Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sad over historical deaths?

335 replies

Personyouneedisnannymcphee · 10/04/2023 18:35

Obviously death happens every day and there are many recent, very sad deaths. But some historical ones actually make me ache a little when I think about them I think due to the details and historical background of them more so than sometimes things I hear on the news. Some of these being:

-the Romanov children. Of course the Tsar was horrific but how they died thinking they were going to safety and then didn’t get killed by bullets as jewels in their clothes protected them so they were finished with bayonets.

-Anne Boylyn’s death because the details of her ladies not letting the men touch her afterwards for fears they’d violate her headless body.

AIBU for sometimes being incredibly sad over these people I never knew or do you have your own historical death that makes your stomach drop when you think of it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Boringcookingquestion · 11/04/2023 11:09

I think it’s normal. Sometimes someone’s story just touches you.

There’s a tower in York where Jewish people went for shelter from an angry mob in the 12th century. When the relationship with the tower’s keeper broke down, many families chose to die together rather than facing the mob outside.

The father of each family killed his wife and children, before killing himself. Thinking of those children looking to their parents to save them and being killed instead, and for those parents to have to choose whether it was kinder to kill their children themselves, or risk sending them out to a crowd of furious people who hated them… it’s just unthinkable.

The people trapped below deck on the titanic always gets to me too.

IcakethereforeIam · 11/04/2023 10:53

Sejanus's daughter, I don't know if her name was recorded. I keep hoping it's one of those things that didn't happen. Something made up to blacken the names of the perpetrators. It was a brief account in an otherwise forgettable novel that's haunted me. I've actively avoided trying to learn more.

Deaths of children always hurt me, particularly from acts of deliberate cruelty. I usually can 'armour' myself but this was unexpected and got through.

Sausagenbacon · 11/04/2023 10:44

tbh, I don't feel sad about things in the past. What upsets me is the absolute knowledge that terrible things are happening to people all over the world now, that I can do nothing about, even if I was aware of them.

Janie1962 · 11/04/2023 10:40

namitynamechange · 11/04/2023 01:00

Kipling's son. Kipling wrote "If" for him after he was born. When WW1 came I think they both saw it as the chance for gallantry/patriotism/dashing heroism but he was too short sighted to be accepted into the army. So Kipling used his influence to pull strings. Only for his son to then die alongside countless other men at the battle of Loos. And Kipling never found out exactly what had happened to him or his body.

Kipling never got over John's death - one of his poems written shortly after John was labelled as 'presumed dead' reads "If any question why we died/Tell them, because our fathers lied" and his subsequent work was far more dark and bitter.

He had quite a tragic personal life; he lost his little daughter Josephine to pneumonia when she was six, about 16 years before John was killed. His surviving daughter, Elsie, married but had no children.

PS - it was actually the Royal Navy John tried to enrol in at first, but he was rejected outright, and Rudyard then pulled strings to get him into the Army. He and Carrie spent many years visiting the area where John's battalion was last seen, and interviewing literally hundreds of survivors, all to no avail. It's so sad; neither of them recovered from it.

Theimpossiblegirl · 11/04/2023 10:39

Gwenhwyfar · 11/04/2023 10:23

Imo if you're very sad about things that don't concern you personally, it's a sign of some sadness closer to home that you're projecting onto something else.

Or that you have empathy and can care about things that don't affect you on a personal level.

CaveMum · 11/04/2023 10:37

All of those mentioning Catherine Howard, I recommend listening the episode of the podcast "Not Just The Tudors" about her. It was first broadcast in 2021 but has been re-released this week so should be at the top of the news feed. It's an interview with historian Gareth Russell who wrote a book about Catherine's short life.

I follow the Auschwitz Museum Twitter feed. Every day they post details about a handful of people that died in the Camp, just a photo and a few basic details about the victim. The numbers involved in the Holocaust are too large to imagine, but seeing the individuals, particularly the children, really drives home the horror.

