Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do these fathers actually want children?

358 replies

Daftasyoulike · 10/04/2023 17:01

I see a lot of posts on MN about absent Fathers who don't pay maintenance, don't make any effort to see their children, etc. Is it unreasonable to ask whether these men ever actually wanted kids in the first place, or was it a case of accidental pregnancies, which were allowed to continue in the hope that 'he will come around to the idea once the baby arrives', and then when the relationship breaks up, you find that he never really cared about having the kids in the first place, so doesn't feel he should contribute emotionally or financially to the raising of his children?

OP posts:
TheVanguardSix · 10/04/2023 18:21

In both of my marriages, both my first and my second husband made big noises about wanting babies. My second husband actually stressed me a bit with his longing and need to have children, only to crown himself shittiest father ever.

Most men go along with what their wives want, someone wrote up thread. That’s too simple. And it’s not an accurate statement. I think certain men identify having kids as a measure of their success. Many men are living a diorama of a life, one that looks good inside a frame on their desk at work or as a favourite image on their camera roll. But in reality they just can’t be the dependable, loving, compassionate partner in a marriage/father in a family they need society to believe they are. And the bottom line is, shitty husbands aren’t ‘normal’. They’ve got huge issues which they hide well initially. Most of them have abusive tendencies and abusers are champions of deceit. They fool everyone, but not all of the time.

What I notice, as a lone parent, is how many of my female friends have gotten it right with their partners. Not perfect, but right. I’m not sure where I went wrong. I really assume most men are not like my two husbands.

My first husband isn’t even bad. He’s a great guy. But as a partner, he was all work. Both of my husbands were very emotionally neglected as children. Alcoholism in the family. When you’re a child, if both your parents can’t display emotional intelligence or operate from an emotionally intelligent place, you’re pretty much fucked (unless you have other good adults around you who can fill that void).

YaWeeFurryBastard · 10/04/2023 18:18

hoven · 10/04/2023 18:15

We have different views on marriage. I believe the mistake has been made once you choose to have a child with someone you are not married to. These couples are more likely to break up when the children are young than married couples.

Having a child is one of the most important things you can do, why not strive to have the best circumstances beforehand such as a man who has committed to you through marriage and an actual good person?

It took me a long time to find my husband who is an excellent father. I broke up with boyfriend who I was with for years due to a lack of commitment or a lack of confidence in their abilities to be a father. It wasn't easy but I had to make these sacrifices for my child

Also agree with this. Of course some men still fuck off after marriage but IME marrying someone is usually a far greater indicator that the man plans on sticking it out.

YaWeeFurryBastard · 10/04/2023 18:17

ClassicLib · 10/04/2023 18:09

In my experience a large proportion of men, even the ones who are happily married or in long-term relationships, are ambivalent at best about having children but agree to become fathers because the woman they love wants to be a mother and he wants to make her happy.

MN has taught me that many women are so desperate to become mothers in the knowledge that their body clocks are ticking that they overlook & ignore all manner of red flags to get pregnant by totally irresponsible & unreliable men.

This. The behaviour of some men is fucking awful and unacceptable, i.e. just fucking off and paying bare minimum maintenance after being “fully onboard” with having kids.

However, I do think women need to take some responsibility for who they decide to have kids with, because unfortunately the signs are often (not always of course) there, but chosen to be ignored as women want a baby no matter what.

I see it a lot on mumsnet to be honest, if a woman says she’s pregnant after a short fling, posters piling on to say what a shit the father is for not being thrilled, but how fantastic the OP is. Whilst the father is clearly a dick for not using condoms if he didn’t want kids, I think it’s also pretty shitty behaviour from the woman in question and most of the time it’s obvious from how thrilled she is that it wasn’t simply a “contraception failure” 🙄.

hoven · 10/04/2023 18:15

BibbleandSqwauk · 10/04/2023 18:10

@hoven but that's the point I'm making..it's not exceptional. Very few people, women included really know what parenting is like but it seems like men are far more able to just decide they don't want to do it anymore. As for not "having" to be the main parent..it's hard enough getting unwilling men to pay for their kids, let alone actually parent. How do you suppose I make my ex do 50/50? I'd bloody love him too, but it was never something he even raised. He just assumed that he could fuck off with ow and I'd do everything.

We have different views on marriage. I believe the mistake has been made once you choose to have a child with someone you are not married to. These couples are more likely to break up when the children are young than married couples.

Having a child is one of the most important things you can do, why not strive to have the best circumstances beforehand such as a man who has committed to you through marriage and an actual good person?

