Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people don't realise

418 replies

CybermanAshad · 10/04/2023 17:54

A few years ago we were a surviving on 30k as a household. It was tight but fine. That was one wage. I was a SAHP as it was cheaper than nursery fees.

We're a family of three with two cats. That's 2 adults and a 4 year old.

Now we have an income of just over 40k and things are harder than ever and we've never struggled so much. That's one wage, child benefit and a student maintenance loan.

We have £5 in the bank to last until 25th of the month. Some food but not much. Both cars need fuel. Before if things were tight there was always some way to get by. Small savings pot (under 1k) we also overpay into our bills account every month not much but would mean if things got tight there might be a spare £100 in there we could use.

Now we have no savings, no spare in the bills account. A combined over draft of £2000 now maxed.

Never thought I'd be wishing DC was back at school to benefit from the school dinner every day.

Desperately trying to get a job. Looking for something that pays about 20k. Would replace maintenance loan and give us 11k extra a year. So far all rejections.

Partner has also managed to get a job paying 8k more a year but doesn't start until May so won't see the benefit until the end of May.

Just feels relentless at the moment.

Saw a thread on here recently with lots of posters saying 85k was nothing in London and people on benefits had a ton of money and had no idea what it was like trying to survive on 85k with no help. I know it's bloody expensive in London but from my own perspective, 85k would be a dream. We don't qualify for benefits beside child benefit which is £87.20 every four weeks.

As I said, a few years ago we got by on 30k and now we're struggling on 40k.

AIBU to think some people don't understand that there's a huge middle section of people who don't recieve benefits but earn under 50k?

I imagine struggling a lot more than those on 85k.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
MoggyMittens23 · 12/04/2023 16:54

HistoryFanatic · 12/04/2023 08:06

I suspect so. OP doesn't seem that worried.

You would spend half of your last £5 on your cats? I feel sorry for your son tbh. You, not so much.

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 16:45

Aaah ok I thought it was per week.
It's £40 a month?
Does that include petrol, road tax, insurance and servicing though?

£200 insurance
£50 MOT
£10 petrol

If I have the money could add another £100 for service. Granted there is a risk of maintenance from the MOT.

A bus does not go my route and I have equipment to carry sometimes. So even with this it wouldn't be much for the wxtra mental stress and hassle it would cause me to get the bus.

Maple2023 · 12/04/2023 16:39

Whippetlovely · 12/04/2023 16:22

It’s £2 capped just until June this is single trip so return is £4. Still cheap at the moment but it’s not going to be like that for long. I do not consider having a car a ‘luxury’ if people live in rural areas they need a car, transport is not reliable and even if you live in a city trains are unreliable and expensive. Not having a car will limit her job opportunities.

I'm not even rural and couldn't get a bus to work Grin
Well I could but I would have to get a bus from my house to the bus station, then another from the bus station to work then a 10 min walk
Total travel time around 90 mins and I live 3.5 miles from work

There's an Aldi 2 miles from me, again no direct route so it's into town (town is the opposite direction from work and Aldi) and back out
It's ridiculous having to go 5 miles in the wrong direction to come back on yourself

Whippetlovely · 12/04/2023 16:22

It’s £2 capped just until June this is single trip so return is £4. Still cheap at the moment but it’s not going to be like that for long. I do not consider having a car a ‘luxury’ if people live in rural areas they need a car, transport is not reliable and even if you live in a city trains are unreliable and expensive. Not having a car will limit her job opportunities.

11inch · 12/04/2023 16:18

If only public transport ran between 2 places at times you wanted it to at reasonable cost. For vast swathes of the country this doesn't happen. Walking isn't the answer either when it is 2 plus miles on national speed limit roads with no footpath.

I sympathize OP, you made decisions a few years ago that seemed rational and now foreseeable circumstances have taken over. Of course people will tell you that you should have predicted the C of L crisis/ pandemic/ war in Ukraine. However if we were all that cautious there would be very little economic growth.

Hudsonriver · 12/04/2023 16:11

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 08:50

Single bus journeys are capped at £2 all over England atm.
As I travel by bus everywhere I get a weekly ticket -£13 currently.
That's £27 up on running a car for £40
£108 a month
Also if the car was sold it would hopefully pay off Ops OD.

