Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be outraged about fee-paying schools and social inequality?

469 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 16:45

I have a ds in Y11 who has been researching potential careers and degrees and it has brought home to me what a horribly unequal society we still have in this country. Apparently 70% of barristers went to public school and there are similar stats for other desirable non-stem roles like journalism and the civil service, as well as medicine. It's a bloody disgrace - what a joke for a supposedly modern society.

And it seems that certain schemes like blind recruitment might also feed into this as although going to Oxbridge might have become slightly more attainable recently thanks to contextual offers and an awareness that those institutions shouldn't be filled with people from certain schools, now blind recruitment means the advantage a state school student may have got from going there is pretty much cancelled out.

To me it seems that ds is most disadvantaged in a way as he wouldn't qualify for schemes aimed at people who are the first in their families to go to uni and we aren't in a deprived area, but he has none of the advantages that would have come from going to an independent school. Everything about us is just average!

He is very bright (predicted all 9s and got that in his mocks) and wants to achieve but it seems that the odds are against people like him having prestigious roles. Obviously when he is quoting these stats at me I'm telling him not to be defeatist and that he has every chance of doing something amazing as long as he keeps working hard, but inside I'm wondering if how true that is.

I've always been against fee-paying schools but him reeling off all these stats at me has just been sickening and yet when Labour make noises about doing something about it there's outrage when in my opinion there should be daily outrage about the current situation.

Can anyone who cares about fairness honestly say I'm BU?

OP posts:
MyDarlingClementine · 11/04/2023 19:34

@coffeerevelsrule

Start to ask your son to research dc with basic sen and how many dc leave primary unable to read. Then look at how many illiterate people end up in prison.

That's your inequality right there.

Many don't need funding to learn how to read or expensive anything. They just need a flexible system that allows for reading to be taught in many ways if one way isn't working.
That's the inequality gap.

If a child can't read by year 4 they are probably already feeling naturally excluded from daily school life and pretty rubbish. Which then affects how they seem themselves and leads into many other issues..

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 19:32

MyDarlingClementine · 11/04/2023 19:24

@jeaux90

Many parents have the luxery of choice.

One of my dd has mild sen that her outstanding state primary couldn't cope with. She couldn't get read nor count by year 4.

We had been told by utterly clueless teachers to "wait and it will come". In the true meaning of the word teachers are mainly absolutely clueless as to any sen. They don't know anything about the basics!
My own journey with my dd has taught me that even the smallest deviations from the norm can't be coped with in state school.

I had to pay for private specially sen tutors and with the smallest teeniest tweaks she was learning within a short space of time and able to access the curriculum.

I had a similar experience with my dd. She is dyslexic and the outstanding primary school had no idea - just said she was cognitively impaired - to say I was very cross is an understatement.

Absolutely agree regarding anything that deviates from the 'norm'. They could not support her and we had pay for extra support ourselves - lucky we had the money not everyone does. And this is what makes me cross - what about all those who haven't got the money to help their children.

logicisall · 11/04/2023 19:29

Staffielove23 · 11/04/2023 15:45

Ahh.. spoken like a true private school parent. You even got the antidote in there. Pull yourself up by your bootstraps folks and spoke moaning about imaginary glass and class ceilings 🙄

@Staffielove23 Ahh.. spoken like a true private school parent. You even got the antidote in there. Pull yourself up by your bootstraps folks and spoke moaning about imaginary glass and class ceilings 🙄

That was all you got from my post which mentioned analysing stats, having supportive families etc?
Spoken like someone who has no idea of what class my family came from but felt free to make spurious assumptions.🙄

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 19:26

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 19:24

Well, I have just spent a very interesting half hour or so reading up on the research around single sex education. The more I read, the less clear cut it seems to be. The research isn't conclusively in favour of single sex education or against it as far as I can see.

Exactly what I have been saying. Sociologist's have spent decades debating this... I remember looking at this many many years ago when I did A level Sociology and not much has changed surrounding this debate. Interesting it certainly is and you can find research to support either side of the debate.

MyDarlingClementine · 11/04/2023 19:26

@jeaux90.
I'm terrified about having to send her to the state comp.

It's supposed to be outstanding but is noitourusly bad at helping any dc with sen. No matter how mild..
If I could pay private I know one thing.

I can hold them to account.

