Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sad over historical deaths?

335 replies

Personyouneedisnannymcphee · 10/04/2023 18:35

Obviously death happens every day and there are many recent, very sad deaths. But some historical ones actually make me ache a little when I think about them I think due to the details and historical background of them more so than sometimes things I hear on the news. Some of these being:

-the Romanov children. Of course the Tsar was horrific but how they died thinking they were going to safety and then didn’t get killed by bullets as jewels in their clothes protected them so they were finished with bayonets.

-Anne Boylyn’s death because the details of her ladies not letting the men touch her afterwards for fears they’d violate her headless body.

AIBU for sometimes being incredibly sad over these people I never knew or do you have your own historical death that makes your stomach drop when you think of it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Boogismyname · 11/04/2023 09:39

Emotionalsupportviper · 11/04/2023 07:56

I hope this doesn't sound facile, but this reminded me of a death that always breaks my heart when I think of it.

That of little Laika - the first dog in space.

She was a stray - picked for her size and placid nature, then comparatively cosseted and trained and accustomed to the tiny capsule she would be restrained in.

She was blasted into space. There was never any intention to try to bring her back - they knew that wasn't possible. They wanted to know if it could be done, and how long she would last.

She died when the cabin she was in overheated because the thermal insulation was damaged. Estimates vary - some claims are that she survived about 4 days - others that she only lived about seven hours. However long it was , it was time spent in terror, and loneliness and she suffered a horrible painful death, cooked alive in space.

We have no right to subject animals to such horror to satisfy our own curiosity and national vanity. It's just bliddy cruel!

Yes that's barbaric. Absolutely disgusting.

LakieLady · 11/04/2023 09:35

Escapefromhell · 10/04/2023 23:29

Wilfred Owen

Dora Carrington

Virginia Woolfe

The women buried in Crossbones graveyard.

Virginia Woolf for me, too.

I think it's partly because it happened near where I live, and I've walked pretty much the length of the stretch of river between my house and the coast, so must have walked past the spot where she went into the river on more than one occasion.

But also because I've loved her books since my late teens, and she had such massive talent and we'll never know how great her late work might have been, and because her struggles with her mental health were so severe.

I also get a pang of sadness when I drive past Shoreham airport since the awful air crash. When I stop at the traffic lights (which I invariably have to, they're never green) I think how terrifying it must have been for anyone who was in the traffic and realised that that plane was going to come down on them, and how shocking it must have been to witness it.

A former colleague was at the air show that day, and saw it happen, but from a distance and it really affected her. It must have been beyond awful for the people who were nearer.

SaySomethingMan · 11/04/2023 09:33

ThefourseasonsFrankie · 11/04/2023 06:03

Emmitt Till

A display of pure human evil. Poor kid.
I think they shared the identity of the old woman on Twitter recently.
I didn’t get the point as it’s not going to bring him back.

There’s no way I will be able to watch the film ´Till’

beguilingeyes · 11/04/2023 09:33

Squirrelsnut · 11/04/2023 09:23

I agree about Jack the Ripper's victims, and the way he's become some sick folk hero. Those women were real, complex human beings just like us and they were butchered because they were poor and vulnerable.

This. The constant walking tours around Whitechapel are horrible.
Would they do the same for the Yorkshire Ripper?

beguilingeyes · 11/04/2023 09:31

I'd never heard of Junko Furuta.. What a horrible, horrible thing. There was also that Indian girl who was gang-raped on a bus and died from what they did to her.
Aberfan haunts me. The fact that if it had happened an hour earlier or a day later no-one would have died. Hillsborough also. The lies by the media (The Sun) and the police trying to blame the Liverpool supporters.

Historically, Llewelyn ap Gruffydd. The last Prince of Wales. Poor Wales.

HikingforScenery · 11/04/2023 09:24

I get terribly sad when I think of all the people who were murdered just because of how they look.
If I listen to Nina Simone’s ´strange fruit’, I’m left disturbed for days

Squirrelsnut · 11/04/2023 09:23

I agree about Jack the Ripper's victims, and the way he's become some sick folk hero. Those women were real, complex human beings just like us and they were butchered because they were poor and vulnerable.

aSofaNearYou · 11/04/2023 09:16

Agreed. I think, Disney is responsible for romanticising Romanovs family.
OP have you heard of the Khodynka tragedy? Nicholas couldn’t care less and still attended the ball that same day. I find those deaths devastating.

