Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be outraged about fee-paying schools and social inequality?

469 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 16:45

I have a ds in Y11 who has been researching potential careers and degrees and it has brought home to me what a horribly unequal society we still have in this country. Apparently 70% of barristers went to public school and there are similar stats for other desirable non-stem roles like journalism and the civil service, as well as medicine. It's a bloody disgrace - what a joke for a supposedly modern society.

And it seems that certain schemes like blind recruitment might also feed into this as although going to Oxbridge might have become slightly more attainable recently thanks to contextual offers and an awareness that those institutions shouldn't be filled with people from certain schools, now blind recruitment means the advantage a state school student may have got from going there is pretty much cancelled out.

To me it seems that ds is most disadvantaged in a way as he wouldn't qualify for schemes aimed at people who are the first in their families to go to uni and we aren't in a deprived area, but he has none of the advantages that would have come from going to an independent school. Everything about us is just average!

He is very bright (predicted all 9s and got that in his mocks) and wants to achieve but it seems that the odds are against people like him having prestigious roles. Obviously when he is quoting these stats at me I'm telling him not to be defeatist and that he has every chance of doing something amazing as long as he keeps working hard, but inside I'm wondering if how true that is.

I've always been against fee-paying schools but him reeling off all these stats at me has just been sickening and yet when Labour make noises about doing something about it there's outrage when in my opinion there should be daily outrage about the current situation.

Can anyone who cares about fairness honestly say I'm BU?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 12/04/2023 09:21

MyopicBunny · 12/04/2023 08:11

Whilst we have a Royal Family this will continue. Because we pay for a set of people to have a privileged existence just because of what vagina they came out of.

Until that is knocked on the head, you'd be naive to think that there will ever be anything like equality in the UK.

Does this really follow if you look to US?

Greater inequality than the U.K. and private / state school divide

Ladybowes · 12/04/2023 09:16

MyDarlingClementine · 12/04/2023 08:48

@Ladybowes @jeaux90 I agree with you both I guess my point is instead of focusing on grammars and private school, we should be looking at what we already have!
And improving that before smashing everything else.

Yes I agree with this to an extend but the last decade has seen exactly the opposite to that in my opinion - a government smashing up the education system - albeit slowly over a decade. Our schools have no money - teachers are going on strike - SEND is terrible where you have to fight to get every last bit of support. Great big fat academy chains where state schools seem to be run like business at the expense of the staff and children. Sadly, I can't see it getting any better in the near future and still many children have terrible experiences of school which is awful. This may explain why we still have a massive persistent attendance problem across all our schools.

Sugarfree23 · 12/04/2023 09:08

Ladybowes · 12/04/2023 08:54

I happen to agree with you on this - although it is a whole new thread. We are fed a line of line that we live in a meritocracy - which clearly isn't true when you have a system with a Monarchy. - we have a hereditary aristocracy - where social class has a massive impact on your life outcomes. But like I said that's a whole new thread.😂

I agree to an extent but if every school was done purely on local catchment area. And ALL children attended the local school.

They'd be a massive incentive for the people who run the country, MPs / MSPs etc to make sure that state schools were properly funded, teachers weren't over stretched. Reduced class sizes in every school. And support SEN kids in every school.

Yes you'll end up with some elite areas, with £££m houses, but if education is funded equally per head then it at least provides a more level playing field.

ChocChipHandbag · 12/04/2023 09:07

Twizbe · 10/04/2023 16:58

I always think with stats like this, the more useful version looks across the age bands as well.

How many barristers close to retirement went to private school vs those just entering the profession.

That's a 40 year time period, where lots has changed in terms of education and recruitment.

Very important point.

Ladybowes · 12/04/2023 08:54

MyopicBunny · 12/04/2023 08:11

Whilst we have a Royal Family this will continue. Because we pay for a set of people to have a privileged existence just because of what vagina they came out of.

Until that is knocked on the head, you'd be naive to think that there will ever be anything like equality in the UK.

I happen to agree with you on this - although it is a whole new thread. We are fed a line of line that we live in a meritocracy - which clearly isn't true when you have a system with a Monarchy. - we have a hereditary aristocracy - where social class has a massive impact on your life outcomes. But like I said that's a whole new thread.😂

BoojaBooj2 · 12/04/2023 08:52

@Hawkins003 and also - is China a capitalist country?
you’re throwing around words you don’t understand at this point

BoojaBooj2 · 12/04/2023 08:51

Hawkins003 · 11/04/2023 22:17

Then instead you have the communist system instead of a capitalist system ?

Is Finland a communist country?