@Hudsonriver

I don't understand your Maths. A weekly ticket for £13 is more than my £40 car.
Plus a bus doesn't even go on my route to work. The assett itself I agree could pay debt off but it's not a magic saving solution.

Aaah ok I thought it was per week.
It's £40 a month?
Does that include petrol, road tax, insurance and servicing though?

Hudsonriver · 12/04/2023 16:08

Teateaandmoretea · 12/04/2023 08:56

Single bus journeys are capped at £2 all over England atm.

😂😂

I have no idea if this true, when we used to have busses it was definitely more.

But most of the population don’t have easy access to busses that go where they want. We don’t have them at all.

https://www.gov.uk/guidance/2-bus-fare-cap

Really have no idea why you are laughing?

In place until June.

£2 bus fare cap

A list of bus companies and bus routes included in the £2 bus fare cap scheme.

https://www.gov.uk/guidance/2-bus-fare-cap

Mollymoostoo · 12/04/2023 14:27

I was a single parent when I first went to uni. Worked in a takeaway at the weekends. Hated it but money is money

Yoyo2021 · 12/04/2023 13:39

Boysnana · 12/04/2023 07:54

That sounds a very difficult situation OP. Sorry you are in it. A lot of others are but that doesn't help you.
Have you tried CAB they are good at looking at what help you can get or debt management.

I read you have cut back as far as possible but look again and see what you need and what you want. They are 2 different things.

I have no cooker at the moment but am lucky enough to have a garden. So I light a fire and cook on that. I don't mind. But for some it would be dire straights.

You can get a slow cooker for 20 pound or air fryer

RockGirl · 12/04/2023 13:03

sashh · 12/04/2023 09:03

Why have you not claimed the parent learning allowance?

Have you got your council tax discount? As a student you don't pay but as your DH isn't he does so you should get 50% knocked off the cost.

Have you opened a student bank account? Most have a free overdraft.

Access your university's hardship scheme or the student union loan, that one is usually interest free.

This is not accurate.

Partner will get 25% off the council tax bill as student is disregraded, so they would need to pay 75% of the total.

Issania87 · 12/04/2023 12:48

I think it's hard whatever you earn tbh. My hudband and I both earn good salaries but are paying £1500 in childcare and no longer get child benefit. So we don't have as much cash as you might think we do, especially now our mortgage and utilities have gone up.

That being said, I realise that we are incredibly privileged compared to other people's situations, and I honestly don't know how some people are coping with only 1 earner in the home or not working at all.

If you aren't having luck finding a job could you do some temping? I used to do it and found the flexibility and variety of roles great.

Rhodesiawassuper1972 · 12/04/2023 12:10

In exactly the same boat. Terrifying times now.

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 09:40

I am shocked at that calculator. Putting in several of my friends income it has them in the top 5 percent on 90k household.

This is in the North. Loads of my friends are the same.

Guess there is wealth out there that isn't necessarily an income.

IBJAS · 12/04/2023 09:33

There’s a lot of people making it work on way less. You definitely need to get rid of one of the cars. If my partner has our car and I need to get about I’ll just walk with the kids in the buggy. If it’s further afield possibly bus but I’d rather walk as free and healthy. I’ll admit as well the worse thing you could have done was get an overdraft because they’re hard to get out of. You need to pay it off fully which means for a few months or even over a year you’ll have less to live on because of this.
You should probably sit down with your partner and see what can cut out or what you might be ‘wasting’ on things that aren’t essential.
Also recommend contacting your local council to see if they have any schemes or what help is on offer. If you’re struggling that bad they might be able to refer you to a food bank or provide a small grant.

Hope things get better for you!

Riverlee · 12/04/2023 09:09

The bus cap is only until end of June.

sashh · 12/04/2023 09:03

Why have you not claimed the parent learning allowance?

Have you got your council tax discount? As a student you don't pay but as your DH isn't he does so you should get 50% knocked off the cost.

Have you opened a student bank account? Most have a free overdraft.

Access your university's hardship scheme or the student union loan, that one is usually interest free.

