Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask whether a child with few clothes is neglected?

244 replies

mosepray · 10/04/2023 20:17

I’ve really been trying to cut down on the numbers of clothes we buy for a few years now and this has left my children (under 10) with 3-4 outfits each per season— obviously way more underwear. I’ve sewn them up smocks/overdresses/pinnies to wear if they’re playing. The expectation is that everything is worn twice and we do a wash once a week.

I remember my grandmother telling me about the flannel dress she wore every day but Sunday when she was 7/8 and it made me think that maybe we don’t need that many clothes.

My friend recently came round and we got onto the topic. She thinks that it’s neglectful to have so few clothes, because I can afford more so why not get more and leave the kids miserable. AIBU to think that’s silly?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 14/04/2023 14:20

Meandfour
We're the same.
Maybe my DC are wild but lots of their play clothes are very definitely play clothes. I'd not taken them out somewhere nice in them.

Our nice place clothes are the same clothes as the play clothes, but not stained. If they get marked they become day to day clothes and we'll replace the nice sets.

Meandfour · 14/04/2023 07:14

Equalitea · 14/04/2023 06:07

I can’t imagine taking my children into the city/to theatre/nice meal in their playing out clothes. I agree we don’t dress up but we do like to look smarter than we would for playing on the local park.

Thank you, this is what I meant.

Ilovecleaning · 14/04/2023 07:08

I don’t know how you keep up with the washing. What about spillages, accidents and other mishaps? I have 2 grandchildren under 5 and their parents buy a lot of their clothes from Vinted and other ‘pre-loved’ sites. Amazing bargains and beautiful clothes. Buy second hand. 😊

Equalitea · 14/04/2023 06:07

TrueScrumptious · 13/04/2023 19:03

You don’t dress up for the theatre, though. You go in normal clothes.

I can’t imagine taking my children into the city/to theatre/nice meal in their playing out clothes. I agree we don’t dress up but we do like to look smarter than we would for playing on the local park.

Meandfour · 13/04/2023 22:37

YunaBalloon · 13/04/2023 19:09

What would you consider smarter clothes? For boys particularly?

But no. They wear their normal clothes for the things you mentioned, we pretty much only go to "nice restaurants" (I reserve meals out for things I'll actually enjoy unless it can't be helped). For parties they more often wear the less smart "play wear" as parties tend to be activities where they get messy.

My boys wear jeans / chino shorts & polos if we’re going for a nice dinner or going out for the evening.
On holiday they have smarter shorts & tops for the evenings than the basic tees and jersey shorts they wear during the day.

When you said they only had 2/3 outfits, and there are 7 days in a week, I took from it that they must get worn quite frequently and would be more likely to be jogger / jersey style shorts and plain tees.
The same 2/3 outfits to wear throughout the 7 weeks school holidays to play out in, go to parties in, wear on holiday and wear for dinner seems abit much to me.

Meandfour · 13/04/2023 22:33

TrueScrumptious · 13/04/2023 19:03

You don’t dress up for the theatre, though. You go in normal clothes.

I didn’t say dress up. I said dress smarter than a pair of jogging bottoms or shorts and a tshirt.

mrsbitaly · 13/04/2023 19:23

I definitely wouldn't say its neglectful but my 10 year old daughter probably would say it was 😂

If you are in a position to buy more I would it doesn't have to be brand new.

YunaBalloon · 13/04/2023 19:09

Meandfour · 13/04/2023 18:26

So the same 2/3 outfits on a week long or fortnight holiday on rotation?
Fair enough shorts and tshirt for a normal meal out but don’t you go to nice restaurants where they dress a bit smarter? Or to parties, concerts, theatre etc?

What would you consider smarter clothes? For boys particularly?

But no. They wear their normal clothes for the things you mentioned, we pretty much only go to "nice restaurants" (I reserve meals out for things I'll actually enjoy unless it can't be helped). For parties they more often wear the less smart "play wear" as parties tend to be activities where they get messy.

TrueScrumptious · 13/04/2023 19:03

Meandfour · 13/04/2023 18:26

So the same 2/3 outfits on a week long or fortnight holiday on rotation?
Fair enough shorts and tshirt for a normal meal out but don’t you go to nice restaurants where they dress a bit smarter? Or to parties, concerts, theatre etc?

You don’t dress up for the theatre, though. You go in normal clothes.

