Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be outraged about fee-paying schools and social inequality?

469 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 16:45

I have a ds in Y11 who has been researching potential careers and degrees and it has brought home to me what a horribly unequal society we still have in this country. Apparently 70% of barristers went to public school and there are similar stats for other desirable non-stem roles like journalism and the civil service, as well as medicine. It's a bloody disgrace - what a joke for a supposedly modern society.

And it seems that certain schemes like blind recruitment might also feed into this as although going to Oxbridge might have become slightly more attainable recently thanks to contextual offers and an awareness that those institutions shouldn't be filled with people from certain schools, now blind recruitment means the advantage a state school student may have got from going there is pretty much cancelled out.

To me it seems that ds is most disadvantaged in a way as he wouldn't qualify for schemes aimed at people who are the first in their families to go to uni and we aren't in a deprived area, but he has none of the advantages that would have come from going to an independent school. Everything about us is just average!

He is very bright (predicted all 9s and got that in his mocks) and wants to achieve but it seems that the odds are against people like him having prestigious roles. Obviously when he is quoting these stats at me I'm telling him not to be defeatist and that he has every chance of doing something amazing as long as he keeps working hard, but inside I'm wondering if how true that is.

I've always been against fee-paying schools but him reeling off all these stats at me has just been sickening and yet when Labour make noises about doing something about it there's outrage when in my opinion there should be daily outrage about the current situation.

Can anyone who cares about fairness honestly say I'm BU?

OP posts:
KathyWilliams · 10/04/2023 20:52

@coffeerevelsrule You said:

For many of these top flight careers you seem to need to be able to do unpaid/low paid internships etc

Children shouldn't have fewer opportunities because of decisions made by their parents though and companies shouldn't be expecting people to do unpaid internships

It's disgusting that jobs are basically open only to those who can afford them - madness.

For people saying he will get there if he works hard, it's not the case. He could get all the qualifications and then just not be able to afford to do the necessary work experience, and that's not fair.

So what actually is your gripe? Is it with young people who have been to independent schools - which is what your thread title suggests - or is it with young people with rich parents (who have very often not been to independent schools, hence their parents having lots of money to spend on other things, including giving them a financial leg-up once they start work/want to buy a house etc)?

If it's with people being richer than you, then there will always be someone richer than you, so you might as well forget about it and just carry on encouraging your son in whatever avenue he decides to pursue.

And rather than being outraged by the statistics your son has found, you could either find some yourself that demonstrate a different story (because one can always find statistics to back up one's own belief). You could also tell him that he will not be well served in life by developing a chip on his shoulder about where he went to school, which is what he risks doing if he's digging up statistics that make him feel hard done by.

3WildOnes · 10/04/2023 20:41

For Oxford his GCSE results will be looked at in the context of the school they were achieved in. Therefore if you can achieve straight 9s in an average comp, you rightly, have an advantage in Oxford entry over a student who achieved straight 9s from a top indi.

SherlockStones · 10/04/2023 20:40

I definitely think the tax breaks and ludicrous charitable status of some of these schools should be removed permanently.

Newmumatlast · 10/04/2023 20:36

SmileyHappyDoggos · 10/04/2023 16:50

I’m just wondering how this has brought it home to you that life isn’t fair, did you not realise before that many people are disadvantaged from birth just because of their race or sex or...... You’re probably more privilege than many if you’re only feeling it now.

Agree. I realised this as a kid and just realised it more and more and more as I grew.

TapestryTeddy · 10/04/2023 20:33

beeswain · 10/04/2023 18:31

@coffeerevelsrule it is a common misconception that Oxbridge give contextual offers - they don't. All offers are the same and based on rigorous selection (entry test/exam then interview). Oxbridge is taking more state school dc because more are applying - we will similarly see this filtering through to professions over time. And although many grad schemes recruit blind, many employers trawl ALL the top universities by offering job fairs and encouraging applications for vacation schemes/internships. Please support your ds to look more widely at the realities.

Indeed Cambridge does give contextual offers. And the winter pool is heavily skewed to state DC given the state school targets.

Hubblebubble · 10/04/2023 20:32

Anecdotally, I went to uni with someone who had attended Milfield. His very expensive education, with amazing sports opportunities, led him to the same average Joe non-Russel group uni as me. Two people I went to state school with went to Oxford and Cambridge respectively. Others when to UCL and Durham.

Ladybowes · 10/04/2023 20:27

@BoojaBooj2 It’s all very tricky. No easy solutions and I certainly don’t have all the answers. I mention people blaming people because some always point to knowing someone who had it hard and made it and I feel this kind of misses the point and frankly is a bit dismissive of the issues many face. The system is stacked against some people and telling them to get a grip and try harder isn’t helpful. Also think that if more jobs were better paid and had more status maybe that would help people feel life was fairer - but that’s a whole other thread 😂

EggBlanket · 10/04/2023 20:27

Children from state schools out perform children from private schools at university. He’ll do just fine.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/04/2023 20:22

Irritateandunreasonable · 10/04/2023 17:38

BUT imagine his future had he gone to a private school.

It might not have been any different.

