Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do these fathers actually want children?

358 replies

Daftasyoulike · 10/04/2023 17:01

I see a lot of posts on MN about absent Fathers who don't pay maintenance, don't make any effort to see their children, etc. Is it unreasonable to ask whether these men ever actually wanted kids in the first place, or was it a case of accidental pregnancies, which were allowed to continue in the hope that 'he will come around to the idea once the baby arrives', and then when the relationship breaks up, you find that he never really cared about having the kids in the first place, so doesn't feel he should contribute emotionally or financially to the raising of his children?

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 10:24

Why are so certain that they're lying? Why is it so impossible for you to believe that their partner changed beyond recognition? Being unable to imagine that anyone's experience might be different to one's own is a real weakness. Surely the simple fact is that people become single mothers in many different circumstances and at many different stages. The one constant (in the context of this thread) is a child or children growing up with one of their two parents failing in their duty of care, yet we still, as a society want to put the responsibility for that on the present parent.

Naunet · 11/04/2023 10:07

Thanks op, now I know it was my mums fault my dad could never be arsed with his 3 kids, 3 kids he had told his wife he wanted and planned for, but really, she was just tricking him.
Poor men, too stupid and easily manipulated to be trusted with a penis 🥺

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 10:05

Then, many (is that better?) lie to themselves and those around them that they had no idea. There were no signs. This, I understand. I have actually read the thread btw. Still feel the same

How you "feel" doesn't override the facts that people have described to you. How dare you imply that the accounts women have given here are untrue.

Or, you could just shut up and stop being so insulting to people when you clearly have no idea what you're talking about
Oh, I have an idea of what I am talking about despite it not being the same as you. And it's hardly insulting 🤷‍♀️

No, you clearly have no idea and think you can tell other women that you know more about their lives than they do. Of course it is insulting when you are blaming women for their husbands abandoning their families.

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/04/2023 09:57

Emptycrackedcup · 11/04/2023 08:06

I agree with this 💯 Making out like women are just these helpless victims does not give them any credit at all. Of course most would have had red flags, and more than one baby is just stupid. Let alone being stupid with multiple men, come on! Maybe instead we should be telling women they should be stronger and smarter and expect more, not that they are aimless beings in their own sad destinies.

Bollocks

Domestic violence often doesn't start until pregnancy even if you have been together many years.

Stop victim blaming.

CJsGoldfish · 11/04/2023 09:57

Implying that this is the reason why most lone parents are in that situation is utterly shit behaviour. And not the case as you can see if you actually read the thread
Meh.
I'm not implying anything. We are all where we are, in part, due to decisions we make. Lone parents are not exempt from this. Plenty of women choose shit fathers for their children. Because they want children. Or for any number of other reasons. Many are in the situation they are in because of this. Why deny it. The men are shit. Their behaviour is shit. Their behaviour is no ones fault but their own. Not one person has implied that it's the womans fault a father acts that way.
Still, the women chose them anyway. Then, many (is that better?) lie to themselves and those around them that they had no idea. There were no signs. This, I understand.
I have actually read the thread btw. Still feel the same

Or, you could just shut up and stop being so insulting to people when you clearly have no idea what you're talking about
Oh, I have an idea of what I am talking about despite it not being the same as you. And it's hardly insulting 🤷‍♀️

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 09:57

I'm not saying it's a good decision, just that I can see the reasoning. Is it so terrible that a woman who has married and had one child in good faith, is a little disillusioned but assumes maybe it's just normal that he's a bit "hands off", he has the big job, she's home more, other women at the toddler groups all have the same gripes so it's the normal next step. Let's not pretend that it's easy to up and leave, give up your dream, disappoint your wider family, face an uncertain future and be that most terrible of all things, a single mum, when actually the alternative isn't abusive, isn't awful, just wearing and unfair. Maybe in that circumstance it makes sense in your head to have your second or third, make them your world, you three a little team with the dad in the background. You'll rumble along. Until he cheats and leaves, or does become abusive, or whatever. This is a hypothetical made up "generalisation" of some people's situation. We seem to expect women to be absolute paragons of good sense, strength, moral certitude, high standards but men can be feckless, fickle shites and guess what, women must be better to compensate.