I don't think anyone would find it particularly tragic if it was just Nicholas that was executed - the tragedy is that it was the whole family including the children.

I don't think privilege stops deaths like the Romanov's or Anne Boleyn being horrific. Personally, execution is just a particularly appalling death to think about. Imagining what those people must have gone through mentally in the run up. It horrifies me to think about more than other tragedies.

Derek Bentley is another sad one.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/04/2023 09:15

Brace yourself @SparkyBlue it is extraordinary and moving and shocking. Brace yourself.

TheNoodlesIncident · 11/04/2023 09:10

Freepo · 10/04/2023 22:02

I am really into mountaineering and get really upset about George Mallory and Sandy Irvine’s deaths. High altitude mountaineering is obviously really dangerous and lots of people have died doing it, but those two deaths in the 1920s really affect me, moreso than more modern tragedies.

I used to pass the house he had lived in and always welled up at this on the gate...

Sad over historical deaths?
chouxfleur · 11/04/2023 09:06

I often pass a house with a blue plaque commemorating the place where Eleanor Marx lived and died, and spare a sad thought for her. She was the daughter of Karl Marx and, in her own right, a writer and a tireless activist for women's rights and workers' rights.

For some reason she fell in love with, and had a 15 year relationship with, a horrid little man called Edward Aveling, who was spendthrift, argumentative and a drunkard. A classic cocklodger, Eleanor paid off his countless debts, paid for him to recouperate by the seaside when he was ill, and forgave his many infidelities, including discovering him in her bed with two prostitutes.

Edward always refused to marry her, (no doubt saying 'it's only a piece of paper - I don't need one to prove my commitment to you') but their relationship continued nevertheless. Until one day Eleanor discovered that he had been having an ongoing relationship with a woman in her 20s and had, in fact, secretly married this OW.

A few days later Eleanor killed herself by consuming rat poison. She was 43.

Aaargh! So sad that such an amazing woman was brought down by a horrid little man. If only she had LTB!!

RosaMoline · 11/04/2023 09:03

Some more:

Princess Mishaal & her boyfriend
Lisa Steinberg
Nixzmary Brown
Sylvia Likens

Kendodd · 11/04/2023 09:02

ToriLynn · 10/04/2023 20:25

Jane Grey 😢 she was used as a child by the people who should have protected her because they wanted power, but she was to pay the price for their greed.

This painting chills me. It shows her being compliant and doing as she's told, reaching for the block, even in her execution. It's in the National Gallery and worth visiting to see that alone.

https://www.nationalgallery.org.uk/paintings/paul-delaroche-the-execution-of-lady-jane-grey

Paul Delaroche | The Execution of Lady Jane Grey | NG1909 | National Gallery, London

Paul Delaroche, The Execution of Lady Jane Grey, 1833. Read about this painting, learn the key facts and zoom in to discover more.

https://www.nationalgallery.org.uk/paintings/paul-delaroche-the-execution-of-lady-jane-grey

Brunts12 · 11/04/2023 09:01

6namechang3 · 10/04/2023 18:46

I think the Romanov children and Anne Boleyn had incredibly privileged lives compared to contemporary peasants. Children would regularly starve to death in both tudor England or czarist Russia. I think we feel a connection because we know their personal stories rather their circumstances being particularly horrific.

Agreed. I think, Disney is responsible for romanticising Romanovs family.
OP have you heard of the Khodynka tragedy? Nicholas couldn’t care less and still attended the ball that same day. I find those deaths devastating.

Huskar Pit disaster, where 26 children aged 7 to 17 died while working, absolutely breaks my heart.

Kolakalia · 11/04/2023 08:59

Speedweed · 10/04/2023 18:50

Yes - I remember feeling so sad about Marilyn Monroe and James Dean. Such a waste.

Also a music group called Viola Beach a few years ago, all killed in a gruesome car crash when so young with all that potential just their career was taking off.

