Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be outraged about fee-paying schools and social inequality?

469 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 16:45

I have a ds in Y11 who has been researching potential careers and degrees and it has brought home to me what a horribly unequal society we still have in this country. Apparently 70% of barristers went to public school and there are similar stats for other desirable non-stem roles like journalism and the civil service, as well as medicine. It's a bloody disgrace - what a joke for a supposedly modern society.

And it seems that certain schemes like blind recruitment might also feed into this as although going to Oxbridge might have become slightly more attainable recently thanks to contextual offers and an awareness that those institutions shouldn't be filled with people from certain schools, now blind recruitment means the advantage a state school student may have got from going there is pretty much cancelled out.

To me it seems that ds is most disadvantaged in a way as he wouldn't qualify for schemes aimed at people who are the first in their families to go to uni and we aren't in a deprived area, but he has none of the advantages that would have come from going to an independent school. Everything about us is just average!

He is very bright (predicted all 9s and got that in his mocks) and wants to achieve but it seems that the odds are against people like him having prestigious roles. Obviously when he is quoting these stats at me I'm telling him not to be defeatist and that he has every chance of doing something amazing as long as he keeps working hard, but inside I'm wondering if how true that is.

I've always been against fee-paying schools but him reeling off all these stats at me has just been sickening and yet when Labour make noises about doing something about it there's outrage when in my opinion there should be daily outrage about the current situation.

Can anyone who cares about fairness honestly say I'm BU?

OP posts:
Lapland123 · 11/04/2023 08:30

I think OP is confusing private school as a confounding factor in outcomes.
Wealth is the causative agent here. If you are wealthy you are most likely going to sink money into private school. If you are wealthy your child can try a career that pays well below minimum wage like newly qualified barrister, as you have that financial fall back.

it isn’t the school that’s somehow creating theses careers.

Both the school, and the years of post uni financial support, (and ski holidays in Aspen!) are just things people with wealth can buy.

The school itself is not a causative factor but a confounder.

Your son has done as well as it’s possible to do at school- a private school would have been a waste of money anyway for him. Private schools great for kids with mild SEN that struggle in large classes. Be happy your child isn’t one of them.

Drfosters · 11/04/2023 08:28

@Oysterbabe I’m sorry but ultimately that is nothing to do with the type of school they go to unless they really do need extra support. I sent my kids to the local state primary. They had classes of 30, resources pretty low (the gym equipment was from about 1960!) but fabulous atmosphere and teaching and mixed ability classes. But where I found them falling behind I made sure I helped them. I ran through their times tables every single morning before school, I did their spellings with them, when my son was struggling with his writing I got extra books and we spent hours working on it at weekends. I supported them with their homework and school projects etc. My kids scored almost 100% in their SATs. Their type of school ultimately made absolutely zero difference to their outcomes. They are immensely privileged to be born to academic parents (genetic lottery- pure luck for us all) and to have me do all that with them because I love educating them and find it easy (there are many parents who themselves struggle with maths and spellings so can’t give that level of support). I went to 3 different primary schools, 2 with classes of 30, and one with a class of less than 15. I don’t recall any difference whatsoever. At my children’s’ primary school if children need extra support they were given extra sessions during the lunch hour so smaller class sizes wasn’t necessary. If you school is not doing that then you need to swap schools as it sounds like your primary is nothing like the one my kids went to.

GiltEdges · 11/04/2023 08:27

coffeerevelsrule · 10/04/2023 18:24

Also you can't really moan about contextualisation at uni entry level and then also moan about blind recruitment at job entry level!

Well I can because as I said, they can cancel each other out. If a state school child works extra hard and then gets a contextualised offer to get to Oxbridge, only to find that's no longer the advantage it once was it's a bit of a bummer isn't it? Both these policies shouldn't be implemented at the same time.

You're looking at it all wrong. The benefit is that your DS would still have had an Oxbridge education. Which, theoretically at least, would give him a better chance at landing a job in his chosen field. Except it won't just be because of the name of an institution on his CV, it'll be based of the merit he demonstrates himself.

Ladybowes · 11/04/2023 08:21

Dassams · 11/04/2023 07:48

They are starting to pull away from my kids with their academic ability

Their ability will be down to genetics.

This is simply not true and the evidence says it's a complex interaction between nature and nurture. This idea academic ability is genetic is so dangerous and damaging to young people.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 11/04/2023 08:19

It's not private school that gives you these advantages, it's money. You could ban private schools tomorrow and it wouldn't make much (if any) difference.

Money buys you a nice house with space, so your children have their own rooms and a quiet area to study, sleep and do homework.

It buys you nice holidays and lots of educational, cultural experiences abroad.

It pays for lots of extra curricular sports and activities that look good on UCAS applications.

It means your parents can pay for tutors and private lessons if you're struggling.

It means you don't need to work through school or university, giving you more time to focus on work.

It means you have access to things like cars and lessons, so you immediately have access to all those jobs that require you to have a driving license.

You can't ban people from having money and spending it on their children.

