Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask whether a child with few clothes is neglected?

244 replies

mosepray · 10/04/2023 20:17

I’ve really been trying to cut down on the numbers of clothes we buy for a few years now and this has left my children (under 10) with 3-4 outfits each per season— obviously way more underwear. I’ve sewn them up smocks/overdresses/pinnies to wear if they’re playing. The expectation is that everything is worn twice and we do a wash once a week.

I remember my grandmother telling me about the flannel dress she wore every day but Sunday when she was 7/8 and it made me think that maybe we don’t need that many clothes.

My friend recently came round and we got onto the topic. She thinks that it’s neglectful to have so few clothes, because I can afford more so why not get more and leave the kids miserable. AIBU to think that’s silly?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 11/04/2023 16:14

Some of your post sounds like some of my experiences.
What I found after having DC is that the issues I felt weren't about the clothes, just the clothes were an outward expression of other inconsistent attitudes/values.

With our DC, we've chosen deliberately to shop second hand, I buy second hand for myself and we try to be environmentally conscious when we can. We try to strike the balance between being conscious and intentional in our consumption and giving DCs the freedom to learn and express themselves.

Whilst DC have more clothes than I'd like them to have, I can't get too bogged down in it whilst most of their stuff is second hand. They can express their preferences and know I'd rather buy them one item new that they really like and will wear lots than what my DPs did with me and the focus was on whatever was on sale/cheap at the time.

Turfwars · 11/04/2023 15:57

I was that kid who's mum didn't think that kids 'needed' nice clothes. And yeah, we didn't 'need' them but it was bloody excruciating wearing my older cousin's hand-me-downs that were decades old and had already gone through my sister before me. I had no friends because I was that weirdo kid.

It also fed into very low self esteem when your parents don't even think that for a big occasion in your childhood you deserve so much as a new pair of socks. I was in my teens before I had a single item of clothing that was new. And that's because I bought it myself!

DM always acts so surprised that I present myself nicely these days "because you was always so scruffy, Turf" eh, you fucking dressed me Mum! Hmm

Anyway, there's a balance between going on spending sprees, and being insanely frugal to the point of affecting your kids - as long as you hit that balance, and pay attention to how the kids feel, crack on.

I'm pretty frugal myself, I buy carefully and ensure what I buy is well cared for and lasts. There's things in my wardrobe over 25 years old and still going strong. But for DS, I ensure he's got the clothes he needs and that he loosely fits in with his peers. Ironically, he is totally happy to gad about in rags, but as long as I ensure he's got the choices to dress better when he wants, I've done my bit.

Lovelyring · 11/04/2023 15:03

Oblomov23 · 11/04/2023 06:57

@HappyValet :

"How do they keep them clean? My children seem to smother themselves in food, pens, mud, just general dirt, and the youngest (in nappies) is constantly dribbling, snotting, pooping all over things... We can't get more than a day out of clothes. "

My 2 are older now, but I don't remember mine being that dirty generally. My kids rarely got dirty. If they were out in the garden in mud they had wellies and coats on. At nursery they had plastic apron for paintwork etc. I just don't remember everyone being permanently dirty.

Very child dependent isn't it. My baby could have worn the same babygrow for a week as they weren't dribbly, rarely spat-uo or vomited, and only ever had about five poo disasters.

My friend's baby was the opposite of this and got dribble, puke or poo on the babygrow so often I think it was a good day if you they were only changed three times!

verdantverdure · 11/04/2023 13:06

I don't even think this is that unusual.

If you take work clothes out of the equation, my husband has two pairs of jeans and two pairs of shorts.

He has two weeks worth of boxers, t shirts/polo shirts and socks though because he travels for work.

And swimwear, sports kit and some scruffy stuff for gardening and decorating etc.

LolaSmiles · 11/04/2023 12:22

PlinkPlonkFizz
You're projecting your own issues there.

The outlook of a family who make a conscious choice to live with less, whatever their reasons, is going to be different to a family who cannot have more due to their financial circumstances and poverty.

It's similar to why, for example, middle class parents or those who are comfortable financially, probably don't feel awkward about second hand clothes, hand me downs and charity shops, whereas those people who view second hand as a sign you can't afford new are going to strive to give their children lots of new clothes.

PlinkPlonkFizz · 11/04/2023 09:36

It's extremely rigid thinking that is more than likely going to effect them when they get older. I grew up in poverty and have MH issues from this, including being bullied at school for my clothes. I think you should save your approach for yourself and take more joy in having nicely dressed children who can express themselves in their outfit choices (without being wasteful) each day. It seems cruel and harsh to me.

Lovetotravel123 · 11/04/2023 09:25

What you are doing is fine. My son generally wears the same few outfits through choice and it’s much better for the environment. As long as they are clean then I don’t see a problem.

2reefsin30knots · 11/04/2023 09:21

My DS12 only has about 5 items of clothing in total he is happy to wear (2 bottoms, 2 tee-shirts and a coat). I buy him other stuff, he won't put it on if it doesn't feel exactly right, so I've given up buying to some extent.

I'm kicking myself because he found a Next tee-shirt he loves in the sale at Christmas. I should have gone back and bought them all! I've ordered another Next tee-shirt online that looked the same- nope, not right.

