Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people don't realise

418 replies

CybermanAshad · 10/04/2023 17:54

A few years ago we were a surviving on 30k as a household. It was tight but fine. That was one wage. I was a SAHP as it was cheaper than nursery fees.

We're a family of three with two cats. That's 2 adults and a 4 year old.

Now we have an income of just over 40k and things are harder than ever and we've never struggled so much. That's one wage, child benefit and a student maintenance loan.

We have £5 in the bank to last until 25th of the month. Some food but not much. Both cars need fuel. Before if things were tight there was always some way to get by. Small savings pot (under 1k) we also overpay into our bills account every month not much but would mean if things got tight there might be a spare £100 in there we could use.

Now we have no savings, no spare in the bills account. A combined over draft of £2000 now maxed.

Never thought I'd be wishing DC was back at school to benefit from the school dinner every day.

Desperately trying to get a job. Looking for something that pays about 20k. Would replace maintenance loan and give us 11k extra a year. So far all rejections.

Partner has also managed to get a job paying 8k more a year but doesn't start until May so won't see the benefit until the end of May.

Just feels relentless at the moment.

Saw a thread on here recently with lots of posters saying 85k was nothing in London and people on benefits had a ton of money and had no idea what it was like trying to survive on 85k with no help. I know it's bloody expensive in London but from my own perspective, 85k would be a dream. We don't qualify for benefits beside child benefit which is £87.20 every four weeks.

As I said, a few years ago we got by on 30k and now we're struggling on 40k.

AIBU to think some people don't understand that there's a huge middle section of people who don't recieve benefits but earn under 50k?

I imagine struggling a lot more than those on 85k.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
angelfacecuti75 · 11/04/2023 19:07

I don't think yabu , no. But if you are struggling on 40k & the benefit cap is 26k (to play devil's advocate) imagine how much the people below you are struggling. I work full time, witn a disabled husband who can't work & he gets no help in terms of disablity benefits. I have a son with sen , and additional needs (adhd/depression) despite being intelligent this holds me back slightly though i often do extra work on top of my full time hours in casual jobs...i can only do so much. I do sympathise. Some immediate advice maybe :
-do u have any forgotten nectar /clubcard /other loyalty points that could help with food etc or other costs (even if not v much ...)
-do u have anyone that could help you re food /loan u money temporarily eg relatives /friends ?
-foodbank?/ Help for households grant that has gone out recently ?
-can u get child benefit paid weekly? I did. Pleaded poverty (it was true and we were both full time workers then) but it helped...
-can u grow ur own food to help cut costs ?
-could u join mse and look at the guide for making extra dosh on there ? Valued opinions has helped me over years...but it isnt instant. Also food coupons are on there too...
-are u getting all the benefits u r entitled too ? Turn to us has a good guide on there re benefit checker....
Erm ...i have written a lot and its all advice i would give a friend & i am so tired but i hope it helps.

Teateaandmoretea · 11/04/2023 19:07

@Flubadubba restaurants are not more expensive either.

Teateaandmoretea · 11/04/2023 19:05

Two cars for example is for the vast majority of households a luxury.

Well if you live outside London and actually want to be able to get to work it’s a necessity.

This is where all the ‘poor Londoners’ stuff is properly grating, they can just use very cheap public transport, the rest of us cannot. It costs £££ if it exists at all.

PretzelBite · 11/04/2023 19:03

It’s all well and good people saying ‘well, there are loads of vacancies where I live’, the op has said she is in an area with low turnover and lots of applicants and is trying to find work. Op, keep looking and apply for anything and everything. Sell old bits and bobs on facebook/vinted. Look for reduced food in supermarkets. Can your dp ask for an advance on his salary for this month? Some workplaces allow this. You can get through this part, you will be ok. Soon your husband’s salary increase will start and you will be bringing in some money yourself. Better times ahead. It’s a shame people try to drag others down and race to the bottom - ‘look at me, I live off a 2p salary!’. Other people suffering are not the enemy and this is not a competition.

Solonge · 11/04/2023 19:03

CybermanAshad · 10/04/2023 18:15

Not London but South East. I meant if we had an income of 85k where we are now if nothing was different that would be a dream. I do realise that London house prices are horrendous.

If you live in the South East the price differential in some areas is the same as London property wise. The point is property and rents are much higher in the SE. If i were you i would aim for any job that pays £15k or similar…you will still be much better off.

MoggyMittens23 · 11/04/2023 19:00

I often see people that are struggling that have pets... I know there is nothing you can do about them now but they must cost you a bit per month. Is it worth it? Don't plan on getting any more after if it's not.

