Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people don't realise

418 replies

CybermanAshad · 10/04/2023 17:54

A few years ago we were a surviving on 30k as a household. It was tight but fine. That was one wage. I was a SAHP as it was cheaper than nursery fees.

We're a family of three with two cats. That's 2 adults and a 4 year old.

Now we have an income of just over 40k and things are harder than ever and we've never struggled so much. That's one wage, child benefit and a student maintenance loan.

We have £5 in the bank to last until 25th of the month. Some food but not much. Both cars need fuel. Before if things were tight there was always some way to get by. Small savings pot (under 1k) we also overpay into our bills account every month not much but would mean if things got tight there might be a spare £100 in there we could use.

Now we have no savings, no spare in the bills account. A combined over draft of £2000 now maxed.

Never thought I'd be wishing DC was back at school to benefit from the school dinner every day.

Desperately trying to get a job. Looking for something that pays about 20k. Would replace maintenance loan and give us 11k extra a year. So far all rejections.

Partner has also managed to get a job paying 8k more a year but doesn't start until May so won't see the benefit until the end of May.

Just feels relentless at the moment.

Saw a thread on here recently with lots of posters saying 85k was nothing in London and people on benefits had a ton of money and had no idea what it was like trying to survive on 85k with no help. I know it's bloody expensive in London but from my own perspective, 85k would be a dream. We don't qualify for benefits beside child benefit which is £87.20 every four weeks.

As I said, a few years ago we got by on 30k and now we're struggling on 40k.

AIBU to think some people don't understand that there's a huge middle section of people who don't recieve benefits but earn under 50k?

I imagine struggling a lot more than those on 85k.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
HappinessDragon · 12/04/2023 07:56

Jilltee · 11/04/2023 18:24

What a heartless comment. Hope you showed more compassion when you worked for the NHS.

Probably didn’t. But no doubt loved wearing a uniform trying to feel superior.
First one in the queue brandishing their lanyard for an extra hours shopping and a discount during covid?

Boysnana · 12/04/2023 07:54

That sounds a very difficult situation OP. Sorry you are in it. A lot of others are but that doesn't help you.
Have you tried CAB they are good at looking at what help you can get or debt management.

I read you have cut back as far as possible but look again and see what you need and what you want. They are 2 different things.

I have no cooker at the moment but am lucky enough to have a garden. So I light a fire and cook on that. I don't mind. But for some it would be dire straights.

Midwinter89 · 12/04/2023 07:53
  • abroad
MoggyMittens23 · 12/04/2023 07:53

CybermanAshad · 11/04/2023 20:25

Totally! 😄😂

Fair enough of course but a lot of us don’t get pets because of the cost. It’s a choice. So if you have pets but are crying poverty then it’s something to think about

Midwinter89 · 12/04/2023 07:52

People saying two cars is a luxury just don’t understand peoples different circumstances. My partner is currently working a toad for 4 days (often travels) and there is very limited public transport where we live. I wouldn’t be able to get to work, the supermarket, or my child’s nursery without a car.

Midwinter89 · 12/04/2023 07:47

@CandleInTheStorm our CT is £200pcm! Wondering why we are paying so much now? Gas and electric is 300 can’t find a cheaper deal. Mortgage is 1k (ordinary 3 bed). Car insurance 600 per year (13 year old mini). Nursery fees will be 1kpcm.

hattie43 · 12/04/2023 07:42

I grew up in a household without much money. Not having much money meant I got used to things being that way, and I’m still trying to train myself out of it. Not having much money meant to me, as a kid, not having wallpaper on the walls or carpet on the floor, not having central heating, not having a bed frame, having one set of sheets so having to sleep without a cover for a few days every few months whilst they were washed and dried. Not having a sofa, we had cushions on the floor. Making putty out of flour, newspaper and water to stuff the cracks where the draughts were

I'm going to be brutal here and say your parents should not have had kids . If you cannot provide better than this it's wrong and totally unfair on children when their basic needs are not met .

