Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do these fathers actually want children?

358 replies

Daftasyoulike · 10/04/2023 17:01

I see a lot of posts on MN about absent Fathers who don't pay maintenance, don't make any effort to see their children, etc. Is it unreasonable to ask whether these men ever actually wanted kids in the first place, or was it a case of accidental pregnancies, which were allowed to continue in the hope that 'he will come around to the idea once the baby arrives', and then when the relationship breaks up, you find that he never really cared about having the kids in the first place, so doesn't feel he should contribute emotionally or financially to the raising of his children?

OP posts:
Comedycook · 12/04/2023 13:33

Society pressure women to get married and have children, young

Yes but the women could only get married if the men were willing to marry them. Why were men so much more willing in previous generations to get married young?

Still happens today.

I disagree...I think now women are more likely to be shamed for wanting to get married and fulfil their biological urge to have children. How many men describe women who are keen to settle down as "psychos?". I've heard it a lot

Nepmarthiturn · 12/04/2023 13:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 12/04/2023 12:21

Comedycook · 12/04/2023 10:23

So why did people in the past get married so young compared to now?

Men are the gatekeepers of marriage. Women are the gatekeepers of sex.

Lots of women are desperate to get married and have kids and just can't find a man who also wants this.

Society pressure women to get married and have children, young.
And shame women who don’t.
Still happens today.
There is a huge stigma of being hapoy, single, childfree woman.

And again, it’s not much of a marriage if it’s only based on having sex/ couldn’t get it otherwise, what a sad life.

Comedycook · 12/04/2023 10:23

CantAskAnyoneElse · 12/04/2023 08:48

truly believe that decades ago men were more willing to marry in their early twenties because it was a way for them to get regular sex. Nowadays, sex outside of marriage is not taboo or hard to find.

Well, I wouldn’t want to be married to a msn who only married me for easy sex.
So tjis really isin’t thr positive you tried to make it into.
Not to meantion: these kind of men cheated like crazy.

So why did people in the past get married so young compared to now?

Men are the gatekeepers of marriage. Women are the gatekeepers of sex.

Lots of women are desperate to get married and have kids and just can't find a man who also wants this.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 12/04/2023 10:18

DHsPoorBack · 11/04/2023 20:24

This is really hitting a nerve eh?

And yes. I know two women who have (in inebriated form) laughed about what they'd done. One directly to me, one I heard second hand. What struck me was the manner in which she spoke, like she was talking about a silly naughty little thing, like she'd eaten all the chocs, but it was ok, we've all done it, right?

I’ve known four women do this, and all have confessed it to me when drunk. Exactly that tone, like, aren’t I silly?

I know on MN nobody does it, but in real life there are many mums who behave reprehensibly because they care more about having a baby than about the interests of that baby. The focus is always on dads - and it should be - but mums are always the victims heroically doing their best.

Women get away with it because they’re the ones raising the kids and they can use that as leverage against criticism - “well at least I’m still here!” - but it’s wrong. Both parents need to be accountable for the decisions they make regarding creating new humans.

I am excepting abuse cases and cases where people completely change overnight but I still believe these to be the minority even if they’re the majority on MN.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 12/04/2023 08:48

*man

CantAskAnyoneElse · 12/04/2023 08:48

truly believe that decades ago men were more willing to marry in their early twenties because it was a way for them to get regular sex. Nowadays, sex outside of marriage is not taboo or hard to find.

Well, I wouldn’t want to be married to a msn who only married me for easy sex.
So tjis really isin’t thr positive you tried to make it into.
Not to meantion: these kind of men cheated like crazy.

Coyoacan · 11/04/2023 21:58

I am old and I've only ever known one young woman who got pregnant to trap her man and she was not the sharpest knife in the drawer.

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 21:46

I don't think the women are owed anything, but the children are. Biology fixes it so that the women do have the final call in that child's existence but men are ultimately 50% of that child and planned or not, they should contribute AT LEAST the paltry CMS amount, and ideally, be enough of a man to be involved in the child's life.

DHsPoorBack · 11/04/2023 21:25

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 20:58

@DHsPoorBack so you know two women which must mean it's rife? I do wish people on all sides could acknowledge nuance. Some women may "trick" men. Some women may make hasty or poor or unwise choices. Some women may be genuinely blindsided after doing everything "right". You know what they all do though (assuming they are single parents)? Stick around. Maybe they need benefits to get by for a while, maybe they don't contribute to the economy as much as they would have, but they parent their kids. In none of the above scenarios (in the context of this thread) do the fathers stick around in any meaningful way. So in the end, regardless of the circumstances of conception, the parent who stays, and pays and parents should surely NOT be the one being slagged off.

I completely agree with this too.

It's not about slagging off single mums at all. Loads of women will have been left high and dry, with fully planned children, because their partner had an affair, or walked out. That's shitty. If you actively try to conceive a child, don't walk out on them.