Teateaandmoretea · 12/04/2023 08:56

Single bus journeys are capped at £2 all over England atm.

😂😂

I have no idea if this true, when we used to have busses it was definitely more.

But most of the population don’t have easy access to busses that go where they want. We don’t have them at all.

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 12/04/2023 08:50

Single bus journeys are capped at £2 all over England atm.
As I travel by bus everywhere I get a weekly ticket -£13 currently.
That's £27 up on running a car for £40
£108 a month
Also if the car was sold it would hopefully pay off Ops OD.

@Hudsonriver

I don't understand your Maths. A weekly ticket for £13 is more than my £40 car.
Plus a bus doesn't even go on my route to work. The assett itself I agree could pay debt off but it's not a magic saving solution.

Ilovecleaning · 12/04/2023 08:36

LucifersLight · 10/04/2023 18:05

You are being unreasonable and I suspect you know it.

Even £30k is a decent salary - in many parts of the UK families do fine on a single minimum wage salary.

My family of 3 lives on £22k and yes we have a mortgage payment of £700 a month.

It sounds like you have probaby bought cars newer than you can really afford or something.

Everyone is far better off now than people were in the 80s/90s when I had a full-time NHS job paying less than £100 take home a week and a mortgage of £500 a month.

Basically everyone got used to money being free (low interest rates) and thought it would last forever.

Boo hoo.

Some big assumptions here and a bit nasty. Boo hoo? Nasty and childish.

Mumsanetta · 12/04/2023 08:31

I actually think the OP is the one who’s tone deaf. She had the luxury of being a SAHP some years ago when others either couldn’t afford it or continued working to build up their earnings. Perhaps the poster who was earning £85k made sacrifices such as going back to work after a short maternity leave and is now reaping the benefits! Everyone is affected by COL why not just say I’m struggling to get by as a student, with just my DH working instead of creating a whole post to effectively say some people don’t know they’re alive (are so lucky)? It’s not a race to the bottom but it’s worth checking your privilege occasionally - you have 2 cars, a small mortgage and you have managed to avoid having to work up to now. Yes, you have a maintenance grant but with a little foresight you could have got a job ages ago to top up your earnings when you first started dipping into savings and your overdraft. The COL isn’t a new thing so I’m surprised you have got to the stage where you have £5 and have maxed out your overdraft before seeing the urgency of getting a job.

Pretty sure it’s annoying to be told that you should consider yourself lucky and others have it worse but perhaps you can now sympathise with the poster on £85k, who, if I remember correctly was actually a single parent.

cupofdecaf · 12/04/2023 08:20

The bigger issue that several people have said is that wages are not keeping up with inflation. People who were living well within their means are suddenly struggling.
A mortgage is not just easy to leave (schools, price of other houses, commutes, support networks). Leased cars agreements aren't easy to get out of. People have other commitments and expenses that a few years ago would have been easy for them to manage but suddenly they can't. It's really rather depressing. I know which way I'll be voting come the election, won't make any difference where I live I think it's been tory since the first MP.

HistoryFanatic · 12/04/2023 08:06

Mumsanetta · 12/04/2023 08:04

I understand loving animals but what you’re saying here is that you would take food out of your child’s mouth to feed your cats? Unless what you’re saying is you’re down to your last £5 this month with cupboards and a freezer full of food.

I suspect so. OP doesn't seem that worried.

RachaelN · 12/04/2023 08:05

Perhaps look at going down to having one car. This is what we decided to do when things got tight.
I was a student with a baby and I agree it was really tight even though I was working part time nights aswell. Tbh it was 3 years of hell. But it did get better eventually.

Mumsanetta · 12/04/2023 08:04

CybermanAshad · 11/04/2023 20:39

Because they are? I rescued them 8 years ago. They're part of the family. I'd spend half of that £5 on them if I needed too!

I understand loving animals but what you’re saying here is that you would take food out of your child’s mouth to feed your cats? Unless what you’re saying is you’re down to your last £5 this month with cupboards and a freezer full of food.

Midwinter89 · 12/04/2023 07:57

@Toffeecat2019 you're right, two of my siblings have decided not to work because they would get less money. My sister just says she can’t afford to work ( no kids).

Swipe left for the next trending thread