ItWillWash · 12/04/2023 07:32

@whatkatydid2013

I don't think it applies to me but it's worth a try. My employer has an office and I'd be more than welcome there but it's in a different country. That's not because they require me to live far away from the office though, it's just where they happen to be based.

whatkatydid2013 · 12/04/2023 07:22

ItWillWash · 12/04/2023 06:41

I'm with you OP.

I'm a single parent and a few months ago we were quite comfortable on £26k p/a. We weren't well off by any stretch of the imagination but we had enough.

I've just applied for UC because we cannot afford food anymore.

The cost of food rising hasn't helped but the biggest factor is energy. My energy costs have quadrupled. I'm topping up the electric by £150 a week. We've always used a lot and I never can figure out why, I can only guess it's down to the computing equipment I run 12 hours a day for work (I work from home) but it's never been more than £30/40 a week until now. We don't use much gas but that's only because I've banned people from using the heating.

My money is running out within two weeks of being paid. Previously it would last us all month. There wasn't much left over but it lasted us.

Have you applied for the tax break for wfh @ItWillWash ? It may not apply to you but if it does every little helps

https://www.gov.uk/tax-relief-for-employees/working-at-home

Claim tax relief for your job expenses

Claiming tax relief on expenses you have to pay for your work, like uniforms, tools, travel and working from home costs

https://www.gov.uk/tax-relief-for-employees/working-at-home

Pclare · 12/04/2023 07:20

Hayfeverseasonalready · 10/04/2023 18:49

Don't understand why you don't qualify for UC? My husband earns 45k a year and I get around £700 per month from UC. Cant afford nursery fees so I had to quit my full time job, then looked into if we'd qualify for UC and this is what we were awarded.
Our rent is £1250 a month if that makes any difference.

How are you entitled to benefits? My husband earns 40k and when I checked a benefits calculator online we weren’t entitled to anything. We have a mortgage, does this make a difference?

Riverlee · 12/04/2023 07:20

I agree, ignore those who say get rid of the car. Without a car it limits job opportunities for a start. It would take me an hour and two buses to get to my workplace, a journey in the car of under fifteen minutes. Plus you need it for your child and parents.

Pclare · 12/04/2023 07:18

How are you entitled to benefits? My husband earns 40k and I looked at how much we would be entitled to if I didn’t return to work and it was nothing!

whatkatydid2013 · 12/04/2023 07:16

CybermanAshad · 11/04/2023 22:54

Can you read? Honestly.

  1. I'm looking for a job.
  1. I need my car for the school run and to look after my elderly parent.
  1. Yes, I wish he was back at school having a hot lunch every day so I don't have to worry financially about feeding him at lunch time. Am I letting him starve? No. Am I making sure he has three meals a day? Yes.

Today he had Weetabix and a fruit salad for breakfast. Lunchtime he had a chicken salad. Dinner he had a homemade pizza which he helped me make. Included homemade dough, homemade sauce, carrots, tomatoes, sweetcorn, spinach, and tuna. That good enough or no?

With the car I’d say if you were not due a change in circumstances then you might need to adjust to sharing a car and to do school runs on foot and running the errands for your parents when your OH is at home. As it is with your OH due a significant raise soon it wouldn’t make sense to sell a reliable older car now. It will doubtless give you extra work options to have a car anyway. Lots of people have mentioned you could do care work for example and many of those jobs require you to have a car. I know our Ukrainian guest is struggling to find work because between jobs with shifts starting before/finishing after public transport is available and those that require you to have a car (care work/cleaning jobs seem to mostly stipulate it) she’s limited in what she’s eligible to do. Then when she applies she’s competing with loads of 19/20 year old Uni students who employers can pay less

Kaiserchief · 12/04/2023 07:09

We didn’t even have a car growing up so I see them as a total luxury. H needed his for commuting and meetings but I’ve only had my ‘own’ on and off since having the kids - when I worked locally I didn’t have one. Yes it was a drag but we couldn’t afford it.

I think people who were brought up with more struggle more without when they’re grown ups. Massive generalisation but I’ve seen it time and again.

I struggled to get a job! I was looking for something local and part time. I have degrees and years of experience. Some people are snobby about cleaning but no-one else is going to pay me £30-£40 an hour.