Biilie82 · 11/04/2023 18:51

CandleInTheStorm · 10/04/2023 21:29

I guess it's the 2 x tax/insurance/mot/repairs and petrol which is why people mention the 2 cars when a family is struggling for money. But I also understand that public transport can be bloody expensive! Other my friend who doesn't drive manages with 3 kids as single mum on public transport ok, then again she lives in town so easier. So many factors!

I often fantasise what it would be like to have the option of two wages coming in the house as a single parent so yabu so say "people don't realise..." because what people actually don't realise is how much more potential a two adult household have to bring in more income!

Agree with this, OP has chosen not to work and then to study and thinks they shouldn’t financially struggle…
OP- YABU, what is it you expect exactly?

Unsure33 · 11/04/2023 18:49

lechatnoir · 10/04/2023 19:13

We have similar income in the SE and it is a struggle

. @LucifersLight Im also intrigued how you manage on £22k with a £700pcm housing bill - do you not get any help? My band c council tax is £200 a month which would leave about £600 for gas, water, electric, food, travel and usual life expenditure and I just can’t see how it’s possible nowadays. this month has seen 1 child need new school shoes and football boots, dentist for me and a hefty charge for hospital parking over a number of days)

Me too because we don’t have mortgage or rent but our rates and bills are high and we would definitely struggle on £22000 before tax .

proppy · 11/04/2023 18:48

It depends when you got on the housing ladder too

Flubadubba · 11/04/2023 18:46

However for your London comment YABU. 85k in London, with a medium sized family, is a struggle. You're looking at around £200k+ to be OK in "inner" London. By inner, I don't mean Zone 1, you'd need a much higher salary to live in Zone 1. I'd say zones 2-3 or 4.
It's not just the rents that are higher. It's nursery fees, school clubs, birthday parties, restaurants, the list is endless. Anything that can be more expensive, generally is.

The residential part of zone 3 here, and agree to some degree, though I would say you can be OK on c120k quite easily. That said, we don't live in a super glam part.

Flubadubba · 11/04/2023 18:42

If you aren't working, have you transferred your tax free allowance to your husband?

www.gov.uk/marriage-allowance

CherryCokeFanatic · 11/04/2023 18:41

It’s all relative. YABU

Georgyporky · 11/04/2023 18:39

Either/both of you can get evening job/s - there are plenty available.

Bluebellwood129 · 11/04/2023 18:39

As an example, a Sunday roast in my local pubs is anything between £18-30 per person. This is for the roast alone.

I live in the North West and that's fairly standard for a decent roast.

Jeclop · 11/04/2023 18:33

CybermanAshad · 10/04/2023 17:54

A few years ago we were a surviving on 30k as a household. It was tight but fine. That was one wage. I was a SAHP as it was cheaper than nursery fees.

We're a family of three with two cats. That's 2 adults and a 4 year old.

Now we have an income of just over 40k and things are harder than ever and we've never struggled so much. That's one wage, child benefit and a student maintenance loan.

We have £5 in the bank to last until 25th of the month. Some food but not much. Both cars need fuel. Before if things were tight there was always some way to get by. Small savings pot (under 1k) we also overpay into our bills account every month not much but would mean if things got tight there might be a spare £100 in there we could use.

Now we have no savings, no spare in the bills account. A combined over draft of £2000 now maxed.

Never thought I'd be wishing DC was back at school to benefit from the school dinner every day.

Desperately trying to get a job. Looking for something that pays about 20k. Would replace maintenance loan and give us 11k extra a year. So far all rejections.

Partner has also managed to get a job paying 8k more a year but doesn't start until May so won't see the benefit until the end of May.

Just feels relentless at the moment.

Saw a thread on here recently with lots of posters saying 85k was nothing in London and people on benefits had a ton of money and had no idea what it was like trying to survive on 85k with no help. I know it's bloody expensive in London but from my own perspective, 85k would be a dream. We don't qualify for benefits beside child benefit which is £87.20 every four weeks.

As I said, a few years ago we got by on 30k and now we're struggling on 40k.

AIBU to think some people don't understand that there's a huge middle section of people who don't recieve benefits but earn under 50k?

I imagine struggling a lot more than those on 85k.

It's tough at the moment, yes but hard to know
your personal full ins and outs without knowing what your outgoings are and if anything has changed in that time.