One of the tweets from today, a 9 year old Hungarian girl called Csibi Sxilvia Guttman murdered in May 1944: twitter.com/AuschwitzMuseum/status/1645652933093015552?s=20

theangrylion · 11/04/2023 10:34

The Srebrenica massacre brings tears to me. The ethnic cleansing, the rape houses, the mass graves still being found.

HoofWankingSpangleCunt · 11/04/2023 10:34

PuttingDownRoots · 10/04/2023 23:21

The story of the Kindertransport always gets me.
The children who were saved by it, but never saw their families again.
And the children who were left behind to the horror that followed.

My grandfather , was rescued from Sachsenhausen concentration camp by the Kindertransport. He never saw his family again. And instead created a new one with another German Jewish refugee and decades later I was born.

Crocodilekneecaps · 11/04/2023 10:29

Stephen Lawrence
Anthony Walker

OldTinHat · 11/04/2023 10:25

Oradour-sur-Glane.

Heartbreaking.

MissDollyMix · 11/04/2023 10:23

It's not so well known but it's absolutely horrific and I often think back to it but in Victorian York there was 'The York Industrial Ragged School' . It was effectively a workhouse for children. Apparently the 'school master' was a cruel man who used to stalk the streets and effectively abduct children who were homeless or orphaned. He received money from the church for each child he had in his 'care' so the more the better as far as he was concerned. Unfortunately he never spent the money on the children and they slowly starved to death. He couldn't be bothered to bury them so he just piled the bodies up in the back of the cupboard in the orphanage. I just can't imagine what those poor, poor children must have gone through knowing their friend's bodies were being kept like that, that any one of them could have been next. Eventually he went mad and slaughtered the remaining children with a knife. And this wasn't really that long ago. Comparatively recent history. The past was a very brutal place.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/04/2023 10:23

Imo if you're very sad about things that don't concern you personally, it's a sign of some sadness closer to home that you're projecting onto something else.

Riverlee · 11/04/2023 10:13

Next to the old lifeboat station in Poole there’s a plaque dedicated to a young lad who died. Everytime I pass it I have to read the plaque and I have a moment of sadness for him and the family he left behind.

areweonabreak · 11/04/2023 10:08

BlueBellsArePretty · 10/04/2023 21:02

Star Hobson 😢 the poor poor wee soul.

I think about this too, she looks a little bit like one of my DD's. At the time I sobbed every time I saw a news article about it.

I also think the same of Maud Watkins who died of Sepsis 11 years ago. My DD had sepsis at 10 months old. Dr's told us over and over it was just viral. I think of poor Maud and her parents and think there but for the grace of god (and my instincts that something was seriously wrong)

camelCase · 11/04/2023 10:06

Lesina · 10/04/2023 21:40

Arthur Labinjo Hughes. The footage of that little boy crying that no one loved him will haunt me to the grave. Unutterable cruelty.

Agree!

I don't normally have any emotional reaction to people I don't know (obviously think it's sad / people are awful etc) but that one got me, I cried when I saw the footage, that poor boy!

loveisanopensore · 11/04/2023 10:06

Maolra Seoighe. A man wrongly convicted and hung in 19th century Ireland. He didn't speak English and the judge and his solicitor didn't speak Irish.

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 11/04/2023 10:05

My mum had a autograph book that had been her mother’s. In it were some incredibly beautiful watercolours and pen sketches, including a pretty girl called Kitty. Mum told me that they had been done by my nanan’s fiancé, but he’d been killed before he was 19 in ww1. It emerged that after that Nanan (Kitty)became depressed and suffered from what we now know as bpd. Mum had rescued the book when nanan was having one of her regular burnings of photos, books and papers. I just felt so sad for that young man (and all the others) who died in another pointless war and for all the women and loved ones they left behind and how their lives had been shattered. (Though, if she had married him I wouldn’t be here)
We lost the book when the container it was in was damaged by sea water when we returned back to England.

