Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do these fathers actually want children?

358 replies

Daftasyoulike · 10/04/2023 17:01

I see a lot of posts on MN about absent Fathers who don't pay maintenance, don't make any effort to see their children, etc. Is it unreasonable to ask whether these men ever actually wanted kids in the first place, or was it a case of accidental pregnancies, which were allowed to continue in the hope that 'he will come around to the idea once the baby arrives', and then when the relationship breaks up, you find that he never really cared about having the kids in the first place, so doesn't feel he should contribute emotionally or financially to the raising of his children?

OP posts:
Rainbowqueeen · 11/04/2023 04:10

A lot of men like the idea of children but not the reality. They also seem to like the idea of a healthy NT child who requires no effort from them but is always available to be “on show” to others.

Simonjt · 11/04/2023 04:03

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 11/04/2023 00:23

Yeah, but a woman can decide to either not have the baby or give it up for adoption. A bloke has no say whether he becomes a father or has to financially support a child, despite contraceptive measures being of mutual responsibility.

Of course, I believe in 'her body, her choice' etc, but I feel men are a lot more likely to end up as an unwilling parent as generally an unwilling female wouldn't usually have the baby.

Yes, they should take precautions like condoms etc but I think it's unrealistic to say they shouldn't have sex at all if they don't want a child. It's not like women do this, is it?

Why are you pretending that only birth mums can give up a child for adoption? When a child is relinquished both parents must agree.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 04:02

Well, there is such a thing as dysfunction passed from generation to generation. Denying that is ridiculous.

Great, just insult people who've survived abusive childhoods, many of whom become the most committed and gentle, loving, warm parents you could possibly have for exactly that reason: that they would give anything to make sure their children are happy and secure.

But you carry on with your victim blaming.

Ironic that when the tragic cases of neglected and abused children make the news everybody says how sad it is and how they'd have loved that child and taken them in. But those who do survive such childhoods are then stigmatised throughout life with hateful comments like you've just made even if they become excellent, kind parents who provide for their children financially and give them a wonderful childhood full of love.

As I said, what absolutely vile posts from so many posters on this thread.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 11/04/2023 03:56

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:30

When you’re a child, if both your parents can’t display emotional intelligence or operate from an emotionally intelligent place, you’re pretty much fucked (unless you have other good adults around you who can fill that void).

Oh great, so now to top it off those of us who had shitty childhoods are also marked as useless parents.

What absolutely vile comments there are in this thread.

Well, there is such a thing as dysfunction passed from generation to generation. Denying that is ridiculous.

Nicecow · 11/04/2023 03:55

reddragon7 · 10/04/2023 21:41

If men don’t want to be fathers, they shouldn’t have sex in the first place. It’s massively unfair.

But this goes for the female too surely?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 11/04/2023 03:54

Mogul · 10/04/2023 17:09

I think there are a lot of 'accidents' and women that hope a man who has said he doesn't want kids will change his mind. It's not right they don't pay but I'm not sure it's right they don't quite get the choice the way women do

Agree with this. Selecting a reluctant, disinterested father for one's offspring is reprehensible. We are the ones who control this; it's highly disingenuous to suggest otherwise.

Nicecow · 11/04/2023 03:53

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 11/04/2023 00:23

Yeah, but a woman can decide to either not have the baby or give it up for adoption. A bloke has no say whether he becomes a father or has to financially support a child, despite contraceptive measures being of mutual responsibility.

Of course, I believe in 'her body, her choice' etc, but I feel men are a lot more likely to end up as an unwilling parent as generally an unwilling female wouldn't usually have the baby.

Yes, they should take precautions like condoms etc but I think it's unrealistic to say they shouldn't have sex at all if they don't want a child. It's not like women do this, is it?

I agree with this. I think if a women chooses to be a single parent (as in accidental pregnancy and the father doesn't want it), then they shouldn't be forced to pay maintenance. I know so many women in this situation who go ahead in this situation and then are surprised when the relationship doesn't work out.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:50

I really cannot believe what a pile of ignorant, ridiculous, misogynistic, vile, irrational, spiteful, unintelligent nonsense I've just read.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:47

gettingoldisshit · 10/04/2023 22:04

OP you won't get a fair hearing on here! On MN its always always the mans fault! Women don't do things like trick men into pregnancy or think its a fantastic idea to have a child with someone they barely know and who they may have only slept with a couple of times!!!!! Confused yes men should take responsibility for contraception but mistakes happen and then only the woman gets a choice on the outcome, yet she is surprised when she ends up a single parent with a child who's father doesn't want to know!

