Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people don't realise

418 replies

CybermanAshad · 10/04/2023 17:54

A few years ago we were a surviving on 30k as a household. It was tight but fine. That was one wage. I was a SAHP as it was cheaper than nursery fees.

We're a family of three with two cats. That's 2 adults and a 4 year old.

Now we have an income of just over 40k and things are harder than ever and we've never struggled so much. That's one wage, child benefit and a student maintenance loan.

We have £5 in the bank to last until 25th of the month. Some food but not much. Both cars need fuel. Before if things were tight there was always some way to get by. Small savings pot (under 1k) we also overpay into our bills account every month not much but would mean if things got tight there might be a spare £100 in there we could use.

Now we have no savings, no spare in the bills account. A combined over draft of £2000 now maxed.

Never thought I'd be wishing DC was back at school to benefit from the school dinner every day.

Desperately trying to get a job. Looking for something that pays about 20k. Would replace maintenance loan and give us 11k extra a year. So far all rejections.

Partner has also managed to get a job paying 8k more a year but doesn't start until May so won't see the benefit until the end of May.

Just feels relentless at the moment.

Saw a thread on here recently with lots of posters saying 85k was nothing in London and people on benefits had a ton of money and had no idea what it was like trying to survive on 85k with no help. I know it's bloody expensive in London but from my own perspective, 85k would be a dream. We don't qualify for benefits beside child benefit which is £87.20 every four weeks.

As I said, a few years ago we got by on 30k and now we're struggling on 40k.

AIBU to think some people don't understand that there's a huge middle section of people who don't recieve benefits but earn under 50k?

I imagine struggling a lot more than those on 85k.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Notamum12345577 · 11/04/2023 21:24

I’m intrigued by this. How would a single person be worse off? There is one less one person to feed, cloth, car etc?

jobie70 · 11/04/2023 21:21

Well I have a disabled DH, a DD awaiting a kidney transplant and she's not working.. and I work part time.. we survive on just under £20k.. but that's with no holidays.. no smoking.. no drinking.. and 1 car.. times are hard and sacrifices have to be made.. but it can be done.. check your budgeting and get rid of everything that isn't a necessity.. we threw out our virgin tv sub, our home phone, downgraded mobiles to sim only packages.. it's hard out there.. and every penny counts.. I hope you get things sorted

OhNoItsThePinkyPonk · 11/04/2023 21:19

YANBU to think some people don’t have a clue, that said I do feel some focus too much on the number and not the situation.

I’m a doctor, I earn £100000, and am grateful for it. When I started my medical journey I was given to believe that as I progressed through the ranks and when I eventually completed my training I would live in this kind of house in that part of town and drive this sort of car. So that’s what my family and I did. We took out mortgages and loans and agreed to pay them back over time, usually secured against future income.

Now things have changed, as they have for everybody (and I’m not trying to pretend for a second that our situation is as challenging as it is for so many others), and we cannot afford our lives. Technically we earn more than we did five years ago but we are no longer able to live in our house of ten years, we have changed our cars, we don’t have hobbies, holidays or meals out. What comes in goes out again immediately and we are close to defaulting on some debt.

I continue to consider myself very fortunate, and am markedly aware of how much more challenging life is for others, nevertheless I do believe that in discussions such as these it is worth remembering that most families live within their means and match income to expenditure regardless of what that income may be. Almost nobody has ‘spare’ money.

I do have sympathy with the OPs position but also with those who are struggling on higher wages. It’s not the wage that’s crippling people, it’s the commitments made when the wage itself was worth more. Perhaps this is all due to poor financial planning on my part, highly likely in fact, but from the day I first went to university I accrued debt with the expectation and indeed promise that my future earnings would adequately compensate.

Or perhaps I’m blinded by middle-class privilege, if so I apologise.

Gh12345 · 11/04/2023 21:19

GloryBees · 11/04/2023 20:56

You have a child and you’d prefer to spend your last £5 on your cat?! You are entirely unreasonable. If I’d been even close to not being able to comfortably support my family, my animals would be the first thing to go. Months ago in your case. I am really struggling with the position you’ve got yourself in, you have done things an unconventional way round, but you need to put your child first.

Get rid of your cat… then all your money problems will go away.

Honestly what a silly response.

Toffeecat2019 · 11/04/2023 21:18

How do people get so much money on UC?? It seems an insane amount of money and encourages people not to work!!! I get no benefits at all and both of us work full time and get no help.

Gh12345 · 11/04/2023 21:14

Yes I agree. Our wages are £10k more than 5 years ago but we seem to be worse off now than ever before. No benefits and we both work super hard for our money (which we never seem to have any). Before people have a go at me… I have been unemployed and on benefits in the past so I know what it’s like.

TookTheBook · 11/04/2023 21:12

Sorry if anyone else suggested this because I've only read page 1, but you should contact Citizens Advice who have advisers who specialize in "income maximisation". For instance they could check if what you said about UC is correct.