Meandfour · 13/04/2023 18:26

YunaBalloon · 13/04/2023 18:22

We go out to eat quite frequently and my kids just wear shorts and t shirt or joggers and t shirt and jumper, depending on the weather. The only time they've had need for smart clothes was once at a wedding where they were bridesmaid and page boy so had quite specific outfits.

"Evenings on holiday" would be shorts and t shirt, though we only really holiday in the UK it's mainly they're often better wrapped up than that!

So the same 2/3 outfits on a week long or fortnight holiday on rotation?
Fair enough shorts and tshirt for a normal meal out but don’t you go to nice restaurants where they dress a bit smarter? Or to parties, concerts, theatre etc?

YunaBalloon · 13/04/2023 18:22

Meandfour · 13/04/2023 17:46

What about when you go out for dinner or when you go out for the evening on holiday?

We go out to eat quite frequently and my kids just wear shorts and t shirt or joggers and t shirt and jumper, depending on the weather. The only time they've had need for smart clothes was once at a wedding where they were bridesmaid and page boy so had quite specific outfits.

"Evenings on holiday" would be shorts and t shirt, though we only really holiday in the UK it's mainly they're often better wrapped up than that!

Meandfour · 13/04/2023 17:46

Knackeredandalsotired · 12/04/2023 07:18

Christ, my DC only have 2-3 casual outfits each and I’ve never even considered they might be neglected. They are boys though, and PP suggested that might make a difference?

They just aren’t v interested in clothes and it hasn’t affected their friendships. Parties are generally activity ones so yes, same trackie bottoms t-shirts and hoody get worn for all. And I’ll buy smart if necessary but other than grannie’s funeral, I can’t actually think of when I’ve needed to.

Is this really such an unusual approach??

What about when you go out for dinner or when you go out for the evening on holiday?

Babycakes6 · 13/04/2023 16:45

I know a mum like you and even my DD noticed her DD always wears the same clothes. Kids gossip about her child always wearing the same clothes.

UnbeatenMum · 12/04/2023 08:31

Although I don't personally think it's neglectful I do think if SS had concerns about a family they would probably add this to the list. Not necessarily a concern on its own but part of a picture, building a case. I just say this in case anyone with a child on a CIN or CP plan is reading and thinking oh it's fine. As part of an eco friendly lifestyle with no other concerns I doubt anyone would worry.
My adopted son's court documents listed things that were obviously unsafe for him alongside things that were more of a grey area and wouldn't have caused him to be removed on their own.

Knackeredandalsotired · 12/04/2023 07:38

Well, I need work clothes, but do indeed only have 2pairs of jeans. More casual tops than the boys, admittedly, but I go to a wider range of activities and have built up my clothes over many years. I buy fewer than 3 outfits per year…

We just don’t enjoy clothes shopping and are fine with wearing the same thing repeatedly.

And yes, we are always clean!

Aprilx · 12/04/2023 07:30

Knackeredandalsotired · 12/04/2023 07:18

Christ, my DC only have 2-3 casual outfits each and I’ve never even considered they might be neglected. They are boys though, and PP suggested that might make a difference?

They just aren’t v interested in clothes and it hasn’t affected their friendships. Parties are generally activity ones so yes, same trackie bottoms t-shirts and hoody get worn for all. And I’ll buy smart if necessary but other than grannie’s funeral, I can’t actually think of when I’ve needed to.

Is this really such an unusual approach??

Of course it is unusual. Do you only have three outfits? I bet none of the parents on here boasting (in that competitive under-eating sense) that their children only require three outfits, only have that themselves. My parents not properly clothing me, is one of the many reasons I resented them later in life.

Knackeredandalsotired · 12/04/2023 07:18

Christ, my DC only have 2-3 casual outfits each and I’ve never even considered they might be neglected. They are boys though, and PP suggested that might make a difference?

They just aren’t v interested in clothes and it hasn’t affected their friendships. Parties are generally activity ones so yes, same trackie bottoms t-shirts and hoody get worn for all. And I’ll buy smart if necessary but other than grannie’s funeral, I can’t actually think of when I’ve needed to.

Is this really such an unusual approach??

Equalitea · 12/04/2023 05:27

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 11/04/2023 16:43

There is no way I would want my children to only have 3 outfits. Mainly because I don’t want to be forced to do washing every week if we have plans or other jobs that need doing. My DD2 is currently leaking through seemingly every nappy so needs a clean outfit (leggings and vest at least) daily. We’ve tried multiple nappy brands and change her regularly. I’d be washing every day with only 3 outfits.