Yeah, because that's what posters have been describing. Oh wait, no, it wasn't that at all. 🙄

Have all of these people had some kind of brain bypass?

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:43

And yet still feel it's a good idea to comment. 🙄🙄

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:42

hoven · 10/04/2023 20:10

@blackbeardsballsack
Yes to reform of CMS no to single parent tax cuts.

Single parents are taxed MORE on the same household income than a two parent household. How is it possible for someone to be this ignorant?!

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:36

@gazpachosoupday sorry about your friend. I'm not denying this happens but I consider it exceptional circumstances.

@hoven what you "consider" is irrelevant. You've been told by many women who have actually experienced it that you're wrong. And based on your comments about family court, child maintenance, social services and relationships you haven't the faintest idea what you're talking about so maybe learn about the actual data on the topic before you post in future so you avoid making a fool of yourself.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:30

When you’re a child, if both your parents can’t display emotional intelligence or operate from an emotionally intelligent place, you’re pretty much fucked (unless you have other good adults around you who can fill that void).

Oh great, so now to top it off those of us who had shitty childhoods are also marked as useless parents.

What absolutely vile comments there are in this thread.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:25

I think it happens but it is the exception rather than the rule.

Perhaps you should listen to the many women on this thread who it has happened to who have told you that it isn't "the exception" @hoven

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:22

I usually hear the mothers complaining about their absent partners. Hence why I question their initial choice they made.
Of course fathers should play a part, but I truly believe the majority of cases are down to poor decision making

And more of the same vile comments. Every single time there's a thread about single parents it's the same.

You should be really ashamed of yourselves.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:21

Unfortunately the bar for men is quite low so many of us accept it. I also think some women are quite willing to overlook large red flags in male behaviour because they want a baby and they'll explain away and minimise crap behaviour because they hope a baby will change him/he'll step up when the baby arrives

And then this crap starts. Every time. So predictable.

Often there are no red flags until the children arrive. You can do everything right and be co-habiting and married for years before children, with a man who does his share of housework and behave respectfully etc, and they still leave after the children are born.

Stop blaming women for men's behaviour.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:18

Did you get any financial 'help' through the divorce settlement?

These people. 🙄 Do you get some sort of sick pleasure from attacking single parents like this @hoven?

In my case I was by far the higher earner if you must know so I had to pay him off. What's your point?

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 03:16

blackbeardsballsack · 10/04/2023 17:23

Oh no, you've caught me out. Yes, my ex husband was tricked by me into proposing, getting married and planning a baby. I had always secretly wanted him to fuck off into the sunset to lead a carefree life whilst I raised DC on my own, with no break, the entire financial and emotional burden, my DC's friends asking why they don't have a dad, my DC enviously watching other kids idolising their dads, and carrying the social pariah stigma of being a single mum and therefore a creature of the underclass no matter how hard I work or how well I parent.

Thanks for that, OP.

This.

My ex-H actually bought a newborn babygrow as one of his presents to me on our first wedding anniversary saying he "hoped by next year we'd have someone to wear it". Yeah, sure, I pressured him into children. 🙄 In fact we waited several years after that before having them. How could I possibly of known he'd do a runner?! Sorry that I didn't have a crystal ball.

What a horrible thread. Yet again stigmatising and blaming the lone parents - almost all women - who are the ones that stay around and do the work of two people, provide everything for their children financially and emotionally and also do everything in the house (which apparently many Mumsnet posters consider another a full time job in itself). And now it is also our fault that irresponsible men leave their children and have no contact and pay nothing?

How about you start respecting single mothers and campaign for a properly enforced child maintenance system OP, with payments that are 50% of the cost of actually raising a child. Or a tax system that doesn't penalise single parents by taxing them more than a two parent household with the same income despite them doing two people's work in half the time. Do something productive with your time.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 11/04/2023 00:23

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 00:05

@StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar what??? How many single mums do you know of who gave the baby up for adoption but the father continued to pay for it? That literally makes no sense. Millions in unpaid child support is owed by absent fathers. Over 90% of single parents are female. Very very few give their babies up for adoption and rarely if ever for purely financial reasons.

Yeah, but a woman can decide to either not have the baby or give it up for adoption. A bloke has no say whether he becomes a father or has to financially support a child, despite contraceptive measures being of mutual responsibility.

Of course, I believe in 'her body, her choice' etc, but I feel men are a lot more likely to end up as an unwilling parent as generally an unwilling female wouldn't usually have the baby.