Many local authorities currently have a fuel fund to support households energy bills costs, so you may be entitled to that if you're struggling. Again Citizens Advice should know about this.

MayThe4th · 11/04/2023 21:11

The reality is that most people live exactly to their means so if the costs go up they struggle.

People should aim to be able to save some money every month when times are good so that they have something to fall back on when times get hard.

I earn £20k plus £4K with london weighting, My mortgage has gone up by over £150 in the past six months, my council tax bill is £187 a month. My DC are over eighteen now and I am not entitled to any benefits.

Likely the places I’m not spending money are that I don’t have a car and I don’t have to pay childcare costs. Because those are the places where the majority spends are.

Netflix, amazon prime, now TV any other subscription services are luxuries and if you can’t afford them then you shouldn’t have them.

If things really are that tight that you’re not able to feed your kids then you firstly need to look t what you’re paying for that you don’t need, and if there genuinely is nothing you can cut back on, (can not don’t want to) then you need to rehome the cats, because you simply can’t afford them, and as much as we love our animals, putting animals above the welfare of your children just isn’t on.

lovescats3 · 11/04/2023 21:10

Why are you running 2 cars ?

CandleInTheStorm · 11/04/2023 21:05

GloryBees · 11/04/2023 20:56

You have a child and you’d prefer to spend your last £5 on your cat?! You are entirely unreasonable. If I’d been even close to not being able to comfortably support my family, my animals would be the first thing to go. Months ago in your case. I am really struggling with the position you’ve got yourself in, you have done things an unconventional way round, but you need to put your child first.

It's getting much more common to study in your 30s and 40s nowadays, either due to not doing well back at school and wanting to increase your earning potential, finally figuring out what you want to do in life, or having a change of/second career.

Not many people leave school, go to university, get a job in the field and do that for life. Things have definitely changed and it's a good thing, especially for women. No longer expected to just get a job for pin money after they have a child and a partner.

Animals are an expense but are also a great joy to people's lives. Mine help combat any loneliness my mental health so wouldn't be the first thing to go. Saying that comes across as though an animal is disposable when actually they are part of the family. I'd be looking at other ways, such as cutting bills/utilities if that's an option before getting rid of a pet that's part of the family.

TollgateDebs · 11/04/2023 21:02

I don't know if any of this will help, but it might for someone and sorry if I am repeating any of the previous advice. Food Pantries (different to food banks and are usually self-referral) - you pay a sub of £5 a week and can get £15 / £20 of food a week and even small savings start to help; is there one local to you? Social tariffs for bills - have you asked your supplier if you qualify, same goes for re-negotiating any phone or tv contracts. Can you move your overdraft to an interest free credit cards? Welfare funds via educational establishment - have you asked for help? Has anyone assisted you with job applications or a CV? There are a great many voluntary agencies and job clubs that will help. Have you considered weekend work, as sometimes the hourly rates are better and with a car you could certainly consider care work as an option, with agencies / companies crying out for people. https://www.turn2us.org.uk/ is a good place to look for advice.

Turn2us - Fighting UK Poverty

Find benefits, grants and financial support online

https://www.turn2us.org.uk

SLeanne · 11/04/2023 21:01

Go back to our grandparents time when families had to manage on rations during the war. Somehow they all managed it. Go back to basics. and stop complaining.

GloryBees · 11/04/2023 20:56

You have a child and you’d prefer to spend your last £5 on your cat?! You are entirely unreasonable. If I’d been even close to not being able to comfortably support my family, my animals would be the first thing to go. Months ago in your case. I am really struggling with the position you’ve got yourself in, you have done things an unconventional way round, but you need to put your child first.

coffeetofunction · 11/04/2023 20:50

I'm a single mum already trying to get by on a 18k income and starting uni in September. I have no idea how I will manage. I have a health condition that will prevent me from working a lot of hours in addition to my placement and uni hours. My eldest child will prevent me from receiving support from the council. I don't really know how many people can and will continue to manage. I have always been frugal but now I'm having to use community shops to manage with food and I'm fortunate I have a friend that gives me food to keep us topped up but without these I wouldn't be eating. I genuinely worry about those that are unseen, going cold and hungry.

Throwncrumbs · 11/04/2023 20:46

LucifersLight · 10/04/2023 18:05

You are being unreasonable and I suspect you know it.

Even £30k is a decent salary - in many parts of the UK families do fine on a single minimum wage salary.

My family of 3 lives on £22k and yes we have a mortgage payment of £700 a month.

It sounds like you have probaby bought cars newer than you can really afford or something.

Everyone is far better off now than people were in the 80s/90s when I had a full-time NHS job paying less than £100 take home a week and a mortgage of £500 a month.

Basically everyone got used to money being free (low interest rates) and thought it would last forever.

Boo hoo.

Yes I agree!

Tealknittedjumpers · 11/04/2023 20:41

İf you're struggling that much your university with have a support fund for students who are struggling. You can take a hardship loan, interest free or apply for a one off grant.

