Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sad over historical deaths?

335 replies

Personyouneedisnannymcphee · 10/04/2023 18:35

Obviously death happens every day and there are many recent, very sad deaths. But some historical ones actually make me ache a little when I think about them I think due to the details and historical background of them more so than sometimes things I hear on the news. Some of these being:

-the Romanov children. Of course the Tsar was horrific but how they died thinking they were going to safety and then didn’t get killed by bullets as jewels in their clothes protected them so they were finished with bayonets.

-Anne Boylyn’s death because the details of her ladies not letting the men touch her afterwards for fears they’d violate her headless body.

AIBU for sometimes being incredibly sad over these people I never knew or do you have your own historical death that makes your stomach drop when you think of it?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Emotionalsupportviper · 20/04/2023 17:53

BMW6 · 11/04/2023 10:02

I am fascinated by Anne Boleyn, but have to say I don't feel terribly sorry for her. She was certainty not a Victim (and I suspect would rail against being portrayed as such), and she was absolutely hateful towards Katherine and Mary - also her own sister Mary.

Anne gambled for the Crown. She won for years, then didn't spot the warning signs in her arrogance.

she was absolutely hateful towards Katherine and Mary - also her own sister Mary.

She was frightened. She knew her own position was very tenuous, and that unless she gave Henry a son she was lost. And she was right.

Emotionalsupportviper · 20/04/2023 17:51

IHateLegDay · 11/04/2023 09:55

I hadn't heard about this tragedy until a year or two ago and I sobbed reading about the mothers who were digging with their hands and tore their fingers down to the bone.

There is a novel based on the disaster "A Terrible Kindness". I had known of the disaster - I am of an age to remember the horror of it on the news - but the detail obviously escaped me. The book is very touching.

This is incredibly moving, too. For people not involved the awfulness of it shocks for a time, but then life intrudes, and it goes out of our minds; for those there it will never be finished with, I think.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-150d11df-c541-44a9-9332-560a19828c47

Aberfan

The mistake that cost a village its children

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-150d11df-c541-44a9-9332-560a19828c47

Emotionalsupportviper · 20/04/2023 17:33

Kolakalia · 11/04/2023 08:59

The one consolation for me with Viola Beach is that they wouldn't have really known. They were killed instantly, so other than a split second of 'wtf' when the car went into the air, that was it.

I often think about John Cantlie. It's been ten years since he was kidnapped in Syria, he was tortured, held captive, saw his cellmates be executed, went through mock executions, and eventually was forced into advocating for the ISIS regime on camera by producing media for them. He was stick and bones and hopefully he knew nobody would actually believe he thought the things he was saying, he was saying them for his own survival. To this day nobody knows where he is, he was almost certainly killed at some point but his final years were horrific.

And the men who were executed on camera with a knife. James Foley. Alan Henning.

I also think of the Jordanian pilot who was set alight in a cage. Against my better judgment I watched that video and his strength to the final moments was unbelievable.

I hadn't heard of the Jordanian pilot, but the fate of many Yazidi women and girls, captured and raped but the Taliban/ Daesh, was the same. Burned alive in cages for not wanting to please their vile abusers. It's not enough to be raped. it seems women have to pretend to enjoy being raped.

BitOutOfPractice · 20/04/2023 17:28

@Emotionalsupportviper (brilliant name!) I think you might be right. She must have come so “close” to him in those years. God I could cry now thinking of the last few paragraphs. Such a clever woman she was.

YesitsBess · 20/04/2023 17:27

marmitegirl01 · 10/04/2023 21:39

Have you been to that garden in London with all the memorials to people who died saving others? It's incredibly moving - quite a high number of children saving their friends and family members.

Postmans Park. It’s such a lovely find in London.

Postman's Park

My father took me here on one of our London tours, and I cried and cried! Ordinary people who died trying to save others.

Postman's Park: London's Hidden Memorial to Heroic Self Sacrifice

Postman’s Park is one of London’s secret spots - a touching and sad memorial to Londoners who lost their lives in heroic acts. Find out more...

https://www.londonxlondon.com/postmans-park-memorial/#:~:text=The%20Watts%20Memorial%20features%2054,saving%20the%20lives%20of%20others.&text=What%20is%20this%3F,-Report%20Ad&text=The%20Postman's%20Park%20plaques%20go,on%20a%20friend%20in%201863.

Emotionalsupportviper · 20/04/2023 17:22

SparkyBlue · 11/04/2023 08:49

I am just coming up to that part now.

I have often wondered if the reason it took her to complete the trilogy was that she had developed such affection for Cromwell that she couldn't bring herself to address his execution.