MyDarlingClementine · 12/04/2023 08:48

@Ladybowes @jeaux90 I agree with you both I guess my point is instead of focusing on grammars and private school, we should be looking at what we already have!
And improving that before smashing everything else.

Ladybowes · 12/04/2023 08:45

jeaux90 · 12/04/2023 08:13

@MyDarlingClementine I'm really sorry about the lack of school support for your SEN DD

The fact is they often fare better in small class sizes and schools for a couple of obvious reasons.

The attention they get and the lack of sheer noise and disruptions so important to mine who has ADHD and ASD.

My DD13 used to come home from her 30 kid in a class state primary absolutely shattered, frazzled and mentally broken.

3 years in a small private all girls school and she is thriving.

I won't apologise for doing something for her that my taxes should pay for I just wish all SEN kids had the same opportunity.

Completely get this and don't knock anyone for sending their children to private school. And having a SEN child too I might have considered if we could have afforded it. As I would have liked my dd to have similar opportunities of more support and smaller classes but work as much we like there is no way we could ever afford the fees - even if we never went on holiday ever again!

I think this is point for some who are opposed to private and grammar schools. Yes many middle classes can if they wanted afford the fees. But vast numbers of the population can never in a month of Sundays afford them. Why should the additional resources that private school get only be available for only the small 6% of the population that have the money (I read somewhere that was roughly the number who go to private school). And while many middle class 'bright' children might do well in the current state sector - what about all the OTHER children. It is interesting how these children are forgotten about in the debate. Imagine how much better less 'bright' children might do with all the additional resources - and how do we know they're not bright anyway - they may have just been neglected and then labelled by teachers as not bright. I know I certainly was labelled by teachers as not 'bright' at school because I too had an unrecognised SEN - which wasn't identified until many years after leaving school. As @MyDarlingClementine said teachers have no SEN training if any and many of these not so 'bright' many have SEN like I did but are just written off as not bright.

jeaux90 · 12/04/2023 08:22

@Sailawaytocromer I'm a lone parent too. I won't apologise for sending my SEN DD to private school.

Sometimes treating everyone the same is the most unfair thing to do.

GoodChat · 12/04/2023 08:20

@Sailawaytocromer you sound bloody brilliant.

Sailawaytocromer · 12/04/2023 08:18

@jeaux90 completely understand

jeaux90 · 12/04/2023 08:13

@MyDarlingClementine I'm really sorry about the lack of school support for your SEN DD

The fact is they often fare better in small class sizes and schools for a couple of obvious reasons.

The attention they get and the lack of sheer noise and disruptions so important to mine who has ADHD and ASD.

My DD13 used to come home from her 30 kid in a class state primary absolutely shattered, frazzled and mentally broken.

3 years in a small private all girls school and she is thriving.

I won't apologise for doing something for her that my taxes should pay for I just wish all SEN kids had the same opportunity.

MyopicBunny · 12/04/2023 08:11

Whilst we have a Royal Family this will continue. Because we pay for a set of people to have a privileged existence just because of what vagina they came out of.

Until that is knocked on the head, you'd be naive to think that there will ever be anything like equality in the UK.

Sailawaytocromer · 12/04/2023 08:08

I’m a single parent (widowed). Two children. One with SEN. Both at private prep school (one of the best in the country), both with generous bursaries.

Oldest is going to a private secondary school next year. It’s consistently top 10 in the country. He’s fiercely academic and it’s the right school for him. A mixed ability school absolutely won’t work as well for him.

Youngest gets a lot of 1:1 help for emotional/behavioural support. She is also fiercely academic and will hopefully join her brother at the same senior school (it has a great learning support department).

I sacrifice a huge amount to pay the (reduced) fees. They have a bursary based on my income but also on their potential, ability and contribution to the school (academic, music and games).

The system is unfair. So is life. My children miss out so much because they don’t have a dad. I compensate where I can, and giving them the best education is one way. The pastoral care at school is amazing.

I see so much nonsense being written about private schools. I’d pick a great state school over a crappy private school any day. And if my children were not highly academic, I would have 100% considered state primary. But their academic ability has been clear from the start (to schools, not just to me, their doting mum). They were both assessed (within the NHS) as part of a SEN report and both have IQs that put them in the top 0.1% of the population. They really do benefit from learning alongside other very bright children.

I’ve done a massive name change for this because I know some people will immediately jump on me.

I want the best opportunities for my children. Once they’re through school and university, they can do what they like. If they’re happy, that’s great. I don’t pile pressure on them to have high stress/profile/status careers. They are great just as they are. I also don’t expect (or particularly want!) them to go to Oxford or Cambridge.