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/04/2023 09:53

Its always the woman's fault isn't it op?. Those poor men who never lie, cheat, abuse....

I was married for many years before the domestic violence started whilst pregnant...entirely my fault I didn't use my crystal ball

It was him who pushed for children and who fucked off when he couldn't hack a child with additional needs. Silly me expecting anything else.

Have we been invaded by MRAs again?

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 11/04/2023 09:50

I totally agree @yyyypppp financial security and having my career is what enabled me to live a good life as a single parent.

I wish we could change the expectation of men to take responsibility through changing the law and culture but that isn't a quick fix. My advice to my daughter will be to ensure she is financially independent to look after herself and any children she may have.

Singapore4 · 11/04/2023 09:47

The old sibling line is offensive. I wanted DS to have a sibling too. What a "sweeping generalised statement" to make. We all have our reasons I sure as hell wasn't following that trend I'm 1 of 4 siblings and my own mother stayed with my dad for years and she thinks she gets brownie points that we all have the same dad as though it's an achievement. Eurghh none of us 4 see our dad as a result but that's not my mother's fault is it.

CJsGoldfish · 11/04/2023 09:43

It may also be the case that the woman wants her child to have a sibling, and while things are not perfect, what is?
So choosing to have a baby with someone they already know is pretty crap then. But hey, don't question that stupid decision or the impact it may have on the children because apparently, that never happens 🙄

NamelessNancy · 11/04/2023 09:39

Offthexmaslist · 10/04/2023 19:42

I would be truly interested in how many accidental pregnancies happen once effective male contraception is available...

Where are the men demanding research into male contraceptive options, fundraising for it etc? There is no demand for it as they are happy to leave the responsibility to women with the option of fucking off as a fallback in the event of an unplanned pregnancy.

yypppp · 11/04/2023 09:23

I don’t think my ex wanted children. That didn’t stop him telling me he couldn’t wait for me to be pregnant and when I was, that it was the most wonderful thing he’d heard. I thought I was having a family with a loving, decent man.

Instead, he became abusive and I was forced to leave before the birth. He barely sees our child. I am lucky that at the time I had huge financial cushioning and my own decent job as well as chunky CMS from the scumbag. This was quite literally the only thing that made what happened manageable. That’s not to say what the piece of shit did hasn’t impacted me… he took away my dream of building a happy life and it’s impacted my career a little, although that would have happened regardless of our relationship. I also feel very sad that I was previously a cheerful and positive person and whilst that is still me, he took away some of my faith in people/life by what he did. He sees our child intermittently but that only began when she was 1. He had no concept of responsibility and presumably no conscience. I hope it haunts him as he ages.

Sadly there are men out there like that and it’s not the fault of women who become pregnant, or even women who become pregnant unexpectedly and don’t wait to abort.

My advice to any young women is make sure you have money and a decent job. Sadly that is the only thing that can properly protect you from the vile ways men can behave in what is still a very much sexist society.

Dis626 · 11/04/2023 09:13

meloonhead · 11/04/2023 09:00

I don't understand how that's a decision worthy of respect. It was never a question of him being the sole carer, that would be you as the mother. All he had to do was give a tiny financial contribution and/or see your son occasionally.

Where did I say that it was a decision worthy of respect? I said that I respected his decision. That is something completely different.

meloonhead · 11/04/2023 09:02

Obviously there's nothing you can do to force him besides using the CMS but I wouldn't say respect. Maybe you didn't mean it like that. Accept more like.

meloonhead · 11/04/2023 09:00

Dis626 · 11/04/2023 08:19

I appreciate that this view may be controversial to many, but my DS was an accident that neither myself or his father wanted at the time. I decided I wanted to keep the baby. He wanted me to get an abortion and made it crystal clear that he didn't want any involvement. I respected his decision to not want to be involved and he hasn't been (financially, emotionallyr or physically).

I don't understand how that's a decision worthy of respect. It was never a question of him being the sole carer, that would be you as the mother. All he had to do was give a tiny financial contribution and/or see your son occasionally.

reddragon7 · 11/04/2023 08:51

Nicecow · 11/04/2023 03:55

But this goes for the female too surely?