What I don't agree with, is one person deceptively, very actively trying to conceive, whilst the other thinks they are having (99%? I don't know the stats) sex protected against pregnancy. If you want to be so low as to deceive someone into extremely likely, but unwanted conception, then don't berate the other person for not standing by you. They would almost certainly not be having sex with the woman if they knew the true likelihood of conception, and the woman knows this, hence the deception.

Both situations, it's the woman raising the DC, most likely excellently.

Women in the former situation have the right to be outraged at how the father is subsequently treating their DC. She didn't choose to be in this position. She has no choice but to pick up the pieces now.

Women in the latter? What entitlement do you think you should have from a person you deliberately deceived to even conceive the baby. You chose to be in this position.

User135644 · 11/04/2023 21:06

Comedycook · 11/04/2023 19:33

The point is, no woman is going to sit there and say "yeah, I hit 38, panicked about my biological clock and had casual sex with no thought other than I'm getting pregnant, regardless of whether the man I was shagging wanted a baby". And volumes of these women exist

Yes they do....of course they do. But look more deeply at that. Why haven't these women met any suitable men who want to get married by that age? The problem is there are heaps of women who want to settle down, get married and have children and fewer men who want this. I truly believe that decades ago men were more willing to marry in their early twenties because it was a way for them to get regular sex. Nowadays, sex outside of marriage is not taboo or hard to find. There is less incentive for men to marry nowadays than in previous generations.

Most men are invisible to women though. Look at dating apps.

BibbleandSqwauk · 11/04/2023 20:58

@DHsPoorBack so you know two women which must mean it's rife? I do wish people on all sides could acknowledge nuance. Some women may "trick" men. Some women may make hasty or poor or unwise choices. Some women may be genuinely blindsided after doing everything "right". You know what they all do though (assuming they are single parents)? Stick around. Maybe they need benefits to get by for a while, maybe they don't contribute to the economy as much as they would have, but they parent their kids. In none of the above scenarios (in the context of this thread) do the fathers stick around in any meaningful way. So in the end, regardless of the circumstances of conception, the parent who stays, and pays and parents should surely NOT be the one being slagged off.

DHsPoorBack · 11/04/2023 20:54

Comedycook · 11/04/2023 19:33

The point is, no woman is going to sit there and say "yeah, I hit 38, panicked about my biological clock and had casual sex with no thought other than I'm getting pregnant, regardless of whether the man I was shagging wanted a baby". And volumes of these women exist

Yes they do....of course they do. But look more deeply at that. Why haven't these women met any suitable men who want to get married by that age? The problem is there are heaps of women who want to settle down, get married and have children and fewer men who want this. I truly believe that decades ago men were more willing to marry in their early twenties because it was a way for them to get regular sex. Nowadays, sex outside of marriage is not taboo or hard to find. There is less incentive for men to marry nowadays than in previous generations.

I completely agree.

The problem is there are heaps of women who want to settle down, get married and have children and fewer men who want this.

Absolutely. It's where the woman wants all that, can't get it, but refuses to accept this. You can't force someone to marry you or settle down. But you can force someone to be a parent if you can get pregnant. So she finds a man who she knows doesn't want any of that, but it is stupid enough not to use condoms, and bingo. No regards to what impact that will have on the child.

If that's what someone chooses to do, then own what you've done. Women capitalise on the fact you can't prove that she orchestrated the whole thing, and when life is hard, deflect onto the man who "left her in this mess." No. Own what you did, be accountable for yourself. Two people irresponsibly conceived. One person chose to have the subsequent child in full knowledge it was not what the other person wanted. You can't force someone to do what you want, just because you are in sole control of a choice they would never make, then berate them for not conforming to your choices.

DHsPoorBack · 11/04/2023 20:24

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 19:35

I know two women who've done this

How would you know that if according to you they lie and never admit it?

What self-contradictory, irrational nonsense.

This is really hitting a nerve eh?

And yes. I know two women who have (in inebriated form) laughed about what they'd done. One directly to me, one I heard second hand. What struck me was the manner in which she spoke, like she was talking about a silly naughty little thing, like she'd eaten all the chocs, but it was ok, we've all done it, right?

DHsPoorBack · 11/04/2023 20:16

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 19:32

How dare you imply that the accounts women have given here are untrue.

Because plenty of women lie

You're accusing us all of lying? Jesus Christ. Pathetic.

Please cherry pick the words you like, and not where I specifically state it's not all women. Well done, stellar effort.

Singapore4 · 11/04/2023 20:00

kitsuneghost · 11/04/2023 18:46

The income tax is per person. There is nothing to stop single people house sharing. This goes if you have kids or not.