My 9yo DD would not be happy to wear smocks and pinnies. She likes choosing her outfit and wearing nice things.

Also, be mindful as your kids get older that their clothes don’t smell (body odor, farts, cheesy feet…) before they look dirty. Having taught 9-10yo children, their clothes often smell because the child was clean but their clothes aren’t. Their parents often don’t notice because they are used to the smell.

Very true, it’s something I’ve noticed too damp/clean hair from the shower but still smell, likely from the clothes.

ParistoMilan · 11/04/2023 21:51

Do they not do any hobbies? Brownies uniform, football/ hockey/ rugby/ netball kit? For any kids that play sports by 9/10 year old that's no where near enough. Creating smocks is actually less eco friendly than either buying second hand or buying well for the first child and passing down. I genuinely don't understand why you couldn't just have second hand/ old/ stained stuff as clothes in the situations where you would use the smocks.

I agree with thinking about how many clothes children need but 3 sets isn't enough. What if they have a water fight/ fall in a river/ a puddle/ chuck spag bol down themselves/ spill paint/ have a nose bleed. That is then instantly 2 sets a day.

PlinkPlonkFizz · 11/04/2023 21:39

LolaSmiles · 11/04/2023 12:22

PlinkPlonkFizz
You're projecting your own issues there.

The outlook of a family who make a conscious choice to live with less, whatever their reasons, is going to be different to a family who cannot have more due to their financial circumstances and poverty.

It's similar to why, for example, middle class parents or those who are comfortable financially, probably don't feel awkward about second hand clothes, hand me downs and charity shops, whereas those people who view second hand as a sign you can't afford new are going to strive to give their children lots of new clothes.

You could be correct @LolaSmiles but I don't think the reason for not having many (or odd) clothes actually matters when it comes to the impact on a child?

Whether it's poverty an ecological reason or something else, the children probably will be affected in some way. It's interesting that nearly all the people commenting on this thread (whose parents for whatever reason gave them limited access to clothes) say it negatively hit their MH, self-esteem or self-worth.

I think poverty has other effects on a child (perhaps increased sensitivity and less resilience than a MC child?) but dressing children (age 9 - awful 😞) in smocks, and having such limited clothing choices, is a severe parenting approach that is likely to have negative consequences. I hope I'm wrong for the children's sake.

CornedBeef451 · 11/04/2023 20:00

I think that's fine if it works for you. DS is growing really quickly so I'm finding it hard to keep up. He usually has 4 pairs of joggers and around 7 t shirts that fit at any one time and I wash twice a week.

DD has more but mostly because she is growing slowly so her things last much longer.

I don't think kids need many clothes, as long as they have enough to wear between washes then it's fine. Most kids really don't care what they wear anyway, although yours might want more choose as they get older.

wellhi · 11/04/2023 19:42

Sounds very eco to me, I applaud it.

Anyway, 4 outfits per season is plenty. I think most people (kids and adults) have way too many clothes.

Definitely not a marker for neglect.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 11/04/2023 16:43

There is no way I would want my children to only have 3 outfits. Mainly because I don’t want to be forced to do washing every week if we have plans or other jobs that need doing. My DD2 is currently leaking through seemingly every nappy so needs a clean outfit (leggings and vest at least) daily. We’ve tried multiple nappy brands and change her regularly. I’d be washing every day with only 3 outfits.

My 9yo DD would not be happy to wear smocks and pinnies. She likes choosing her outfit and wearing nice things.

Also, be mindful as your kids get older that their clothes don’t smell (body odor, farts, cheesy feet…) before they look dirty. Having taught 9-10yo children, their clothes often smell because the child was clean but their clothes aren’t. Their parents often don’t notice because they are used to the smell.

2bazookas · 11/04/2023 16:42

Good for you.
My grandchildren don't have masses of clothes, and quite a number are secondhand; their parents (very high earning) social circle do a lot of sharing and passing on.

Your friend is nuts. Ask her what steps she is taking to reduce consumption and waste and make the future greener and better for her children?

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 11/04/2023 16:30

DedicatedFollowerOfFashion84 · 10/04/2023 20:23

Are the clothes they own weather appropriate, fit well and clean? If the answer to those is yes, then it’s absolutely fine. Children don’t need half the amount of clothes most people seem to think they do. It’s completely wasteful and I much prefer your approach. Good for the environment and teaches them from a young age that their worth doesn’t come from their appearance or clothing

Absolutely agree with this.