I honestly don't believe my dd's future would be any different if we had sent her to a private school.

iaapap · 10/04/2023 20:20

I wonder if it’s 70% of people who are currently barristers, or whether it’s 70% of newly qualified barristers. Most professions are trying desperately to increase diversity in every way.

anyway, having done jury service and watched the defence barrister, I would say he was the lowest form of scum I’ve ever seen. In a trial for sex crimes, the misogynistic victim blaming and ripping apart every aspect of the victim’s life to try and make her look “a mental liar” made me want to vomit. I’d steer well clear of being a barrister. The law doesn’t lead to justice in a lot of cases.

Also, your ds might consider that having a teacher as a mum is a pretty big advantage in life. And that having a deadbeat dad is the reason that he might not be able to afford certain things.

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 20:06

Ladybowes · 10/04/2023 19:48

True however, debate exists as to exactly why this is the case. Is it for example attitudes in the home? Is it Lad culture? Is it stereotyping and labelling by teachers. As I said in a previous post it’s fairly complex stuff not easy to solve but we need to try and we need not to blame people - as that’s usually unhelpful

The study referred to earlier is only among FSM people. So, all equally poor/rich.
I don't think people are 'blaming' but if culture is an issue - what can we do to change it? More talks in disadvantaged schools (something that I'm heavily involved in?) Direct recruitment?

I'm not a sociologist by any means but having mixed with lots of people there's a markedly different attitude to grades, and it's not just 'valuing education'. It's about opportunities. Again, 100% my own observation, not claiming this is scientific.
Non-white British people (albeit that study singled out 'Irish) know the odds are stacked against us. 'Education', and by extension a job that relies on measurable things like qualification is one of the few routes out of poverty. Hence it's emphasized. Of course once you get in there's discrimination at higher levels, but leave it for the moment.
However white British people can still find their way although they don't get the grades.
My white husband is from a farming background. A lot the kids in surrounding areas didn't give much of a toss r.e schools and exams. They're now all gainfully employed in the agricultural industry or trades.
But all the jobs around there are who knows who. I don't think any POC would have had a look in. My husband told me in his school there were Indian kids but they were mocked, bullied and excluded. Certainly we stood out as a mixed race couple...
A lot of these 'diversity' stats focus on all the sexy jobs people aren't getting, but it's not just that. It's for the 'average' person. What opportunities do they have.

Ladybowes · 10/04/2023 19:48

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/04/2023 19:38

@Ladybowes it’s well reported that white boys from lower socio economic backgrounds have the worst outcome in the education system.

True however, debate exists as to exactly why this is the case. Is it for example attitudes in the home? Is it Lad culture? Is it stereotyping and labelling by teachers. As I said in a previous post it’s fairly complex stuff not easy to solve but we need to try and we need not to blame people - as that’s usually unhelpful

nowtherearethree · 10/04/2023 19:45

My daughter went to a comprehensive school it was a good one. She applied to go to Oxford but did not get a place. She went to another RG university and is now a fully qualified GP

Hawkins003 · 10/04/2023 19:42

Ladybowes · 10/04/2023 19:13

Yes this may be true but at least we have children in schools with better resources. I would like to thing all schools would improve if private schools etc were abolished as more people would complain and not stand for some of the rubbish that currently goes on in state schools. For example, maybe all children could be taught in classes of 15 like in private schools imagine how that would help every child - may be I am idealistic - but I would like to see this happen.

I can understand your, perspectives, it's an ideal one,

Saniflo · 10/04/2023 19:39

Oh god. I can't stand the middle class sometimes! Especially when they have the actual audacity to say they are worse off than people from a "deprived background". Get a fucking grip. If your son can't do well for himself with all the privilege he has, then frankly, he doesn't deserve it.

Dibblydoodahdah · 10/04/2023 19:38

@Ladybowes it’s well reported that white boys from lower socio economic backgrounds have the worst outcome in the education system.

BoojaBooj2 · 10/04/2023 19:35

OK I haven't read the whole thread OP, but as a teacher ... how are you so naïve about the way the world works?

Your DS 'reeling off' statistics aside...which as PP pointed out are probably outdated...

'Fee paying schools' are an indicator of privilege. Yes - the Eton type. But also for other 'private' schools indicative of parents who care about education. I bet if you did a similar study comparing the achievement of students from high-achieving, leafy comp private schools with expensive houses in the catchment area you'll find similar stats.

Similarly there are a fair number of fee paying schools catering to SEN children, working parents who find it has a better deal with wraparound care etc. How are they more advantaged compared to you?

The world is open. There are plenty of ways for your DS to make it in a supposed 'difficult' field if he wants to. No need to make excuses.

What you SHOULD be concerned about, IMO instead of contextual offers is 'middle earners' getting caught in the maintenance loan top up trap.

ChristinaXYZ · 10/04/2023 19:34

I think there's lots of things here - you are conflating money and private schools as others have said. You also seem very angry about it all but there are always unfair things. It is always easier to get into a job held by one of your parents. Doctors sons become doctors, lawyers kids become lawyers, etc.