A landlord wouldn't allow a child in a house share 🤣🤣🤣

Keepthetowel · 11/04/2023 19:41

These men absolutely do get the choice. Babies are a known consequence of having sex. Use condoms properly, have a vasectomy or don’t have sex. Men do have a choice until the known possibility of a pregnancy happens.

reddragon7 · 11/04/2023 19:37

Comedycook · 11/04/2023 19:33

The point is, no woman is going to sit there and say "yeah, I hit 38, panicked about my biological clock and had casual sex with no thought other than I'm getting pregnant, regardless of whether the man I was shagging wanted a baby". And volumes of these women exist

Yes they do....of course they do. But look more deeply at that. Why haven't these women met any suitable men who want to get married by that age? The problem is there are heaps of women who want to settle down, get married and have children and fewer men who want this. I truly believe that decades ago men were more willing to marry in their early twenties because it was a way for them to get regular sex. Nowadays, sex outside of marriage is not taboo or hard to find. There is less incentive for men to marry nowadays than in previous generations.

Agreed.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 19:35

I know two women who've done this

How would you know that if according to you they lie and never admit it?

What self-contradictory, irrational nonsense.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 19:34

The point is, no woman is going to sit there and say "yeah, I hit 38, panicked about my biological clock and had casual sex with no thought other than I'm getting pregnant, regardless of whether the man I was shagging wanted a baby".

Except plenty of women do openly admit to that if that's what happened.

Those of us who've stated we were married for years before having children and our ex-husbands really wanted children and planned a family with us are hardly going to be making up imaginary ex-husbands. Get a life and stop attacking other women.

Comedycook · 11/04/2023 19:33

The point is, no woman is going to sit there and say "yeah, I hit 38, panicked about my biological clock and had casual sex with no thought other than I'm getting pregnant, regardless of whether the man I was shagging wanted a baby". And volumes of these women exist

Yes they do....of course they do. But look more deeply at that. Why haven't these women met any suitable men who want to get married by that age? The problem is there are heaps of women who want to settle down, get married and have children and fewer men who want this. I truly believe that decades ago men were more willing to marry in their early twenties because it was a way for them to get regular sex. Nowadays, sex outside of marriage is not taboo or hard to find. There is less incentive for men to marry nowadays than in previous generations.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 19:32

How dare you imply that the accounts women have given here are untrue.

Because plenty of women lie

You're accusing us all of lying? Jesus Christ. Pathetic.

DHsPoorBack · 11/04/2023 19:07

How dare you imply that the accounts women have given here are untrue.

Because plenty of women lie. What a ridiculous notion to pretend they don't. It's not saying anyone specifically here is lying, just that every woman claims her pregnancy was either planned with the father or a genuine accident. Lots will be the case. And lots are neither, it's the woman faking she's on the pill, knowing the man wouldn't go anywhere near her if he knew she was on no birth control. You can't go example by example, because only the woman knows the real truth. Some of the accounts that there were no red flags will be absolutely true. Some of the men involved will have been fundamental in planning a child then acting appallingly and abandoning that child.

The point is, no woman is going to sit there and say "yeah, I hit 38, panicked about my biological clock and had casual sex with no thought other than I'm getting pregnant, regardless of whether the man I was shagging wanted a baby". And volumes of these women exist. They are no better than the shitty men who plan children and walk out, leaving the child with one parent. If they had any decency, they'd use a sperm donor and own their deliberate choice to have a child. But they go for the free option of finding an idiot man who won't use condoms, then play the victim, announcing him a deadbeat for not wanting the child she already knew he didn't want and collect their money for 18yrs to boot.

I know two women who've done this. I've also had several women (prior to me marrying and having DTwins) when I was with a very wealthy man, suggest "it wouldn't be a bad thing" if I were to orchestrate a baby.

You can pearl clutch and be professionally offended all you like. For every single mother who was screwed over by a shitty man, there's a single mother who orchestrated her situation, but hell will freeze over before she'll admit that. Because when it's tough, and not all she expected, and she's got no support, she doesn't want to take the accountability that she put herself in that situation. Much more palatable to pretend she's the victim. Of course this thread is only full of the women screwed over by shitty men. But not because it's the landslide majority, because zero single mothers who orchestrated their situation will never say this.

User135644 · 11/04/2023 19:00

reddragon7 · 10/04/2023 21:41

If men don’t want to be fathers, they shouldn’t have sex in the first place. It’s massively unfair.

But if they don't have sex then they're not going to find much of a relationship either (unless they meet an asexual woman). They're living as a monk in that case.

Few men will live a life of celibacy because they don't want to be fathers. They should take more control of contraception in that case, but they're relying on someone else taking the pill and condoms can break.

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 18:57

That's the whole point, it shouldn't be per person. It should be on a household basis.

Yeah single parents should move children into house shares with random adults. No safeguarding issue at all with that, great idea! 🙄