ItWillWash · 12/04/2023 06:41

I'm with you OP.

I'm a single parent and a few months ago we were quite comfortable on £26k p/a. We weren't well off by any stretch of the imagination but we had enough.

I've just applied for UC because we cannot afford food anymore.

The cost of food rising hasn't helped but the biggest factor is energy. My energy costs have quadrupled. I'm topping up the electric by £150 a week. We've always used a lot and I never can figure out why, I can only guess it's down to the computing equipment I run 12 hours a day for work (I work from home) but it's never been more than £30/40 a week until now. We don't use much gas but that's only because I've banned people from using the heating.

My money is running out within two weeks of being paid. Previously it would last us all month. There wasn't much left over but it lasted us.

Hudsonriver · 12/04/2023 06:27

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 01:02

But public transport could be way more than £40.
Do they need to carry equipment for their job etc

Single bus journeys are capped at £2 all over England atm.
As I travel by bus everywhere I get a weekly ticket -£13 currently.
That's £27 up on running a car for £40
£108 a month
Also if the car was sold it would hopefully pay off Ops OD.

ComputerWifeKaren · 12/04/2023 02:18

Lone parent, can't work. One child, with severe behaviour issues, no support whatsoever. Struggling on far less than that. Desperate not to lose our home. No one seems to understand - much less provide support without passing the book constantly. Wondering how much worse it could be than this.

T1Dmama · 12/04/2023 01:46

I have friends who literally need to rely on friends and family buying them food or going to the food bank! It’s disgraceful!

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 01:02

But public transport could be way more than £40.
Do they need to carry equipment for their job etc

Laustin2010 · 12/04/2023 00:48

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 00:32

Cars are not even that expensive. They have potential if things go wtonof course.

Mine costs approximately £40 this is so worth it for the convenience. A bus doesn't even go on my route to work and if did £2 a day is a lot more.

That’s an extra £40 a month they need. It’s not about luxury, it’s about necessity. Walking is so good for you, cheaper too. Cars cost in insurance, tax, maintenance, services, mot. It’s an unnecessary cost if they can get rid of one car. I walk 30 mins each way to work, kids walk to school, we have 1 car. It can be done.

Laustin2010 · 12/04/2023 00:40

EddyF · 12/04/2023 00:28

How many times does the OP have to state she needs both cars? Grrr. The OP has also repeatedly stated that she is looking for a job!

There are many comments on here if you haven’t seen. No need for a car to do school run - walk. If school is not within walking distance then it’s out of catchment. Jobs - there are many many around. Nhs advertise all the time. Many nhs jobs for porters, cleaners. Op is joy thinking outside the box & is expecting tax payers to subsidise their living costs.

Laustin2010 · 12/04/2023 00:33

There are many comments on here if you haven’t seen. No need for a car to do school run - walk. If school is not within walking distance then it’s out of catchment. Jobs - there are many many around. Nhs advertise all the time. Many nhs jobs for porters, cleaners. Op is joy thinking outside the box & is expecting tax payers to subsidise their living costs.

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 00:32

Cars are not even that expensive. They have potential if things go wtonof course.

Mine costs approximately £40 this is so worth it for the convenience. A bus doesn't even go on my route to work and if did £2 a day is a lot more.

EddyF · 12/04/2023 00:28

How many times does the OP have to state she needs both cars? Grrr. The OP has also repeatedly stated that she is looking for a job!

Laustin2010 · 12/04/2023 00:14

I think you’re being slightly unreasonable. Firstly do you need 2 cars? If one is at home as a student. That will save a huge amount of money.
Secondly, I know it’s not ideal but sell the cats. If you’re that poorly off you wouldn’t have the cats. Vet costs, pet insurance, food etc all adds to your outgoings.
Look at your monthly outgoings & see what you can cut back on. Put money aside from what you’ll save. Do you smoke? Drink? you can’t compare London to you. London prices are extortionate. A 2 bed flat in London can cost £2000 rent per month. Petrol is more. Parking is more. Costs are way higher in London that you would be paying so hence the salary. Could you get a job towards London & travel by train?