a "oooh look at me and my alternative ways, while everyone else is so wasteful"

My only advice would be to be careful about homemade smocks etc as they get older and their peers become more fashion/style aware as you don't want them to be singled out as "different"

NEmama · 10/04/2023 22:18

What if they are sick or spill stuff when not wearing aprons. What if you can't get washing dry. You'd need minimum 10 outfits.

Hedwigharlot · 10/04/2023 22:16

Your 9 year old must be amazingly placid and compliant to wear a smock. My 8 year old daughter wouldn't wear a smock in a million years.

MrsRinaDecker · 10/04/2023 22:16

I think it’s one of those things where if you’re middle class, doing it for environmental reasons, and the clothes are frugi / mini boden and the ilk, then it’ll get a very different reaction to if you live on a council estate, claim benefits, and shop at primark or H&M.
I actually don’t think a capsule type wardrobe is a bad thing when kids are younger, but 3-4 outfits is cutting it a bit fine. There’s a middle ground for sure!

L3ThirtySeven · 10/04/2023 22:13

“I remember my grandmother telling me about the flannel dress she wore every day but Sunday when she was 7/8 and it made me think that maybe we don’t need that many clothes.”

This would be poverty in your nan’s day, but honestly neglect today. Your current level of 3-4 outfits per season is minimalist but not neglect. I wouldn’t be tempted to reduce any more.

Mogginsthemog · 10/04/2023 22:10

I was the same, Earlgrey .
My mother didn't like spending money on clothes. I'm sure i voiced my displeasure at the situation at some point, but the answer was tough.
Unless your dcs are 100% happy with being dressed like an extra from Little House on the Prairie then, yes its neglectful.

Bunnycat101 · 10/04/2023 22:09

“A six yr old is VERY different to 3yr old, they're generally less messy and are in school uniform 5 days out of 7.”

I wish that was true in my house. My 6yo is much messier than my 4yo… I think some children are naturally neat and tidy (my youngest) and some basically look like they’ve been dragged through a hedge backwards however hard you try (my eldest).

EarlGreywithLemon · 10/04/2023 22:08

YunaBalloon · 10/04/2023 22:04

Did you voice your issue to your parents at the time?

I agree that if the child is unhappy then a compromise can be reached. For example my kids choose the fabric pattern of their clothes and whether they want a hood/ collar/ twirly skirt or shorts etc. They also have very distinct different clothes, so you couldn't mistake them wearing the same red t shirt week in week out for example.

No - I assumed they couldn’t afford it so I didn’t want to upset them. I was absolutely indignant later to hear that this wasn’t the reason!

HoarderAMA · 10/04/2023 22:08

I had hardly any clothes growing up and it's contributed to my hoarding tbh.

CloseRunningRiver · 10/04/2023 22:08

When I was junior school age, walking home, a boy I knew asked why I always wore the same clothes, he wasn’t being rude, I didn’t have many clothes but they were always clean. My mother didn’t work, ( my father worked, a reasonably well paid occupation) and there were three children, and I guess she didn’t see the need for more, if they were washed and neat.
I was a bit embarrassed and denied it, but it was true, I didn’t have many clothes.

justanotherdrama · 10/04/2023 22:07

I used to have tonnes of stuff for my eldest to the point where I was getting rid of stuff with tags on!!! I used to buy so much especially in sales where I thought I was getting a bargain!!!

By the time I had my second child (different gender!) I was overwhelmed and said I'd try and control myself a bit more!!!

I tend to have less stuff but the stuff I have is Of much better quality - washes better etc....... I tend to buy from Fruji, next, M&S rather than primark and H&M as I've found it just doesn't wash brilliantly.

I'd struggle on 3-4 outfits tho my daughter especially likes to choose her outfits and I don't think that's unreasonable.

I also sell/ pass on things my 2 have finished with (not underwear and socks!) and try to give it another lease of life.

Boogismyname · 10/04/2023 22:06

ImAvingOops · 10/04/2023 20:31

I don't think it's neglectful, but it does sound joyless. There's a middle ground between having too much and having only the bare essentials!
I can't see you getting away with this for much longer - kids get into fashion, they like developing their own style. What about 'occasion' clothes, like party dresses?

I do agree that lots of kids have way more than they could ever wear and when they are small and need new clothes every couple of months, it makes sense to not have tons of outfits that will be outgrown before they get used sufficiently. But I think you need about 7 or 8 outfits rather than 3 or 4 tbh.

I'd honestly agree with this.

Briallen · 10/04/2023 22:05

It’s fine if they’re happy. My 10 year old would happily wear the same joggers every day if I let him. He doesn’t seem to appreciate that I need to wash them 🙈 daughter lives in comfy leggings and tops. They wear a fraction of their wardrobes really.

YunaBalloon · 10/04/2023 22:04

EarlGreywithLemon · 10/04/2023 21:59

A bit of a different perspective: I was that child who didn’t have many clothes for a number of reasons, one of which being that my father believed children didn’t need that much (or that many things generally). I absolutely hated it. I definitely stood out and longed to be one of the children who always looked nice. It certainly felt neglectful to me. When I was older, and I found out that it was mostly ideology driven and not because my parents couldn’t afford it (although cash was a tight at times) I was absolutely furious with them - and I still am. I felt they put their lofty principles ahead of my well being.
As a result, it’s so important to me that my children are well dressed - nothing overboard, but a reasonable range of nice, good quality clothing and shoes that they like wearing. I do not want them to be the kids who got the pitying looks I did as a child.

Did you voice your issue to your parents at the time?

I agree that if the child is unhappy then a compromise can be reached. For example my kids choose the fabric pattern of their clothes and whether they want a hood/ collar/ twirly skirt or shorts etc. They also have very distinct different clothes, so you couldn't mistake them wearing the same red t shirt week in week out for example.

aSofaNearYou · 10/04/2023 22:03

Not neglectful, but a bit stingy I'd say. Not the end of the world, but I think there's a middle ground between this and tons of clothes - which might allow for a bit of self expression.

Andanotherone01 · 10/04/2023 22:01

Talk of ‘pinnys’ and ‘overdressses’ sounds like Christmas at the workhouse but crack on

Lachimolala · 10/04/2023 21:59

My youngest went through 3 t-shirts today alone 😂 my daughter also loves to change up her outfits. I wouldn’t say they have excessive amounts though, just cheap and cheerful stuff.

If I could get away with much less I definitely would! I’m not disciplined enough with washing what we do have though. It would be a disaster, I don’t think it’s at all neglectful though. Perhaps a bit dull but some kids don’t care about clothes etc.

EarlGreywithLemon · 10/04/2023 21:59

A bit of a different perspective: I was that child who didn’t have many clothes for a number of reasons, one of which being that my father believed children didn’t need that much (or that many things generally). I absolutely hated it. I definitely stood out and longed to be one of the children who always looked nice. It certainly felt neglectful to me. When I was older, and I found out that it was mostly ideology driven and not because my parents couldn’t afford it (although cash was a tight at times) I was absolutely furious with them - and I still am. I felt they put their lofty principles ahead of my well being.
As a result, it’s so important to me that my children are well dressed - nothing overboard, but a reasonable range of nice, good quality clothing and shoes that they like wearing. I do not want them to be the kids who got the pitying looks I did as a child.