MyDarlingClementine · 11/04/2023 19:24

@jeaux90

Many parents have the luxery of choice.

One of my dd has mild sen that her outstanding state primary couldn't cope with. She couldn't get read nor count by year 4.

We had been told by utterly clueless teachers to "wait and it will come". In the true meaning of the word teachers are mainly absolutely clueless as to any sen. They don't know anything about the basics!
My own journey with my dd has taught me that even the smallest deviations from the norm can't be coped with in state school.

I had to pay for private specially sen tutors and with the smallest teeniest tweaks she was learning within a short space of time and able to access the curriculum.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 19:24

Well, I have just spent a very interesting half hour or so reading up on the research around single sex education. The more I read, the less clear cut it seems to be. The research isn't conclusively in favour of single sex education or against it as far as I can see.

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 19:20

Emotionalstorm · 11/04/2023 18:42

I agree with your comments. This is why we will be sending out daughter to private school when the time comes. Unfortunately unless your parents are on benefits or you are ethnic minority the system very much works against you if you go to a comprehensive school.

What have benefits and ethnic minorities got to do with any of this? I don't understand.

MyDarlingClementine · 11/04/2023 19:16

Oopp and distracted in the classroom. They are not inter related. No school can just ask dc not to come back. It's all a process whenever they are.

If someone can afford private education it says firstly that they think it's worth it. So you have a parent who values education.
They may or may not have money for anything else or have these amazing contacts bit the bottom line is... I think education is special.

So that's a pretty good base line to start with.
A school can't infuse children with confidence either. But if your parent can't read and is unsure that may play into the child.

MyDarlingClementine · 11/04/2023 19:10

@Sugarfree23.. You have conflated two issues there... One saying private school " children". Have more confidence.

faffadoodledo · 11/04/2023 18:56

Gosh @TapestryTeddy that's a pretty nasty response! Just trying to winkle out the precise studies you have in mind. As I said, there's a lot out there and perhaps you could point people to the best. Blimey! You're the one making the assertions about single sex (which by the way I haven't disputed), so do please share.

Emotionalstorm · 11/04/2023 18:42

I agree with your comments. This is why we will be sending out daughter to private school when the time comes. Unfortunately unless your parents are on benefits or you are ethnic minority the system very much works against you if you go to a comprehensive school.

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 18:38

Ah well @faffadoodledo at least you are acknowledging that I do know what I am talking about rather than giving me your idiot's guide to widening participation as you were earlier. Almost thirty years teaching in schools across the spectrum has given me some insight. The 'google is your friend' response is what I consider an apt reponse to the patronising tone of 'So forgive me for not accepting your no doubt well informed opinion as gospel'. Well spotted Sherlock! Oh and @MrsBennetsPoorNerves can find her own statistics.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 18:38

I'm familiar with the research about girls performing better in single sex schools, as I have already acknowledged. I am merely saying that I would like to see some research on the longer term social impacts of single sex education before arriving at any conclusions on this.

Believe it or not, I am not wedded to any particular position on this question - I am genuinely open-minded about it. I would just like to see more evidence regarding the long term impact, beyond the time when children are actually at school. I'm sorry if this annoys you but I don't think it is an unreasonable position to hold.

As for Google being my friend....well, I found various research papers on the subject, but nothing very conclusive. One paper stated that women who had been to single sex schools were more confident than girls who had attended co-ed schools. One stated that people who had attended single sex schools tend to hold more sexist views and accept gender stereotypes more readily. A few stated that people who had attended single sex schools were more likely to feel anxious in mixed sex environments. One stated that there was no observable difference between those who had attended single sex vs co-ed schools other than an increased risk of divorce for men at age 42! One literature review stated that two thirds of the research found no real impact in either direction. And a few other papers cast doubt on the validity of the studies that had apparently shown that girls perform better in single sex environments. So all in all, a very mixed picture and I would have to spend a lot more time reading and evaluating sources in order to reach an informed opinion.

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 18:06

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 17:51

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves there is much well documented proper research on single sex education being better for girls, particularly in the secondary years. It is easily accessible. Google is your friend.

This is true but with research in this area it often difficult to isolate the one factor that is causing girls to perform better in single sexed schools - yes people have theories but we actually don't know for sure if the fact there are no boys in the school is the factor the causes the girls to perform better.

This is why on the whole I don't have a problem with single sexed schools - but grammars and privates schools well yes they need to go in my opinion.

faffadoodledo · 11/04/2023 18:04

Oooof 'google is your friend' has to be the most patronising phrase in the internet! I think @MrsBennetsPoorNerves probably wanted you to show her the particular reference to respond to, @TapestryTeddy
As you know, there's good and bad research out there, and you seem to know what's what!

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 17:51

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves there is much well documented proper research on single sex education being better for girls, particularly in the secondary years. It is easily accessible. Google is your friend.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 17:42

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 14:49

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves sometimes direct experience goes a long way, whether you accept or reject (when it suits you) anecdotal evidence. I know single sex schools very well. They work. Just because you or your much referenced DD don't have experience of them doesn't negate their effectiveness.

I'm not dismissing your personal experience at all, but equally, you are not the only person with direct experience of single sex education. I know some people who experienced that kind of education and swear by it. Equally, I know some people who experienced it and would rule it out for their children. So forgive me for not accepting your no doubt well informed opinion as gospel. Personally, I would like to see some proper research before reaching any conclusive view on the subject.

3WildOnes · 11/04/2023 17:26

Staffielove23 · 11/04/2023 17:08

Then why are certain occupations dominated by private schooled children and not wealthy middle class state schooled children?

Other than barristers are other occupations dominated by privately educated children? Around 30% of doctors were privately educated, whilst 20% of students are privately educated for 6th form. So they are slightly over represented but not dominating. Very few children from disadvantaged backgrounds go into medicine. It is mostly the children of the middle class.

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 17:19

BoojaBooj2 · 11/04/2023 17:10

I don’t think people don’t ‘want to share’ the wealth. They’re just not confident that the government will actually give them stuff instead of spanking it up the wall. Regardless their billionaire mates aren’t really going to pay more anyway are they?

We also have an ageing population.

As a young person I’m happy to pay more tax if I’d get better services. But as I see it the moneys probably going to disappear and I’ll still be told to pay for things ‘because I can afford it’, with no provision in my old age.

Tragedy of the commons…

You’re probably right about the lack of trust regarding our government and the political system. My parents are baby boomers and yes currently have an ageing population but that won’t last forever - this is why we are being made to work longer for less.. the government knows there are fewer people to pay into the pension pots.. and if I was cynical, I might think they wanted us to die before we could claim our pensions…

3WildOnes · 11/04/2023 17:19

Sugarfree23 · 11/04/2023 16:33

A lots of that will be having private tutoring as well as school.

But it's also a known factor that some of the top state schools also have the biggest drop outs of kids not getting into 2nd year at Uni.
Tutored their way through school and fall fall when left to own devices.

I dont think that is true but feel free to share any research you have.

BoojaBooj2 · 11/04/2023 17:10

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 15:51

Of course you’re right. And maybe it’s something I might consider but I guess you’re missing the point of my posts. I would argue the whole tax system needs reform but I guess too many don’t want to share the wealth out. We sadly seem to live in I’m alright Jack society.. so leave it alone.

I don’t think people don’t ‘want to share’ the wealth. They’re just not confident that the government will actually give them stuff instead of spanking it up the wall. Regardless their billionaire mates aren’t really going to pay more anyway are they?

We also have an ageing population.

As a young person I’m happy to pay more tax if I’d get better services. But as I see it the moneys probably going to disappear and I’ll still be told to pay for things ‘because I can afford it’, with no provision in my old age.

Tragedy of the commons…

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 17:10

And which occupations would those be @Staffielove23 ?

Staffielove23 · 11/04/2023 17:08

3WildOnes · 11/04/2023 16:10

I really don't think it makes that much difference. Wealthy middle class children tend to out perform their peers when in state school too.

Then why are certain occupations dominated by private schooled children and not wealthy middle class state schooled children?

faffadoodledo · 11/04/2023 16:44

What, @Sugarfree23, do you mean tutoring only happens in state schools? Honestly this is a worn out old MN trope. My kids went to a state school and I can tell you tutoring was not common (mine never had any and nor did their friends). And let's be honest, some kids (I know a few) went private and had tutoring. There seems to be a widespread misconception that tutoring in state schools is common or only happens in that sector.
As for your assertion about state school drop outs from university - figures please?

Swipe left for the next trending thread