CybermanAshad · 11/04/2023 20:39

GloryBees · 11/04/2023 20:36

You’re down to your last £5 and you say your cats are worth it. How on earth??

Because they are? I rescued them 8 years ago. They're part of the family. I'd spend half of that £5 on them if I needed too!

OP posts:
CandleInTheStorm · 11/04/2023 20:37

CybermanAshad · 11/04/2023 20:31

Yeah, I'm sure we had one during the pandemic and they asked so many questions. If I can avoid it I definitely will. Still waiting to hear on a couple of jobs I applied for so hopefully I'll get lucky with one of those!

Just don't give up your studies! Take the short term pain for the long term gain! I'd start looking at your utilities/bills and see where you can save there. I just got my broadband reduced from £47 to £28 through a bit of haggling. It's always a great place to start looking at where you can save as it all adds up! Even TV subscriptions, I never have them all at the same time (Netflix/Now TV/Prime/Disney plus etc) but choose one based on what's on it that month. I also only ever use Vinted or Marketplace for stuff and never buy new. People sell boots worth £££s on there they've worn once for under a tenner!

GloryBees · 11/04/2023 20:36

You’re down to your last £5 and you say your cats are worth it. How on earth??

Doggate1 · 11/04/2023 20:32

2 cats … 2 cars … sorry but seriously … some people have to use shank’s pony and eat their cats !!!

CybermanAshad · 11/04/2023 20:31

CandleInTheStorm · 11/04/2023 20:29

Just be very careful with a mortgage holiday and only use it as the very last resort.

Yeah, I'm sure we had one during the pandemic and they asked so many questions. If I can avoid it I definitely will. Still waiting to hear on a couple of jobs I applied for so hopefully I'll get lucky with one of those!

OP posts:
CandleInTheStorm · 11/04/2023 20:29

CybermanAshad · 11/04/2023 20:27

Partner earns 30k before tax. I get a 9k student maintenance loan so there's not tax on that.

Thanks for the advice. Definitely going to look into a mortgage Holiday :)

Just be very careful with a mortgage holiday and only use it as the very last resort.

CybermanAshad · 11/04/2023 20:27

Changingtides1234 · 11/04/2023 20:15

Can I ask is this £40k earned before tax or after? Sorry if you’ve already mentioned. May not help you now but martin (money dude I forget his name) says there’s a neat thing you can do with credit cards. Instead of paying things monthly and getting charged you pop it in an interest free credit card and pay that off over the year saving a lot.

i know asda do £15 pound boxes in some areas (my friend does that and it helps her)

vinted for clothes (when needed) I love it. You get so many good things (I’m always amazed at how every parent keeps clothes in good quality and I just can’t.)

take a mortgage holiday (I think you can do 3 months no questions asked)

finally your overdrafts. If you’re getting interest in one of them (I don’t know if you’re in a student account for one and getting it interest free) what you can do is “financial restructuring” it may have a different name now. Basically call your bank explain the situation and they may convert your overdraft to a loan and you could end up paying less in interest. I did this about 10 years ago I was paying 200 in interest, did the restructuring and ended up paying 159. But I was actually paying it off.

you will find work. It will get better.

if my post didn’t help I’m sorry.

Partner earns 30k before tax. I get a 9k student maintenance loan so there's not tax on that.

Thanks for the advice. Definitely going to look into a mortgage Holiday :)

OP posts:
CybermanAshad · 11/04/2023 20:25

CandleInTheStorm · 11/04/2023 20:15

I agree op. I'd be living in a box with my cats before I got rid of them! 😅😅

Totally! 😄😂

OP posts:
user0243 · 11/04/2023 20:23

I don't know what outgoings you could cut back on but we've been in a similar siuation for the last couple of years after the company I worked for closed in lockdown and I'd already committed to being a SAHM to 2 dc.
We went through the bank accounts and cancelled all non-essentials like magazines, extra TV subscriptions, Amazon etc.
I meal plan every week now which saves me loads on the food bill and I buy food online so it's much easier to stick to budget.
All the kids clothes except shoes, PJ's & undies are bought from vinted.
Not bought new clothes for ourselves in a couple of years.
No pets. One family car (a nice one, but we'd paid off the last one so could afford it) No expensive days out unless we save Tesco vouchers etc for them.
Zoo passes etc are bought as birthday presents by family.
I do online surveys to top up by £30-£40 a month and enter every competition I'd be happy to win.
I sell everything the kids have outgrown to go towards what they need.
We grow our own veg in the summer and use the hob rather than oven to cook where we can.
I've also just restarted a small ebay business which only earns me a few hundred a month if that, but I do use the cashflow to borrow from if needed, as it's now regular enough that I know it'll be topped up in the next couple of days.
Our total income is c.50k and our mortgage & council tax payments come to £1350 a month. I drive as little as possible and always shop around for the best deals.
There are loads of great threads on here about ways to cut back or make a little extra, even if you think you can't, and MoneySavingExpert has some really good suggestions and a great budget planner.