Taking two wealthy groups - it is probably hard as premiership footballer's kid to become a barrister; it is proabably hard as a barrister's kid to become a professional footballer. Like most things in life it is who you know not what you know that gets you the break. If your child is talented, bright and works hard there are lots of very well paying jobs that he can go into that don't need the kind of leg up you're comlaining about. Focus on that. Maybe become a solicitor if law really is where his interest is as you can move across later when he has some income under his belt

https://www.thelawyerportal.com/blog/can-a-solicitor-become-a-barrister

The inequality is annoying but not life blighting and it does not stop him becoming a barrister a bit later if he wants. He may prefer being a solicitor; he may eventually want to do something else entirely. Try and let it go because you do seem very angry and this will come across in your discussions with him (the pessimism) in ways you'd perhaps prefer it did not.

Can a Solicitor Become a Barrister?

Are you a solicitor looking to transition to the bar? Can a solicitor even become a barrister? Find out all you need to know in this piece.

https://www.thelawyerportal.com/blog/can-a-solicitor-become-a-barrister

CheersForThatEh · 10/04/2023 19:23

Arent you just moaning about not being wealthy though?

Hes getting top grades. So your beef is that you cant paid for a brand name school?

Or that you cant afford to send him on unpaid internships?

That's life. There's a reason the elite is a tight loop. Of course commoners csnt compete with people with millions in the bank. That's the whole point.

Gruelle · 10/04/2023 19:20

Wee bit naïve, @GoodChat. The educational opportunities at Oxford and Cambridge can be stupendous, but I’d be surprised if most prospective students weren’t fully aware that an Oxbridge degree might be advantageous for the rest of their life. (Not always in the most obvious ways.) It’s definitely a fun thing to have on your CV.

Ladybowes · 10/04/2023 19:18

Hawkins003 · 10/04/2023 19:09

@Ladybowes
Education can and never will be truly equal basically due to the way humans are and how we learn.

But does not mean we should not try and make things fairer. As someone who is neurodiverse I get this more than anyone but things can be done. Talk like this is a way of excusing people from trying.

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 19:16

KathyWilliams · 10/04/2023 18:43

I love the way you gloss over the fact that ds does not have two parents willing/able to work two jobs to pay for him to go to private schools or to save for his future. Is it my fault I'm divorced and ex doesn't contribute financially?

I love the way you gloss over the fact that my DC have one parent who is divorced with an ex husband who has made no financial contribution at all - but because they went to independent schools, you imagine they are somehow able to do unpaid work experience.

You and I both have shit ex husbands, and both have children who have benefited from a supportive and educated parent. Neither of us could say that our children have been disadvantaged, and it's ridiculous to stamp your feet and say it's not fair. You're far better encouraging your son to carry on doing his best and to believe that the world is his proverbial oyster, rather than limiting his horizons with your own silly prejudices.

Where have I said I'm assuming all parents whose dc went to fee paying schools can afford to support them through internships etc? I said a few posts in that I realised that wealth was more of a factor than schooling, though in many cases the two are of course strongly correlated. And I really wish people would stop assuming I'm saying to ds everything I say on here. Obviously I'm not - the point of the thread isn't for me to come on and repeat everything I've already said to him. What an odd assumption.

I also agree with the pp who said some of these posts amount to blaming people for being poor and I would also say there's an attitude that there should in no way be an attempt to make societies fairer - there's lots of talking about how superior some parents are for the choices they have made and implied criticism of others who've chosen differently and no awareness that children should not have to suffer for this. Some people seem to see the world in a very black and white way - others are worse off therefore you should in no way complain about inequalities that do exist and do affect your own life.

I'll of course be encouraging ds to research further, to keep working hard and valuing his own strengths and to find productive ways around the hurdles he will face. I'm actually capable of doing that while at the same time continuing to believe there is an inherent unfairness at play.

OP posts:
beeswain · 10/04/2023 19:13

@GoodChat they do! (I know you know!) The qualities that get dc into Oxbridge are the qualities that will probably help them succeed in their chosen profession. Which may be well paid or it may not -a large number of Oxbridge grads end up in healthcare , education or research - so not that well paid or prestigious. But presumably happy and fulfilled and using their hard earned degree.

Ladybowes · 10/04/2023 19:13

Hawkins003 · 10/04/2023 19:07

The issue with education is say you had all the same schools, all state, no private ect.
Soon as lessons begin, some students will be great at x subjects, some will be ok some will need extra help.
That's inside the classes.

Then outside school various parents will hire tutors, or use YouTube or Google to help their children learn and achieve greatness or at least be better.

Yes this may be true but at least we have children in schools with better resources. I would like to thing all schools would improve if private schools etc were abolished as more people would complain and not stand for some of the rubbish that currently goes on in state schools. For example, maybe all children could be taught in classes of 15 like in private schools imagine how that would help every child - may be I am idealistic - but I would like to see this happen.

Lcb123 · 10/04/2023 19:11

YABU if you only just realised this. But he is far from disadvantaged. Where you go to uni is of minimal importance in my experience and I have a very well paid good job

Swipe left for the next trending thread