SerafinasGoose · 11/04/2023 10:05

Fernticket · 11/04/2023 09:59

Some more I have thought of.
Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman.It must have been especially terrifying for the second one to be killed as she would have known what was coming.
All the victims of the Yorkshire Ripper who were villified by the press for being street workers, with no thought to what drove them to that in the first place ( and not all of them were street workers).
The 5 girls in Ipswich murdered by Steve Wright, especially Paula Clennell who was interviewed by the local TV station. She said then how scared she was.

How very odd. I'd just written a post referencing the many, many women who have been murdered to satisfy the perversions of men, then refreshed the page (losing my post) and saw yours.

I had also listed the five women who died at the hands of the monstrous Wright in Suffolk. Poor Paula was for some reason the one who stuck in my mind the most, perhaps because of that interview.

The senseless killing of Sophie Lancaster has haunted me ever since and I've never forgotten it. More recently her mother, Sylvia, who campaigned in her daughter's name ever since to S.tamp O.ut P.rejudice, H.ate and I.ntolerance E.verywhere.

It would have been a nice dream. Not possible, but Sylvia Lancaster was a wonderful example of returning good for evil. Just a tragedy; neither of them deserved that fate.

BMW6 · 11/04/2023 10:02

I am fascinated by Anne Boleyn, but have to say I don't feel terribly sorry for her. She was certainty not a Victim (and I suspect would rail against being portrayed as such), and she was absolutely hateful towards Katherine and Mary - also her own sister Mary.

Anne gambled for the Crown. She won for years, then didn't spot the warning signs in her arrogance.

DorritLittle · 11/04/2023 10:02

Oh my god all of these!

Fernticket · 11/04/2023 09:59

Some more I have thought of.
Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman.It must have been especially terrifying for the second one to be killed as she would have known what was coming.
All the victims of the Yorkshire Ripper who were villified by the press for being street workers, with no thought to what drove them to that in the first place ( and not all of them were street workers).
The 5 girls in Ipswich murdered by Steve Wright, especially Paula Clennell who was interviewed by the local TV station. She said then how scared she was.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 11/04/2023 09:58

No - I wish more people would actually think about historical deaths like that. There's a huge culture of 'gore tourism' in London about executions , Jack the Ripper etc and when you think about it, it's weird. They were real people who suffered but because it was long ago, somehow the humanity gets lost. I remember thinking this when I was in Westminster Abbey looking at all the tombs of people I had heard so much about in history books etc. It made it real.

IHateLegDay · 11/04/2023 09:55

Fizzadora · 10/04/2023 21:46

Aberfan.

I hadn't heard about this tragedy until a year or two ago and I sobbed reading about the mothers who were digging with their hands and tore their fingers down to the bone.

dottiedodah · 11/04/2023 09:51

Anne Boleyn always seems the saddest death to me(not taking anything from his other wives ,sad for them too of course) A recent trip to Hever Castle ,her childhood home was so sad.We visited her Bedroom ,which was so moving .Just a young girl with hopes and dreams .Also Henry 8th bedroom there when he stayed over .No hint of her terrible fate.

Rinkydinkydoodle · 11/04/2023 09:50

Lesina · 10/04/2023 21:40

Arthur Labinjo Hughes. The footage of that little boy crying that no one loved him will haunt me to the grave. Unutterable cruelty.

Agreed. I was asked at an interview what I’d do differently with my life if I had the ability to time travel for just one day, and they looked at me funny when I said I’d go and break into that house, and any of the others I could get to in time. I suppose it’s because it’s ‘nothing to do with me’ and so many terrible things have happened and will keep happening to defenceless infants people just say oh that’s a pity and move on, but that footage is torture. It’s forever stuck in my head as proof of how cruel people can be to their children and what makes it worse is I know this will be happening right now to countless others. Less sadness, more impotent fury.