Oh yeah, but the post is about absent fathers who refuse to take responsibility, not mothers.

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 08:47

No, and again, that's a gaslighting response. @Nepmarthiturn is trying to make the point that contrary to the sweeping generalisations on here, many many single parents did not blithely carry on having babies 2 and 3 with unsuitable dads, but that circumstances change. It may also be the case that the woman wants her child to have a sibling, and while things are not perfect, what is? Better two to one dad than the messy dynamics of step and blended families perhaps? Life is difficult, messy and there is no crystal ball. The vast majority of women in this situation, when compared to the men who fathered the children are doing a stellar job, so to answer the original question, some do want them, them change, some never did, but the reality is that the child exists and should be provided for by both parents.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 08:47

Nope. My two were both still babies when their father suddenly changed and left.

Singapore4 · 11/04/2023 08:41

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 08:37

You are clearly in the minority though if after baby no1 cane along and your DH hid his true colours until you went on to continue to have more kids to him

No she isn't. Per the many stories on the thread.

Why do you think your opinions override the realities described by the many women who have actually lived through this?

I agreed with your point upthread I'm not sure where you are going with over riding anybody point.

Perhaps I have touched a nerve because I dared to ask why women have continued to have have baby no 2 and no 3 despite existing issues? Perhaps I have touched a nerve with you?

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 08:39

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 08:22

@Emptycrackedcup but surely the "expecting more" should also be aimed as the men. We should expect non resident fathers to pay. We shouldn't have whole websites dedicated to helping men get out of it. We should have HMRC working with the CMS to ensure correct payment is made and if it is not, debt accrues that the man must pay back before he gets access to any state pension. It shouldn't be socially acceptable for men to see their kids twice a month (especially ones with whom they did live with and have a relationship prior to the relationship breakdown). Why are women the problem here?

And enforce it like tax evasion: don't pay, go to prison. Or lose your driving licence etc like in some other countries. Proper sanctions and enforcement. And stop penalising single mothers by taxing us more etc. But no, instead we get blamed for what the father has done. 🙄

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 08:37

You are clearly in the minority though if after baby no1 cane along and your DH hid his true colours until you went on to continue to have more kids to him

No she isn't. Per the many stories on the thread.

Why do you think your opinions override the realities described by the many women who have actually lived through this?

Singapore4 · 11/04/2023 08:34

@BibbleandSqwauk don't take this the wrong way. This is my own personal opinion based upon my previous relationship and the circle of friends I have. To not see your kids, do the bare minium and pay a decent amount of money (as in the maximum effort you can) as a father you are immoral for me this is someone's character flaw. There could be numerous reasons for a relationship breakdown as a mother and again my position is totally different to a man's. There's not ANY type of "complication" where I wouldn't move heaven and earth to make sure my Son is provided for and not only that, that we spend time together.

I believe people change and relationships of course. Not seeing your child though is something fucking else. Perhaps I can't relate though as DS sees his dad but he's another one that he is the minium camp and pays CMS begrudgingly.

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 08:25

@Singapore4 thanks. the thing is though, I don't think my ex did "hide his true colours". He changed. I don't think he was pretending or lying for years. I think a number of things happened that caused a perfect storm and got him to a place where he felt differently and there's not much you can do about that. Frequently women post on the Relationship board about this and how their partner has become a stranger overnight. There's no planning for that, or mitigation.

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 08:22

@Emptycrackedcup but surely the "expecting more" should also be aimed as the men. We should expect non resident fathers to pay. We shouldn't have whole websites dedicated to helping men get out of it. We should have HMRC working with the CMS to ensure correct payment is made and if it is not, debt accrues that the man must pay back before he gets access to any state pension. It shouldn't be socially acceptable for men to see their kids twice a month (especially ones with whom they did live with and have a relationship prior to the relationship breakdown). Why are women the problem here?

Dis626 · 11/04/2023 08:19

I appreciate that this view may be controversial to many, but my DS was an accident that neither myself or his father wanted at the time. I decided I wanted to keep the baby. He wanted me to get an abortion and made it crystal clear that he didn't want any involvement. I respected his decision to not want to be involved and he hasn't been (financially, emotionallyr or physically).