OP, you touched a bit of a nerve with me. If you could see my bank statements you would not believe I could afford independent schools. And actually, if my children were not so bright, not musical and didn’t play sport, they almost definitely wouldn’t have the bursaries that make their school possible.

I will continue to hope for a more equal future for everyone, while giving my own children all the support I can.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 12/04/2023 07:46

Also, it goes on the previous year's income, which was a nightmare for a student of mine whose previously well-paid parent had to give up work due to ill health the year the dd went to uni

You can ask for an assessment on the current year's income if your income has dropped, so hopefully your student didn't miss out.

I do agree that the student finance system is deeply flawed, though.

coffeerevelsrule · 12/04/2023 07:34

It’s awful to have to compete on one’s merit and not be the most privileged kid.

Well the thread is about how merit is so often superseded by wealth but go ahead and think that that's how I feel about it if it makes you feel good.

ChristmasJumpers Yes, the student finance system is a disgrace. All it looks at is parental income and it ignores factors like outgoings/how many children there are etc. I'm pretty sure it hasn't been adjusted to take into account col crisis either.Also, it goes on the previous year's income, which was a nightmare for a student of mine whose previously well-paid parent had to give up work due to ill health the year the dd went to uni, Yet if you complain about it here people will pile on to tell you it's absolutely fine and either you should have been saving since the age of 21 to send your then hypothetical dc to uni and/or they are adults and it's up to them to get jobs to get through uni, followed by anecdata about dd who went to a top uni and worked 40 hours a week plus f/t in the holidays and it was a piece of piss and she still graduated top of her year. In reality it's really unfair and makes life difficult for many families.

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 12/04/2023 07:14

State not stage!

TheaBrandt · 12/04/2023 07:14

I wonder this too really not seeing it. We all stage educated and achieved very well. My teens at a very good single sex state dd1 got string of 8s snd 9s and has nice sensible friends. Dd2 has befriended girls from the private schools they were all here yesterday. Zero difference between them. Maybe it’s area specific but here £18k pa per teen would be a waste of money,

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 12/04/2023 06:59

SueVineer · 12/04/2023 02:01

I think it’s difficult to separate that these children are a self selected group of offspring of generally the most successful parents (at least financially). Also most decent private schools have tests for admission so there is an element of aptitude too. So it’s just not comparable to most if not all state schools.

interestingly there is a school near me that focuses on being a “nurturing environment” with no admissions test. The academics aren’t particularly great in comparison to state schools and I don’t know if the kids are really getting much of an advantage. But it’s difficult to know how they would do otherwise I suppose

I think that's my point, really. Once you adjust for factors like family background and wealth etc, there really isn't much difference in outcomes. So what exactly is the added value, I wonder?

lifesrichpageant · 12/04/2023 05:30

YANBU!!! Totally disgraceful! And a big "blind spot" in UK society based on some of the comments you're getting on here. We left the country for this reason.

Lizzt2007 · 12/04/2023 05:23

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 17:02

Alright, I was a dick to say he was most disadvantaged but it is a bit gutting when you see it all laid out. For many of these top flight careers you seem to need to be able to do unpaid/low paid internships etc, which I would be totally unable to support him in as a divorced teacher with two kids and an ex who doesn't contribute. But obviously that doesn't make him more disadvantaged than many but it's unfair.

I had a friend at school in this position. She took a year out, worked bloody hard and saved every penny she could, then went to uni. When it came time to do her internship she had those savings to support herself, and she also took on a part time evening/weekend job to supplement her income. There are solutions op, but you have to be willing to work for them rather than just complaining that it's not fair.

Littleroseseverywhere · 12/04/2023 04:50

Oh good lord. He is disadvantaged compared to some. Advantaged compared to most others. That’s life, you can’t always be the most privileged person, and play the victim card. Any parent feeding that is doing their kid a disservice.

ChristmasJumpers · 12/04/2023 04:24

I wanted to jump on and defend what you said about him being disadvantaged by not being in a low enough income bracket for uni help. I grew up in a very low income household and got the full loan, bursary and some additional funding for uni, which meant I was able to afford to go. DD is only a baby, but me and DH now earn almost the exact "average" salary each, which would mean DD would get much less help. With things the way they are right now, we wouldn't be able to help her financially at all!

Littleroseseverywhere · 12/04/2023 04:12

I’m sorry your kid isn’t more privileged than he already is op; and that he needs to compete, that the pair of you sit at home and discuss stats on how he’s not the most privileged. But more privileged than most. I feel for him. I really do. It’s awful to have to compete on one’s merit and not be the most privileged kid.

back in The real world it’s important to teach your kid about privilege, about what they can achieve. And to not sit and focus on how they aren’t THE most privalaged.