Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do these fathers actually want children?

358 replies

Daftasyoulike · 10/04/2023 17:01

I see a lot of posts on MN about absent Fathers who don't pay maintenance, don't make any effort to see their children, etc. Is it unreasonable to ask whether these men ever actually wanted kids in the first place, or was it a case of accidental pregnancies, which were allowed to continue in the hope that 'he will come around to the idea once the baby arrives', and then when the relationship breaks up, you find that he never really cared about having the kids in the first place, so doesn't feel he should contribute emotionally or financially to the raising of his children?

OP posts:
kitsuneghost · 11/04/2023 18:46

The income tax is per person. There is nothing to stop single people house sharing. This goes if you have kids or not.

User135644 · 11/04/2023 18:44

TrishM80 · 10/04/2023 19:02

What I find amazing in the UK is the amount of women who get pregnant within a few months of a relationship. Like they're so desperate for a baby as an accessory like a designer handbag or something, that they'll just let any arsehole be the father!

And then complain when said arsehole doesn't turn out to be father of the year!

It's genetics as well though. If the man is a hunk or successful then they assume he'll produce good offspring, whether he'll be a good father or not. Then that kid grows up to be an arsehole who some other woman will want to bang.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 18:35

Mumsnet did say on a thread a while ago that they'd look into campaigning on this issue to get the tax code change to remove the single parent penalty, but I've not seem anything more from them on it since. It's exactly the type of thing they should be campaigning on because it is discrimination against women and children, given that 90% of primary resident single parents are women.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 18:29

So as an example @theblackradiator if a couple have a household income of £60k (assuming equally split for simplicity) their monthly net pay is £4070. Plus they will get child benefit. A single parent household with the same £60k income will have net pay of £3654. And no child benefit,

So single parent pays an additional £416 tax per month and has no child benefit.

It's a disgrace.

MrsPepperpot79 · 11/04/2023 18:24

I'm sure it could be the case. In my own situation, he begged for kids, did ivf for him (his only chance of kids), but when they arrived he discovered he liked the idea, not the reality. So he buggered off, and openly told csa he was going self employed so that he could dodge maintenance. Some men are tricked, some just go with the flow, some are irresponsible arseholes. Some are genuinely stand-up guys. And sometimes you can't tell which until it's too late.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 18:22

theblackradiator · 11/04/2023 17:47

do single parents pay more in income tax than couples?? that's shocking and why is this I never realised this. x

Yes, because unlike most decent countries there is no allowance to ensure that they aren't being taxed more than another household with the same income. So a couple can earn £25k before paying income tax, a single parent only £12.5k. The couple can earn £100k before paying higher rate tax but the single parent only £50k. Single parent also loses child benefit if earning over £50k but a couple can earn £100k and keep it all. The effective tax rate for a single person at £100k is over 100% - you actually lose tens of thousands of pounds by getting a payrise - because you lose tax free childcare and funded hours at nursery and your personal allowance is withdrawn. A couple can earn £200k before that happens. So single parents are penalised at every level of the tax system. For many it means hundreds or even thousands of pounds less in net income per month, taken to subsidise households with two parents to share the load of earning and childcare between them.

It's grossly unfair and the UK is a huge anomaly on this. That's one of the main reasons that there's so mucj poverty/ more disadvantage in single parent households in the UK than there is elsewhere.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 18:15

Same with the financial support that’s available through divorce - why has no one told me about this before ?

I know! I wished @hoven had told me about this before I had to pay my husband off in the divorce. Those silly solicitors, he should have been paying me apparently!

theblackradiator · 11/04/2023 17:49

sorry no idea why I added the kiss on the end of my last message 🙄

theblackradiator · 11/04/2023 17:47

do single parents pay more in income tax than couples?? that's shocking and why is this I never realised this. x

ThatsN0tFunny · 11/04/2023 17:44

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 17:34

Don't forget @ThatsN0tFunny that @hoven also says social services will look after our children for a weekend to give us a break if we like. I'd like to know how to organise that please. Oh and how I apply for my single parent tax discount because currently I'm being charged more than a couple with my earnings. But @hoven clearly knows lots that none of us do! @hoven is an expert.

It’s it great to have an expert like this here on MN. When I think of the hours and days I’ve wasted over the last year trying to get my kids father to pay child support and the thousands of pounds he owes them ! If only I had known I could take him to this ( free) court where it would all be sorted out . So I can’t wait to hear all the details from @hoven

Same with the financial support that’s available through divorce - why has no one told me about this before ?

Im so glad I clicked onto this thread, Im sure it’s going to be such an education .

TheVanguardSix · 11/04/2023 17:42

I think hoven is gone. I noticed lots of deleted posts yesterday night.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 17:34

Don't forget @ThatsN0tFunny that @hoven also says social services will look after our children for a weekend to give us a break if we like. I'd like to know how to organise that please. Oh and how I apply for my single parent tax discount because currently I'm being charged more than a couple with my earnings. But @hoven clearly knows lots that none of us do! @hoven is an expert.