However for your London comment YABU. 85k in London, with a medium sized family, is a struggle. You're looking at around £200k+ to be OK in "inner" London. By inner, I don't mean Zone 1, you'd need a much higher salary to live in Zone 1. I'd say zones 2-3 or 4.
It's not just the rents that are higher. It's nursery fees, school clubs, birthday parties, restaurants, the list is endless. Anything that can be more expensive, generally is.
As an example, a Sunday roast in my local pubs is anything between £18-30 per person. This is for the roast alone.

JessTD · 11/04/2023 18:32

This is a fascinating thread. We’re struggling on about £90k a year household income in the SE. Two adults, a baby and a toddler. I truly loathe my full time job but have to stick with it for nursery and mortgage reasons. It does feel like a race to the bottom and makes me sad.

BluebellBlueballs · 11/04/2023 18:30

I think what people don't understand is how much money has depreciated as everything seems double the price of yesteryear.

We are a 2a 2c family and ten years ago I earned 32k and my hubby 23k. We did fine, ate what we liked, holiday most years, even paid for a 12k wedding in 2015. I replaced my wardrobe constantly and was always buying shite I didn't need

Now I'm on 54k and he's on 28k and I feel guilty shopping at tesco rather than aldi and I'm trying not to buy any new clothes this year and if I do it's sales only.

Not what I would have expected in my 40s mud career

Wtf happened?

MaidOfSteel · 11/04/2023 18:29

JassyRadlett · 10/04/2023 19:18

....and still be taking home a whole lot more after that tax.

Honestly, the 'we pay so much tax!' bleating from some makes everyone in this salary bracket look like tin-eared wankers.

Well said, Jassy!

wentworthinmate · 11/04/2023 18:29

All care homes crying out for staff from cleaners to carers and in your circumstances you’d be able to work nights for more money. Lots of menial jobs out there if you are need money.

proppy · 11/04/2023 18:29

@Feelingss I would say it's unusual that a house that only needs cosmetic work eg repainting to be priced 50k plus less than similar houses.

Jilltee · 11/04/2023 18:24

LucifersLight · 10/04/2023 18:05

You are being unreasonable and I suspect you know it.

Even £30k is a decent salary - in many parts of the UK families do fine on a single minimum wage salary.

My family of 3 lives on £22k and yes we have a mortgage payment of £700 a month.

It sounds like you have probaby bought cars newer than you can really afford or something.

Everyone is far better off now than people were in the 80s/90s when I had a full-time NHS job paying less than £100 take home a week and a mortgage of £500 a month.

Basically everyone got used to money being free (low interest rates) and thought it would last forever.

Boo hoo.

What a heartless comment. Hope you showed more compassion when you worked for the NHS.

ABliss · 11/04/2023 18:06

All I can advise is that you use your vote wisely. Decades of poor political forward thinking have led to us being exposed. I hate to turn this into a political debate, but the UK had a wealth of resources and export to offer.
Now, on a fairly decent salary, we struggle.
My wife and I bring in 72k a year and we feel the burn. We get zero financial help. We're very lucky have 1140 hours in Scotland. But that barely touched the sides.

What people underestimate is the amount of debt when on lower income. And once you get a higher paying job, all you're doing is repaying that enormous amount of debt and not really benefitting from the pay rise. The system is designed to squeeze everything out of us.

You're not being unreasonable. This is modern day Britain we have voted for.

itsjustnotok · 11/04/2023 18:06

I really think our benefits system is screwed up tbh. I know people who are on UC and scrape by. I know a few people who are on UC and have more money than mine and my DH wages combined. We pay nearly £1000 a month extra in rent. I totally get why we don’t receive help but I genuinely don’t understand how someone can get UC and still be able to afford weekend pub crawls, holidays and frequent shopping trips whilst someone else on UC can barely scrape by. Pupil Premium is a weird one too. 7 years extra help when the family are doing really well. No wonder we don’t have the money for those who really need it, moreover though it gives anyone claiming any kind of benefit a bad name. I hate money!

Toomuchtrouble4me · 11/04/2023 18:04

Doesn’t matter how old cars are - both need tax and insurance plus fuel so you’re not broke whilst you’re running two cars. You’re fine, get a bike and keep 1 car.

Feelingss · 11/04/2023 18:03

proppy · 11/04/2023 16:28

However, I know lots of people here would never have bought the house (run down, needed work) as it wasn't "Insta ready" but its meant we have a very cheap mortgage.

For most people now it's better to buy the insta ready house as renovation costs are astronomical...

Nothing structural, just shabby and needed painting. I agree if its huge structural costs as they can be 1000s. By my estimation we have spent £8,000 over the last 4 years (including a new boiler) but probably saved around £50-75K on what a 'nicer' house would have been.