Dassams · 11/04/2023 08:04

But if they've got a teacher with the time to sit with them and go through things really thoroughly until they've grasped it because they only have 12 in the class, they're going to do better than a kid who has something explained once to the group between the teacher trying to stop one of the other kids throwing chairs.

I would argue that the less able students will benefit more from such small classes. Hence why Universities give out offers in context of the different schools.

Elvira2000 · 11/04/2023 08:01

This thread is so depressing. To summarise the responses to the OP 1) you are privilegied so you are in no position to speak about inequality in the uk or 2) shut up and accept the status quo.

Move abroad, then return to the uk. You'll be horrified by what people accept/activately vote for as a nation.

Oysterbabe · 11/04/2023 07:58

Dassams · 11/04/2023 07:48

They are starting to pull away from my kids with their academic ability

Their ability will be down to genetics.

To an extent yes. But if they've got a teacher with the time to sit with them and go through things really thoroughly until they've grasped it because they only have 12 in the class, they're going to do better than a kid who has something explained once to the group between the teacher trying to stop one of the other kids throwing chairs.

TheaBrandt · 11/04/2023 07:54

Anecdotally Dh and I and our siblings achieved our full potential at state schools. Dh and one sister got all As at A level and went to Cambridge/ got a first at another top university respectively. My own dd got mostly 9s last year. You can’t blame the difference in ability entirely on the school though I can see the appeal of doing so.

MarshaBradyo · 11/04/2023 07:53

Oysterbabe · 11/04/2023 07:39

It is disheartening.

My 2 have similar aged cousins. The cousins go to a private primary that we couldn't afford. They are starting to pull away from my kids with their academic ability and I'm definitely a bit jealous that I can't do the same for my children. Their school has 12 children in each class and highly experienced teachers. My children have 30 kids and a newly qualified teacher. The teacher is very good, this isn't a criticism of him, but he has a big class of kids, some with SEN, and my kids will never get anything like the attention they would get in private. We do our best to educate them ourselves out of school too, but we both work so there's only so much time. We need to improve conditions in state schools to give them a fighting chance.

Dc just used a mixed state and switched sector to selective. He’s fine academically, doing well.

Other dc is at a highly sought after state some dc will do just as well academically as a selective private. A big difference is the selection obviously which creates the difference overall in results.

Tarantullah · 11/04/2023 07:51

Even if fee paying schools didn't exist people from families with money would likely still fare better in some fields as they'd have the financial safety net to pursue their passion, tutors, extra curriculars, wouldn't have to work part time whilst studying, would possibly have more 'role models' for their chosen career in their network who they could get advice from. Society at its core isn't fair, but actually university admissions and recruitment has come on leaps and bounds compared to years gone by to try and widen access and opportunities.

Coming from a stable home in a decent area with family who have gone to uni and likely work in professional roles has no doubt given your child a distinct advantage even if you don't think it has.

Dassams · 11/04/2023 07:48

They are starting to pull away from my kids with their academic ability

Their ability will be down to genetics.

TheaBrandt · 11/04/2023 07:47

Absolutely agree Seymour our family is the same. A child with supportive educated emotionally intelligent parents going to a decent state school is just as fortunate. It’s more complex than simply state v private.

Our house as I type is crammed with 14 year old pals of my teen the majority of which go to local private schools (she is state). There is not one iota of difference between them.

Oysterbabe · 11/04/2023 07:39

It is disheartening.

My 2 have similar aged cousins. The cousins go to a private primary that we couldn't afford. They are starting to pull away from my kids with their academic ability and I'm definitely a bit jealous that I can't do the same for my children. Their school has 12 children in each class and highly experienced teachers. My children have 30 kids and a newly qualified teacher. The teacher is very good, this isn't a criticism of him, but he has a big class of kids, some with SEN, and my kids will never get anything like the attention they would get in private. We do our best to educate them ourselves out of school too, but we both work so there's only so much time. We need to improve conditions in state schools to give them a fighting chance.

Seymour5 · 11/04/2023 07:34

DH and I left school at 15, had DC young, both worked so we could afford to live in an area with reasonable schools. DH grew up where school was seen as a necessary evil! DC are hard workers, and are fortunate that they are well qualified, and earn well, as do their partners. They have substantial homes, great holidays, and the DGC go to good state comps. I see their upbringing as privileged, compared to their parents, also compared to many others, even without private school or generational wealth.

IMO, all parents can do is give their children the best opportunities they can. No society is ever completely fair.

sleepwhenidie · 11/04/2023 07:33

Gruelle · 10/04/2023 17:04

No one cares where you went to school at the Bar. Chambers do like Oxbridge Firsts and academic prizes. However, what distinguishes a large proportion of practising barristers (as opposed to those who left after Bar exams or after pupillage) is (still) having sufficient independent income to survive the first few years when fees are slow to come in but Chambers rent is constantly rising. These people may well have come from independent schools - but that’s because they’re from wealthy families, not because the school somehow magicked a career for them.

People don’t (f’rinstance) go skiing because they went to private school, or own huge houses in quaint villages because they went to private school, or remember lockdown as a lovely peaceful time of long walks and gardening and family togetherness because they went to private school - they have access to these things because they have money, probably across generations.

Not sure what else to say to you …

^this.