I know I did (three times reader here, too).

thecatsthecats · 20/04/2023 17:20

ToriLynn · 10/04/2023 20:25

Jane Grey 😢 she was used as a child by the people who should have protected her because they wanted power, but she was to pay the price for their greed.

One of my ancestors was shamefully closely involved in that affair.

People who know me say, "Oh cool, very Game of Thrones", but if you give even an iota of thought to it, it was awful.

Emotionalsupportviper · 20/04/2023 17:17

electricmoccasins · 11/04/2023 07:59

What... Having sex with Francis Dereham so not being a virgin for Henry? Or possibly having sex with Thomas Culpeper?

Kathryn was a motherless child, abandoned by her father, groomed by aristocratic young men for their on sexual pleasure, married off to the King by her ambitious uncle, and executed for falling for the attentions of the King's groom. She was no older than 23 at her death and likely much younger. Yes, she committed treason, but all my pity is for her and certainly not the King!

This ⬆

It beggars belief how much autonomy many people think women had in that time.

They were effectively pawns in sexual politics and their own feelings weren't taken into account.

I doubt that a sixteen year old girl would be likely to be enthusiastic about marriage to a middle-aged, morbidly obese, semi-invalid with a putrid, stinking leg ulcer which refused to heal and which rendered him bad-tempered and aggressive.

Poor girl.

Emotionalsupportviper · 20/04/2023 17:07

Whenharrymetsmelly · 11/04/2023 06:01

I think Anne Boleyn was very clever and you're not giving her much credit at all

She was very clever, in that she managed to make the king marry her, and not just use and discard her as he had with so very many women - but ultimately she could not refuse him. He made sure that no other man would go near her.

She was initially sent back to England from France to be married off to a cousin; when that marriage fell through she joined Katherine of Aragorn's ladies-in-waiting where she met and became covertly engaged to Henry Percy - but his father and Cardinal Wolsey refused to countenance the marriage for political reasons.

She was then sent away from court to Hever, where she fell into King Henry's sphere - and he set his sights on her. She did well to hold him at arm's length as log as she did.

Schoolplacechoicemyth · 18/04/2023 23:46

I walk past a churchyard each day which has a gravestone for a little girl who died only 5 years old (100 years ago). It always makes me sad.

NewspaperTaxis · 18/04/2023 23:10

Bit off topic but that is one reason to visit or familiarise yourself with the cemetery in which your parent is likely to be laid to rest, way before their passing looks imminent. Otherwise, any weekly visit to the cemetery is dogged by reading these heartbreaking little testimonies on gravestones, usually having to take one's emotions and condense them into a tidy telegram length piece. By the time you reach your parent's grave when you're already in mourning, you may be in bits. This particularly applies if the visit to the cemetery thing is largely new to you.

CaptainCallisto · 18/04/2023 22:20

There is a tiny grave in the cemetery near my parents' house, dated early 1800s, which just says, "Foundling. Age 2-3 days. Known only unto God". All the circumstances surrounding that little headstone just break my heart; the mother having to make that choice, the baby left alone, and the person who found them and did what they could, even if it was just to see them buried with care.

DorritLittle · 18/04/2023 12:20

Cattenberg · 16/04/2023 21:55

There was a gravestone in our local cemetery for a four-year-old boy who’d died in the 1950s. I can’t remember the full inscription, but it was quite detailed and said he was his parents’ only child. I could feel the heartbreak in every line.

Below were the inscriptions for the boy’s parents, who’d died many years later. They were in their early forties when their beloved only child was born.

I’ve been to that cemetery twice since and that gravestone seems to have disappeared. I suspect it was one of those that failed safety testing and was removed. I wonder if anyone still remembers that family and what they went through?

Also, in a tiny village churchyard near me, is the grave of a baby girl who was born shortly before me and sadly died when she was less than two months old. Her first name is similar to mine, our middle names were the same and our surnames are different but have the same number of syllables. I think of her every time I pass through the village. Life is so arbitrary and unfair.

That is so sad. I find cemeteries heartbreaking at times.

Cattenberg · 16/04/2023 21:55

There was a gravestone in our local cemetery for a four-year-old boy who’d died in the 1950s. I can’t remember the full inscription, but it was quite detailed and said he was his parents’ only child. I could feel the heartbreak in every line.

Below were the inscriptions for the boy’s parents, who’d died many years later. They were in their early forties when their beloved only child was born.

I’ve been to that cemetery twice since and that gravestone seems to have disappeared. I suspect it was one of those that failed safety testing and was removed. I wonder if anyone still remembers that family and what they went through?