EmilyGilmoresSass · 11/04/2023 17:03

Good username, suits you and your attitude.

ThatsN0tFunny · 11/04/2023 16:50

@hoven

Im still waiting for an answer to the two polite questions I asked you upthread.

  1. You said I could take my husband to court to get him to pay child support . How do I do that ?
  2. You said to another poster that she could get financial help during the divorce ? How and where do I apply for this?

I see you have also suggested that I can get my husband to see his children more. This is a great idea that I had never thought of - how do I do that please ?

I hope you will answer soon as there are lots of other posters who would benefit from this information too.

Thanks .

blubberball · 11/04/2023 16:38

In my case, we were together from teenagers and had planned dc in our early 20s. We both seemingly wanted the same things in life, and both wanted the dc. Seems like the reality of dc was too much for him to step up to. We separated, he doesn't pay any maintenance or any responsibility to the dc. He doesn't even bother with them any more, and it's just sad tbh. I feel sorry for the dc that that's their dad.

Ingrowncrotchhair · 11/04/2023 16:32

GobbieMaggie · 11/04/2023 15:02

loads of men really really want to be fathers, they often don’t want to put in any of the hard work but they LOVE the idea of being a father as a status. It brings professional and social status. It’s a complete myth that women are all dragging men into this. And it suits men very well that this myth exists.

The mass of men are pretty ambivalent abut having kids, it's the women who really really want them.

please share where you got this information from. I will only accept peer reviewed, published in a decent journal, paper. What some 5 random blokes down the pub told you doesn’t count.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 11/04/2023 15:19

Why the hell any woman even bother having kids with men, if most here know men don’t want them?
Easier to go alone from the start.
Or this news not out to the masses, only on MN?

GobbieMaggie · 11/04/2023 15:02

loads of men really really want to be fathers, they often don’t want to put in any of the hard work but they LOVE the idea of being a father as a status. It brings professional and social status. It’s a complete myth that women are all dragging men into this. And it suits men very well that this myth exists.

The mass of men are pretty ambivalent abut having kids, it's the women who really really want them.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/04/2023 14:24

There are far more women than men who desperately want children. There are will therefore be women who will prioritise getting a baby over who the father is. I myself know four such women. I know that there are men who appear to be good and then reveal their true character, but I think they're in the minority. I think it's more common for women to overlook things because of the priority they assign to having a baby.

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 11/04/2023 14:00

loads of men really really want to be fathers, they often don’t want to put in any of the hard work but they LOVE the idea of being a father as a status. It brings professional and social status. It’s a complete myth that women are all dragging men into this. And it suits men very well that this myth exists.

I would agree with this, along with a PP's comment that her partner pushed her into child-bearing and only then did he show his true colours: once she was trapped.

My ex was desperate to have children. IMO this was for two reasons:

  1. He had an idealised fantasy life in his head of what having children would be like, to make up for his own fractured childhood (including some rather, ahem, traditional ideas about male and female roles); and

  2. A child would anchor me to him for life, which dealt with his abandonment issues.

We did not have children, are no longer together and he has children with his new partner. Apparently the reality of life with kids was rather a shock for him. Quelle surprise Hmm

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 13:37

Why would I want to get married again, knowing that the guy could cost me a load of my assets in the case of a future divorce? Or claim a stake on my house, or battle my DC for my estate if I died first? My DC's only opportunity to inherit since, you know, the father fucked off. Commitment my arse. Committing your money right into the hands of an adult who could deprive your DC of it.

Absolutely. Marriage was the most disastrous financial decision I ever made. Never, ever again.

blackbeardsballsack · 11/04/2023 12:51

I know they are no guarantees but I honestly believe its better than just having a 2nd child unmarried. It's the committment side of things that I'm interested in.

@Singapore4

Why would I want to get married again, knowing that the guy could cost me a load of my assets in the case of a future divorce? Or claim a stake on my house, or battle my DC for my estate if I died first? My DC's only opportunity to inherit since, you know, the father fucked off. Commitment my arse. Committing your money right into the hands of an adult who could deprive your DC of it.

Tomorrowisagesaway · 11/04/2023 11:00

Many men leave their families, not just their wives/partners, because they can. There's no real social stigma and no big financial penalty.

Lots of fathers just don't care about their children the way nearly all mothers do.

NamelessNancy · 11/04/2023 10:49

Again, if the truth is that men are, in huge numbers, being deceived into fatherhood by scheming, feckless women, why are they not clamouring for better male contraceptive options? Or maybe that's actually not such a common story?

meloonhead · 11/04/2023 10:28

Where did I say that it was a decision worthy of respect? I said that I respected his decision. That is something completely different.

Relax @Dis626. You used the word respect and I said in the next post, a minute later, that maybe you meant acceptance. It wasn't clear. Respect isn't a word I'd use, that makes it sound like a perfectly valid choice and it's not.

I'm not out to get you, I think it's poor that he'd leave your child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread