Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be outraged about fee-paying schools and social inequality?

469 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 16:45

I have a ds in Y11 who has been researching potential careers and degrees and it has brought home to me what a horribly unequal society we still have in this country. Apparently 70% of barristers went to public school and there are similar stats for other desirable non-stem roles like journalism and the civil service, as well as medicine. It's a bloody disgrace - what a joke for a supposedly modern society.

And it seems that certain schemes like blind recruitment might also feed into this as although going to Oxbridge might have become slightly more attainable recently thanks to contextual offers and an awareness that those institutions shouldn't be filled with people from certain schools, now blind recruitment means the advantage a state school student may have got from going there is pretty much cancelled out.

To me it seems that ds is most disadvantaged in a way as he wouldn't qualify for schemes aimed at people who are the first in their families to go to uni and we aren't in a deprived area, but he has none of the advantages that would have come from going to an independent school. Everything about us is just average!

He is very bright (predicted all 9s and got that in his mocks) and wants to achieve but it seems that the odds are against people like him having prestigious roles. Obviously when he is quoting these stats at me I'm telling him not to be defeatist and that he has every chance of doing something amazing as long as he keeps working hard, but inside I'm wondering if how true that is.

I've always been against fee-paying schools but him reeling off all these stats at me has just been sickening and yet when Labour make noises about doing something about it there's outrage when in my opinion there should be daily outrage about the current situation.

Can anyone who cares about fairness honestly say I'm BU?

OP posts:
SueVineer · 12/04/2023 02:01

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 22:32

That doesn't answer my question though.

I accept that people must believe that they are getting value for their £18k a year fees or whatever, but I don't personally see what that value is, unless their child has SEN or some other difficulties that mean they need smaller class sizes, more teacher time etc.

I don't disagree that most people will put their children first. I would have genuinely sent my dd private in a heartbeat if I had believed that she would get a better education, so no judgement from me, I just didn't think it was worth it. So I am always curious as to what the parents who do pay think they're getting for their money and what difference they think it makes to their dc.

I know lots of privately educated adults and lots of privately educated dc. I genuinely don't see that they are any happier or more successful than people from similar backgrounds who are state educated. I really don't see much difference at all tbh.

I think it’s difficult to separate that these children are a self selected group of offspring of generally the most successful parents (at least financially). Also most decent private schools have tests for admission so there is an element of aptitude too. So it’s just not comparable to most if not all state schools.

interestingly there is a school near me that focuses on being a “nurturing environment” with no admissions test. The academics aren’t particularly great in comparison to state schools and I don’t know if the kids are really getting much of an advantage. But it’s difficult to know how they would do otherwise I suppose

SueVineer · 12/04/2023 01:51

coffeerevelsrule · 11/04/2023 23:10

Alright, SueVineer, calm down. I have already acknowledged some of the inconsistencies in what I have posted and I see no reason to attack me because I am worried that my highly able son may be at a disadvantage further down the line because of money and not his ability. What parent wouldn't feel that way? You may not have done any unpaid work before pursuing your elite career, but ds currently thinks he would like to be a barrister and that is a career, as confirmed by several people on here, that does require significant financial outlay and the ability to support oneself while training/making very little money in the early years. It would be a bit shit if he were to miss out because of money. It's not a case of me blaming everyone else as if I'm failing to take responsibility for the fact that I'm not wealthy enough to support him in that. And no, I haven't spoken this way to ds and I'm not saying it makes it impossible and he doesn't see it as impossible either, but it is unfair.

As for wanting ds to have a contextual offer to Oxbridge, the way his grades are looking at the moment he wouldn't need one anyway. Ds attends a slightly better than average comp (going by P8 scores) and has never received any tutoring. Someone mentioned teachers tutoring their own kids - I have no time to do any such thing and would be worse than useless at the majority of subjects anyway. I've given him some exam strategies for the subject I teach and I'm sure the impact has been marginal. I do stand by what I said about it not making sense to widen access to Oxbridge while at the same time trying to remove some of the benefits gained by attending. I'm not sure why that's difficult to understand.

I’m perfectly calm, thanks.

it’s not true that if your ds wants to be a barrister he needs financial support from elsewhere. It depends entirely on the set and type of law. The commercial sets tend to earn reasonably well straight away. But those are extremely difficult pupilages to get. Criminal work which is low paid is easier to get but obviously financially difficult.

re Oxbridge- very many kids who are extremely talented with straight As don’t get into Oxbridge each year. “Widening access” basically means you think your son can get an advantage by being from a certain background even though he remains pretty privileged. So he gets to leapfrog another kid with the same grades because of his background. Then you want to get rid of blind applications so your son retains this unfair advantage!

why do you think your son should get an advantage simply for attending a particular university anyway? if anything entrenches privilege it’s the Oxbridge dominance of certain institutions in the uK. How is it any different from private schools?

Reality is that the standard to obtain a decent pupilage is extremely high for the best spots and there are many great candidates losing out each year. It’s nothing to do with private schools- simply it’s a tough environment that only the best can navigate. These are people who are truly exceptional. Not to do your son down but getting all top marks in some GCSEs isn’t exceptional. Of course it’s great and well done to him but not exceptional.

Similarly with medicine- many kids with straight As and fantastic applications are not getting in to university courses. IT’s competitive and most won’t make it.

Groutyonehereagain · 12/04/2023 01:49

It’s not up to you @coffeerevelsrule how people spend their money. Our neighbour sends their child to a private school but they never have a holiday, they both work full time, she works as a midwife and is always doing extra shifts. It’s their choice.

Emotionalstorm · 12/04/2023 01:47

The main benefit from going to Oxbridge is that people think that you're smarter when you're not.

Emotionalstorm · 12/04/2023 01:44

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 23:31

@coffeerevelsrule I can see what you are saying but I would add that to believe that one cancels out the other assumes that all Oxbridge confers is a label and I do not believe that is the case at all. I think an Oxbridge education does builds a number of marketable strengths such as critical thinking, ability to perform under pressure, juggling a heavy work schedule with sport commitments etc. Any selection process worth its weight should pick up on those strengths and it is those rather a university brand that should set the candidate apart. I would caveat that with the comment that I don't believe these skills are exclusive to Oxbridge but the short terms and intensive tutorial systems do foster development in certain areas.

I went to Oxbridge and I disagree. Oxbridge is the same as any other uni and their students are no smarter or have any more marketable strengths than someone who graduated from say the University of East Anglia.

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 23:31

@coffeerevelsrule I can see what you are saying but I would add that to believe that one cancels out the other assumes that all Oxbridge confers is a label and I do not believe that is the case at all. I think an Oxbridge education does builds a number of marketable strengths such as critical thinking, ability to perform under pressure, juggling a heavy work schedule with sport commitments etc. Any selection process worth its weight should pick up on those strengths and it is those rather a university brand that should set the candidate apart. I would caveat that with the comment that I don't believe these skills are exclusive to Oxbridge but the short terms and intensive tutorial systems do foster development in certain areas.

coffeerevelsrule · 11/04/2023 23:10

Alright, SueVineer, calm down. I have already acknowledged some of the inconsistencies in what I have posted and I see no reason to attack me because I am worried that my highly able son may be at a disadvantage further down the line because of money and not his ability. What parent wouldn't feel that way? You may not have done any unpaid work before pursuing your elite career, but ds currently thinks he would like to be a barrister and that is a career, as confirmed by several people on here, that does require significant financial outlay and the ability to support oneself while training/making very little money in the early years. It would be a bit shit if he were to miss out because of money. It's not a case of me blaming everyone else as if I'm failing to take responsibility for the fact that I'm not wealthy enough to support him in that. And no, I haven't spoken this way to ds and I'm not saying it makes it impossible and he doesn't see it as impossible either, but it is unfair.

As for wanting ds to have a contextual offer to Oxbridge, the way his grades are looking at the moment he wouldn't need one anyway. Ds attends a slightly better than average comp (going by P8 scores) and has never received any tutoring. Someone mentioned teachers tutoring their own kids - I have no time to do any such thing and would be worse than useless at the majority of subjects anyway. I've given him some exam strategies for the subject I teach and I'm sure the impact has been marginal. I do stand by what I said about it not making sense to widen access to Oxbridge while at the same time trying to remove some of the benefits gained by attending. I'm not sure why that's difficult to understand.

OP posts:
SueVineer · 11/04/2023 22:48

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 18:24

Also you can't really moan about contextualisation at uni entry level and then also moan about blind recruitment at job entry level!

Well I can because as I said, they can cancel each other out. If a state school child works extra hard and then gets a contextualised offer to get to Oxbridge, only to find that's no longer the advantage it once was it's a bit of a bummer isn't it? Both these policies shouldn't be implemented at the same time.

Right. So your children should get a “contextual” (ie lower) offer to Oxbridge because you think the other children are more privileged but there should be no schemes like blind recruitment that benefit children less privileged than your children. So basically your children should have an unfair advantage- does that summarize it?

Sittwritt · 11/04/2023 22:39

Oh for God’s sake seriously? Don’t plunge your family into this shit way of thinking. We can afford private but don’t wanna waste the money as it could get them ahead in property and not renting, plus I work in private and it’s all spoon fed to the kids. My DD is supremely organised and just doing so well. Would not swap it. Sense of responsibility and focus you can buy even if you throw money at it.

SueVineer · 11/04/2023 22:33

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 18:36

Well this is pretty insulting. I love the way you gloss over the fact that ds does not have two parents willing/able to work two jobs to pay for him to go to private schools or to save for his future. Is it my fault I'm divorced and ex doesn't contribute financially? Maybe (I don't think so though. Is it ds's fault? Absolutely not, so, yes, he is at a disadvantage by that matrix. Will ex and I benefit from inheritances? Maybe, maybe not. Am I supposed to feel admiration for those who do and choose to spend it on their kids' education? Not sure what your point is there. I've had no money from my parents thus far, inheritance nor other help. I work on average around 60 hours a week in my job and often feel like I'm hanging on by my fingernails with parenting - a second job is no way possible and I would have had no childcare for it when it was needed anyway.

So you're lecturing me about being advantaged but there's two measures in your own post by which me (and therefore my kids) are absolutely not.

I'm pretty sure my holiday find would not have come close to paying for private school for 2 kids and I'm opposed to them anyway so it wasn't a consideration.

You’re being pathetic. I went to a (reasonably poor) state school and am from a single parent family. I went to an elite university and worked in the city for years. I’ve never done any unpaid work. Your son is privileged. He may not make it, lots don’t. But you should stop blaming everyone else.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 22:32

Staffielove23 · 11/04/2023 22:16

People wouldn’t pay copious amounts of money and make huge sacrifices if they thought that, supporting their bright children within the state sector, was on par with a private education. The wilful ignorance on this thread is astounding. Just accept that you’ve put your children first and stop pretending that it’s equal or ethical. I get it, I’m a mum too and would always put my child first because that’s what good parents do but I am under no illusion.

That doesn't answer my question though.

I accept that people must believe that they are getting value for their £18k a year fees or whatever, but I don't personally see what that value is, unless their child has SEN or some other difficulties that mean they need smaller class sizes, more teacher time etc.

I don't disagree that most people will put their children first. I would have genuinely sent my dd private in a heartbeat if I had believed that she would get a better education, so no judgement from me, I just didn't think it was worth it. So I am always curious as to what the parents who do pay think they're getting for their money and what difference they think it makes to their dc.

I know lots of privately educated adults and lots of privately educated dc. I genuinely don't see that they are any happier or more successful than people from similar backgrounds who are state educated. I really don't see much difference at all tbh.

volleyballing · 11/04/2023 22:24

Not really the point of the thread but I always thought that the children of teachers were at a big advantage in terms of being able to access support. Especially at the primary level. At the moment my child has a tutor and I pay a lot for an hour of their time. I’d love to be able to provide that kind of support to her day to day.

Hawkins003 · 11/04/2023 22:22

TeenLifeMum · 11/04/2023 22:18

The world is run by money and isn’t fair. Sadly it’s true.

And some people will be better at some subjects than other people, ect that's why society can never be truly equal because how would you then standardise what equal is.

Hawkins003 · 11/04/2023 22:21

Staffielove23 · 11/04/2023 21:49

It’s totally understandable to want the best for your kids but don’t pretend, and own the fact that your are putting your kids ahead of wanting an equal society.

That's the thing no matter how it's spun, society will never be equal, so with that perspective, it's a factually impossibility, therefore then it's do your best children.

lucylantern · 11/04/2023 22:19

VestaTilley · 11/04/2023 21:54

YABU. DH is a barrister, my best friend writes for a broadsheet, another friend is a charity CEO, I work for a bank: we all went to state schools.

It is changing, and will continue to move in state school kids favour as private schools fall further out of favour. Don’t let your DC be put off aiming high.

None of these anecdotes really prove anything on their own though do they. I know people in all of those fields (although not the exact same job in every case) who went to private school.

I’m not disagreeing with your overall point that things are improving but I do think analysing large-scale patterns is more useful than drawing out individual examples.

TeenLifeMum · 11/04/2023 22:18

The world is run by money and isn’t fair. Sadly it’s true.

Hawkins003 · 11/04/2023 22:17

BoojaBooj2 · 11/04/2023 21:49

The problem isn’t people doing better. It’s whether people have the ability to fulfil their potential, should they wish it. Keyword here being ‘wish’. Also the lower earning sections of society should be paid enough for the basics (food, shelter, healthcare and education).

You can have lots of very rich people. Fine. Not a problem if the poor people have enough to eat.

20% of people get B’s and C’s? Fail? Fine, provided that’s the best they can do and they still have opportunities to do other things that don’t depend on grades.

What’s not fine is people falling by the wayside when it could have been prevented, and megacorps profiting off the backs of the poor.

Then instead you have the communist system instead of a capitalist system ?

Staffielove23 · 11/04/2023 22:16

People wouldn’t pay copious amounts of money and make huge sacrifices if they thought that, supporting their bright children within the state sector, was on par with a private education. The wilful ignorance on this thread is astounding. Just accept that you’ve put your children first and stop pretending that it’s equal or ethical. I get it, I’m a mum too and would always put my child first because that’s what good parents do but I am under no illusion.

SueVineer · 11/04/2023 22:14

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 17:02

Alright, I was a dick to say he was most disadvantaged but it is a bit gutting when you see it all laid out. For many of these top flight careers you seem to need to be able to do unpaid/low paid internships etc, which I would be totally unable to support him in as a divorced teacher with two kids and an ex who doesn't contribute. But obviously that doesn't make him more disadvantaged than many but it's unfair.

Pretty much none of those careers require unpaid internships. Journalism and media really is the only one. I work in an elite profession and there are plenty of opportunities for people who didn’t go to private schools. It’s tone deaf to complain about your white middle class sons lack of privilege.

lucylantern · 11/04/2023 22:14

nonevernotever · 11/04/2023 21:09

On the civil service, just to add that I don't think my department is alone in being staffed mainly by people who were state school educated at all levels and insisting that all work experience/internships/student placements are properly paid.

I think the stats quoted relate to the Senior Civil Service specifically, although I also think they’re a bit old.

I couldn’t find anything more recent although apparently 59% of Permanent Secretaries were privately educated, as of 2019, and a further 14% went to a grammar. Obviously though that’s a very small group made up of people who entered the workplace around 30 years ago, so not necessarily representative of today’s entrants and future leaders.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 22:06

Staffielove23 · 11/04/2023 21:33

Yes, let’s just pretend people pay upwards of 18k annually for no advantage.

So what do you think that advantage actually is? How does it manifest itself? What is the difference, in your opinion, between bright, well supported children who go to private schools and bright, well supported children who study in the state sector? And why do you consider that to be worth £18k a year?

MyDarlingClementine · 11/04/2023 21:59

And more than that why can't they be happy places inside?

MyDarlingClementine · 11/04/2023 21:59

@Staffielove23

Enjoying school goes hand in glove with a happy child hood. But at the same time why should state comps be so huge and immensely ugly frighting looking places.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/04/2023 21:59

TapestryTeddy · 11/04/2023 20:09

It is true that there is a lot of conflicting information out there on single sex education. As I see it, there are two angles to this and this is where a lot of studies get a bit bogged down. There is the academic angle and there is clear evidence in many studies that single sex educated girls do much better in maths, science and STEM overall and they are more likely to go on to pursue those areas at university. This aspect is more clear cut. The social aspect is more qualitative, subjective and ambiguous and in my humble opinion it very much depends on the girl and the wider cohort. In a supportive environment girls can do brilliantly socially. The flip side is that in a co-ed environment the presence of boys can diffuse the sometimes competitive cliquey-ness (if that is a word) of girls which can be quite damaging to some. So I do agree that the jury is a bit out in that respect. However, I have worked more recently with ethnic minority girls in single sex selective schools and I do believe that for them, particularly where there is a cultural background of female subjugation, single sex education can be a real game changer and that environment can really can blow open their world and help them to challenge convention. It is hard to explain but I think the essence is that they just have a blank canvas to be themselves and that outlet combined with a realisation of their own intelligence can be very powerful for them. I have also worked with girls of similar background in a co-ed environment and I did get a sense of them being more introverted and less aspirational. I know they still have to tackle the world and that is certainly co-ed but it still seems to be a really useful stepping stone in their journey.

Yes, I can well imagine that girls from certain backgrounds might benefit from that kind of environment.

3WildOnes · 11/04/2023 21:57

Staffielove23 · 11/04/2023 21:51

A child is so much more likely to achieve if they have an enjoyable time at school.

Yes, but this isn't exclusive to private schools. There are lots of fantastic state schools in lovely leafy areas. There is one a few miles down the road from me, very middle class intake and results similar to the private school mine attend. I couldn't afford the £1mil+ it costs to buy a house in catchment though. So I'll say it again, I think the realy advantage is being born into a relatively wealthy middle class family, not whether you attend a private school or not.