I just have to keep the things he will wear clean- which is also wasteful, just in a different way.

racquel86 · 11/04/2023 09:18

If it works for you and your children it works and is fine! My 17month old barely has any new clothes or toys, they're all hand me downs.... is that neglectful? No xxx

WishIwasElsa · 11/04/2023 09:16

I don't think it's neglectful however I have 2 dc's under 10 and I think I would struggle with so few clothes for them. I try to get things worn twice but more often than not they got something on it after day 1 so it needs washing. However that's me and if it works for you then it is all good.

Zola1 · 11/04/2023 09:12

Also my 13 year old is clothes obsessed and literally would spend thousands on her wardrobe if she could. And she needs designer this and that to keep up with her friends.
Littlest is an actual pig in a dress, she gets changed at least once a day.
Middle two, ones always covered in mud from football and one is always covered in cheesy wotsit crumbs.
Mine definitely need more than 3 outfits. I'd say the boys have less as theirs are more expensive, tracksuits etc.

Zola1 · 11/04/2023 09:09

I don't think its neglectful, kids need clean and well fitting clothes that are suitable for the weather and season. They don't need millions of outfits. They do need their clothes to not be worn, stained or damaged.
In relation to the smocks..please stop for your 9 year old soon, you don't want her to become that weird kid as she approaches upper primary and high school.

Lovelyring · 11/04/2023 09:06

I think it's fantastic and we should all be doing this.

I read that most adults only need 20 outfits and shouldn't be buying more than five items a year, and that was a generous estimate. For an adult.

We were given loads of clothes second hand which was kind but there is so much tbh it's stressful and overwhelming. I should have been more selective!

Greenfairydust · 11/04/2023 08:28

Neglect would be if they had dirty clothes and clothes/shoes that were not weather-appropriate.

But I think you are also being a bit unreasonable.

If money is tight you can easily find clothes in charity shops/places like Primark for a few pounds.

This is going to become an issue when your kids start their teens and won't want to go around wearing handmade ''smocks''.

User1794537 · 11/04/2023 07:44

Children started having loads of clothes when the Next sales became popular and people would queue and then buy bags and bags of stuff for the DC, before this people didn't really bother. Primark also became quite popular around this time which meant more opportunity to buy loads of cheap stuff. DS was born in 1992 when all this was going on and yes, I did queue in the Next sale and bought lots of unnecessary clothes. We need to go back to the old days with clothes, I'm sure it was less stressful.

Fandabedodgy · 11/04/2023 07:42

If they are decent and clean then it's not neglectful at all.

Equalitea · 11/04/2023 07:41

My children have always had so many clothes but in all honestly even now in their later teen years they tend to choose to wear the same favourite outfits, perhaps not 3-4, more 6-7 though.

I don’t think I’d have managed on so few outfits, even through secondary school my children would have a spillage and need to change their clothes some days. I wouldn’t have been able to launder the clothes quick enough!

Children can be quite cruel and I was always conscious that my children didn’t wear the same clothes for parties/non school uniform days etc.

User1794537 · 11/04/2023 07:36

It's only recently that people have had as many clothes as they do now, up until about the 80/90s most people had a few everyday outfits and usually one for best

LolaSmiles · 11/04/2023 07:34

3 might be too few for me because I'd want some float in case I didn't get a loaf of washing on or they got really muddy in the garden, but on the whole I agree with you on principle. As long as the clothes are weather appropriate and they fit, they don't need to have several dozen options.

There's no reason for children to have the number of clothes they have. Mine have too many and I'm consciously aiming to reduce what they have.

User1794537 · 11/04/2023 07:31

Sounds very sensible to me, many people have far too many clothes including myself.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 11/04/2023 07:30

Sounds fine.
We grew up with 3 of most things - 1 on, 1 in wash, 1 spare. Plus a party dress and a few school clothes. We always had clean clothes.

borntobequiet · 11/04/2023 07:15

Sounds reasonable to me, but I brought my kids up in the 1980s with little money. I’m rather horrified at the number of unnecessary clothes my DGC seem to have and the endless washing and drying that goes on. I had neither the appliances nor the time. Despite this, my children looked tidy, clean and reasonably well dressed - and they still look after their clothes.

Doingmybest12 · 11/04/2023 07:13

For me it is more about what you are saying and the messages your children are receiving than what they've got. Hopefully it isn't too much of a big deal for anyone and not part of a day in day out awareness and talk about ethical living that might make them worry or feel different to their peers. I hope they've got something fun that they like to wear because it makes them feel nice and they've made a choice etc. Other than that you must be very organised to run such a tight ship and hopefully this is also in a balanced way too.

Oblomov23 · 11/04/2023 06:57

@HappyValet :

"How do they keep them clean? My children seem to smother themselves in food, pens, mud, just general dirt, and the youngest (in nappies) is constantly dribbling, snotting, pooping all over things... We can't get more than a day out of clothes. "

My 2 are older now, but I don't remember mine being that dirty generally. My kids rarely got dirty. If they were out in the garden in mud they had wellies and coats on. At nursery they had plastic apron for paintwork etc. I just don't remember everyone being permanently dirty.

Oblomov23 · 11/04/2023 06:52

Shocked at all these responses. Most kids I know, even teens, have a few favourite things they like and could get by on very little. Even I wear the same few things week on week. Neglect? Oh purlease.