Many graduates won’t choose lots of those careers because there’s an initial
period (at least) when you earn very little. It’s having the financial ability to get through that that leads to being a disproportionate number of people with wealthy backgrounds working in them. They will happen to have attended private school bc they/their family are wealthy.

Also, complaining about blind interviewing in the same breath as private school advantage is nuts.

mamnotmum · 11/04/2023 07:28

Unpopular opinion but 'it's life' I'm afraid.

Money does not buy you everything ..... but there's not many things that can't be bought.

It's unfair that some children grow up in poverty and are hugely disadvantaged in school and life from it. While others grow up in the most prestigious home attending the top schools. But everyone can't have an equal start in life.

With grades like that and clearly a great work ethic he'll do well in life.

faffadoodledo · 11/04/2023 07:22

@TapestryTeddy where is your evidence of Cambridge contextual offers? They use contextual date (rightly) to decide which of their many talented applicants to make offers to. But those offers are all the same.
Contextual consideration prior to an offer is perfectly valid, and indeed advantageous to the university. If they have two candidates with identical grades and predictions, and one went to a crap comp where they had to do lots of self study, and the other to a small class sized, shiny private school, who do you think might be the better candidate?
It really does a disservice to students who have battled more odds to suggest they're getting a leg up with a lower offer; they're not.
Granted some other universities do this to targeted schools; Cambridge does not.

KvotheTheBloodless · 11/04/2023 07:19

Please don't lump the civil service in with those other careers - the notion of 70% of SCS (senior civil servants) being public-school educated is mad!

Actual stats: 25% went to a fee-paying school (not the same as elite public schools!).

It's still not ideal, but they are doing a lot to try to recruit a wider range of candidates. Most SCS I know are normal folk from state schools.

coffeerevelsrule · 11/04/2023 07:16

The answer to the important issue you raise is not to lower the educational experience of every young person to that of those at the worst sink comp but to raise them to the experience of young people at the most modest independent school which I promise you is largely not about money.

Lovepeaceandunderstanding I find that quite an insulting comment about 'sink comps' - what do you even mean by that? And if we are talking about raising standards and opportunities for everyone I promise you it absolutely is about money, even though some of that money needs to be spent long before children get to 'comps' in supporting their families through initiatives like Surestart etc, which were cut by the Tories.

OP posts:
coffeerevelsrule · 11/04/2023 07:12

Can people stop stating how supportive ds's parents are? I'm not saying ex is unsupportive as such but he has had zero input into the dc's education and doesn't contribute financially. Ds2 is considering various careers and has been laughed at and told some of the options he's considering are boring. It won't matter to ds in the long run but it's a bit irritating reading about ds's supportive parents in the light of it.

As for our holidays, £3k per year is an estimate and includes one European break and a couple of mini breaks in the UK. We've only had them since the divorce 7 years ago (and didn't have them in the 2 covid years) as before then money was a lot tighter as I hadn't been in my career long (only started it at 30) and ex didn't have a career. When I took control of my own finances I realised by being more sensible we could afford modest holidays abroad but I really don't think I could have stretched to sending two dc to private schools and I wouldn't have wanted to as I disagree with their existence and always have. I work in a deprived area and would absolutely hate to work in a private school. I don't think it would be fulfilling at all. I do think there are a lot of people here who have 'scrimped and saved' to send their dc to private schools and are quite defensive about being told they have bought a privilege for their child, even though they presumably knew they were, hence their decision to scrimp and save.

I said a few posts in that I was well aware ds is at an advantage compared to many and I support the schemes to improve access to higher education, including those my dc won't benefit from. That doesn't mean we should ignore glaring inequalities that still exist and not strive to make a more equal society. All the 'life's not fair, suck it up' comments here are a bit sickening really and I do think some posters accusing me to encourage ds to develop a chip on his shoulder are again just feeling defensive about the privilege they know they have bought for their dc.

OP posts:
MrsMikeDrop · 11/04/2023 07:00

I'd assume someone who went to private school had wealthy parents, I wouldn't assume they were clever if anything far from it - based on my own experiences.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 11/04/2023 06:54

Personally I think it’s not private school conferring some magical benefit. It’s money. There’s a similar unfairness in the way in many places the best state schools are the ones in the expensive catchments and the worst state schools are the ones in deprived catchments.

Setting that aside, I think if your son is state educated and gets straight 9s over the next 2.5 years you’ll find he’s top of the pile in the employment market (assuming he’s a nice person). People who’ve got super bright children who’ll excel in state school are better off keeping them in state even if they can afford private.

StockPop · 11/04/2023 05:46

By accident of birth your son was born clever and to supportive parents, and you want that to help him get ahead in life. Yet you're outraged thst another child, born by accident of birth to rich parents, would do the same?

Itsashitbusiness · 11/04/2023 05:34

Yeah it's rubbish but not really a surprise OP , come on? And your son has alot going for him having a supportive family and being academically able. I would suggest you look up the outcomes for care experienced kids - that is heartbreaking ! Add in if they are black or disabled and their opportunities are so restricted! It's a bloody shame and we should be fighting for care leavers !