It took me a long time to find my husband who is an excellent father. I broke up with boyfriend who I was with for years due to a lack of commitment or a lack of confidence in their abilities to be a father. It wasn't easy but I had to make these sacrifices for my child

TheMatriarchy · 10/04/2023 18:10

There is a smorgasbord of reasons why feckless men abandon their children - laziness, immaturity, selfishness etc. Really the question should be, how and why do they get away with it?

BibbleandSqwauk · 10/04/2023 18:10

@hoven but that's the point I'm making..it's not exceptional. Very few people, women included really know what parenting is like but it seems like men are far more able to just decide they don't want to do it anymore. As for not "having" to be the main parent..it's hard enough getting unwilling men to pay for their kids, let alone actually parent. How do you suppose I make my ex do 50/50? I'd bloody love him too, but it was never something he even raised. He just assumed that he could fuck off with ow and I'd do everything.

ClassicLib · 10/04/2023 18:09

In my experience a large proportion of men, even the ones who are happily married or in long-term relationships, are ambivalent at best about having children but agree to become fathers because the woman they love wants to be a mother and he wants to make her happy.

MN has taught me that many women are so desperate to become mothers in the knowledge that their body clocks are ticking that they overlook & ignore all manner of red flags to get pregnant by totally irresponsible & unreliable men.

weinerdog · 10/04/2023 18:09

Mogul · 10/04/2023 17:09

I think there are a lot of 'accidents' and women that hope a man who has said he doesn't want kids will change his mind. It's not right they don't pay but I'm not sure it's right they don't quite get the choice the way women do

Agree about happy accidents, but tbh, sometimes men are perfectly on board with these accidents too.

But also

When women choose not to have a child, then the child either don't exist (termination) or are adopted to people who want them. Child may have emotional issues.

When a man decides he doesn't want a child, the child is just fatherless and the mother has to scrimp to get by, often. Mother is the sole carer. Child may have emotional issues.

So it's not a direct comparison. And it's more than just a minor inconvenience to the father, as I think someone else mentioned: any financial help or involvement is for the benefit of the child, not to punish him.

No man is suffering from paying for a child they made. Child maintenance is a whopping £7 per week for fathers who claim any benefits regardless of how much they may earn from work and whether they have any living costs. Same price to maintain your child (who needs childcare, food, clothes, activities) as adopting a WWF panda so a bargain for them if anything.

StopStartStop · 10/04/2023 18:08

They want children. Some of them insist their wives/partners give them children. Then they meet someone new and they want to walk away from the wife and the children she birthed.

It's male entitlement.

diflasu · 10/04/2023 18:07

I know quite a few where the driving force for kids was the man - who then fucked off and sometimes were supposedly good step parents to other kids.

They often suddenly want contact when new DP comes along which then trails off.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 10/04/2023 18:07

hoven · 10/04/2023 18:04

I think it happens but it is the exception rather than the rule.

Also mothers do not have to have main custody of their child and they can go to the courts for a different custody/visitation split.** Again it is a matter of choice

Have you seen the family court threads? It's not just as easy as that unfortunately and you cannot force someone to see a child in any case.

MeinKraft · 10/04/2023 18:06

Well maybe the mothers didn't want the child either in the first instance. Doesn't mean you don't step up and look after them and love them when they come into existence.

LolaSmiles · 10/04/2023 18:05

Yes but what about those partners who claimed that they wanted children , who were a great partner until they had children. How could anyone know that they would turn out terrible parents?
Totally anecdotal (and I'm sure there are some men who were genuinely good partners and then changed), but there's an awful lot of threads on MN where a poster declares their DP/DH was a great partner or great dad and has changed, but it then materialises:

  • they've never particularly done much around the house before children
  • they 'helped' around the house before having children as long as his partner told him what needed doing
  • they've always been prone to wasting large chunks of time gaming/at the pub/with his friends/on his hobby
  • the poster has overlooked all the above because they didn't mind making the house look nice
  • he sometimes holds the baby when he gets in from work
  • he's paying a proportional share of the bills whilst his partner is on maternity leave
  • being a great dad means that he plays with the children whilst mum does the housework and all domestic responsibilities
  • being a great dad means he takes the children out to soft play so mum can get the laundry done
  • being a great dad is that he allows mum to have half an hour for a bath once a week

He's 'changed' tends to end up meaning:

  • he still prioritises himself
  • he was selfish before and takes up a hobby that has to be done at a good time to opt out of bedtime and weekend childcare
  • he's doing exactly the same as he was doing but all the additional tasks are falling to mum.
  • he is just as shit a dad/partner as he was after 1 child, but 3 children in he's exactly the same
hoven · 10/04/2023 18:04

BibbleandSqwauk · 10/04/2023 18:00

@hoven I find your stance incredibly insulting. I'm not denying that there are some women who choose to continue pregnancies knowing the father is unlikely to be a "good" one, but you seem determined to ignore what you are being told, that many men were perfectly decent partners, husband's and actually even fathers up to a point. Til they weren't any more. I have had this argument on other threads with women determined to believe that there are ALWAYS red flags. There really isn't. The question you should be asking is why does the UK system make it so easy for absent fathers to be so, and why does society seem to accept it as perfectly reasonable parenting to do 4 days a month as standard?