Yes, they should take precautions like condoms etc but I think it's unrealistic to say they shouldn't have sex at all if they don't want a child. It's not like women do this, is it?

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 00:05

@StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar what??? How many single mums do you know of who gave the baby up for adoption but the father continued to pay for it? That literally makes no sense. Millions in unpaid child support is owed by absent fathers. Over 90% of single parents are female. Very very few give their babies up for adoption and rarely if ever for purely financial reasons.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 10/04/2023 23:56

I think women would likely think more carefully about having a baby if they had to give it unconditional financial support like men do, rather than knowing they can give it up for adoption and move on. If they had to continue paying for 18 years it'd be an entirely different scenario.

JudgeRudy · 10/04/2023 23:51

I think many men that don't parent never wanted the children in the first place. I think some think it's in everyone's interest to cut ties due to drama with the mum and some quite like the idea of a family but the reality of looking after 2 kids in a bed sit/nanas house is far from rosey...and finally men that have small children probably haven't really bonded in a deep and meaningful way.
I'd like to see the stats of teen v baby/toddler relationships.

GobbieMaggie · 10/04/2023 23:46

Stillcountingbeans · 10/04/2023 23:04

I think what many men really want is a '1950's style' wife. One who does all the housework and cooks his meal every night. They confusedly think that having a baby will somehow turn their partner into this domestic wife.

Of course they also like the idea of 'father' as a status, but want/expect the woman to do all the actual work of parenting.

They don't say this out loud, but this is the common fantasy.

But somehow they think the woman is also supposed to pay half of all the bills.

I think that’s what a lot of women think men think. But most men are pretty ambivalent about having kids in the first place. It’s women who push for them ; no pun intended.

Sailingaround · 10/04/2023 23:44

PaigeMatthews · 10/04/2023 19:35

I agree with this.

id add that some men do make a decision to plan a child. They want the child. But they dont expect to have responsibility for them. That’s for the woman. Even with a lot of fathers who are still living with their families and are present on weekends, how many still consider the mother the default parent? How many of those good fathers take the day off if the child is sick, arrange all the appointments, buy all the clothes, sort parties etc etc etc.

I agree with both of you. I had a friend who could never meet me without her kids until they were old enough to attend school. I asked why her partner couldn’t have them for a few hours considering he was at the time unemployed long term, and she said he said “a child should be with their mother”.
Not surprisingly she is has consistently been the one who liaises with schools, deals with bills and organises every single one of the kids birthdays and Christmas presents and holidays despite them both working now.

And another friends partner has kids in various countries that he doesn’t financially support. I could never get with an absent father! It definitely should be something men are shamed for.

I don’t care if they think they were “tricked” into it. You rarely hear stories of decent responsible men “lured” into fathering children hmm wonder why that is? Perhaps because the decent ones don’t leave it to women and use their own condoms.

to the pp saying it mostly happens to people who weren’t married, I don’t have stats but most of my friends whose kids have absent fathers were once married to the father of their children. In a couple of cases the men were actively pushing for another child shortly before they jumped ship. I have no idea what their logic on the second child was.

I do know one girl from school who was casually seeing a guy and fell pregnant and that guy has denied the child. She did make a stupid choice by having sex with an irresponsible guy unprotected, but so did he and she’s been left to bring up the child.

As for men not wanting kids…maybe it’s a cultural thing but ALL of the men I know/have dated who are from Eastern European backgrounds, African and Caribbean backgrounds and even some American cultures definitely want at least two children and see that as a non-negotiable in a marriage unless of course there are fertility issues . It’s certainly not something foisted on them by their wives.

theblackradiator · 10/04/2023 23:38

Stillcountingbeans · 10/04/2023 23:04

I think what many men really want is a '1950's style' wife. One who does all the housework and cooks his meal every night. They confusedly think that having a baby will somehow turn their partner into this domestic wife.

Of course they also like the idea of 'father' as a status, but want/expect the woman to do all the actual work of parenting.

They don't say this out loud, but this is the common fantasy.

But somehow they think the woman is also supposed to pay half of all the bills.

yes I agree with this. Ive seen this with the men in my own family. My dbro expected his wife to stay at home to do all the cooking, cleaning, shopping, childcare and have his meal on the table when he came home from work he wasn't happy when she wanted her own independence and to go out to work as it meant she wouldn't be there to have his evening meal on the table and he'd have to do a couple of hours of parenting his own kids until she got home from work.
Many men just expect women to take over from their mothers and look after them so they can carry on doing as they please being looked after by "her indoors".