Once I became a mother I grieved again for cases like James Bulger too.

The one consolation for me with Viola Beach is that they wouldn't have really known. They were killed instantly, so other than a split second of 'wtf' when the car went into the air, that was it.

I often think about John Cantlie. It's been ten years since he was kidnapped in Syria, he was tortured, held captive, saw his cellmates be executed, went through mock executions, and eventually was forced into advocating for the ISIS regime on camera by producing media for them. He was stick and bones and hopefully he knew nobody would actually believe he thought the things he was saying, he was saying them for his own survival. To this day nobody knows where he is, he was almost certainly killed at some point but his final years were horrific.

And the men who were executed on camera with a knife. James Foley. Alan Henning.

I also think of the Jordanian pilot who was set alight in a cage. Against my better judgment I watched that video and his strength to the final moments was unbelievable.

purpledalmation · 11/04/2023 08:58

I agree lady Jane grey was especially sad and tragic.

awaynboilyurheid · 11/04/2023 08:54

oachkatzl · 11/04/2023 08:12

Anne Frank really gets me. All that time hidden in the attic before being caught and then dying just a few weeks before liberation.

Me too, I went to where she and her family were hidden when we were in Amsterdam, I knew it would be sad but I could have went in a corner and wept.
Her dad had pinned a map to show how the allies were advancing and winning he must have heard or listened to the radio at night they must have had hope that help was coming.
Then I saw the detailed map by the Nazis and that was someone’s actual job, that showed every single Jewish family in Amsterdam, they were making sure they got every single one.
I sobbed all the way round it was horrific I could never go to a concentration camp I would be howling.

thatgingergirl · 11/04/2023 08:53

Jan Palach - such a shocking death. I was just in my teens and starting to take an interest in the world and politics. I still have his poem that I copied out at the time tucked in a drawer.

CaptainCallisto · 11/04/2023 08:52

The sinking of the Empress of Ireland always breaks my heart. It sank in the St Lawrence River in Canada in 1914, after being hit by another ship in fog, and 1,012 people died. It went down very quickly and the water was freezing, so nobody had a chance. But hardly anybody has heard of it because it happened just before WW1 broke out. To make it worse, I think it's 12 people who have since died diving the wreck.

I'm also really saddened by the men who died on the Mary Rose. Just the thought of those men on the deck, trapped by the netting they'd put over the deck to deter boarders, knowing the ship was going down...awful.

SparkyBlue · 11/04/2023 08:49

BitOutOfPractice · 11/04/2023 08:15

I have read the Wolf Hall books about Thomas Cromwell three times. And seen the RSC production. Every time I have sobbed at his death. (Sorry for the spoiler).

I am just coming up to that part now.

ThefourseasonsFrankie · 11/04/2023 08:48

Holocaust, transatlantic slavery (all these people in sheer terror at what was happening to them and some being thrown overboard to their watery deaths eg Armistad.

electricmoccasins · 11/04/2023 08:41

BitOutOfPractice · 11/04/2023 08:15

I have read the Wolf Hall books about Thomas Cromwell three times. And seen the RSC production. Every time I have sobbed at his death. (Sorry for the spoiler).

The power of Hilary Mantel. For 100s of years people cried over Thomas More rather than Thomas Cromwell. I’m with you btw. Sobbed!

stormelf · 11/04/2023 08:37

ToriLynn · 10/04/2023 20:25

Jane Grey 😢 she was used as a child by the people who should have protected her because they wanted power, but she was to pay the price for their greed.

She's who I immediately thought of when opening this thread

Stopsnowing · 11/04/2023 08:36

CockSpadget · 11/04/2023 01:31

I’d never heard of Suzanne so I’ve just looked up her story. That poor poor girl. I will never comprehend how humans can carry out such depravity.

I was horrified at the time - it got so little attention.

Alleycat1 · 11/04/2023 08:29

As a previous poster mentioned : Junko Furuta.
That the mothers of the boys involved could actually defend their horrific depravity and that sentences were so light.

Otherwise too many horrific deaths to mention (holocaust, Inquisition, so-called honour killings etc.) which give me nightmares if I think about them too much

Swipe left for the next trending thread