I think it happens but it is the exception rather than the rule.

Also mothers do not have to have main custody of their child and they can go to the courts for a different custody/visitation split.** Again it is a matter of choice

Divorcedalongtime · 10/04/2023 18:04

This question is beyond insulting. I think a lot of men and women do not understand just how much is involved in raising children before they are actually there themselves…. and men have an easier out than women.

GobbieMaggie · 10/04/2023 18:04

TomatoSandwiches · 10/04/2023 17:59

Men need to not be so passive in their life choices, if men don't want children they should avoid vaginally penetrative sex and use multiple methods of contraception, just as women should.

It shouldn't matter if a man wants to contribute financially to his offspring or not, it should be enforced.

What multiple methods of contraception is available to men then ?. There’s only one I can think of that doesn’t involve a very sharp knife !.

EasterBreak · 10/04/2023 18:03

So my child's dad see him until he was 3 years old. Always contributed something. Then went no contact and stopped contributing after meeting a new woman and getting her pregnant. I'd contact him to arrange contact and he said I was harassing him and to not contact him. I ended up going to CSA and he made my child do a DNA test even though we were a couple, he was at the birth and signed the birth certificate. Obviously this proved my son was his and he said he didn't care and he had a new family now. Bare in mind he was a good dad until my son was 3 years old. Over a decade later he showed up with a letter claiming he was depressed and made bad choices and now wanted to be a dad. My then teenager told him he was not interested in seeing him.

SmileyPaella · 10/04/2023 18:03

Mogul · 10/04/2023 17:09

I think there are a lot of 'accidents' and women that hope a man who has said he doesn't want kids will change his mind. It's not right they don't pay but I'm not sure it's right they don't quite get the choice the way women do

Hallelujah 🙌

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 10/04/2023 18:02

hoven · 10/04/2023 17:58

@QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat partners or husbands? If it's the former it's a poor choice. Having a child with your sex partner/ friend and expecting commitment

What does it matter if it's a long term relationship with a house and children?

ThatsN0tFunny · 10/04/2023 18:02

@hoven what kind of legal action do you suggest ?

Id also like to know about the financial “ help” during you mentioned to another poster . Where do I apply for this - is it through benefits or taxes ? Can you link to the relevant page on the government website please ?

Thanks in advance .

JamSandle · 10/04/2023 18:00

A friend of mine has just had her fourth baby. There are three different dads involved and none of them pay or help out. The most recent comes over to have sex and go.

I know she always wanted babies. And I think in her rush to do that she picked quite careless men.

I think for these guys it was the ability to not use protection they liked. The thought of a baby was neither here nor there.

BibbleandSqwauk · 10/04/2023 18:00

@hoven I find your stance incredibly insulting. I'm not denying that there are some women who choose to continue pregnancies knowing the father is unlikely to be a "good" one, but you seem determined to ignore what you are being told, that many men were perfectly decent partners, husband's and actually even fathers up to a point. Til they weren't any more. I have had this argument on other threads with women determined to believe that there are ALWAYS red flags. There really isn't. The question you should be asking is why does the UK system make it so easy for absent fathers to be so, and why does society seem to accept it as perfectly reasonable parenting to do 4 days a month as standard?

Redminionpenguin · 10/04/2023 18:00

Mine said he did - 4 years of ttc, fertility tests and then treatment. You don't wank in the pot if you don't want it.
Left while I was pregnant, no maintenance as gave up work and didn't claim benefits, went on to have 3 more dc (one within a year of me giving birth).

GobbieMaggie · 10/04/2023 17:59

An awful lot of men are , at best, ambivalent to the idea of having kids and a sizeable minority are more than just a tad resistant. The thing is their partners will proceed with a pregnancy, or even engineer it ( how naive to think I wouldn't want kids ) knowing this. The result is all too frequently, predictable.

That men will willingly embark on a life or celibacy or voluntarily submit to surgical sterilisation is delusional and only punted out to justify an equally irresponsible act.

TomatoSandwiches · 10/04/2023 17:59

Men need to not be so passive in their life choices, if men don't want children they should avoid vaginally penetrative sex and use multiple methods of contraception, just as women should.

It shouldn't matter if a man wants to contribute financially to his offspring or not, it should be enforced.