Also, in a tiny village churchyard near me, is the grave of a baby girl who was born shortly before me and sadly died when she was less than two months old. Her first name is similar to mine, our middle names were the same and our surnames are different but have the same number of syllables. I think of her every time I pass through the village. Life is so arbitrary and unfair.

COPPER3 · 15/04/2023 22:02

9/11 Twin Towers...will forever be shocked at the bodies throwing themselves out of windows.
This is a truly poignant thread. God bless all souls involved..

mbosnz · 15/04/2023 17:18

The victims of the Beslan Siege/massacre.

Delcelia Witika.

James Whakaruru

Craig Manukau

Chris and Cru Kahui.

Too many of our little mokopuna in New Zealand, who died such callous, cruel, lonely deaths at the hands of those who should have loved their tamariki, nurtured them, cared for them, protected them.

The victims of Hillsborough.

The victims of Dunblane.

The victims of Aberfan.

JudgeJ · 15/04/2023 16:21

My mother lost all faith over Aberfan. It was entirely preventable. Nobody gave a flying fuck and nobody was prosecuted - can you believe it?

Even worse, £1.75 million was donated to a fund set up for the bereaved families but some of this was used by the coal board in clearing the site.
I can still recall arriving home from school, be about 15, and my mother was sitting on the sofa crying about it, we knew nothing, such was the standard of communication in the early 60s

JudgeJ · 15/04/2023 16:15

Not a famous death, but my dad lost a cousin in the Ibrox disaster in 1971. I remember my dad reminiscing about it and his voice cracking when he said "he was just a wee boy watching a football match".

That reminds me of my parents' story of the Burnden Park disaster in 1946 when 33 people died on Bolton's old ground. My father, recently back from India, went to the 2nd round Cup match versus Stoke City. As he got near to the ground he met up with a couple of old RAF colleagues and, seeing the massive crowds going to the match, they decided to go into town for a few drinks and a catch-up. When he arrived home at about 7pm, he wasn't a great drinker, my mother screamed at him, he hadn't heard of the deaths, she'd heard off the radio and when he hadn't come home she assumed the worst.

HurdyGurdy19 · 15/04/2023 16:02

Speedweed · 10/04/2023 18:50

Yes - I remember feeling so sad about Marilyn Monroe and James Dean. Such a waste.

Also a music group called Viola Beach a few years ago, all killed in a gruesome car crash when so young with all that potential just their career was taking off.

Once I became a mother I grieved again for cases like James Bulger too.

The year after the Viola Beach tragedy, Coldplay were headlining Glastonbury. During their set, they played a video of Viola Beach, thereby letting Viola Beach "headline" Glastonbury. I thought that was a lovely gesture. Viola Beach may well have gone on to headline Glastonbury had their lives not been so sadly cut short.

Londre · 15/04/2023 15:49

YANBU. There was a girl in the news who came to the UK from Canada to meet her boyfriend online and he end up murdering her. I don’t know why that upset me so much - I don’t even know her.

I think what made me even sadder was if she didn’t require a covid test to return back to Canada, she probably would still be alive.

Moofart · 15/04/2023 15:46

Not quite historical but Shanann Watts and her beautiful girls Bella and Celeste, not forgetting her unborn baby she had named Niko. That case will never leave me x

JudgeJ · 15/04/2023 15:35

DorritLittle · 11/04/2023 22:50

How did you get into that? Sounds fascinating. So sad though. I don’t know people in the past who lost multiple family members to things like flu kept going.

Many of the on-line genealogy sites welcome volunteers to transcribe documents, I do it for a county on-line parish clerks. If you search on line parish clerks there are about 8 counties that I know of.
One of the most interesting ones I did was the baptism of a baby in the early 20th century, it was the church we had attended prior to moving. I realised that the 'baby' was a member of our former congregation whose golden wedding and 80th birthday we had been to!

Cattenberg · 13/04/2023 11:59

I also remember reading about a married couple and her mother who were tried by the Nazis for treason/resistance activities. The husband tried to take all of the blame in court, insisting that the women knew nothing about it. But the women spoke out and took their share of the blame. All three were executed. I wish I could remember their names.

Cattenberg · 13/04/2023 11:54

I haven’t read the full thread, but completely agree with the pp who suggested George Stinney.

Also, some of the people who resisted the Nazis were unbelievably brave e.g. Hans and Sophie Scholl and Helmuth Hübener. They were facing execution and still tried to take all the blame into themselves to save their friends. They were so young as well.

Boogismyname · 13/04/2023 11:52

The Wineville chicken coop murders.